Paul Goetz

The Follow-Up Showdown

Tv EN ↓ 118 episodes

A podcast that focuses on sequel-less films and underwhelming sequels themselves. Hosts and guests submit competing pitches in hopes of finding a truly worthy successor to the original.

Be sure to visit the podcast's website and support the creator: soundcloud.com

Author

Paul Goetz

Category

Tv

Podcast website

soundcloud.com

Latest episode

Nov 17, 2026

Where to listen?

Podcasts in the app Replaio Radio Coming soon

Podcasts are coming to the app soon. Install now and be the first to see a whole new take on podcasts

Get it on Google Play Install for free Android 10M+ downloads · 4.7+ rating iOS soon

Episodes

Ep. 40 - "Homeward Bound II: Lost in San Francisco" w/ Paul Jr. 05.04.2021

SPECIAL PAUL JR. EDITION!! Travis and Lauren suffer through an incredible journey and Paul tries to keep a peaceful household when the incomparable Paul Jr. joins the pack for a sniff around 1996's "Homeward Bound II: Lost in San Francisco."

Ep. 39 - "Casablanca" w/ David Seltzer 29.03.2021

SEASON FINALE!!! Grievances are aired, favorite fruits are listed and returning guest David Seltzer discovers that he's just not a "line guy" when the popcorn party postulates a sequel to the 1942 untouchable classic, "Casablanca."

Ep. 38B - "Back to the Future Part IV" Part II 23.03.2021

A FOLLOW-UP SHOWDOWN ROADSHOW!!! Travis and Lauren share their thoughts and feelings on the "Back to the Future" trilogy as well as their joint pitch for a Part Four while moving from Los Angeles to North Carolina.

Ep. 38A - "Back to the Future Part IV" w/ Robert Doyle, Lauren Goetz & Adam Grun 23.03.2021

Movie feels, old-timey business logos and sympathies for Biff Tannen are brought to the table when Paul and guests Robert Doyle, Lauren Goetz and Adam Grun grace the world with contenders for the fourth installment to the "Back to the Future" franchise. Whose will take the "Welcome Home, Uncle Joey" cake? This time, YOU decide!!!

Ep. 37 - "The Jesus Rolls" w/ Travis Rae & Tony Vinci 15.03.2021

Three Gentlemen of Lebowski search far and wide for unsung heroes when guests Travis Rae and Tony Vinci join Paul in the gutter for a viewing of 2020's "The Jesus Rolls."

Ep. 36 - "Forrest Gump" w/ Robin Ferris-Hanson 08.03.2021

Guest Robin Ferris-Hanson leads a mindful meditation, Paul regrets some poorly chosen words and Lauren pinch hits when the Guff Gallery gives it to 1994's "Forrest Gump."

Ep. 35 - "Ripley's Game" / "Ripley Under Ground" 01.03.2021

Lauren's super-senses earn her a nickname, Paul lectures about upstairs apartment etiquette and Travis goes full Hannibal when the repo team of the silver screen goes cat-to-mouse with 2002's "Ripley's Game" and 2005's "Ripley Under Ground."

Ep. 34 - "Bring It On Again" w/ Jen Seltzer & Alex Tempel 22.02.2021

The Seltzer Sisters provide expert commentary while Paul and other guest Alex Tempel have logistical questions when 2004's "Bring It On Again" gets the takedown treatment.

Ep. 33 - "Avatar" w/ Mario Colli-Moon 16.02.2021

Paul recounts his days as a "sh*t-uponer" and Laurvis McKorney is unleashed when guest Mario Colli-Moon returns to aid in outshining the yet-to-be-released sequels to 2009's "Avatar."

Ep. 32 - "Son of the Mask" w/ Ethan Edenburg 08.02.2021

Everybody boos at least once when the passionate pinheads reunite with guest Ethan Edenburg for a spirited debate on 2005's "Son of the Mask."

Ep. 31 - "Beetlejuice" w/ Becca & Zak White 01.02.2021

Paul gives a live candy bar review and Travis welcomes him to the gutter when guests Becca and Zak White join our goofy guild in extending the saga of 1988's "Beetlejuice."

