The Carton Show with Craig Carton & Chris McMonigle

Carlos Mendoza is OUT as Mets manager, but was he really the problem? Todd Zeile joins Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle on WFAN to deliver a powerful defense of Mendoza, saying he was sent into battle with "no weapons" and that the front office deserves far more blame. Zeile also questions David Stearns' roster construction, discusses Steve Cohen's role in the firing, and reveals what really happe...

Craig Carton & Comedian Paul Virzi talk about his new found friendship with Jaxson Dart, his upcoming tour, and they take calls on the Mets firing of Carlos Mendoza.

Friend of the Carton Show comedian Paul Virzi joins Craig to catch up on life including how the Knicks changed the way he viewed the world and how he views the Mets firing of Carlos Mendoza through a Yankees fans lens.

Craig and Petey react to the firing of Carlos Mendoza and the need for David Stearns to take ownership of the team's struggles. They explore the lack of accountability within the roster before shifting gears to discuss a unique summer drink recipe. 01:00 - Harvard's Influence on Stearns 03:17 - Demanding Mets Accountability 09:28 - Watermelon Espresso Drink Recipe

Craig Carton reviews Carlos Mendoza's departure statement and critiques David Stearns' performance as general manager. He considers the case for Wally Backman as a potential manager who could bring much-needed toughness to the organization. Additionally, the conversation touches on the fan experience at Citi Field and the hurdles of finding a viable replacement for Stearns. 01:00 - Mendoza's Farew...

Carton explains why Steve Cohen actually did Mendoza a favor, shifts the blame squarely onto David Stearns, questions the future of the Mets organization, and breaks down what happens next with Andy Green taking over as interim manager.

Bret Boone joins the guys at 97.3 The Fan in San Diego to give his perspective on one of the hottest topics in Baseball - as his Brother and Yankees Manager, Aaron Boone, had to straighten one of his stars out after a questionable decision.

Chris McMonigle breaks down a big series win for the Yankees, including a thrilling win in the series finale against Tarik Skubal. C-Mac raves about the season that Paul Goldschmidt is having, how the former MVP looks like his prime self, and the Yankees can only hope he keeps up this pace, especially while Giancarlo Stanton is out (7:58). Plus, reactions to that huge home run from Jasson Domingue...

Carton and Big Mac dissect the New York Mets’ historic defensive failure and the fan base's growing frustration with President of Baseball Operations David Stearns. They discuss the significance of the Pete Alonso chants and evaluate the team's trade assets as the season slips away. Additional topics include Nike's marketing of Victor Wembanyama and controversial rumors surrounding Hollywood legen...

Craig and Big Mac vent about the New York Mets' embarrassing doubleheader loss, focusing on a historically bad six-error performance and the subsequent fan revolt. They discuss the viral Pete Alonso chant, criticize the front office's roster construction, and debate if a leadership change is necessary to salvage the franchise's culture. 01:45 - Mets Hit Rock Bottom 05:02 - The Pete Alonso Decision...

Craig Carton reacts to his daughter's decision to attend a Mets game despite the team's ongoing struggles and recent blowout losses. They also debate a caller's claim that older fans may never see another Mets championship before discussing the Knicks revoking season tickets for playoff resales. Finally, the conversation turns to Nike's new Victor Wembanyama sneakers and a rumor about Jamie Lee Cu...

They evaluate the New York Mets' current irrelevance compared to the long-standing standard of the New York Yankees. The conversation touches on the leadership vacuum in the Mets' clubhouse following Steve Cohen's comments on team captains. They also preview an upcoming show featuring Plaxico Burress and Paul Virzi while debating viral social media trends and personal anecdotes. 01:50 - Mets Irrel...

Craig slams David Stearns over his roster construction as the Mets struggle with mounting defensive errors and failed reclamation projects. They highlight the massive run differential gap between the Yankees and the rest of the American League while discussing Paul Goldschmidt's MVP-level resurgence. The conversation also touches on past front office scandals and upcoming guests Paul Virzi and Pla...

It is June 25, 2026, and the New York Mets are officially a $370 million disaster zone. Craig Carton and Chris "Big Mac" McMonigle pull no punches as they declare the Mets completely irrelevant before the summer even gets rolling.

When Craig Carton suggests his co-host Chris McMonigle should throw out the first pitch at Yankee Stadium, things take a hilarious turn! Craig claims the fame is going straight to Chris's head, leading to an impromptu studio acting challenge to see how a "normal person" would actually react to the offer. Watch the chaos unfold as the Hoff, the intern, and an entirely clueless Gallo get dragged int...

Craig and Pete preview Plaxico Burress' upcoming guest appearance before diving into bizarre urban legends like the Marilyn Manson rib rumor. The conversation shifts to a viral video involving a JP Morgan executive and a heated debate over The Beatles' discography. They also discuss the Mets' bleak future compared to the 1990 Yankees and upcoming vacation plans. 01:00 - Plaxico Burress Guest Hosti...

Craig Carton goes OFF after Nike unveils a Statue of Liberty-themed sneaker for Victor Wembanyama featuring "You're Welcome" in English and French. Carton sees it as a slap in the face to Knicks fans after New York's NBA Finals victory, while Chris McMonigle thinks the shoe is actually hilarious because Wemby just lost to the Knicks.

Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle react to a longtime Knicks season ticket holder who says the team revoked his tickets after he sold his NBA Finals seats. Is the organization cracking down on ticket resellers, or is this unfair to loyal fans who've supported the team for decades?

The Carton Show and several callers vent about the New York Mets' embarrassing performance and growing fan apathy following a six-error game. They discuss the potential firing of manager Carlos Mendoza and whether Wally Backman or David Stearns can fix the franchise's clown show culture. 01:00 - Mets Fan Apathy 04:39 - Hiring Wally Backman 08:34 - David Stearns' Future 13:48 - Jeff Wilpon's Reacti...

After a disastrous Mets collapse, Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle react to the fan who started the viral "Pete Alonso" chant and explain why September could become a full-blown nightmare for David Stearns and the Mets front office. Will Mets fans give Alonso a hero's welcome when he returns to Citi Field with Baltimore? Could it become the loudest anti-management statement in franchise history? C...

After surrendering 20 runs in a disastrous doubleheader and committing SIX infield errors, Mets fans are fed up. Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle react to the growing outrage at Citi Field, the chants for Pete Alonso, the backlash against David Stearns, and whether Steve Cohen's biggest gamble has completely blown up in his face.

My Man Pots N' Pans Ohhhh Yeahhhh | The fellas break down a boring NBA Draft, the Mets are in total freefall, Aliens will reportedly abduct Neymar and fans at the World Cup, Craig makes his pitch for small-town Mayor, Jaxson Dart has crazy expectations, and much, much more. Tell Ya Friends!

Craig and Cmac discuss another Kodai Senga meltdown and also last night's NBA Draft might have been the worst ever. Plus, enough of the Anthony Volpe bashing.

Craig and Cmac discuss the massive expectations surrounding Jaxson Dart this season. Plus, apparently aliens will invade the World Cup and abduct Lionel Messi and Neymar tonight.

Craig and Cmac discuss the disaster at Citi Field. Are the Wilpons still running the Mets? Plus, Craig calls multiple local butchers to find the answer on pulled pork. That and much more.