The Bucklesberry Lemonade Podcast

In late May and early June of 1993, two violent crimes shook eastern North Carolina. On May 30, 1993, 65-year-old Audrey Leggett was working alone at Cherry’s Cupboard in Bear Grass, North Carolina when she was shot multiple times during an apparent robbery. Around $200 was taken. The weapon was a .22 caliber firearm. No arrests were made. Just seven days later, on June 6, 1993, a gunman hid insid...

In this episode of Bucklesberry Lemonade , we revisit a collection of North Carolina cases where the answers never came and the trail quietly went cold. Spanning decades and counties across the state, these stories include unexplained deaths, missing connections, and crimes that left more questions than conclusions. Some cases made headlines, others faded into local memory — but all remain unresol...

Tonight on BucklesBerry Lemonade , we step away from true crime and into the quiet, shadowed woods of the American South—where not every voice belongs to who you think it does. This episode features true paranormal encounters shared by listeners and firsthand witnesses, including: A gentle but unsettling ghostly presence in a farmhouse kitchen near Grifton, North Carolina A replay of the Appalachi...

He Blamed the Moon: The Williamston Murder That Shocked North CarolinaIn 1960, the murder of 17-year-old Judith Diane Hardison stunned the small town of Williamston, North Carolina — but what followed in court was even more disturbing. In this episode of BucklesBerry Lemonade, Tim breaks down the Jimmie Lee Honeycutt case, a historic North Carolina true crime story that featured one of the strange...

Unsolved True Crime Cases from the South’s Past – Where the Past Doesn’t Rest From moonlit lovers’ lanes to quiet front porches… and from highways that erase identities to a small Southern town shattered by gunfire—this episode dives deep into four of the most chilling true crime cases in Southern history . We begin with The Texarkana Moonlight Murders (1946) —the infamous Phantom Killer who stalk...

North Carolina’s Missing: The Last Ordinary Day Five people. Five separate disappearances. One shared truth: each of them woke up to what should have been an ordinary day — and were never seen again. In this episode of North Carolina’s Missing , we examine five unresolved missing persons cases from across the state, spanning different years, counties, and circumstances — yet all bound together by...

"Pull up a chair and pour a glass of tea—tonight, we’re traveling from the Blue Ridge peaks to the salt spray of the Outer Banks to uncover 7 of North Carolina's most enduring mysteries." In this special "Shadow Side" anthology, we explore the legends that live in the gaps of history. We lead with our anchor story, The Pactolus Light . Journey back to 1910 to hear the tragi...

Welcome to this episode- TRACES, PLACES, AND CASES: Where the Clues Don't Add Up! In this special, high-octane episode, we break down three of the most bizarre and frustrating UNSOLVED mysteries in American history, proving that the truth is often hidden in the last place you look—or in the clues that make the least sense. We investigate: The mystery of Brandon Lawson starts and ends with a ch...

Three victims. Three graveyards. Three stories the stones refused to bury. In this Southern Gothic true-crime episode of Bucklesberry Lemonade , Tim takes you deep into the chilling cases of: William Deshawn Hamilton — The Cemetery Child of DeKalb County Curry Spivey — The 15-Year-Old Found in a New Bern Cemetery Margaret Fetterolf — The Woodlawn Jane Doe Identified After 45 Years Each case began...

Four Florida women vanished under hauntingly strange circumstances — Jeana Burrus, Cindy Rogers, Susan Basile, and Gail Joiner. In this Southern-Gothic true crime deep dive, we uncover the clues, the theories, and the secrets the pines still keep.

NEW EPISODE: 50 States, 50+ Strange Unsolved True Crime Cases + BONUS STORY — The Tale of Two Irenes Dive into one of our most ambitious true crime episodes yet. We explore every U.S. state , uncovering mysterious unsolved homicides , chilling missing persons cases , and the strange patterns that still haunt investigators decades later. From small-town vanishings to cases with eerie coincidences,...

A chilling 20-year pattern of disappearances and death in East Lumberton, NC — a killer who may still walk free.#TrueCrime #UnsolvedMystery #Lumberton #NorthCarolina #BucklesBerryLemonade #Podcast

n this haunting Southern Gothic true crime compilation, The BucklesBerry Lemonade Podcast revisits Alabama’s most heartbreaking mysteries — the unsolved disappearances of Brenda Kay Green , Sherry Lynn Marler , Carla Rebecca Corley , and Melinda Wall McGhee . Each of these women vanished under eerie and unresolved circumstances, their stories echoing through decades of unanswered questions and sma...

