The Rewatch Recap

In Dustin’s series finale recap: It’s Halloween, when Reapers can be seen as their true selves. As George tries to dodge those that knew her when she was alive, Reggie rebels against tradition and a serial killer keeps the Reapers busy all day.   GUEST INFO Kay on Instagram/Threads/TikTok: @fmwlpod https://linktr.ee/fmwlpod   SHOW INFO https://linktr.ee/therewatchrecap Theme by Dustin Transitional...

Kay’s recap of the penultimate episode finds George (as “Millie”) rewriting her own Happy Time dossier to give to her mother. After 80 years, Rube is finally reunited with his daughter, Mason gets banished from Der Waffle Haus, and Ray’s Graveling wreaks havoc.   GUEST INFO Kay on Instagram/Threads/TikTok: @fmwlpod https://linktr.ee/fmwlpod   SHOW INFO https://linktr.ee/therewatchrecap Theme by Du...

This week’s recap takes a tearful turn for Dustin with Mason & Daisy trying to keep Ray’s demise a secret while Roxy investigates his disappearance. Also, George helps prep for another Happy Time send-off, Reggie searches for a missing J.D.   GUEST INFO Kay on Instagram/Threads/TikTok: @fmwlpod https://linktr.ee/fmwlpod   SHOW INFO https://linktr.ee/therewatchrecap Theme by Dustin Transitional...

Kay recaps a memorable episode that finds George trying to convince her reap of their death while the Ray situation gets darker for Daisy & Mason. GUEST INFO Kay on Instagram/Threads/TikTok: @fmwlpod https://linktr.ee/fmwlpod   SHOW INFO https://linktr.ee/therewatchrecap Theme by Dustin Transitional sounds provided by Zapsplat.com

Reaps continue when Dustin recaps how George seeks justice for a John Doe reap, Reggie makes a friend, and Daisy desperately tries to gain Ray’s approval as Mason watches on with dread.   GUEST INFO Kay on Instagram/Threads/TikTok: @fmwlpod https://linktr.ee/fmwlpod   SHOW INFO https://linktr.ee/therewatchrecap Theme by Dustin Transitional sounds provided by Zapsplat.com

Kay’s week to recap an episode that has George bitter about Trip, Joy planning a date, Rube searching for answers, and Daisy flirts with a shady guy at a bar (played by Will & Grace ’s Eric McCormack).   GUEST INFO Kay on Instagram/Threads/TikTok: @fmwlpod https://linktr.ee/fmwlpod   SHOW INFO https://linktr.ee/therewatchrecap Theme by Dustin Transitional sounds provided by Zapsplat.com

In Dustin’s recap, George continues to go after Trip, Daisy’s reap triggers her flight response, and Reggie cons both parents into doing her homework for her.   GUEST INFO Kay on Instagram/Threads/TikTok: @fmwlpod https://linktr.ee/fmwlpod   SHOW INFO https://linktr.ee/therewatchrecap Theme by Dustin Transitional sounds provided by Zapsplat.com

In this week’s recap, Kay not only tells us how Grandma Phyl’s stay at the Lass house is going, we learn about Roxy & Mason’s drunken reap, how much Rube hates children, George’s flirting with a possible reap, and the return of Pet Reaper Kid! GUEST INFO Kay on Instagram/Threads/TikTok: @fmwlpod https://linktr.ee/fmwlpod   SHOW INFO https://linktr.ee/therewatchrecap Theme by Dustin Transitiona...

Dustin recaps George’s first high-profile reap, Daisy’s loss of faith, Mason’s next mess-up, and a special guest brings positivity into the Lass house.   GUEST INFO Kay on Instagram/Threads/TikTok: @fmwlpod https://linktr.ee/fmwlpod   SHOW INFO https://linktr.ee/therewatchrecap Theme by Dustin Transitional sounds provided by Zapsplat.com

In this recap, Dustin & Kay learn George may not be as confident as she once thought, Reggie isn’t as grown up as she wants to be, and Joy isn’t as joy-less after all. Go figure.   GUEST INFO Kay on Instagram/Threads/TikTok: @fmwlpod https://linktr.ee/fmwlpod   SHOW INFO https://linktr.ee/therewatchrecap Theme by Dustin   Transitional sounds provided by Zapsplat.com

Dustin recaps an episode where time is of the essence – or is it? Whether pressed for it or having plenty of it, the Reapers all learn a lesson in patience, for themselves and others.    GUEST INFO Kay on Instagram/Threads/TikTok: @fmwlpod https://linktr.ee/fmwlpod   SHOW INFO https://linktr.ee/therewatchrecap Theme by Dustin   Transitional sounds provided by Zapsplat.com

In this recap, Kay gives us the dish on George’s mean girl ways in an episode from 2004 that has unexpected insights into our present day 2025.   GUEST INFO Kay on Instagram/Threads/TikTok: @fmwlpod https://linktr.ee/fmwlpod   SHOW INFO https://linktr.ee/therewatchrecap Theme by Dustin   Transitional sounds provided by Zapsplat.com

