The Creep Off

The Creep Off

Congratulations, you have discovered the greatest and only comedy true crime competition on the internet! Every week our hosts Karl and Vinnie go head-to-head and each make their nominations for the biggest creep in any given category. Then You the listener get to decide the points, and the loser spins the dreaded wheel of consequences. 

Author

The Creep Off

Category

True Crime

Podcast website

www.podomatic.com

Latest episode

Jul 6, 2026

Where to listen?

Podcasts in the app Replaio Radio Coming soon

Podcasts are coming to the app soon. Install now and be the first to see a whole new take on podcasts

Get it on Google Play Install for free Android 5M+ downloads · 4.8 rating iOS soon

Episodes

Episode 96: Drag & Drop 18.01.2022

This week Karl & Vinnie make their nominations for creepiest White Supremacist: In the Scum Parade we meet a new mother, a man who went over the edge and a motocross circus stuntman who loves to mentor kids:   You can vote here Patreon.com/TheCreepOff

Episode 95: Prognosis Screw Loose 11.01.2022

This week country roads take Karl & Vinnie to West Virginia to search for the biggest creep from the Mountain State: In the Scum Parade we meet a randy door dasher, a scorched lover and a self-proclaimed millionaire who just wanted to be loved. 

Episode 94: Ooh-ooh That Smell 04.01.2022

This week Karl & Vinnie are joined in studio by Cros to make their nominations for biggest creep of 2021: In the scum parade we meet a very puzzling naked man, a fake autist and a Chinese couple just looking for a fresh start to their new year! 

Episode 3: Who Are These Creeps #2 26.12.2021

Hey folks, we hope that everyone is having a fun holiday weekend! Karl & Vinnie are traveling and will have a new episode out later in the week. Until then enjoy this special Patreon bonus edition of the show. 

Episode 93: Creepmas 2: Jailbait & Switch 20.12.2021

In this very special Christmas edition of the Creep-Off our pal Kevin joins us for an episode sure to fill you with holiday cheer: In the scum parade we check in on a 90’s child star, we meet a bruised knuckled Son in law and a Maryland man who decided to seize the day: Did we mention Karl spins the wheel?

Episode 92: America's Best Value 13.12.2021

This week Karl and Vinnie make their nominations for the biggest creep from America's "Natural State" Arkansas: In the Scum Parade we meet possibly the worlds laziest mother, a CNN producer and for once...an actual hero! 

Episode 91: Journals & Jesus 06.12.2021

This week Karl & Vinnie search the state of Rhode Island for their biggest creep: In the scum parade we meet an inconsiderate roommate, we learn why surgeries should not be performed with soldering irons and how procrastinating can turn 6 months into 40 years. 

Episode 90: All in the Family 29.11.2021

This week Karl and Vinnie make their nominations for Creepiest Security Guard: In the scum parade we meet a cat mom, a family man, and a heavily armed hero who simply wants his pizza! 

Episode 89: Creepsgiving 2: No Thanks 23.11.2021

This week Karl and Vinnie celebrate the second annual Creepsgiving by nominating the creepiest perpetrators of some of turkey day's biggest atrocities: In the Scum Parade we learn that even bad pizza is pizza, we meet a canine loving Alabama man & a booze blaming squatter.  Have a great Thanksgiving! 

Episode 88: She Loves Me For Me 16.11.2021

This week we find out that dead people don’t tell tales, but sometimes the stories get out anyway. Join Karl & Vinnie as the search for the creepiest Undertaker: In the scum parade we meet a gassy inmate, a body positive murderer and a couple that just really wanted a baby 

Episode 87: Humpday! 10.11.2021

In this weeks episode Vinnie & Karl make their nominations for the creepiest of the Hollywood Elite: In a jam packed edition of the Scum Parade we meet a scorned strip club patron, a terrible baby sitter/dog lover & a traumatized inmate.  Don't forget to vote at thecreepoff.com  Leave us a voicemail: 585-371-8108 

Episode 86: The Trains Don't Run to Thailand 02.11.2021

This week Karl and Vinnie leave no buffet unturned in their search for the worlds creepiest fatso: In the Scum parade we meet a strict Father, a true Kentucky legend and a moldy old lady: Karl spins the wheel of consequences! what will be his fate? Tune in to see.

