The Not Natural Podcast
The Not Natural Podcast
The Not Natural Podcast is an episodic rewatch of Supernatural, hosted by superfan Holly Jones.
Be sure to visit the podcast's website and support the creator: podcasters.spotify.com
Author
The Not Natural Podcast
Category
Podcast website
Latest episode
Apr 23, 2025
Where to listen?
Podcasts in the app Replaio Radio Coming soonPodcasts are coming to the app soon. Install now and be the first to see a whole new take on podcasts
Episodes
2.11 Playthings 23.04.2025 47:54
Come join me as I talk about one of the creepiest Supernatural episodes, Season 2, Episode 11: Playthings. We're talking about my hatred for AI, my love for Rule 34, and asking ourselves, why does Sam look so sexy while crying?
2.10: Hunted 16.04.2025 41:17
We are pulling a Winchester and rising from the dead! I am back and this week talking about getting ghosted, One Direction fanfiction, and the sexiness of Supernatural villains. We’re talking about Season 2, Episode 10: Hunted.
2.09 Croatoan 05.03.2025 38:40
Is this the best mid-season finale? Would I survive in an apocalypse? Is Sam crying thinking he’s going to die a little hot? These questions and more will be answered this week as we discuss Season 2, Episode 9: Croatoan.
2.08 Crossroad Blues 26.02.2025 41:04
If I have to hear another man play the blues I’m going to kill him. This week, we’re talking about hellhounds, complaining about exes, and as always, listening to me lose my mind. We’re discussing Season 2, Episode 8: CrossRoad Blues.
2.07 The Usual Suspects 19.02.2025 34:56
Is this Law and Order? Join me as I discuss Season 2, Episode 7: The Usual Suspects, also known as, Criminal Minds without the joys of Matthew Grey Gubler.
2.06 No Exit 12.02.2025 36:26
Ellen Harvelle I can treat you better than your dead husband ever could! Join me this week to talk about pick-me girls, serial killers, and the sexual appeal of cement trucks.
2.05 Simon Said 05.02.2025 40:09
Andy Gallagher, my best friend, the only spotlight in this episode. As Daniel Molloy said it best, “It’s a telenovela!” This week we’re dealing with evil twins, quarter-life crisises, and conspiracy theories. We’re talking about Season 2, Episode 5: Simon Said.
2.04 Children Shouldn't Play With Dead Things 29.01.2025 43:08
To be honest this episode is 99% not about Supernatural. We're talking about Thai dramas, spitting in hair, and mostly complaining about the pretty awful Season 2, Episode 4: Children Shouldn’t Play With Dead Things.
2.03 Bloodlust 22.01.2025 52:34
WE’RE SO BACK! This episode’s got everything you could ever want! Vampires! Sam’s tied up! Amber Benson! Join me to talk about the horny horny Season 2, Episode 3: Bloodlust.
2.02: Everybody Loves A Clown 01.01.2025 56:27
Pennywise, what are you doing here? Dean, why do you look so sexy destroying your car? All these questions and more will be answered as I discuss Season 2, Episode 2: Everybody Loves A Clown.
2.01 In My Time of Dying 18.12.2024 54:31
GOOD NEWWSSSS SHE’S DEAD!! R.I.P John Winchester I hope we never have to see you again. This week, nothing else matters because John finally bites the dust. Come with me to celebrate as I talk about Season 2, Episode 1: In My Time of Dying.
1.22 Devil's Trap 11.12.2024 1:04:11
Ok the end is nigh for reals this time…This week me and my sister watch part two of the finale. We mostly focus on radio show hosts, how hot Dean is, and how shitty John is. Finish season one with us as we watch Season 1, Episode 22: Devil’s Trap.
1.21 Salvation 04.12.2024 1:15:59
The John Winchester hate club grows even bigger as my sister joins me to talk about Season 1, Episode 21: Salvation. This week we get a little blasphemous as we talk about holy water, Bible verses, and Hinge dates.
1.20 Dead Man's Blood 27.11.2024 1:02:51
Did someone say vampires?! This week I’m talking about my favorite topic, vampires, and my least favorite, John Winchester. We’re watching Season 1, Episode 20: Dead Man’s Blood.
1.19 Provenance 20.11.2024 53:37
Sam’s going on a date, Dean’s a misogynist, I won’t shut up--what else is new?! This week I’m ranting and raving about Season 1, Episode 19: Provenance.
1.18 Something Wicked 13.11.2024 48:03
Everyone give a round of applause for John Winchester’s A+ parenting. In this episode join me to talk about Season 1, Episode 18: Something Wicked.
1.17 Hell House 06.11.2024 44:04
Who you gonna call?! This week’s episode I’m talking about ghosts hunters, Halloween, and prank wars. We’re watching the very fun Season 1, Episode 17: Hell House.
1.16 Shadow 30.10.2024 47:39
John Winchester they will never make me like you. This week join me to talk about the return of Meg, the hotness of Sam, and my opinions on phone sex. We’re talking about Season 1, Episode 16: Shadow.
1.15 The Benders 23.10.2024 1:02:16
It’s just people? Dean’s getting his ass kicked by an eight year old? I’m writing fanfiction? On this special episode, my sister joins me to talk about the logistics of cages, how hot Sam is, and whether or not she could survive The Hunger Games as we discuss Season 1, Episode 15: The Benders.
1.14 Nightmare 16.10.2024 51:10
There’s more psychic children, Sam is getting visions during the day, and THE BOYS DRESS AS PRIESTS. Join me this week to recreate Fleabag season 2 as I talk about Season 1, Episode 14: Nightmare.
1.13 Route 666 09.10.2024 1:02:35
Is this the worst Supernatural episode? Does it have the best sex scene? Me and my friend Gabe answer all this and more as we talk about Season 1, Episode 13: Route 666.
1.12 Faith 02.10.2024 54:54
Dean’s dying. He’s wearing a black hoodie. What more could you want?! I’m losing my mind talking about Season 1, Episode 12: Faith.
1.11 Scarecrow 25.09.2024 1:05:50
Nothing like a wholesome, All-American sacrifice. On a very special episode, my sister joins me to talk about Season 1, Episode 11: Scarecrow.
1.10 Asylum 18.09.2024 34:36
Dumb teens doing dumb teen things like breaking into an insane asylum. Also, John Winchester is calling! This week we’re going over Season 1, Episode 10: Asylum.
1.09 Home 11.09.2024 44:52
There’s no place like…the childhood house your mom burned alive in. We’re talking about Season 1, Episode 9: Home.
Similar podcasts
Replaio is not a podcast publisher; show names, artwork and audio belong to their authors and are distributed through public RSS feeds.