The Creep Off

The Creep Off

Congratulations, you have discovered the greatest and only comedy true crime competition on the internet! Every week our hosts Karl and Vinnie go head-to-head and each make their nominations for the biggest creep in any given category. Then You the listener get to decide the points, and the loser spins the dreaded wheel of consequences. 

Author

The Creep Off

Category

True Crime

Podcast website

www.podomatic.com

Latest episode

Jul 6, 2026

Where to listen?

Podcasts in the app Replaio Radio Coming soon

Podcasts are coming to the app soon. Install now and be the first to see a whole new take on podcasts

Get it on Google Play Install for free Android 5M+ downloads · 4.8 rating iOS soon

Episodes

Episode 121: Kids Just Can’t Play Outside Anymore 11.07.2022

This week Karl & Vinnie make their nominations for the biggest creep from the land of the rising sun Japan: In the scum parade we meet a drug mule and her online boyfriend, a terrible tenant and fake cop in a pickup truck: Less than 30 tickets remain for the Creep Off Live featuring the Roast of Karl & Vinnie tickets are available at Creepoffroast.com Here are the links to this week’s scum...

Episode 120: The One with the Cow Bikini 06.07.2022

This week Vinnie is joined by special guest host Kowell Hamburger (Karl in a bikini) and our pal Mark to discover who is the creepiest dairy farmer: In the scum parade we meet a really hot mom, an amateur paramedic and a very jealous meth enthusiast!  Read the full stories here  mini-pit-bull-stolen-ozone-park-2.jpg (2000×3418) (nypost.com) Maui man accused of fatally electrocuting girlfriend seve...

Episode 119: Variety is the Spice of Meth 27.06.2022

This week Karl & Vinnie make their nomination for biggest creep from the Aloha State of Hawaii: In the scum parade we meet a great lawyer, a terrible nurse and we check back in on one of our favorite pervs.  Check out the links to this week’s Scum Parade Stories  Man accused of climbing on roof of Mass. home, secretly recording girl as she changed (yahoo.com) Ohio Supreme Court suspends licens...

Episode 118: Keep the Receipt 20.06.2022

This week Karl and Vinnie search for the worst of the worst as they make their nominations for creepiest prison cell mate. This week's creeps will make even the hardest criminal dry heave: In other news Karl spins the wheel and lands on a brand-new consequence  Check out the stories we covered in this week’s scum parade:    Woman set fires in DeWitt apartment building 3 times in 4 days, police say...

Episode 117: Serious Calls Only! 13.06.2022

In this lighthearted edition of the Creep Off Karl and Vinnie dabble in substitute teaching. Karl debuts a brand-new SJ deep fake video: In the scum parade we get down to the bottom of what's really wrong with the media...they are lazy. Support the show, find us on patreon and get cool exclusive merch To learn more about the creeps in this weeks Scum Parade here are some helpful links Owner of Mas...

Episode 116: Why Do We Podcast? 06.06.2022

This week Karl and Vinnie make their nominations for creepiest butcher: In the scum parade we meet a slapable Popeye's employee, a man who hid his father's poodle and quite possibly the worst teacher's assistant of all time, check out the stories here:   Popeyes Chicken Manager Arrested For Allegedly Slapping Teen Employee In The Face (yahoo.com)   Man, 33, Confessed To Burying His Father's Dog Al...

Episode 115: No Rubber Ducky 01.06.2022

This week Karl & Vinnie dive into the world of Pest Control Workers and spin the tandem wheel of consequences: In the Scum Parade we meet a pissed off and on trailer park resident, a shitty surf shop patron and a very scary pimp. Please consider supporting the show on Patreon, and enjoy bonus episodes and exclusive merch Here are the links to this week’s scum parade stories: Victim Doused With...

Episode 114: Two Sides to Every Story 23.05.2022

This week Karl & Vinnie make their nominations for creepiest real estate agent: In the scum parade we meet a newly convicted newlywed, a 5 year old Chinese bully and finally we learn how to “Incite prostitution”

Episode 113: Nashville Hangover Edition: "A Crime of Opportunity" 17.05.2022

In this special Scum Stream wide release Karl & Vinnie are joined by Cros & Trucker Andy while they all nurse hangovers and discuss some of the worst scum we have covered in a while, this episode was recorded in front of studio audience. 

Episode 112: Shame on Me 10.05.2022

This week Karl and Vinnie are joined by our pal Shuli Egar to discover who is the biggest creep from Nashville: In the scum parade we meet a Florida man who claims to be Jesus, a creepy British undertaker and we learn about a good old-fashioned case of jailhouse justice. For all things Shuli visit Shalomshuli.com

Episode 111: Knife, Knife, Ouch 03.05.2022

This week Karl & Vinnie celebrate mother's day by making their nominations for creepiest mom: Karl's Dinner with a listener consequence is finally determined: In the Scum Parade we meet a prank video call enthusiast, a modern-day witch hunter and a 14-year-old monster.  

Episode 110: I Don't Like Your Parents Either 25.04.2022

This week Karl & Vinnie make their nominations for the biggest creep in Alaska: We debut a brand new game from our friend Cardiff Electric: In the Scum Parade we meet a below average employee (even by TSA standards), A driving instructor who found love and a man who loved himself. 

