The Carton Show with Craig Carton & Chris McMonigle

Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle debate whether Timothée Chalamet is a REAL Knicks fan, argue over the best owner in New York sports, break down the Knicks’ historic playoff run, roast “fake fandom,” and somehow spiral into Bernedoodles, Scarface quotes, Euphoria, and fake boobs

Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle react to the growing Jaxson Dart controversy after the Giants rookie introduced President Trump at a public event and why Craig believes people are overreacting to a young quarterback exercising free speech.

Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle break down the Jaxson Dart controversy after the Giants rookie introduced President Trump at a political event, Abdul Carter’s reaction, and why winning cures everything in New York sports. Plus, the guys react to the Knicks’ historic NBA Finals run, Penn Station chaos surrounding a potential Game 6 at MSG, and why Jim Dolan & Leon Rose deserve credit for taking a...

Things got completely unhinged on WFAN as Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle debated whether the Yankees postponing a game with the Rays means Chris is secretly SCARED of Tampa Bay.

Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle go completely off the rails talking Knicks NBA Finals tickets, outrageous Madison Square Garden prices, and whether Craig should try sneaking into the Finals with a PRESS PASS on WFAN.

Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle celebrate the Knicks punching their ticket to the NBA Finals and absolutely unload on all the national NBA analysts who mocked the Jalen Brunson signing.

Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle debate whether these New York Knicks are putting together the greatest playoff run in NBA history on WFAN.

Craig reacts to the Knicks’ dominant playoff run, calls out all the doubters who trashed Mike Brown, Mikal Bridges, and Leon Rose earlier this season, and explains why this Knicks team is unlike ANYTHING the NBA has ever seen. From Jalen Brunson’s leadership to the Knicks destroying teams in closeout games, Carton says this run has officially become historic. Plus, Craig gives credit to James Dola...

Is there any hope for the Mets to make a run towards a playoff spot? Boomer and Gio debated the likelihood, while Evan Roberts explained his doubts that the team is good enough to revive the season. Plus, reaction to Clay Holmes' injury and how the team can withstand it, and Craig Carton went scorched earth on the organization for giving Gary Carter's number to Nick Morabito before changing course...

The Yankees are showing concerning weaknesses, according to Tommy Lugauer, but they can be fixed by October. Plus, Evan and Tiki revisit their great debate over Aaron Judge's claim as the King of New York Sports. Chris McMonigle discusses Gerrit Cole's return, and Evan calls for Austin Wells to be sent down.

Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber wonder if this is the season of destiny for the Knicks as they go up 2-0 on the Cavs in the Eastern Conference Finals. Plus, Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle declare the Knicks unbeatable; Boomer & Gio celebrate the Knicks taking a 2-0 lead live at D’Jais in Belmar and why Boomer says this is the best Knicks team since 1999; Carton calls out all the Knicks and Jalen Br...

Chris McMonigle is NOT happy after the Yankee bats were nonexistent in the final two games of the series against Toronto, settling for a series split after being shut down by Trey Yesavage in game three and a committee of arms in the series finale, scoring just one run over the final two games. C-Mac sounded off on the "miserable" at-bats, the rough series finale by Jazz Chisholm, and the continue...

They celebrate the New York Knicks' commanding 2-0 series lead over the Cleveland Cavaliers while evaluating the team's defensive identity compared to the 1990s. The discussion also covers a wave of New York Giants news, including Joe Schoen's extension and injury updates for Malik Nabers. Finally, a heated debate breaks out over whether Jalen Brunson has officially surpassed Aaron Judge as the pr...

Craig and Big Mac celebrate the Knicks taking a 2-0 lead over the Cavaliers and analyze the team's defensive dominance. They also discuss the New York Giants' decision to extend Joe Schoen and the potential impact of Malik Nabers' injury. 01:20 - Knicks Take 2-0 Lead 06:10 - Greatest Knicks Defense Ever 12:33 - Joe Schoen Extension Debate 16:13 - Malik Nabers Injury Concerns 20:57 - Knicks NBA Fin...