Dustin recaps the episode that finds George on a Happy Time retreat in the wilderness while Mason scrambles to find his missing post-it before his reap expires. GUEST INFO Kay on Instagram/Threads/TikTok: @fmwlpod https://linktr.ee/fmwlpod   SHOW INFO https://linktr.ee/therewatchrecap Theme by Dustin   Transitional sounds provided by Zapsplat.com

As Kay recaps: George’s day gets worse and worse as Mason tries to take on slight of hand and Daisy starts to find religion?   GUEST INFO Kay on Instagram/Threads/TikTok: @fmwlpod https://linktr.ee/fmwlpod   SHOW INFO https://linktr.ee/therewatchrecap Theme by Dustin   Transitional sounds provided by Zapsplat.com

Kay returns to join Dustin for the second (and final) season of this Reaper show where the season premiere has everyone questioning their afterlife and making extreme choices.   GUEST INFO Kay on Instagram/Threads/TikTok: @fmwlpod https://linktr.ee/fmwlpod   SHOW INFO https://linktr.ee/therewatchrecap Theme by Dustin   Transitional sounds provided by Zapsplat.com

Dustin & Chelley bask in another brilliant episode as the gang learns that the jig is up! After superhumans start to go public, the gang become famously known as The ASBO 5. As Simon goes into hiding, a fellow superhuman resorts to killing for attention. MA (only adults recommended)   GUEST HOST INFO Chelley on Instagram: @talespointhorrorbookclub Chelley’s website: www.talesofyesterday.co.uk...

Chelley and Dustin love this episode recap where the gang helps host a charity costume party at the center while trying to figure out who killed Nathan (again). At the same time, Kelly meets a sweet guy with a mysterious problem… MA (only adults recommended)   GUEST HOST INFO Chelley on Instagram: @talespointhorrorbookclub Chelley’s website: www.talesofyesterday.co.uk   SHOW INFO https://linktr.ee...

Conti? Conti? Is there a Conti here?! Dustin & Chelley get creeped out when a random citizen’s super ability is to see the world as his favorite video game. The gang takes cover and they gain a new ally. MA (only adults recommended)   GUEST HOST INFO Chelley on Instagram: @talespointhorrorbookclub Chelley’s website: www.talesofyesterday.co.uk   SHOW INFO https://linktr.ee/therewatchrecap Theme...

This episode has Dustin & Chelley asking: Why does Nathan suddenly love Simon? Can Alisha entrap the mysterious masked vigilante? Will Curtis learn more about the strange girl from his flash forward? Are there any more Cornettos in the freezer? MA (only adults recommended)   GUEST HOST INFO Chelley on Instagram: @talespointhorrorbookclub Chelley’s website: www.talesofyesterday.co.uk   SHOW INF...

After Chelley & Dustin debate what their supervillain power would be, the recap finds Nathan discovering he has a brother. Also drugs start to affect everyone’s power. MA (only adults recommended)   GUEST HOST INFO Chelley on Instagram: @talespointhorrorbookclub Chelley’s website: www.talesofyesterday.co.uk   SHOW INFO https://linktr.ee/therewatchrecap Theme by Dustin Transitional sounds provi...

Chelley Returns! She and Dustin dive right back into Community Service. The gang finds Nathan back-from-the-dead while dealing with a mystery hero, a psychotic shapeshifter, and of course, a new probation worker. MA (only adults recommended)   GUEST HOST INFO Chelley on Instagram: @talespointhorrorbookclub Chelley’s website: www.talesofyesterday.co.uk   SHOW INFO https://linktr.ee/therewatchrecap...

For the second “Brief-Cap” in the Buffy “Not Themselves” category, Dustin finds Buffy getting poisoned by a demon that makes her (and the audience) believe that none of the slaying is real and she’s actually locked up in a mental institution.   GUEST INFO Kay on Instagram/Threads/TikTok: @fmwlpod https://linktr.ee/fmwlpod   SHOW INFO https://linktr.ee/therewatchrecap Theme by Dustin Transitional s...

Kay starts off week 2 of the Buffy “Brief-caps” – giving us some fun perspective on the episode that has all the adults in town acting like teenagers again, with Giles and Joyce drawing the most attention.   GUEST INFO Kay on Instagram/Threads/TikTok: @fmwlpod https://linktr.ee/fmwlpod   SHOW INFO https://linktr.ee/therewatchrecap Theme by Dustin Transitional sounds by Dustin

In the second Robot-themed “Brief-cap”, Dustin talks about John Ritter’s legendary performance as the psychotic android dating Buffy’s mom.   GUEST INFO Kay on Instagram/Threads/TikTok: @fmwlpod https://linktr.ee/fmwlpod   SHOW INFO https://linktr.ee/therewatchrecap Theme by Dustin Transitional sounds by Dustin

In their first “Brief-cap” (be gentle it’s their first time), Dustin & Kay mention what works and what doesn’t for the first season Buffy episode that finds Willow the subject of a demon catfish.   GUEST INFO Kay on Instagram/Threads/TikTok: @fmwlpod https://linktr.ee/fmwlpod   SHOW INFO https://linktr.ee/therewatchrecap Theme by Dustin Transitional sounds by Dustin