That Sounds Terrifying

In this episode, Jess and Nick recap their time at Geva Theater seeing The Woman in Black, a terrifying play that everyone should go see. It runs until February 8th, 2026 so get tickets soon. Jess tells a story about a mother who is maliciously ignored in her home own for years, while Nick entertains listeners with two short tales of the theater and an old hotel. MAKE SURE TO LIKE, SHARE AND SUBSC...

We’re back from hiatus! The holidays are over but we recorded this before Thanksgiving, so this episode is the ghost of the holidays you didn’t know you needed. Jess tells stories of a near death experience that leads a women to recovery. Nick tells us about Duffy’s cut and the creepy things one family found there. MAKE SURE TO LIKE, SHARE AND SUBSCRIBE. We Need Your Terrifying Tales Share your te...

In this chilling episode, Nick and Jess explore some real experiences Jess had while on vacation in Italy, visiting a centuries-old church. From phantom chanting to a map of hell written in Latin that led to an encounter with a ghostly child and unexplained scratches on her leg. Whether it’s sacred ground or sinister energy, this episode reminds us that sometimes we don’t really know where the roa...

Ryan Gosling and His Childhood Ghost From shadowy figures lurking in his room to the night his entire family saw the same apparition, Ryan Gosling’s childhood was haunted by more than imagination. Years later, he still remembers the old man in the corner… and wonders if some ghosts never really let go. Part III of the Backstage with the Paranormal Series Produced and Edited by TST Intern, Ashlyn D...

Nick and Jess celebrate a major milestone with the 50th episode of That Sounds Terrifying ! They look back on favorite moments, chilling encounters, and the funniest memories from their journey so far. This milestone episode also brings new tales, a nautical brush with the ghostly legacy of the Edmund Fitzgerald and the story of a podcaster who may have left himself a little too open to the parano...

Step inside the eerie side of rock royalty in this chilling tale of Elton John’s ghostly encounters. From a mysterious force that pressed down on his chest in a Belgian hotel to the Victorian lady said to haunt his Windsor estate, Elton’s experiences blur the line between superstition and the supernatural. Whether it’s imagination or something otherworldly, one thing is certain, even the Rocket Ma...

That Sounds Terrifying took the stage at the Rochester Museum & Science Center’s After Dark: Carnival of Curiosity for a special live episode! Nick and Jess shared their experiences, told paranormal stories, and explored Rochester’s haunted history. An audience member even stepped up to share their own encounter. The night concluded with a live, interactive “choose your own adventure,” placing...

Some hauntings linger in the strangest ways, sending messages through experiences, mirrors, and dreams. In this episode of That Sounds Terrifying, Nick shares a chilling reminder of why you should never make your own Ouija board and a story about a breakfast you’ll never forget, even if it leaves you hungry for answers. Jess recounts a personal encounter from an open house that took an unexpected...

Season 3 of That Sounds Terrifying begins with an unforgettable episode, Anubis . Jess shares one of her most personal experiences, while Nick brings two chilling tales: a nurse’s unsettling moment while preparing a patient for their journey home, and a story from Reddit about a brother who found a way to communicate through sign…even after death. Share your terrifying tales with us so that you or...

In this bite-sized spooky story, we dive into the chilling legend of the Dybbuk Box, and how rapper Post Malone may have gotten a little too close for comfort. From eerie curses to unexplained misfortunes, this 90-second tale shares the haunted history of the infamous box and why it continues to terrify believers and skeptics alike. Part I of the Backstage with the Paranormal Series Produced and E...

In the chilling debut of our Terrifying Short Tales series, a forgotten box of home videos unravels a past that was never meant to be uncovered. What begins as nostalgia quickly descends into something far darker phantom figures in the background, a stranger in the role of father, and a horrifying truth buried beneath holiday lights and static. Some tapes should never be played, because once you p...

Nick and Jess unravel unsettling tales where time doesn’t play by the rules, from a lifeguard’s chilling poolside encounter to a family’s strange detour. Explore some time slips, vanishing figures, and ghostly scenes that feel too real to ignore. Strange things happen. Are you paying attention or are you too short on time? We Need Your Terrifying Tales Share your terrifying tales with us so that y...

Nick and Jess return with a collection of supernatural tales that blur the line between reality. From portal guardians and a shadowy figure lurking on a mysterious floor of an apartment building to a basketball mysteriously dribbling in a basement of a childhood home. These are stories of encounters that will leave you questioning what’s hiding in the spaces we sometimes overlook. We Need Your Ter...

