The Lethal Library

In this Idaho case from 1983, Kathy Gittel tries to restart her life after leaving Keith Rosencrantz, but he won’t let the relationship end quietly. Dani and Stephanie walk through a string of escalating red flags: tense drop-ins, threats, alcohol-fueled behavior, and the kind of controlling rage that pulls family and bystanders into the blast radius. Then one summer night in Buhl, neighbors hear...

In this episode of The Lethal Library, Dani and Stephanie revisit a shocking 1950 Boise crime involving a well-known neighborhood grocer and two young men who knew him personally. What starts as a tense plan to rob the store, using a pistol and a sock filled with rocks, turns into a brutal attack that stuns the East Boise community. Investigators move quickly as witness accounts, confessions, and...

In this episode of The Lethal Library, Dani and Stephanie cover a 2008 Meridian case that begins with a tense living situation on Snyder Street and a plan to get Doug Halpin out of a house tied to Karen LaFollett. Instead of handling it legally, LaFollette contacts two men from Bakersfield, California (Stanley Hahn and John Joseph Green) who drive to Idaho, meet with her for instructions, and pick...

Dani and Stephanie detail a Mountain Home–area case that starts with a young Air Force couple trying to “do the right thing” with counseling… and ends in a rural roadside tragedy that shocks a community. What happens in the small window between a blow-up argument and a violent collision becomes the central question, with investigators and attorneys battling over intent, timing, and what the eviden...

In this episode of The Lethal Library, Dani and Stephanie dive into a wild Idaho 2015 case that starts with a Subaru slamming into a 2,500-pound breeding bull on dark Highway 95 near Council, and somehow spirals into one of the state’s most explosive, community-splitting showdowns. They unpack open range law (and why it confuses everyone), the chaos at the crash scene, and how a call to the ranche...

In this episode of The Lethal Library, Dani and Stephanie head to West Boise for a 2001 case that starts with a routine, prearranged visit between estranged spouses—and spirals into a nightmare that leaves a neighborhood stunned behind yellow tape. With a clear trigger warning for domestic violence, they unpack what neighbors noticed (and what police didn’t), why prosecutors chose a grand jury rou...

In this episode of The Lethal Library, Dani and Stephanie cover a 2016 Boise case that starts with Mark Irwin disappearing under deeply suspicious circumstances: mail piling up, a running AC, missing bedding, and his van gone. Very quickly, two people close to him pop up trying to pawn his property, leading to a wild police encounter and a much bigger investigation. The hosts walk through how law...

Dani and Stephanie bring The Lethal Library listeners to Power County, Idaho, where a late-night meth run in 1997 spirals into paranoia, betrayal, and a brutal outcome that shocks the area and pulls in the Fort Hall Indian Reservation and the icy waters of American Falls Reservoir. As investigators race to piece together what happened, the case barrels into a courtroom fight packed with small-town...

In this episode of The Lethal Library, Dani and Stephanie dig into a grim 1976 Idaho case that starts with a missing Payette butcher and ends with a shocking discovery along a dirt road in the Boise foothills: a partially burned, headless, armless torso hidden under a wooden door. As investigators connect the scene to Ronald Meads’ disappearance, attention quickly turns to his new wife, Sally, who...

In this episode of The Lethal Library, Dani and Stephanie head into Valley County for a 1995 Memorial Day weekend story that begins with a Northern California teen tagging along to an Idaho cabin trip with a Boise-area crew; and then becomes a months-long mystery when 19-year-old Jeffrey David Towers doesn’t make it home. The hosts unpack what drew Jeff to this group, why locals in Patty Flat alre...

Dani and Stephanie head back to North Idaho for the story of Anna Old, a reliable, Harley-riding transplant who had recently returned to the Bonners Ferry area and was trying to untangle herself from a tense living situation with John Funkhouser. When Anna doesn’t show up for an early work shift, concern escalates fast, and what friends find at the house sets off a chain of events that ends in a h...

Dani and Stephanie dive into another death row case in Idaho: A Boise State student leaves work for class and vanishes, along with her unmistakable green Mustang. That same morning, a brand-new Micron employee doesn’t show up either… and his wife finds their home weirdly “off”. Two days later, with a deputy finally at the house to take a missing-person report, the phone rings; what’s said on that...

On this episode of The Lethal Library, Dani and Stephanie take on a Boise true-crime case that starts with a dependable 61-year-old woman leaving for a late-night cleaning shift—and never coming home. The investigation spirals into a messy mix of Idaho arts-world politics, a former Russian ballet director with a dramatic past, a whirlwind marriage, and timeline details that refuse to stay consiste...

