Kelly Nugent and Lindsay Katai
Teen Creeps
Grownup comedians Kelly Nugent and Lindsay Katai discuss the trashy teen horror of their awkward neon youth - from the rise of MTV to the fall of ... well, MTV. So tighten those side ponytails, push your pogs to one side, fire up your 56k dial-up modem, and subscribe. New episodes every Wednesday. All creepy opinions expressed are those of the hosts. Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.
Be sure to visit the podcast's website and support the creator: www.teencreepspod.com
Author
Kelly Nugent and Lindsay Katai
Category
Podcast website
Latest episode
Nov 18, 2026
Where to listen?
Podcasts in the app Replaio Radio Coming soonPodcasts are coming to the app soon. Install now and be the first to see a whole new take on podcasts
Episodes
Francine Pascal's Sweet Valley High #104-106: The London Werewolf Trilogy with Ryan Mogge 26.09.2018 1:47:21
Murder most foul! Sweet Valley High correspondent Ryan Mogge (Same Day Shipping) returns to the studio with Kelly and Katai to discuss the SVH London Werewolf trilogy, woefully inaccurate blurbs, willful ignorance of red flags, and the real-life advantages of being a method actor. Plus, Ryan reveals the shocking true story of her journalist past, and everyone tries their hand at the perfect wolf h...
The Lost Boys with Oscar Montoya 19.09.2018 1:44:50
MICHAEL!!! Oscar Montoya (Inside The Disney Vault) joins Kelly and Katai to discuss the 1987 film The Lost Boys, talking genre-defying bullies, the pros and cons of turning into vampires, and the soundtrack to end all soundtracks! CHECK OUT OSCAR'S PODCAST, INSIDE THE DISNEY VAULT! https://twitter.com/ITDVpodcast FOLLOW OSCAR ONLINE! https://www.instagram.com/ozzymo/ https://twitter.com/ozzymo CON...
Kami Garcia and Margaret Stohl's Beautiful Creatures: The Manga with Ben Blacker 12.09.2018 1:24:16
Some loves are meant to be. Others are cursed. Ben Blacker (Hex Wives, The Writers Panel) joins Kelly and Katai to break down Kami Garcia and Margaret Stohl's Beautiful Creatures: The Manga, talking the strengths and weaknesses of manga presentation, magical rules and restrictions, the Confederacy, and so much more! PREORDER HEX WIVES NOW! https://www.vertigocomics.com/comics/hex-wives-2018/hex-wi...
Laura Powell's Game of Triumphs with Veronica Osorio 05.09.2018 1:34:12
Exclusive. Ancient. Dangerous. Veronica Osorio (Sassy Tarot, Treks and the City) joins Kelly and Katai to talk Laura Powell's Game of Triumphs, the Tarot, signs and love languages, and so so much more! SUBSCRIBE TO SASSY TAROT! EP1 PREMIERES ON TUES OCT 9TH! https://itunes.apple.com/us/podcast/sassy-tarot-with-veronica-osorio/id1434932800 CONNECT W/ TEEN CREEPS ON TWITTER, INSTAGRAM, & FACEBOO...
Sinclair Smith's Dream Date with Marnie Shure 29.08.2018 1:31:17
SWEET DREAMS... AND REST IN PEACE! Marnie Shure (The AV Club) joins Kelly and Katai to talk Sinclair Smith's Dream Date, nightmare boyfriends, dweebie protagonists, the sound that motorcycles make, themed birthday parties, and more! CONNECT W/ TEEN CREEPS ON TWITTER, INSTAGRAM, & FACEBOOK: https://twitter.com/teencreepspod https://www.instagram.com/teencreepspod https://www.facebook.com/teencr...
R.L. Stine's Sunburn 22.08.2018 1:08:19
THE PERFECT TAN OR THE PERFECT MURDER??? Kelly and Katai talk R.L. Stine's deeply disappointing Fear Street fake-out-a-thon SUNBURN, featuring ghost boys, shark attacks, and ferris wheel deaths that aren't actual deaths at all but memories of previous deaths. Plus a scientific survey of leeches and Jason Statham's grapefruit sized shoulder muscles. And some unforgettable listener voicemails about...
Lois Duncan's Stranger with my Face with Patrick Ehlers 15.08.2018 1:20:09
Who (or What) Is Trying to Take Over Laurie's Life? Lois Duncan correspondent Patrick Ehlers (Nintendo Cartridge Society) returns to Teen Creeps to dig into the legit scary doppelganger saga "Stranger with My Face" with Kelly & Katai, talking writers in denial, dope houses, astral projection, and more!!! CONNECT W/ TEEN CREEPS ON TWITTER, INSTAGRAM, & FACEBOOK: https://twitter.com/teencree...