Episode 85: It's a Viscous Cycle 26.10.2021

This week Karl & Vinnie celebrate their favorite holiday by nominating their biggest Halloween Creeps: In the scum parade we meet a real pumpkin head, A couple celebrating their first anniversary and a new father with a million dollar arm. 

Episode 84: Karl's Off 18.10.2021

In this special one off episode Vinnie & Eric Zane go head to head in a wildcard round. The stakes are high in this battle if Vinnie loses he will take the polar plunge if Eric loses he will do the “30 day Truck Nuts” consequence: In the Scum Parade we meet a opportunistic burglar, a miniature horse lover and a holey baby  For all things Eric Zane visit EricZaneShow.com To vote this week visit...

Episode 83: Price Check 12.10.2021

This week Karl and Vinnie make their nominations for the world’s biggest Comic Con Nerd: In the scum parade we meet an innovative fast food worker, an Alabama father to be and a mother who simply took her baby shopping. 

Episode 82: Is He Okay? 04.10.2021

This week Karl & Vinnie are joined by our new pal Eric Zane from the Eric Zane Show to celebrate the start of Jocktober with our second attempt to discover who is the creepiest radio personality of all time: In the Scum Parade we meet a woman who just wanted to cuddle longer, A man who just wanted to keep God happy and finally we learn why living in Syracuse is a health risk. To Vote: https://...

Episode 81: Hey This Guy is Not a Doctor! 27.09.2021

This week Vinnie & Karl go back to school and nominate their choices for creepiest elementary teacher: In the scum parade we meet a wildly dysfunctional couple, a pervy pastor and the worst of them all a male nurse. 

Episode 80: C-3PEEHOLE 20.09.2021

This week Karl & Vinnie search for the biggest creep from France: It’s baby tossing season In this week’s Scum parade. We also come up with new business ideas and learn about a fun new trend called “Sounding”! 

Episode 79: Concrete Enema 13.09.2021

This week the boys are joined by Weird Medicine’s Dr. Steve! Listen as they try to discover who is the creepiest medical professional of all time: Dr. Steve gives us all an update on his battle with Covid 19: In the Scum Parade we meet the “cool” mom, a piss collector and a former Marine in the service of God.  Check out the  Weird Medicine Podcast  or weekly on Sirius/XM Faction Talk Follow Dr. S...

Episode 78: Greetings from Gary Indiana 09.09.2021

In the triumphant return to the studio plans changed and we had no choice but to have a wildcard round: In the Scum Parade we meet a man who hated his mother in law, we learn why sharing CP on social media is not a great idea and that cages for people are so 2019 

Episode 2: Scum Stream Bonus Episode 30.08.2021

Karl & Vinnie are traveling this week. Enjoy the audio version of the first ever Scum Stream Bonus episode! Check out Patreon for a brand new bonus episode with Dick Masterson from the Dick Show! patreon.com/thecreepoff

Episode 77: Kindergarten Cookout 24.08.2021

This week Karl and Vinnie return to China, spoiler they have a lot of creeps in China: In the scum parade we check in on a British clown, we meet a very disappointed grandmother and her equestrian grandson,  finally another horrific murder lands at Karl's club feet. 

Episode 76: A Passion for Justice 16.08.2021

In this weeks jammed pack episode Karl & Vinnie submit their nominations for biggest creep in China: We head back down to the basement with a Mathew Lewinski update: In the Scum Parade We meet a woman who’s got the moves, a pissed off Coroner and a stern reminder that kids can be creeps too: Karl reaches 5 points and Vinnie spins the wheel of consequences (spoiler he is not happy about it): Fi...

Episode 2: Creeps 'N Roses: Box of Gimmicks 11.08.2021

In this episode Vinnie, Brian McBride, RJ Purpura & Mike Barry watch with bated breath to find out who gets the first impression rose from Colton Underwood. You would not believe this, but there was a surprising amount of work that went into an episode that sounds this terrible. Enjoy! 

Episode 75: About Creeps, by Creeps, for Creeps 09.08.2021

This week the boys dig their toes into the pacific sand and make their nominations for the biggest creep from the land of the rising sun: In the Scum Parade we meet an amateur photographer, A man who forgot his password and we break the story on a very very naughty notable WATP discord contributor. This one was tough

Listen to the The Creep Off podcast in Replaio

Radio and podcasts in one app - free, with no sign-up. Install today and do not miss the launch

Get it on Google Play

Replaio is not a podcast publisher; show names, artwork and audio belong to their authors and are distributed through public RSS feeds.