In this soulful and spooky episode, Nick and Jess are joined by their friend and fellow improv performer Catie for a conversation that touches on everything from comedy and ghost stories to the mysteries of reincarnation and spiritual energy. Together, they share chilling tales of supernatural encounters from a grandmother’s spirit appearing on a familiar road, to a haunting drive involving a tan...

In this weird and winding episode, Nick and Jess dive into everything from audio mishaps and awkward AIM screen names to concert plans in duplicity. Along the way, they spiral into three chilling tales around creepy office vibes, the terrifying truth about tech, and a shadowy intruder in a wide-brimmed hat. Blending fun banter with dark fears, this episode proves that even the most casual conversa...

In this special episode of That Sounds Terrifying , Nick and Jess speak to Stephen for an in-depth conversation about his spiritual journey and deep ties to Rochester’s rich supernatural history. From chilling childhood encounters in a historic home to his current work with the Rochester Spiritual Society, Stephen shares personal experiences, stories, and insights into the city's spiritualist lega...

Hosts Nick Koziol, Christine Smith, and Jess DeCotis team up for a special crossover episode of That Sounds Terrific in the 585 and That Sounds Terrifying , joined by creative writer/producer Kendrick Foxx. Born in small-town Alabama and forged in the high-stakes world of L.A. film production, Kendrick shares his fascinating journey from engineering student to streaming-feature filmmaker. The epis...

Has a place ever filled you with overwhelming sadness or fear? If so, you won’t want to miss this episode. Co-host Nick opens up about a personal story he’s long kept private—one that reveals a deep emotional connection to a tragic event. Jess dives into two chilling Reddit tales featuring faceless figures and towering shadowy entities. It’s a raw, resonant conversation about ghostly encounters an...

In this unique crossover episode, worlds collide as That Sounds Terrific in the 585 teams up with That Sounds Terrifying for a dynamic and thought-provoking conversation. Hosted by the terrific Chris Lindstrom—Co-Founder of the Lunchador Podcast Network and long-time champion of Rochester’s food scene—this episode flips the script as Chris interviews Nick Koziol, Christine Smith, and Jess DeCotis...

Nick and Jess unravel tales of a cursed tree tied to mysterious deaths and ghostly encounters on Civil War battlefields. They discuss the strange bluish glow from soldiers' wounds and a historical tour that becomes a little too real for some tourists. We Need Your Terrifying TalesShare your terrifying tales with us so that you or your stories can possibly be featured on the show at thatsoundsterri...

Nick and Jess unravel two chilling tales in this episode. Jess shares the eerie story of a man whose car accident exposes the dark truth behind a local myth—but things aren’t quite what they seem. Meanwhile, Nick recounts the harrowing tale of a man who ignored the unspoken rules of buying a haunted house, only to suffer the horrifying consequences of his mistake. We Need Your Terrifying Tales Sha...

In this episode, Jess shares a ghost story of young love, loss, and mysterious wet footprints. Then, it’s time for some improv horror! Nick takes Jess on a choose-your-own-adventure journey through an AI Dungeon tale about a Halloween party at a haunted manor—where one wrong choice could mean disaster. Will Nick and Jess make it out of this adventure or will the haunted manor claim them? Tune in t...

In this episode, Nick and Jess are joined by musician and storyteller Pradip who shares spooky childhood experiences in the Adirondacks and eerie manifestations in the old family cabin. The trio delves into these real-life paranormal experiences and two other haunting tales, blending music, memories, and mystery into one captivating conversation. About our Guest, Pradip Ananda: Pradip has been int...

In this episode, Nick shares a haunting tale of a family forced to move into a home inherited from their grandfather after a devastating fire—only to discover they're not alone. Jess dives into a terrifying nightmare her husband experienced and then also gives an encounter from a Reddit story invloving the spirit of a grandmother seeking help from beyond the grave. Tune in as Nick and Jess unravel...

Nick and Jess share stories of childhood encounters with the paranormal, including glowing figures, mysterious visitors, and comforting signs from loved ones. They explore why children might be more connected to the supernatural and reflect on the unexplainable ties between the living and the dead. Don’t miss this fascinating and spine-tingling episode! We Need Your Terrifying Tales Share your ter...