Stephanie Meyer's Twilight 08.08.2018 1:45:32
SEXY, SPARKLY VAMPIRES... That's right, the time has come for Kelly and Katai to reckon with the YA phenomenon that is Stephanie Meyer's Twilight. And their reactions may surprise you. Did they love it? Hate it? Both? Listen to find out! Plus they sink their teeth into the really important things... Edward and Bella's impossible outfits. Vampire baseball. Edward's meadow laps. The origin of heavy...
V.C. Andrews's Whitefern 01.08.2018 1:21:53
MY SWEET AUDRINA ALL GROWED UP... For their 100th Episode of Teen Creeps, Kelly and Katai dig into the long awaited ghostwritten sequel to V.C. Andrews's classic My Sweet Audrina, WHITEFERN, and Spoiler Alert: IT ISN'T GOOD! But it does make for a fun episode! Kelly and Katai talk stupid little idiots, the ghostwriter's inability to evoke atmosphere, and the 2011 YouTube hit "Smang It" by Yung Hum...
R.L. Stine's Fear Street: You May Now Kill The Bride 25.07.2018 1:12:01
TWO SISTERS DIVIDED BY TIME... Kelly and Katai dig into R.L. Stine's BRAND NEW Fear Street installment, YOU MAY NOW KILL THE BRIDE, and find Stine up to his same old tricks-- nonsense, misdirection, family curses, cartwheel deaths, dumb guys, c*nt scale candidates, and so much dang cringey fun that it's almost too much to handle. Almost. Enjoy!!! CONNECT W/ TEEN CREEPS ON TWITTER, INSTAGRAM, &...
R.L. Stine's 99 Fear Street: House of Evil Books 1-3 (w/Jason Sheridan) 18.07.2018 1:36:19
The House was EVIL... and EVIL... and EVIL!!! Kelly and Katai dig into all three installments of R.L. Stine's House of Evil with Jason Sheridan (Podcast: The Ride). LISTEN TO PODCAST: THE RIDE: https://itunes.apple.com/us/podcast/podcast-the-ride/id1296636702?mt=2 SUBSCRIBE TO THE TEEN CREEPS PATREON to get bonus episodes, merch, and more: https://www.patreon.com/teencreeps CONNECT W/ TEEN CREEPS:...
Dia Reeves's Bleeding Violet 11.07.2018 1:17:00
Crazy never looked so beautiful... Kelly and Katai return to Dia Reeves's Portero universe to discuss Bleeding Violet , digging into the book's depictions of mental illness, sex positivity, and transphobia, as well as YA fiction's role in representing mental health and social issues. CONNECT W/ TEEN CREEPS ON TWITTER, INSTAGRAM, & FACEBOOK: https://twitter.com/teencreepspod https://www.instagr...
Franklin W. Dixon's The Hardy Boys Casefiles #73: Bad Rap with Alex Fernie 04.07.2018 1:12:01
Cool is the rule when you're ON A CASE... and Danger's IN YOUR FACE! Kelly and Katai are joined by writer and Hardy Boys correspondent Alex Fernie (Childrens Hospital, Bajillion Dollar Properties) to break down the surprisingly boring and mostly embarrassing "Bad Rap" installment of the Hardy Boys Casefiles, which features way less danger than you'd think and way more descriptions of eating and tr...
Christopher Pike's The Last Vampire 4: Phantom 27.06.2018 1:08:58
The monster... might be an angel! Kelly and Katai dig into the fourth installment of Christopher Pike's The Last Vampire series, Phantom, talking vampire bedside manner, evil babies, and more. Plus middle school memories of Greco-Roman nicknames and the intense fear that your crush might find out that you have a crush on them. The horror! Listen! CONNECT W/ TEEN CREEPS ON TWITTER, INSTAGRAM, &...
Grady Hendrix's My Best Friend's Exorcism 20.06.2018 1:21:51
Is their friendship powerful enough to beat the devil? Is your stomach strong enough to get through the tapeworm milkshake scene? Much like My Best Friend's Exorcism, this week's Teen Creeps might leave you feeling nauseous at times, but it's totally worth the ride. So come along with Kelly and Katai for a trip through this awesome, gross, moving book. And as a bonus, you'll find out what TCBY sta...
Kathryn Reiss's Time Windows 13.06.2018 1:13:32
A dollhouse, a ghost... a secret!!! Kelly and Katai enter Kathryn Reiss's TIME WINDOWS, a truly scary book that combines three of their favorite things-- looking into peoples' windows, ghosts, and drama. Not to mention secret compartments, multiple timelines, and prophetic aunts. CONNECT W/ TEEN CREEPS ON TWITTER, INSTAGRAM, & FACEBOOK: https://twitter.com/teencreepspod https://www.instagram.c...