Episode 109: It Is a Sin 18.04.2022

This week Karl & Vinnie celebrate Easter by making their nominations for creepiest priest: In the scum parade we meet a hungry fake cop, a man looking for a hitman on a budget and some Indian reptile enthusiasts. Support the show on Patreon  Vote this week Thecreepoff.com

Episode 108: Quit While You Are Ahead 12.04.2022

In this special creep off exhibition match Vinnie goes head to head with Dick Masterson to discover who is the creepiest mental health professional: In the scum parade we meet a one man member of the mile high club, a couple of star wars fans and a Scottish trans infant inmate. 

Episode 107: Free Sex 05.04.2022

This week Vinnie spins, and a new round begins. Listen as the boys go head-to-head in a no holds barred wildcard match: In the scum parade we learn about a man’s feud with a British hotel chain, we meet a couple that loved their dogs, and a demon hunting mother of a newborn. If you want to do a good thing you can donate to Dylan’s fundraiser: Dylan's Defenders (gofundme.com)

Episode 106: #106 Baby's Day Out 28.03.2022

This week Karl & Vinnie make their nominations for creepiest bartender and dish some red-hot Hollywood goss: In the Scum Parade we meet a man whose date was interrupted, we learn about a unique shopping experience you can only get in Rochester Ny and finally we meet a pair of forgetful new parents. 

Episode 105: There is No Such Thing As a Free Pony Ride 21.03.2022

This week Karl and Vinnie make their nominations for creepiest carnival worker: In the Scum Parade we meet a woman in labor who just wanted to the pain to stop, a prospective tanning salon employee and a very drunk and angry British crack head. You can vote now at thecreepoff.com Watch this episode on Rumble

Episode 104: Legalize Hugs 14.03.2022

In this week’s show Karl & Vinnie make their nominations for the biggest creep from the great state of Idaho: In the Scum Parade we meet a pizza man with a bladder issue, a man who only wanted to make his son the best he can be and a 10-year-old baby murderer. Vote this week at The Creep Off Support the show and get cool merch on Patreon

Episode 103: The Island of Dr.Moron 07.03.2022

In this edition of the creep of Karl & Vinnie make their nominations for Creepiest Fake Doctor, well one of them does: In the Scum Parade we meet a woman’s Only Fan, a lunatic from Cincinnati and a Father who leads by example: In other news Karl’s dinner with a listener date is chosen, and Vinnie accepts the challenge of a listener Vote this week at Thecreepoff.com Support the show on Patreon

Episode 102: Make Your Own Kind of Music 28.02.2022

In this wildcard edition of the Creep Off Karl & Vinnie had the freedom to pick any creep they want as long as they are not a pedophile or a murderer: In the scum parade we meet a Veterinarian who loved dogs, A brother who loved his sister and a woman who made her child a tattle tail  To vote this week visit: thecreepoff.com To help Vinnie Pick Karl's dinner date find us on patreon  

Episode 101: I Sniffed a Girl 21.02.2022

This week Karl & Vinnie celebrate President's Day by making their nominations for creepiest person to ever sit in the oval office: In the scum parade we meet a hungry drunk man, a driver with the worst intentions and a new mom: Karl spins the wheel of consequences and accepts a listener challenge We are currently 1 week and 28 patrons away from the official roast of Karl & Vinnie! Help mak...

Episode 100: Guess I'm The Idiot 14.02.2022

To celebrate 100 episodes Karl & Vinnie nominate creeps from their hometown Rochester NY: In the scum parade we meet another male nurse, a caregiver with a bad memory, a boyfriend who couldn’t keep his relationship or his girlfriend together and finally we close episode 100 with a friendly reminder about what happens to pedophiles in prison! Thanks for listening. Voting is officially back at t...

Episode 99: Prove Us Wrong 08.02.2022

In this week’s competition Karl & Vinnie nominate the biggest creeps from the state of Pennsylvania: The boys get into a spirited argument regarding Vinnie’s “Polar Plunge” Consequence: In the Scum Parade we meet an orally fixated equestrian, a pair of very strict parents and a man whose hatred of mayo was his hill to die on.  You can vote this week at: Episode #99 Voting | The Creep Off on Pa...

Episode 98: Virginia is for Puppy Lovers 31.01.2022

This week Karl & Vinnie Make their nominations for the biggest creep from the commonwealth of Virginia: In the Scum Parade we meet meth dealing animal trainer, the best Mom ever and a dad who’s no end job crushed his soul and his kid.  

Episode 97: The "Tails Never Fails" Fallacy 24.01.2022

 This week Karl & Vinnie were supposed to nominate their picks for creepiest dead musician, but Karl misunderstood the assignment: In the scum parade we meet a gentleman having a lark in the park, a nerd on a mission and a real mama’s cop Click here to  Vote for who you thought bought the biggest creep this week 

Listen to the The Creep Off podcast in Replaio

Radio and podcasts in one app - free, with no sign-up. Install today and do not miss the launch

Get it on Google Play

Replaio is not a podcast publisher; show names, artwork and audio belong to their authors and are distributed through public RSS feeds.