The silence is often the loudest sound in true crime. In this deeply personal and reflective episode, Tim and Lisa turn the focus inward, revisiting the cold cases and missing persons stories from North Carolina that have stayed with them long after the microphones were turned off. These are the souls who deserve justice, the faces that refuse to fade, and the mysteries that still ache with the pa...

Tim dives into one of the most audacious true crime fraud cases of the 21st century: the stunning betrayal carried out by Eddie Tipton , the man whose job was to protect the American lottery system. Tipton, the former security director for the Multi-State Lottery Association (MUSL), found the perfect loophole: he installed a single, malicious line of computer code to predict winning numbers on spe...

The North Carolina Jewel Heists: Three Ways to Steal a Million Dollars | BucklesBerry Lemonade Tim dives deep into three real-life, high-stakes jewelry store robberies across North Carolina, showcasing the shocking audacity and masterful planning of modern professional thieves. From the mountains of Asheville to the coastal plains, discover three entirely different methods criminals used to walk a...

Vanished After Breakfast: The Waffle House Disappearances Four true crime mysteries — one eerie common thread. In this episode of The BucklesBerry Lemonade Podcast , we step beneath the humming neon lights of the South’s most iconic diner — Waffle House — where comfort food and late-night confessions collide with chilling disappearances. From Roanoke Rapids, North Carolina to Atlanta, Georgia , th...

From the foothills of Catawba County to the salt marshes of Pamlico Sound, North Carolina hides a collection of mysteries that refuse to rest. In this special BucklesBerry Lemonade Southern Gothic episode, Tim and Lisa unravel the unsolved disappearances and deaths that still echo through small towns and quiet backroads: Robert Connor – Claremont, 2003 : A man vanishes after leaving home one morni...

Vanished in the Sunshine State: Four Florida Mysteries That Never Let GoBeneath the golden glow of Florida’s sun lies a darker truth — one of vanished souls and unanswered questions. In this special BucklesBerry Lemonade compilation, we revisit four haunting cases that still echo through the palms and highways of the Sunshine State. The Vanishing of Marjorie Wilson — a young woman disappears, leav...

Stories in this episode: Gone: The Chilling Mystery of a Mother and Daughter Who Vanished 2 Years Apart — Joyce Elizabeth Harper and her teenage daughter Kimberly Cozart, both lost in San Diego County, bound by fate and mystery. Lost to the Night: The Unsolved Disappearance of Lisa Farmer — A young mother disappears, echoing eerily similar unsolved crimes in Lawton, Oklahoma. Timothy Armstrong’s M...

Road Trip to the Unsolved: Chilling Missing Persons Mysteries Join us for a haunting journey across the country as we dive into some of the most baffling cold cases in American history. This special compilation episode is perfect for a long drive, a late night, or a rainy afternoon. From the misty backroads of Virginia to the quiet neighborhoods of North Carolina, South Carolina, Oklahoma, and Tex...

Virginia’s quiet towns and welcoming neighborhoods hold stories that never found their endings. In this episode of BucklesBerry Lemonade , we explore four haunting disappearances: Gerald Bradshaw – vanished from Virginia Beach Rebecca Crist – gone without a trace from Fairfax David Blockett – a two-week-old infant taken from his Newport News home Barbara Monaco – missing after a night out in Virgi...

Eastern North Carolina: The Unseen & UnheardHaunting Homicides, Vanishing Points, and Unclaimed IdentitiesJourney into the shadowed corners of Eastern North Carolina, where the unanswered echoes of unsolved crimes linger in the heavy Southern air. This episode uncovers five chilling cases that remain unresolved to this day: the brutal homicides of Curry Spivey and Camile Whalen, the puzzling d...

Cases covered in this episodeRobert Connor (Claremont, NC – 2003)Kimberly Thrower (Laurinburg, NC – 2004)Calvin Brazier (Rocky Mount, NC – 1975)Judith Deavers-Hyder (Garland, NC – 2015)Helen Darlene Fuller & Phil “Skip” Parselli (Durham/South of the Border – 1981) #podcast #subscribe #crime #truecrimecommunity

The Vanishing of Steve Lewis Arrowood Jr. | Southern Gothic True Crime MysteryIn 1975, 19-year-old Steve Lewis Arrowood Jr. left his home in Gastonia, North Carolina, and vanished without a trace. When his car was found abandoned days later near a apartment complex, investigators uncovered a trail of strange clues, chilling theories, and unanswered questions that have haunted his case for nearly f...