Hidden Killers Podcast

The Murder Of Sandra Birchmore

News EN ↓ 219 episodes

Welcome to "The Murder of Sandra Birchmore," a podcast channel dedicated to uncovering the dark and disturbing details surrounding the tragic death of Sandra Birchmore—a case that has shaken the foundations of trust in law enforcement in Massachusetts. Sandra Birchmore was a young woman whose life was marked by manipulation and exploitation at the hands of multiple police officers, including those from the Stoughton Police Department. Beginning when she was just a minor, Sandra became entangled in inappropriate relationships with men who should have protected her but instead abused their power...

Be sure to visit the podcast's website and support the creator: www.truecrimetodaypod.com

Author

Hidden Killers Podcast

Category

News

Podcast website

www.truecrimetodaypod.com

Latest episode

Nov 17, 2026

Where to listen?

Podcasts in the app Replaio Radio Coming soon

Podcasts are coming to the app soon. Install now and be the first to see a whole new take on podcasts

Get it on Google Play Install for free Android 10M+ downloads · 4.7+ rating iOS soon

Episodes

Sandra Birchmore Was Called a Suicide for Years. What Made a Jury See Murder? 17.11.2026

Sandra Birchmore's death was called a suicide for years before a federal jury convicted Matthew Farwell of killing her and causing the death of her unborn son. Retired FBI agents Jennifer Coffindaffer and Robin Dreeke join me to talk about what made that jury see murder, and what's still unanswered. The medical examiner first ruled Sandra's death a suicide and later changed it to undetermined. Her...

Sandra Birchmore's Department Had Warning Signs Years Earlier. What Else Did It Miss? 17.11.2026

Sandra Birchmore's police department had warning signs about one of its own leaders before she died. Retired FBI agents Jennifer Coffindaffer and Robin Dreeke tell me what else that department, and the investigators who handled her death, might have missed. Former deputy chief Robert Devine ran the Stoughton police Explorers program, and he was demoted years before Sandra died after an internal in...

Sandra Birchmore's Family Got One Conviction. Will There Be More? 16.11.2026

Sandra Birchmore's family has one conviction, and they say the verdict isn't the end of their push for accountability. Retired FBI agents Jennifer Coffindaffer and Robin Dreeke tell me whether more charges could follow Matthew Farwell's. Farwell was convicted of killing Sandra and causing the death of her unborn son. His twin brother William testified with federal immunity. A state board tied form...

Sandra Birchmore's Case Returns to the Office That Never Charged Farwell. Who Oversees It? 16.11.2026

Sandra Birchmore's case is going back to the office that never charged Matthew Farwell, and this time Djuna Perkins is in charge. Retired FBI agents Jennifer Coffindaffer and Robin Dreeke tell me who should oversee her review and what it would take for Sandra's family to trust the system again. Perkins says she can't imagine people in a department as small as Stoughton's didn't know what was happe...

Sandra Birchmore's Family Heard 'Deadlock.' What Was Keeping the Jury Apart? 16.11.2026

Sandra Birchmore's supporters heard her jury was deadlocked, and her former neighbor Jean Falletti said the whole room just kind of collapsed. Less than a day later, the same jury found Matthew Farwell guilty of killing Sandra and causing the death of her unborn son, and I ask retired FBI agents Jennifer Coffindaffer and Robin Dreeke what had been keeping those jurors apart. The judge told jurors...

Sandra Birchmore Deserved Protection. Who Failed Her?! 16.11.2026

Sandra Birchmore was twenty-three when she was killed. A federal jury convicted Matthew Farwell, the former Stoughton detective who had met her through a police youth program when she was a child, of killing her and her unborn son. Still, so much of the trial put Sandra’s private life under a microscope. And too many people continue to judge her instead of asking why adults failed to protect her....

Farwell Guilty: Sandra’s Family Heard WHAT After Deadlock?! 15.11.2026

Sandra Birchmore’s family waited while the federal jury considering Matthew Farwell’s guilt told the judge it could not agree. Then, on November 10, 2026, the jury returned guilty verdicts on both counts. The courtroom reacted audibly. Farwell’s lawyers reached out to comfort him. For Sandra’s relatives, this was the end of one courtroom fight, not the end of their loss. Tony Brueski reconstructs...