Leslie Rule's Whispers from the Grave 06.06.2018 1:24:48
Let's do the time warp again! Kelly and Katai take a trip through Leslie Rule's time traveling mystery/high school drama fest, WHISPERS FROM THE GRAVE. Plus your faithful hosts discover a mutual love for the unfortunately named Souplantation, where "everything tastes kind of bad but good" (trademark pending). And finally, Kelly levels the ultimate insult against Katai! Will their friendship surviv...
Richie Tankersley Cusick's The Mall 30.05.2018 1:09:22
Someone is shopping... for MURDER!!! Kelly and Katai wade through the crowd of creeps, mall phantoms, and bro cops that populate Richie Tankersley Cusick's The Mall, encountering some familiar YA tropes along the way, including friends who don't believe anything the main character says, as well as a main character who leaves out important details when she's talking to her friends. Plus get ready f...
Orson Scott Card's Ender's Game with Keith Kingbay and Jesse Neil 23.05.2018 1:28:36
A famous book, a bad man, and two special guests. Keith Kingbay and Jesse Neil (New Player Has Joined podcast) join Kelly and Katai to talk Orson Scott Card's puzzling, troubling, and at times moving young adult classic Ender's Game, as well as the book's relationship to its author's professed homophobia. LISTEN TO NEW PLAYER HAS JOINED: https://starburns.audio/podcasts/new-player-has-joined/ CONN...
Fran Arrick's Steffie Can't Come Out To Play 16.05.2018 1:21:13
A somber detour leads to some important conversations as Kelly and Katai dig into "the original Lifetime movie," Fran Arrick's Steffie Can't Come Out To Play, the story of a fourteen year old runaway who falls victim to sex trafficking in New York City. Kelly and Katai debate the book's saddest moment, Google "Do pimps really dress like that?" AND discuss sex workers, sex trafficking legislation,...
Ellen Steiber's Zodiac Chiller #4: Twisted Taurus 09.05.2018 1:15:34
SHE GETS WHAT SHE WANTS-- ALWAYS! Kelly and Katai dig into Ellen Steiber's witchy creepfest Twisted Taurus from the Zodiac Chiller series. Plus listener voicemails about Goosebumps geekouts, orgasms, and emo bangs. And send us your best "Dean Crepes" inspired art! SUBSCRIBE TO THE TEEN CREEPS PATREON to get bonus episodes, merch, and more: https://www.patreon.com/teencreeps CONNECT W/ TEEN CREEPS:...
Barbara Steiner's Spring Break 02.05.2018 59:34
SUN, SURF... MURDER??? Kelly and Katai dive into SPRING BREAK, Barbara Steiner's Point Horror mashup of cliffside haunted houses, unprepared sexy teenagers, creepy old guys, red herrings, ghost shit, escaped mental patients, bird knowledge, and angsty swimming. In the process, they learn an important lesson... If you floash the oash, you scoash down the coash! SUBSCRIBE TO THE TEEN CREEPS PATREON...
Ann M. Martin's Baby-Sitters Club Super Mysteries #1: Baby-Sitters' Haunted House w/ Alice Wetterlund 25.04.2018 1:30:37
The BSC will protect the kids! But who will protect the BSC! Kelly and Katai are joined by Baby-Sitters Club aficionado Alice Wetterlund (Treks and the City podcast) to break down a truly shocking entry in the Baby-Sitters Club canon, Super Mysteries #1: Baby-Sitters Haunted House. All your most pressing BSC questions will be answered. Questions like... Why doesn't Stoneybrook have a Planned Paren...
BONUS Patreon Preview | "Creepy Crushes" Minisode & "The Haunting of Hill House" Outside Genre Episode 18.04.2018 1:26:34
Hey Teen Creeps listeners! Curious about what's going on behind the Patreon paywall? This week we wanted to give you a free preview of some of our favorite Patreon moments. Please enjoy our "Creepy Crushes" Minisode (3:56) and our Outside Genre Episode on Shirley Jackson's "The Haunting of Hill House" (28:50). And we hope you'll take a second to consider becoming a Patreon subscriber! Your generos...
Dhonielle Clayton's The Belles 11.04.2018 1:19:16
Brilliant commentary on racial identity and the commodification of beauty woven into a chilling fantasy narrative plus leeches, arcana, and blood magic thrown in for good measure? Um, that's a YES from us. Kelly and Katai deliver a strong recommendation for Dhonielle Clayton's The Belles and they crown a new Queen of the All Caps C Scale... She is Beyond C, a Supernatural C, a Monster C... If you'...
Similar podcasts
Replaio is not a podcast publisher; show names, artwork and audio belong to their authors and are distributed through public RSS feeds.