In this episode of The Lethal Library, Dani and Stephanie head back to North Idaho for a bizarre 1984 case that has everything: a stranger on a roadside walk, a weird note left near a bridge, bar chatter that turns into a bad idea, and a “citizen’s arrest” that escalates into something far darker in the woods. The situation quickly snowballs into a messy courtroom saga filled with refiled charges,...

In this gripping episode, Dani and Stephanie dive into a shocking true crime tale from rural Idaho that will leave you speechless. On October 25, 1998, Meta Jones was preparing dinner for her soon-to-be stepson's church farewell, but she never made it to the event. Found dismembered in a canal, Meta's murder exposed a chilling crime driven by jealousy, family loyalty, and twisted materna...

Welcome back to The Lethal Library with Stephanie and Dani! In this episode, we travel back to October 1904 in Boise, Idaho, where a husband walks into a sinister plan set by his wife and their mysterious lodger. What follows is a tale of shocking confessions, a dramatic trial, and the ultimate punishment that riveted the entire state. Join us as we unravel this sensational story filled with old-t...

Join Dani and Stephanie as they chat about the chilling tale of Jimmie Vurel Thomas, a notorious figure whose criminal escapades span three locations and three decades. From the mysterious murder of a horse trader in 1977 California to a jail-breaking kidnapping in Idaho, and finally a chilling case in South Africa, we cover every wild twist and turn. Was he Mr. Worldwide or Mr. Why-Didn’t-You-Jus...

In this episode of The Lethal Library, hosts Dani and Stephanie go over the chilling true crime story of Anthony Wayne Montwheeler. From his violent childhood origins to a horrific series of crimes stretching across Idaho and Oregon, Montwheeler manipulates the system with claims of insanity, evading harsh penalties repeatedly. The episode unpacks Montwheeler's life, touching on his manipulat...

In this gripping episode of Lethal Library, Dani and Stephanie delve into the senseless and tragic killing of Penny Dawn Moore outside a Taco Bell in Boise, Idaho. Penny's boyfriend, Brent Tortolano, claimed innocence, but evidence and witness testimonies told a different story. With a mix of true crime details, cheeky commentary, and side tangents about fast food, this episode highlights the...

Angie Leon thought she had finally had the chance to start over, but a quiet morning in Nampa, Idaho, changed everything. Join Dani and Stephanie in this episode of The Lethal Library as they explore a true crime story that shook law enforcement, the courts, and an entire community. Angie, a young mother of three, faced horrific abuse from her ex-husband, Abel Ramirez Leon, who continually violate...

n this wild and tragic tale from Idaho and Utah, Dani and Stephanie unravel the chaotic and heartbreaking story of Natalie Turner, her ex-husband John Ock, and Natalie's fiancé, David Gaylor. A dramatic custody battle over two children escalates into a bitter war that spills into gunfire, leaving Natalie dead, John critically injured, and David facing serious charges. Tune in for an episode f...

In this episode of The Lethal Library, Dani and Stephanie look into the unsolved case of Christopher Reese, a 25-year-old man brutally murdered during a robbery at Jackson's Food Store in Notus, Idaho. Despite a meticulously planned heist, the suspects left behind crucial evidence, and years later the case remains open. The hosts discuss the crime's impact on the small town, the laughabl...

In this episode of The Lethal Library, Dani and Stephanie look into a chilling case that rocked Idaho in 2016. Steven Nelson, a man simply looking for companionship, faced a brutal and fatal attack near Lake Lowell. Join us as we unravel the details of this heinous crime, the shocking aftermath, and the infuriating shortcomings in Idaho's hate crime legislation. Along the way, we sprinkle in...

Get ready for another unbelievable tale as Dani and Stephanie dive into the 2015 Boise triple homicide committed by a champ of criminal stupidity, Adam Dees. We'll unpack the tragic story of the Welp family and how a foolhardy attempt at robbery turned into a horrifying crime. Think stolen credit cards, useless disguises, and the worst escape plan you've ever heard. We also highlight the...

Join Dani and Stephanie as they dive into the chilling tale of Todd C. Hagnis, who turned a simple arson call near Boise Airport into a grisly double homicide investigation. Discover how a mundane porch beer and lighter led detectives to ghastly hidden bodies and a bizarre confession. We'll take you through the harrowing and methodical police work, and the perplexing twists that left everyone...