They Remade It: The Movie Comparison Podcast

In this episode of They Remade It, Stuart and Jacob once more take a look at heists and romance as they compare the two versions of "The Thomas Crown Affair". How does changing something as simple as a bank robbery to an art heist make a world of difference in the intrigue? And what of the connections between McQueen/Dunaway and Brosnan/Russo? Join the two as they dissect character dynam...

In this enchanting episode of They Remade It, Stuart and Jacob go all the way back to Disney's first full-length animated feature and compare it against the recent box-office debacle that was 2025's "Snow White". What happens a charming and beautiful fairy tale adaptation receives a 21st-century reimagining with over-politicization? Why the hell did Dopey NEED to speak at all, wa...

In this very spicy episode of They Remade It, Stuart and Jacob embark on a journey through time and morality as they compare two adaptations of a Buddhist parable turned horror story: the hauntingly beautiful "Onibaba" from 1964 and its modern reimagining, "The Dreadful," set during the War of the Roses. There are some hot takes flying back and forth in this one, something that...

In this episode of They Remade It, Stuart and Jacob turn the volume up to 11 as they dive into the world of rock mockumentaries with a comparison of the iconic "This Is Spinal Tap" and its long-awaited sequel "Spinal Tap II." What makes the original such a funny, comedic staple in the genre and how do the aging rockers of the legasequel compare? How many cameos are too many? An...

In this episode of They Remade It, Stuart and Jacob go through yet another musical as they're looking at two takes on Victor Hugo's classic novel. One of them isn't even a musical, huh?! Yes, similarly to previous topic "The Phantom of the Opera", there are non-musical versions that have been eclipsed by the ones with songs. How do things hold up? Is the story better to watch when people aren't be...

In this episode of They Remade It, Stuart and Jacob tackle the tumultuous terrain of marital discord with a comparison of two adaptations of "The War of the Roses." Danny DeVito's dark comedy from 1989, and Jay Roach's more modern and very slightly lighter take. Are these features too dark? How many antics are too many? Will this episode lead to Stuart and Jacob getting a separat...

In this episode of They Remade It, Stuart and Jacob delve into the realms of time travel with a comparison of two adaptations of H.G. Wells' classic tale, "The Time Machine". There are plenty of differences in how motivations are captured, but what of the characters? And how do the machines and the set designs differ? And what of the Uber-Morlock?! Also featured in this episode is an...

In this episode, Stuart and Jacob kick off season 9 (yes, 9!) of the show with a thrilling comparison of two dystopian action films, with the original transporting us to the far off year of 2017. The duo dives into the absurd creativity of the original, and put it up against a much more realistic (at least by today's standards) take on what our modern day looks like. I mean hey, ultimately bot...

Stuart and Jacob have made it through yet another year, but they aren't done talking yet! They have the whole of 2025 to go over, and they have some thoughts on a range of topics (and maybe a rant or two as well). Throughout the course of this longer than average episode, they discuss varying aspects of the year, reviewing The Oscars , upcoming releases, a few of the individuals that were lost, an...

In this episode, Stuart and Jacob are joined by special guest Hannah as they take on a decade spanning musical, with examinations of the 1982 and 2014 films (and the Disney produced, made-for-TV 1999 version). Charm is explored and nostalgia expounded upon as they look upon the many memorable performances of 1982m, look at how they were done on television with a smaller budget, and then jump all t...

In this episode, Stuart and Jacob dive into the enchanting(?) world of romantic comedies as they compare the beloved 1934 classic "It Happened One Night", directed by Frank Capra, with its 1956 musical remake "You Can't Run Away from It", directed by comedian and actor Dick Powell?! The two explore the charming chemistry between leads Clark Gable and Claudette Colbert, and...

In this episode, Stuart and Jacob embark on a wild ride through the world of espionage as they look at the 1967 comedic spoof "Casino Royale" and the much more serious Daniel Craig iteration of 2006. They delve into the absurdity of the original film, which features a star-studded cast and multiple James Bonds, and discuss how its chaotic narrative pokes fun at the spy genre. Is it any g...

In this spine-chilling episode, Stuart and Jacob welcome Stephanie back to the show as they dive into the haunting realms of the undead and compare the iconic 1922 silent film "Nosferatu," directed by F. W. Murnau, with the 2024 Robert Eggers remake. They explore the eerie atmosphere of the original, characterized by its German expressionism and the unsettling performance of Max Schreck,...

