The Monster Mashup

Send us Fan Mail In 1928, three men from rural Pennsylvania murdered a local powwow healer named Nelson Rehmeyer. Why? They believed he'd put a curse on them. Known as the Hex Hollow Murder, this bizarre true crime case blends backwoods superstition and folk magic with the desperation to ditch bad luck. What drove these men to kill? And why does the legend still haunt York County nearly a cen...

Send us Fan Mail Step inside the infamous LaLaurie Mansion, one of the most haunted and horrifying landmarks in New Orleans. In this episode, we explore the true story of Delphine LaLaurie, a Creole socialite whose elegant image masked unspeakable cruelty. From her rise in high society to the 1834 fire that exposed her dark secret, we unravel fact from folklore. We also trace the mansion's ev...

Send us Fan Mail The Greenbrier Ghost is the only documented case in U.S. history where a ghost helped solve her own murder. In this chilling true story from 1897 West Virginia, the spirit of Zona Heaster Shue allegedly returned from beyond the grave to name her killer, leading to a real conviction in court. Follow us on all platforms for behind-the-scenes content, bloopers, short episodes and mor...

Send us Fan Mail In this episode, we dive into the dark legacy of the Cecil Hotel in Los Angeles, California, from its troubled history and infamous guests to the chilling disappearance of Elisa Lam. Join us as we explore the hotel’s ties to legendary serial killers, Richard Ramirez and Jack Unterweger. We also cover the strange occurrences that were commonplace like guests jumping out of windows...

Send us Fan Mail Beneath the streets of Paris lies a chilling labyrinth of bones...the infamous Paris Catacombs. In this episode we uncover the dark history behind this underground ossuary, explore spine-tingling legends, and discuss the eerie mystery of the lost footage found deep within the tunnels. From mass graves and ghost stories to modern-day cataphiles, discover why the Catacombs remain on...

Send us Fan Mail Join us as we continue the discussion on the disappearance of flight MH370. But most importantly... we also learn what a Mangosteen is. What do you think happened to Flight MH370? Follow us on all platforms for behind-the-scenes content, bloopers, short episodes and more!  Instagram - @themonstermashuppodcast TikTok - @themonstermashup YouTube - @themonstermashuppodcast Send us an...

Send us Fan Mail Join us for part I of unpacking one of the most complex and unsolved aviation mysteries - the disappearance of flight MH370. We discuss the many theories that have surfaced and how believable we think each one is - but, the question remains: what evidence is missing? And, who benefits from it staying hidden?  Part II drops on Sunday, June 22nd, 2025. We appreciate you listening! ...

Send us Fan Mail In this episode we talk about ocean farts, make Cyclops puns and figure out what Manganese is...  Follow us on all platforms for behind-the-scenes content, bloopers, short episodes and more!  Instagram - @themonstermashuppodcast TikTok - @themonstermashup YouTube - @themonstermashuppodcast Send us an email at themonstermashuppodcast@gmail.com. We appreciate your support. Stay spoo...

Send us Fan Mail In this episode, we talk about a ghost cat named Morris. Oh, and the myriad of messed up things that "Doctor" Norman Baker did to his patients... Follow us on all platforms for behind-the-scenes content, bloopers, short episodes and more!  Instagram - @themonstermashuppodcast TikTok - @themonstermashup YouTube - @themonstermashuppodcast Send us an email at themonstermash...

Send us Fan Mail In this episode, Morgan learns that Long Beach and Long Island are not the same place. We debate whether the hype surrounding the RMS Queen Mary is actually warranted and the role consumerism plays in amping up how haunted people think a location is.  Sources US Ghost Adventures   Britannica   LA Times #1 , #2 Navy History ABC7 Warfare History Network Screen Rant #1 , #2 Telegraph...

Send us Fan Mail Warning! This one is graphic and listener discretion is advised... On today's episode, Keegan gets the idea for a new ghost hunting show. We also explore the Villisca Axe Murder House. Which is a case that is still unsolved to this day.  Sources US Ghost Adventures House Beautiful Vice Atlas Obscura   All That's Interesting   Murder House Follow us on all platforms for b...

Send us Fan Mail In this episode, Keegan is physically incapable of not making fish faces while recording, we discuss why a house with 160+ rooms has only 1 shower and try to figure out what's behind all the doors in the Winchester Mystery House. Most importantly, we talk about the house's most famous visitors - Walt Disney and Harry Houdini.  Sources https://www.visittheusa.com/experien...

Send us Fan Mail In this episode we unpack all things Medusa. Oh and the horrific way  Pegasus was born...  Follow us on all platforms for behind-the-scenes content, bloopers, short episodes and more!  Instagram - @themonstermashuppodcast TikTok - @themonstermashup YouTube - @themonstermashuppodcast Send us an email at themonstermashuppodcast@gmail.com. We appreciate your support. Stay spooky!

Send us Fan Mail The gang solves the Mothman crisis and also learns about herons. Keegan returns and is now a permanent fixture. He's sort of like a moth - persistent and sensitive to light (which still might also mean he's secretly a werewolf).  Follow us on all platforms for behind-the-scenes content, bloopers, short episodes and more!  Instagram - @themonstermashuppodcast TikTok - @th...

Send us Fan Mail This one is more than Team Edward vs. Team Jacob. On today's episode we talk about Werewolves. Welcome our guest and new permanent fixture on the show, Keegan. Who also may be a... Werewolf himself? Follow us on all platforms for behind-the-scenes content, bloopers, short episodes and more!  Instagram - @themonstermashuppodcast TikTok - @themonstermashup YouTube - @themonster...

Send us Fan Mail Follow us to Sleepy Hollow, New York as we study the Headless Horseman, America's oldest ghost story (and a school mascot?). Though there are a few versions of this frightful monster, by far the most well-known in the U.S. is Washington Irving's portrayal of him, which we cover in addition to some other fun facts. Let us know what you think of this episode by visiting us...

Send us Fan Mail Hang out with us as we unpack the legend of the Woman in White...also, we might've been haunted by her ghost?  Follow us on all platforms for behind-the-scenes content, bloopers, short episodes and more!  Instagram - @themonstermashuppodcast TikTok - @themonstermashup YouTube - @themonstermashuppodcast Send us an email at themonstermashuppodcast@gmail.com. We appreciate your...

Send us Fan Mail Dimitri lives under a rock and a drone may have sighted "Nessie." Join us as we deep dive into all things Loch Ness monster. Follow us on all platforms for behind-the-scenes content, bloopers, short episodes and more!  Instagram - @themonstermashuppodcast TikTok - @themonstermashup YouTube - @themonstermashuppodcast Send us an email at themonstermashuppodcast@gmail.com....