The Guessnicity Podcast

What happens when someone believes the law no longer applies to them? This week, Luther is joined by Ty to explore three real cases involving sovereign citizens whose encounters with law enforcement ended in tragedy. From a routine traffic stop and a deadly eviction standoff to a planned ambush that shocked the nation, these stories reveal just how dangerous anti-government extremism can become.

This week on The Guessnicity Podcast, Luther flies solo to explore three workplace crimes that turned deadly. From a coworker murder and a whistleblower assassination and to a manager found dead behind a Pizza Hut, these cases prove that sometimes the most dangerous place isn't the streets—it's work.

On this episode of The Guessnicity Podcast , Tam and Bri join me as we break down a deadly hit-and-run, a viral airport incident, a disturbing child abuse case, and a heartbreaking family tragedy. From unbelievable to unimaginable, this episode will keep you guessing until the very end. Sorry for the audio quality. Our laptop crashed and Tam ended up having to record on our iPad.

Since I missed a week I decided keep some of extra off topic conversations I normally cut and leave in the uncut episode. Sorry for leaving you guys hanging. On this episode of Guessnicity , I’m joined by Kent, Jess, and Ty as we take you through a series of cases that all have one thing in common… They happened in public. From a movie theater incident that left an entire audience walking out… to...

A routine flight. A normal day. Then gunshots at 22,000 feet. On this episode of The Guessnicity Podcast , I break down the terrifying story of a flight that went from calm to catastrophic in just minutes. I’ll walk you through it like you were there… and leave out just enough for you to make the call. Can you guess who? This is my first solo episode. So be nice. 

On this episode of The Guessnicity Podcast, I’m joined by Ty, Tam, and Tomeka as we dive into some truly disturbing and unpredictable cases. From a trusted professional hiding a dark secret, to a man whose shocking confession unraveled a brutal crime, to a married couple at the center of a prostitution and racketeering investigation—this episode has it all. As always, we break it down, react in re...

On this episode of The Guessnicity Podcast , I’m joined by Kent and Ty as we break down the Dayton Webber story—a quadruple amputee who shot and killed his friend. Then we lighten things up with some wild cases, from an arrest at Chuck E. Cheese to a tense hostage standoff. It’s a mix of shocking moments and hilarious commentary—classic Guessnicity energy.

On this episode of The Guessnicity Podcast , I’m joined by Jess and Becky for a fun one. We kick things off with a listener-submitted case from Cassie involving a man who claims he didn’t get what he paid for at a strip club. Then we switch it up with a series of cases where every suspect is named either Jessica or Becky. It’s chaotic, hilarious, and full of classic Guessnicity energy.

On this episode of The Guessnicity Podcast , I’m joined by Ty as we kick things off by reacting to bodycam footage from inside a frat house after police and firefighters respond to a smoke alarm call. Then we switch things up with some rapid-fire cases where every suspect happens to share the same name—Tyrone. It’s chaotic, hilarious, and classic Guessnicity fun.

On this episode I am joined by the ladies!!! Tam, Jess, and Tomeka. We start off the show talking about the Richard Ferguson case and verdict. From there we jump into our standard Guessnicity format and I bring two cases sent in by listeners and one I brought. This episode will most definitely keep you on your toes. Did you get any right? On this episode of Guessnicity.

On this episode of The Guessnicity Podcast , I’m joined by Ty and J Cal as we dive into cases involving police officers who were arrested or fired for their actions. As the stories unfold, a clear pattern begins to emerge, leading to a deeper question and some real dialogue. Tune in for a wild episode filled with debate, and classic Guessnicity energy.

On this episode of The Guessnicity Podcast , I’m joined once again by Tam and her little sister Bri. We break down one case I brought to the table along with three wild listener-submitted cases. From a criminal who chose a very tight hiding spot, to a medical student with neighbor issues, to a drunk school bus driver—this episode has it all. All that and more on Guessnicity .

On this episode of The Guessnicity Podcast , I’m joined by Tam, Meka, and Ty. Ty and Meka kick things off with a big announcement before we dive into chilling cases of serial killer couples. Buckle up for a wild and entertaining ride—this one’s packed with twists, debate, and our signature guessing game. Can you guess who?

On this episode of The Guessnicity Podcast , Jess and Kent are back for another fun ride. We dive into cases where the suspects are current or former members of the military—but with a twist. Not only do we guess the race, we also try to guess which branch they served in. Can you guess who?

On the first episode of Season 3 of The Guessnicity Podcast , I’m joined by Tam and our daughters for another family affair. We dive into cases where suspects called 911 to make false claims—turning the tables and pointing fingers at themselves. Can you guess who’s lying about the crimes being committed?

On this season finale of The Guessnicity Podcast, it’s a true family affair as we dig into cases involving crimes committed against family members—and I’m joined by several of my guests from throughout the year. Thank you to everyone who listens and supports the show; this episode is dedicated to you. Enjoy this longer, special edition of Guessnicity, and I’ll see you again in 2026!

On this season finale of The Guessnicity Podcast, it’s a true family affair as we dig into cases involving crimes committed against family members—and I’m joined by several of my guests from throughout the year. Thank you to everyone who listens and supports the show; this episode is dedicated to you. Enjoy this longer, special edition of Guessnicity, and I’ll see you again in 2026!

Recorded during Thanksgiving week, this episode of The Guessnicity Podcast is a family affair once again as I’m joined by Tam and the girls. We break down a drive-thru altercation, a chronic butt-sniffer, a slick escape artist, and a murderous husband. It’s chaotic, hilarious, and full of classic Guessnicity energy—perfect for the holiday week.

On this episode of The Guessnicity Podcast, I’m joined by Kent and Ty as we kick things off with a quick chat about AI before diving into the cases. From a man committing unspeakable acts against a 6-year-old, to a shady barber, a sledgehammer attack, and even a soccer player gone rogue—this episode covers it all. Tune in for chaos, conversation, and classic Guessnicity energy.

Ty is back on The Guessnicity Podcast! He gives us an update on his surgery and recovery before we dive into three wild cases—a shady tow company, a killer cop, and a deplorable pediatrician. It’s equal parts outrageous and eye-opening, with plenty of laughs along the way.

On this episode of The Guessnicity Podcast, I’m joined by Jess for an honest and heartfelt conversation. She opens up about her past, clears up an old 11:59 rumor, and shares personal stories about losing her brother and growing up with a stepdad who was a police officer. It’s real, reflective, and a side of Jess you’ve never heard before.

In this episode of The Guessnicity Podcast, it’s a true family affair! I’m joined by Tam and our daughters as we tackle a mix of wild and surprising cases—from an unsuspecting drug dealer to an entitled airline passenger, and a mysterious missing phlebotomist. It’s laughter, guesses, and family fun all wrapped into one unforgettable episode of Guessnicity.

It’s Halloween on The Guessnicity Podcast! Ty, Kent, and Jess join me to uncover real-life monsters—from killers who lived with corpses to one who served human meat from his BBQ stand. Dark, disturbing, and unforgettable—this is Guessnicity: House of Horrors.

On this episode of The Guessnicity Podcast , I’m joined by Meka and Ty as we tackle two listener-submitted cases. From an 11-vehicle carjacking and a fake UPS worker to a killer backpacker and a coach-turned-youth-minister scandal, this one’s packed with chaos and conversation. Tune in for the wild ride!

On this episode of The Guessnicity Podcast, I’m joined by Tam and her sister Bri as we expose church leaders who were anything but holy. From a priest who impregnated his victim to a Christian school principal accused of abuse—we’re diving into the scandals behind the pulpits. All that and more in this can’t-miss episode.