Paul Goetz

The Follow-Up Showdown

Tv EN ↓ 118 episodes

A podcast that focuses on sequel-less films and underwhelming sequels themselves. Hosts and guests submit competing pitches in hopes of finding a truly worthy successor to the original.

Be sure to visit the podcast's website and support the creator: soundcloud.com

Author

Paul Goetz

Category

Tv

Podcast website

soundcloud.com

Latest episode

Nov 17, 2026

Where to listen?

Podcasts in the app Replaio Radio Coming soon

Podcasts are coming to the app soon. Install now and be the first to see a whole new take on podcasts

Get it on Google Play Install for free Android 10M+ downloads · 4.7+ rating iOS soon

Episodes

Ep. 63 - "The Super Mario Bros Movie" w/ Mario-Colli Moon 17.04.2023

A SHOWDOWN FOLLOW-UP!!! Mario butt-shames a cat. Paul speaks without knowing the canon. Lauren has scoring FOMO and Travis is a fuddy-duddy. Let's a-go!

Ep. 62 - "Indiana Jones & the Temple of Doom"/ "Indiana Jones & the Last Crusade" w/ Sachin Medhekar 03.04.2023

An episode of a different show from the future.

Ep. 52B - "Son of Frankenstein" w/ Kelly McDevitt 20.03.2023

Paul unveils a secret episode. Guest Kelly McDevitt pinpoints the surest sign of a feminist tale. Travis doesn't just mean to be counter. Lauren's hopes for a monster baby are dashed. Who doesn't love a bonus?

Ep. 61 - "Creed III" w/ Mario Colli-Moon* 06.03.2023

A SHOWDOWN FOLLOW-UP!!! Lauren does have to go. Mario is owed a treat. Paul & Travis make due. *Ding Ding*

Ep. 60 - "Hannibal" w/ Pacific Obadiah 20.02.2023

Lauren keeps a superpower in her back pocket. Paul f*cking loses it. Travis has a potentially prophetic dream and special guest Pacific Obadiah knows what he's doing in our longest episode ever!! Fptfptfptfptfptfptfptfptfptfptfptfptfpt (*the sound of a human liver paired with fava beans being eaten and subsequently washed down with a nice chianti*).

Ep. 59 - "French Connection II" 06.02.2023

Lauren divulges how Travis takes his coffee. Paul performs live. Anybody wanna a milkshake?

Ep. 58 - "They Call Me MISTER Tibbs!" 23.01.2023

Paul regrets a gift. Travis and Lauren team up on a bawdy joke. Yeahhh. OH YEEEEAAAAHHHHH!

Ep. 57 - "More American Graffiti" w/ Tony Interdonato & Chris Newell 09.01.2023

Travis and Paul have big reactions to each other's reactions. Lauren and guest Chris Newell relive their cruising days while other guest Tony Interdonato gets unhinged with his pitch. Peace and love y'all.

Ep. 56 - "Avatar: The Way of Water" w/ Mario Colli-Moon 26.12.2022

A SHOWDOWN FOLLOW-UP!!! Travis and Mario curse up a storm and have trouble counting to four. Lauren counts fine but curses the absolute most. Paul keeps it clean and numerically correct. Merry Christmas!!!

Ep. 55 - "Rocky II" 12.12.2022

Travis makes Lauren cry. Lauren makes Paul get good and spicy. Paul makes Travis lose control of his tone and face. It's gonna be a good one, ya know?

Ep. 54 - "Titanic II" w/ Erin Marie Hogan 28.11.2022

Travis makes a game-changing proposal. Lauren gets her own segment. Paul looks to you for support of his underrepresented opinion. Guest Erin Marie Hogan brings about a landmark episode with her insider's insight. Podcast, straight ahead!!!

Ep. 53 - "Fargo" Season One w/ Dustin Weiskopf 14.11.2022

A CONTINUATION CELEBRATION! Paul has notes but also solutions. Travis and Lauren remember guest Dustin Weiskopf but also not completely. Oh yah? Yah.