In this horrific start to Halloween 2025, Stuart and Jacob embark on a thrilling adventure through the sands of time as they compare the original 1932 classic "The Mummy" with its 1999 blockbuster remake. They dig deep into the lackluster atmosphere of the early Universal monster film, featuring Boris Karloff's iconic performance, and contrast it with the action-packed Fraser romp that quickly bec...

In this episode, Stuart and Jacob set sail on a tumultuous journey through cinematic history as they compare the classic Oscar-winning 1935 film "Mutiny on the Bounty" with its 1962 remake. They explore the brutal world of Captain William Bly and the rebellious Fletcher Christian fighting for his cause. What makes the 1935 version resonate more with its audience? How does Trevor Howard&#...

In this episode, Stuart and Jacob dive into the enchanting world of Disney as they compare the beloved 1950 animated classic "Cinderella" with its 2015 live-action remake. Back to the Disney well once again, eh? They explore the timeless tale of kindness and perseverance, dissecting how the animated version captures the essence of fairy tales while the remake attempts to add depth and co...

In this episode, Stuart and Jacob do some investigating to compare the iconic 1974 classic "Chinatown" with its 1990 sequel, "The Two Jakes." They explore the masterful storytelling and character depth that made "Chinatown" a defining film of its genre, while dissecting the baffling choices and tonal shifts in its follow-up. How does Jack Nicholson as an actor change over time? What does the seque...

In this episode, Stuart and Jacob embark on a thrilling comparison of the original 1988 miniseries "The Bourne Identity" and the more iconic 2002 film version. They delve into the contrasting storytelling approaches, character development, and the coherence of each film. Which Bourne is a better Bourne? Is Damon's version of the character more unhinged? Are these intelligence agencie...

In this episode, Stuart and Jacob tackle the highs and lows of the "Fantastic Four" franchise, diving deep into the original 2005 film and its disastrous 2015 reboot. They discuss the charm and campiness of '05, from Chris Evans' great performance as Human Torch to the surprisingly decent practical effects that *mostly* hold up today (some REALLY don't). But they don't sh...

In this riveting episode, Stuart and Jacob dive into the treacherous waters of "The Most Dangerous Game," comparing the original 1932 classic with its 2022 remake. They explore the differences in acting choices, set design, and how the adaptations of the original short story go about their storytelling. And they just can't help but rip into the 2022 version for its questionable produ...

In this episode, Stuart and Jacob dive into the gritty underworld of the "French Connection" franchise, comparing the original 1971 classic with its 1975 sequel and the lesser-known 1986 made-for-TV pilot movie, "Popeye Doyle." They explore the evolution of the Jimmy "Popeye" Doyle, portrayed by Gene Hackman, and how his journey shifts from a hard-nosed detective in N...

In this "epic" episode, Stuart and Jacob venture into the iconic world of "Conan the Barbarian," comparing the original 1982 Schwarzenegger film with the 2011 Momoa remake. They dissect the themes of revenge, identity, and barbarian culture... oh who are we kidding? They complain about the set dressings and color and acting on display, this isn't necessarily a high-brow sho...

In this mind-bending episode, Stuart and Jacob explore the narratives of "Abre los ojos" (Open Your Eyes) and its American remake, "Vanilla Sky," starring America's favorite maniac, Tom Cruise. They dissect the themes of reality versus fantasy, identity, and the consequences of wealth as they look at the twin stories of our main characters. How do the character arcs differ...

In this gripping episode, Stuart and Jacob tackle the intense world of "Cape Fear," comparing the original 1962 film directed by J. Lee Thompson with Martin Scorsese's 1991 remake. They dig deep into the chilling narratives of revenge and obsession, exploring the contrasting portrayals of Max Cady by Robert Mitchum and Robert De Niro. What makes De Niro's performance so unpredict...

In this episode, Stu and Jacob dive into the world of "Marty," exploring the 1953 television play and its 1955 feature film adaptation that won an astounding 17 awards, including Best Picture. They discuss the poignant themes of love, societal pressure, and self-acceptance as they follow Marty Poletti, an Italian-American butcher, on his journey through loneliness. How does the transitio...