The Blue Frontier - American Everton Analysis

EVERTON 25/26 SQUAD ASSESSMENT PART 2: MIDFIELDERS. With Hayden Hackney's move from Middlesbrough finalized, Shan and Ryan dive straight into Everton's CAM, CM, and DM positions. In true Blue Frontier fashion, they build on the four needs laid out in Part 1 — more open play creation, better progression, stronger ball retention and press resistance, plus greater athleticism — then run the current s...

At long last, The Blue Frontier heads into the offseason with its annual Everton squad assessment. James, Shan, and Ryan break down the team from every angle, using overall results, attacking and defensive outcomes, physical data, style-of-play metrics, and individual performance numbers to get at the real question: what does Everton need to fix before the summer transfer window? The trio looks be...

Everton close the Premier League season with a flat 1-0 away loss to Tottenham on May 24, 2026, helping Spurs secure survival and giving Everton supporters one final grim data point in a month-long collapse. James and Ryan try to rise above the obvious frustration, reviewing the match with a fair but unsentimental eye before turning to the bigger question: was this just late-season recency bias, o...

Everton's Premier League home campaign ends with a 1–3 defeat to Sunderland on May 17, and with it, any remaining hope of European football next season. The Blue Frontier breaks down a match that told the same story in ninety minutes that the last six weeks have been telling: a fluky lead, a predictable collapse, and substitutions that answered nobody's questions. James, Ryan, and Shan walk throug...

Everton continue their tale of two halves approach with an uneven performance at Selhurst Park that took a point from a Palace team with nothing to play for coming off a midweek match.  The Blue Frontier pushes past the disappointment and into the game analysis to figure out what went wrong and how Everton can still keep in the European race for another week.   Shan and Ryan get in a ton of listen...

Everton 3-3 Manchester City was one of those matches that earns its own Wikipedia entry... and The Blue Frontier is here to unpack it in full. James and Ryan break down a game that had the Toffees 3-1 up with 20 minutes left before Jeremy Doku's stoppage-time equalizer yanked the draw back for City. A suffocating first half (26 Everton passes in the opposition half to City's 210), David Moyes' hal...

Everton travel to London and make club history... the bad kind. For the second straight league game, they concede a stoppage time winner, a first in the club's existence. The executioner is Callum Wilson (naturally), now at nine goals in his last eight against the Toffees. Final score: West Ham 2-1, and with it, Everton's most winnable remaining fixture gone. Discussion points include: the tactica...

The first Merseyside Derby at the Hill Dickinson Stadium had everything going for it: a weakened Liverpool side, an electric atmosphere, and an Everton squad riding recent momentum. Alas, Virgil van Dijk's stoppage-time header made it 2-1, and James, Ryan, and Shan are left to sift through the crushing defeat. They cover the key moments: a disallowed Ndiaye goal, Beto's equalizer, a refereeing dis...

Everton are finally back with a first team match, and the Blue Frontier is back with the recap... and what a game to return to. The Toffees made it nine points from losing positions this season, coming from behind twice to snatch a critical draw in what amounted to a European six-pointer at the G-Tech. It started badly when a second-minute penalty concession forced Everton into above-average first...

With the Premier League on international break, James and Shan zoom out, working bottom-to-top through all 20 teams to deliver three-word verdicts, standout statistics, and best and worst transfer grades for each side: Wolves' "too little, too late" transformation under Rob Edwards, Arsenal's march toward the title on a steady diet of set pieces and gamesmanship. Along the way, they take stock of...

In what may be an early seminal moment at the Hill Dickinson Stadium, Everton and its support bullied Chelsea to a 3–0 defeat that was as satisfying as they come. Beto netted first with a composed chip over a shaky Robert Sanchez, then capitalizing on a Sanchez howler set up by a marauding Gana Gueye, and Iliman Ndiaye curled a 7% xG shot into the dead corner to really start the party. Jordan Pick...

Arsenal 2–0 Everton, but the scoreline flatters the hosts. Everton traveled to the Emirates without Tarkowski, reshuffled their back line, and outchanced Arsenal from open play for most of the afternoon, only to concede twice in the final minutes and leave with nothing. James, Shan, and Ryan break down what the underlying numbers actually showed, the quietly strong outings from James Garner, Gana,...

The Blue Frontier welcomes Joe Thomas, Everton FC correspondent for the Liverpool Echo, for one of the show's most substantive conversations of the season: part press access deep-dive, part squad forensics, part meditation on what it means to cover a club that spent several years being as much a financial crime story as a football one. Joe unpacks the disconnect between how David Moyes sees Tyler...