They break down the New York Knicks' dominant playoff run and the massive expectations for a potential championship parade. The conversation covers Yankees roster updates, including Gerrit Cole's return and Anthony Volpe’s status, while exploring the history of New York sports culture. Anecdotes about SNL legends and the evolution of celebrity ownership add flavor to the local sports discourse. 01...

Craig and Big Mac debate whether Jalen Brunson has officially taken the King of New York crown from Aaron Judge. They also examine the polarizing reaction to Jackson Dart's political appearance and celebrate the legendary history of the New York Cosmos. 11:50 - Traffic Report 13:45 - Jackson Dart's Political Appearance 31:34 - Brunson vs. Judge Debate 42:13 - Judge's Infamous Outfield Error 51:10...

Craig and Big Mac react to the New York Giants' quiet announcement of a multi-year extension for GM Joe Schoen. They discuss Jalen Brunson’s historical standing with the Knicks, debate the greatest American soccer goalkeepers, and welcome Big Mac's son to predict Gerrit Cole’s return to the Yankees. These discussions take place on the Carton Show as the crew gears up for the holiday weekend. 01:20...

Gallo, Big Mac, and Pete face off in a holiday-themed trivia competition on the wheel. They test their knowledge on famous JBs, iconic New York sports managers, and classic Memorial Day staples. Big Mac and Pete secure victories as they successfully name lists of entities under pressure. 01:00 - Famous JBs Challenge 05:18 - NY Sports Manager Trivia 10:34 - Memorial Day Traditions

Who is the true King of New York sports right now: Aaron Judge or Jalen Brunson? Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle go all-in on one of the biggest debates in NYC sports.

New York Giants rookie quarterback Jaxson Dart is already making headlines before taking a regular season snap. Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle react after Dart appeared at a political rally to introduce President Donald Trump and Craig says the reaction from Giants fans is going to be completely divided.

Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle react to the Knicks taking a commanding 2-0 lead in the Eastern Conference Finals and debate whether New York is officially a one-basketball-team town. Craig says the Nets “don’t exist” in NYC sports culture and explains why the Knicks are the team that unites the city. The guys also dive into Alex Rodriguez being single again after appearing at Madison Square Gard...

Craig and Evan debate which New York team would have the biggest championship parade before diving into a history lesson on ticker tape records and the Salem Witch Trials. They also react to Rob Manfred's appearance at the Knicks game and analyze roster moves for the Yankees and Mets. Finally, they weigh the impact of significant injury news for the Giants as the Knicks move closer to the NBA Fina...

The Carton Show look back at Eddie Murphy's iconic SNL bits and Joe Piscopo's classic impersonations leads into a discussion about the challenges of parenting. They also explore the generational bond of sports fandom as the Knicks' deep playoff run creates scheduling conflicts for the upcoming holiday weekend. 01:00 - Eddie Murphy SNL Stories 04:16 - Whiskey Dares & Parenting 06:47 - Sports Fandom...

Craig & Chris analyze Josh Hart's humorous comments regarding analytics and the Knicks' unselfish team dynamic. They also offer food recommendations for Citi Field to a caller, debate the aesthetics of various delivery driver uniforms, and discuss the latest injury updates for Malik Nabers and the Giants. 01:00 - Knicks Chemistry 03:20 - Citi Field Food Tips 07:30 - Delivery Uniform Debate 09:53 -...

The New York Knicks are now TWO wins away from the NBA Finals and Craig Carton is officially all in. Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle react to the Knicks dominating the Cavaliers again, Josh Hart’s huge night, Jalen Brunson’s leadership, Mikal Bridges’ defense, and why this team might be the best Knicks squad ever assembled. Plus, the mood changes quickly when Craig turns his attention to the New...