Sandra Birchmore’s Final Hours: What Did the Defense Miss?! 15.11.2026

Sandra Birchmore’s voice belongs at the center of this story. In the final arguments at Matthew Farwell’s federal trial, the defense portrayed her pregnancy announcements as evidence of an imagined future with Farwell. Her death, they argued, was suicide. On November 10, 2026, jurors convicted Farwell on both federal counts. Tony Brueski sits down with criminal defense lawyer Bob Motta of Defense...

Sandra Birchmore: The Evidence Behind Farwell’s Verdict 15.11.2026

Sandra Birchmore was twenty-three and pregnant when she died. For years, her death was officially treated as suicide. Now Matthew Farwell has been convicted in federal court. A federal jury convicted former Stoughton detective Matthew Farwell on November 10, 2026, of killing Sandra Birchmore and causing the death of her unborn child. The verdict came after jurors briefly reported being deadlocked....

Sandra Birchmore: Who Failed Her Before the Federal Case?! 14.11.2026

Sandra Birchmore’s family kept asking questions after local authorities treated her death as suicide. The federal case against former Stoughton detective Matthew Farwell has forced a second examination of what those early investigators did—and what they left undone. Farwell denies killing Sandra, who was pregnant when she died in February 2021. Tony Brueski speaks with retired FBI Special Agent Je...

Sandra Birchmore: The Last Texts Farwell Couldn’t Explain 14.11.2026

Sandra Birchmore was getting ready for a baby, according to the messages prosecutors presented to jurors. At 7:46 p.m. she asked Matthew Farwell to buy the baby’s going-home outfit. Later she told him her door was open. The building camera then captured his visit, and prosecution experts say Sandra’s phone stopped recording steps minutes before he exited. Those details are at the heart of the gove...

Sandra Birchmore's Family Fought for Answers for Years. What Was Farwell Telling Himself? 13.11.2026

Sandra Birchmore's family heard the word guilty for Matthew Farwell, convicted by a federal jury of killing Sandra and her unborn son, and psychotherapist Shavaun Scott joins me to talk about how Farwell lived with it and how the people around Sandra failed her. It starts with how Farwell carried on. The FBI says his wife gave birth to their third child about 13 hours after he was at Sandra's apar...

They Put Sandra Birchmore's Worst Days on Trial. Would Anyone Believe You? 13.11.2026

Sandra Birchmore's private life was laid out in a federal courtroom so Matthew Farwell's lawyers could argue she took her own life. The jury rejected that and convicted Farwell of killing Sandra and her unborn son, and psychotherapist Shavaun Scott joins me to talk about why Sandra was the one being judged. The defense leaned on her grief over her mother and grandmother, her mental health history,...

Sandra Birchmore Told a Cop She Was 15. What Makes a Man Look the Other Way? 12.11.2026

Sandra Birchmore told people about Matthew Farwell long before anyone stopped him. After a federal jury convicted Farwell of killing her and her unborn son, psychotherapist Shavaun Scott joins me to talk about why the people around her looked away. Sandra texted his twin, William, also a Stoughton cop, that she was fifteen when it began with Matthew. William answered "Nice," and later testified he...

Sandra Birchmore Thought Farwell Would Leave His Wife. Why Did She Believe Him? 12.11.2026

Sandra Birchmore wanted Matthew Farwell in her baby's life, and after a federal jury convicted him of killing her and her unborn son, psychotherapist Shavaun Scott helps me understand why she held on. Sandra first knew him as an officer in the Stoughton police youth program. Prosecutors said their relationship began when she was fifteen, weeks before he married his wife. In the last months of her...

Sandra Birchmore Never Met Her Son. How Does Farwell Look at His Own? 12.11.2026

Sandra Birchmore's case ended with a conviction: a federal jury found Matthew Farwell guilty of killing her and her unborn son. I asked psychotherapist Shavaun Scott how the man who did that keeps going. Sandra believed Farwell was the father of her baby and was already getting ready for him. A stroller box sat in her apartment, and she'd told more than 80 people she was pregnant. A DNA test later...

Sandra Birchmore's Jury Hit a Wall After Ten Hours Over THIS 12.11.2026

Sandra Birchmore's jury hit a wall after about ten hours and told Judge Denise Casper it was deadlocked. Bob Motta of Defense Diaries read the wall as the motive half of the federal charge against Matthew Farwell, not the murder. Motta argues Sandra's own life answers it: she had an attorney ready to go after Farwell for child support, and once that filing went public, Motta says she would have to...