Six points from six. The Blue Frontier's entertainment value gets put to the test with a relatively dull but crucial 2–0 Everton win over a hapless Burnley side, and Ryan, James, and Shan do their cautious, reluctant best to celebrate without losing the plot. James Garner's pinpoint set-piece delivery unlocked the low block (Tarkowski's 20th career goal), Kiernan Dewsbury Hall's emphatic overlappi...

Everton pulled off another road masterclass, edging Newcastle 3-2 in a St. James' Park barnburner that had everything: deflections, drama, and one of Jordan Pickford's all-time great saves. On this week's Blue Frontier, James and Shan unpack how David Moyes' side climbed to second in the Premier League's away table (24 points from 13 trips, with just four losses all season) by leaning on a rock-so...

Everton fell 0-1 at home to a resurgent Manchester United, staying winless at Hill Dickinson Stadium in 2026. Benjamin Sesko's 72nd-minute counter-attack goal (following a long ball from Cunha to Mbuemo) decided a match where Everton created next to nothing from open play, even after dominating late possession at 81%. Ryan, James, and Shan dig into the lineup that left fans baffled and furious: Ja...

The Blue Frontier is thrilled to welcome Paddy Boyland, The Athletic's Everton correspondent and co-host of the Everton Byline podcast, for our first proper guest episode. Hosts James, Ryan, and Shan dig deep with Paddy in a wide-ranging, insightful conversation. Paddy opens up about his Liverpool upbringing in a family of die-hard Evertonians, his first Goodison memories under Walter Smith's cent...

The shiny new stadium at the docks hasn't solved Everton's old habits. Despite a dominating performance on the stat sheet (clocking a massive 2.91 xG to Bournemouth's 1.33) the Toffees found a way to let a lead slip through their fingers in the pouring rain. James, Ryan, and Shan dissect a match where the "xG Gods" decided free will was an illusion and the struggles at Hill Dickinson Stadium conti...

In a tale of two halves, Everton make their half count more and the Blue Frontier is here to analyze all the details from this one. Shan and Ryan get into the match, the tactics, Marco Silva vs. David Moyes, and so much more.  But first, the duo gets into a hearty debate on the lineups and the approach from Moyes with Tyler Dibling and other young players at Everton.  Then it's an objective look a...

The January transfer window closed with a strategic pivot that signals Everton's commitment to a younger, more dynamic squad profile. James, Ryan, and Shan break down the arrival of Tyrique George, the 19-year-old Chelsea prospect whose high-tempo style and directness offer a much-needed spark in attack. The scouting report weighs George's raw potential against the physical demands of the Premier...

Everton secured a dramatic point at the Amex as birthday boy Beto bundled home a 97th-minute equalizer to keep the Toffees in the Premier League's top half . Facing a late injury to Vitaliy Mykolenko, David Moyes opted for a "Tall Guys FC" approach, deploying four natural center backs across the defensive line, including Jarrad Branthwaite at left back and Jake O'Brien at right back . While the fi...

On this episode, James and Shan break down Everton's 1-1 draw vs Leeds United at the Hill Dickinson Stadium. Trailing after James Justin's first-half opener, David Moyes flipped the script at halftime, switching to a three center back formation and introducing Jarrad Branthwaite (his season debut) alongside a returning Kiernan Dewsbury-Hall. The changes sparked a second-half revival, capped by Thi...

The full triumvirate of James, Shan, and Ryan is back to unpack the Toffees' gritty 1-0 Premier League triumph at Aston Villa. It's Everton's first league win at Villa Park since 2016, shattering Villa's 11-match home streak in a match that started as a tactical chess game between injury-hit sides and evolved into a showcase of disciplined grit. Thierno Berry's exquisite chip over Emi Martinez sea...

Everton's FA Cup hopes crumbled in the third round as they fell to Sunderland at Hill Dickinson Stadium, drawing 1-1 before a dismal 3-0 penalty shootout defeat. Hosts James and Shan dissect the frustrations: a bare-bones squad ravaged by suspensions, injuries, and AFCON absences forced youngsters like Harrison Armstrong, Merlin Rohl, and Tyler Dibling into the spotlight. James Tarkowski and Jake...

The full trio reunites on The Blue Frontier to unpack Everton's bizarre 1-1 Premier League draw against rock-bottom Wolves at Hill Dickinson Stadium on January 7, 2026. Michael Keane's pinpoint volley handed the Toffees an early edge, but stagnation set in after the break, letting Mateus Mane curl home an equalizer that highlighted cracks in the Keane-Tarkowski center-back duo. Chaos ensued with K...