Ep. 30 - "She's All That" w/ Adam Hofbauer 20.01.2021

Prom politics are analyzed, Guest Adam Hofbauer over-prepares and we all get a glimpse of what the world would be like if Travis had the powers of a studio executive in this fan-fueled episode focused on 1999's "She's All That."

Ep. 29 - "The Room" w/ Nick Gartner & Erin Marie Hogan 11.01.2021

Pizza toppings, hairlines and proximity to genitals are obligatory subject matter when Paul sets out to prolong 2003's "The Room" with guests Nick Gartner and Erin Marie Hogan.

Ep. 28 - "Lost Boys: The Tribe" w/ Brooks Hall 05.01.2021

Guest hosts Steve Clemmons & Katie Hoyt establish the "Minute-to-Michael Ratio" and guest judge Brooks "BJ" Hall doesn't want to go into Paul's imagination during a high stakes face-off with 2008's "Lost Boys: The Tribe."

Ep. 27 - "Thelma & Louise" 28.12.2020

The Cinema Successors have the impudence to follow up a "fixed point" in movie history. It's the ultimate challenge: Continuing the story of 1991's "Thelma & Louise."

Ep. 26 - "Beauty and the Beast: The Enchanted Christmas" w/ Sierra Green & Jason Peugh 21.12.2020

Deck the halls. Skip the songs. Avoid the quicksand. These and more are the lessons learned and discussed when the cheery chuckleheads get the better of 1997's "Beauty and the Beast: The Enchanted Christmas" with gleeful guests Sierra Green and Jason Peugh.

Ep. 25 - "While You Were Sleeping" w/ Kelly Nienaltowski & Mark Whitten 14.12.2020

Paul gives gifts, a new record is set and Adam Sandler comes up a lot somehow when the festive foursome are joined by guests Kelly Nienaltowski and Mark Whitten for a Christmas chronicling of 1995's "While You Were Sleeping." Featuring guest host Lauren Goetz.

Ep. 24 - "Highlander II: The Quickening" w/ Sachin Medhekar 07.12.2020

There should've only been one. At least that's what Paul and guest Sachin Medhekar argue about 1991's "Highlander II: The Quickening" in an episode that doubles as our unwitting tribute to the late Sir Sean Connery.

Ep. 23 - "S. Darko" 30.11.2020

Ever wonder which of our hosts was the coolest in their twenties? Find out definitively when the opinionated oddballs supplant 2009's "S. Darko."

Ep. 22 - "Blade Runner 2049" 23.11.2020

A CONTINUATION CELEBRATION! In the spirit of the holiday, the self-appointed sequel specialists give thanks to 2017's "Blade Runner 2049" and discover the epic sass of director Ridley Scott in the process.

Ep. 21 - "Twister" w/ Dustin Weiskopf 16.11.2020

Garth Brooks' acting career is discussed and a new Travis-based segment is solidified when single movie superfan Dustin Weiskopf gets in on the fun of prolonging the tale of 1996's "Twister."

Ep. 20 - "Sex and the City 2" w/ Aliya Kamalova, Anaika Miller, Marina Miller & Kim Seltzer 09.11.2020

Compliments are freely exchanged, fun facts are personalized and Hollywood is introduced to new powerhouse filmmakers The Millers when Paul and guests say to hell with the format whilst reimagining 2010's "Sex and the City 2."

Ep. 19 - "The Matrix" Series w/ Mario Colli-Moon 02.11.2020

Travis critiques the way we all think and guest Mario Colli-Moon introduces half votes when the Trivial Trinity spar over 2003's "Matrix" sequels.

Ep. 18 - "It Follows" w/ Jason Peugh 26.10.2020

Greatest scares, Full House character assignments and an invasive tiebreaker haunt our hosts as they are joined by scare actor Jason Peugh for a Halloween episode focused on 2014's "It Follows."

Ep. 17 - "The Fly II" w/ Will Runyon Jr. 20.10.2020

Paul adds to a personal saga while his cousin neighbors a Covid-19 hot spot when the clunky bunch sticks it to 1989's "The Fly 2." With Will Runyon Jr.

Listen to the The Follow-Up Showdown podcast in Replaio

Radio and podcasts in one app - free, with no sign-up. Install today and do not miss the launch

Get it on Google Play

Replaio is not a podcast publisher; show names, artwork and audio belong to their authors and are distributed through public RSS feeds.