Ep. 52 - "The Bride of Frankenstein" w/ Kelly McDevitt 31.10.2022

A CONTINUATION CELEBRATION! The crew talks the first two "Frankenstein" movies with their biggest fan, Kelly McDevitt. This leads to a discussion on who is the hunkiest man of all time. Naturally. Happy Halloween!!!

Ep. 51 - "Easy Rider: The Ride Back" w/ Nick Gartner 17.10.2022

Paul gets things wrong. Travis has heard it before. Lauren supposes some men are young. Guest Nick Gartner is Jane Fonda. Far out, man.

Ep. 50 - "The Last Days of Patton" w/ Keith Watson 03.10.2022

Travis doesn't recognize a word : 0 Guest Keith Watson promotes the Riverfront Times' "Best Movie Theater in St. Louis." : D Lauren has to work :( Paul steals all the pitches ;) Happy 50th!!!!!

Ep. 49 - "My Blue Heaven" 19.09.2022

We break the unofficial sequel to "Goodfellas"'s balls. Martin Scorsese will hate Travis if his movie gets made. Paul can't get his Malkovich past a Walken. Lauren finds kindred rage spirits. Hit the 'eys and the ohs.

Ep. 48 - "Texasville" w/ Aliya Kamalova 05.09.2022

The episode gets lost. Paul invites original guest Aliya Kamalova to join him in recounting what they can about the nineteen years later sequel to "The Last Picture Show." Hamburger Helper is discussed. Now we're cookin' with gas!

Ep. 47 - "Toy Story 2" 22.08.2022

A CONTINUATION CELEBRATION! A young Lauren walks into a Jim Carrey based nightmare. Paul and Travis debate techniques for befriending Bonnies. An old contest is settled and a new theme is introduced. Welcome to Season Three.

Season Three Trailer 15.08.2022

You know what they say, third time's a theme.

Ep. 46 - "Blade Runner: Black Lotus" 08.03.2022

A SHOWDOWN FOLLOW-UP!!! The power of a great theme song saves the day when the bombastic bingers blast through 2021/2022's "Blade Runner: Black Lotus."

Ep. 45 - "And Just Like That" w/ Aliya Kamalova & Kim Seltzer 08.03.2022

A SHOWDOWN FOLLOW-UP!!! Guests Kim and Aliya provide a fresh perspective while Paul tries and fails not to talk too much when the three of them refuse to be gaslit by 2021/2022's "And Just Like That."

Ep. 44 - "Highlander 3: The Sorcerer" w/ Sachin Medhekar 07.01.2022

A SHOWDOWN FOLLOW-UP!!! What does illusion mean? Can immortals truly love? Where does decapitation start? These and more questions are asked but not necessarily answered when Sachin Medhekar rejoins the gleesome threesome for one final gathering about 1994's "Highlander 3: The Sorcerer."

Ep. 43 - "The Matrix Resurrections" w/ Mario Colli-Moon 31.12.2021

A SHOWDOWN FOLLOW-UP!!! Minds are waggled, Denny's misses an opportunity and the internet lies to guest Mario Colli-Moon when the big screen bandits actually find themselves in agreement about 2021's "The Matrix Resurrections."

Ep. 42 - "He's All That" 10.12.2021

A SHOWDOWN FOLLOW-UP!!! A two decade dry spell, thirty minute shoot days and a fifty year old man are all theories presented by the Team de Talkies about WTF happened to 2021's "He's All That."

Ep. 41 - "Ghostbusters: Afterlife" w/ Zak White 03.12.2021

A SHOWDOWN FOLLOW-UP!!! Self-made sound effects, Ruddy runs and misused mini marshmallow men make fine fodder for the trifling trio's return to the airwaves as they vary in opinions about 2021's "Ghostbusters: Afterlife" with returning guest Zak White.

Listen to the The Follow-Up Showdown podcast in Replaio

Radio and podcasts in one app - free, with no sign-up. Install today and do not miss the launch

Get it on Google Play

Replaio is not a podcast publisher; show names, artwork and audio belong to their authors and are distributed through public RSS feeds.