What If Sandra Birchmore's Case Landed in a State Courtroom With Cameras? 12.11.2026

What if Sandra Birchmore's case moved from a federal courtroom with no cameras to a state courtroom where everyone could watch? Bob Motta of Defense Diaries explains how that could happen: if Matthew Farwell's jury hung, Motta says Massachusetts can bring a straight murder charge without proving Farwell's motive. If the jury acquitted, Motta says his wife's research shows the state may be blocked...

What If Sandra Birchmore's Jury Believed Farwell Killed Her and Still Couldn't Convict? 11.11.2026

What if Matthew Farwell walked out of federal court not guilty? Bob Motta of Defense Diaries says Sandra Birchmore's case is in federal court only because the local DA wouldn't bring it, and that choice put justice for her at risk. Norfolk DA Michael Morrissey declined to charge Matthew Farwell. That left federal prosecutors with a statute that demands more than murder: proof Farwell killed Sandra...

Sandra Birchmore's Killer Was Never Charged by the State. The DA Pointed at WHO? 11.11.2026

Sandra Birchmore's family heard Matthew Farwell found guilty in federal court, and her cousin Barbara Wright said the state should have done this itself. Norfolk County's district attorney says his hands were tied. Sandra's cousin Angelique Pirozzi said the State Police investigator kept telling her there was no evidence Farwell killed Sandra, and that troopers were hanging their hat on the medica...

Sandra Birchmore Made Farwell a Copy of THIS at Walmart 11.11.2026

Sandra Birchmore went to Walmart and had something copied for the man prosecutors say came to kill her. Bob Motta of Defense Diaries says that receipt is the reason Matthew Farwell could never testify. In the days before Sandra died, her friends noticed Farwell had turned sweet again after treating her badly. Motta reads that as a man making sure she let her guard down. His theory is that Farwell...

Sandra Birchmore Had a Baby to Fight For and Never Wrote THIS 11.11.2026

Sandra Birchmore had a baby on the way and something to live for, and Bob Motta of Defense Diaries says that's why the defense story of a sudden suicide falls apart. Once Sandra learned she was pregnant, Motta says, she stopped letting Matthew Farwell run the relationship and started protecting her child. If Farwell had really ended it that night, Motta argues she would have put it all in writing:...

Sandra Birchmore and Nancy Guthrie: Sandra's Coworkers Warned a Trooper, and He Saw THIS 11.11.2026

In both Sandra Birchmore's case and Nancy Guthrie's case, the first investigators made up their minds fast. Prosecutors told the jury State Police treated Sandra's death as a suicide, even after her coworkers spoke up. According to The Wall Street Journal, the first deputies at Nancy's home thought the blood on her porch might be from a nosebleed. Tony and retired FBI behavior chief Robin Dreeke g...

Sandra Birchmore's Family Sobbed at the Verdict. Farwell's Lawyer Did THIS. 10.11.2026

Sandra Birchmore's family waited almost six years to hear a jury call Matthew Farwell guilty, and as they sobbed, Farwell's attorney rubbed his back. This is the full account of the Farwell verdict for everyone who has followed Sandra's case. Sandra was 23 and pregnant with a baby boy when she died in her Canton apartment. Prosecutors said Farwell, a Stoughton police detective, killed her to keep...

Sandra Birchmore Wanted This Baby. Farwell's Lawyer Told the Jury Something Else. 10.11.2026

Sandra Birchmore wanted this baby. Her friends, her therapist and prosecutors all told the jury so. In closing arguments on Nov. 6, 2026, Matthew Farwell's defense told jurors something else about the way she shared her news. Defense attorney Kimberly Stevens called Farwell's life, wife and kids a fantasy for Sandra, the girl he first met at 13 in the Stoughton police youth program. Stevens leaned...

Listen to the The Murder Of Sandra Birchmore podcast in Replaio

Radio and podcasts in one app - free, with no sign-up. Install today and do not miss the launch

Get it on Google Play

Replaio is not a podcast publisher; show names, artwork and audio belong to their authors and are distributed through public RSS feeds.