Supernatural First Watch Podcast

Listen in as Kimberly unpacks Supernatural, Season 2 Episode 14, "Born Under a Bad Sign," where Sam’s missing week spirals into blood, betrayal, and a master plan gone rogue. She covers the wild ride of amnesia, clues, and just a dash of sinister menthols Dean’s refusal to follow Dad’s most chilling orders—even when the evidence is stacked against Sam demon hijinks, holy water plot twists, and the...

Join your host Kimberly for a breakdown of Supernatural Season 2 Episode 13, Houses of the Holy. She covers the showdown between Sam’s faith and Dean’s stubborn skepticism a killer spirit with a holy twist (but is celestial justice ever that simple?) the tangled ethics of smiting sinners “for their own redemption” why a motel’s magic fingers and a SpongeBob altar cloth might be essential gear for...

Listen in as Kimberly dives into "Nightshifter," the action-packed Supernatural episode where a routine bank case goes sideways—complete with a bank heist, a conspiracy theorist, and the return of a deadly monster. She covers the wild twists when bank robbers aren't after cash…and aren't even human conspiracy theories, Doctor Who doppelgängers, and the unforgettable Ronald Reznik why Sam and Dean...

Join your host Kimberly in Supernatural Season 2 Episode 11, Playthings. She explores: Classic Horror Vibes, Supernatural Style: The episode pays direct homage to iconic horror films like The Shining , with haunted dolls, a chilling old hotel, and ghostly apparitions straight out of cinematic nightmares. The Family Business Gets Personal: Sam and Dean butt heads (again) over their priorities—savin...

This week on the podcast, Kimberly dives deep into Season 2 Episode 10, Hunted. An episode packed with psychics, hunter drama, and the ongoing mystery behind Sam’s powers. No filler here — it’s a full-on arc episode! Spoiler: Trust is in short supply. We chat about: Trust No One? — Even in a hunter’s network, not everyone is on your side. Be careful who you trust is more than a mantra Unpacking De...

Join your host Kimberly for Supernatural Season 2, Episode 9, Croatoan. She'll explore... Expect the unexpected : It’s not always monsters with fangs—sometimes it’s an invisible enemy (and questionable science). Creepy but true meets horror trope-tastic : The lost colony of Roanoke, “Croatoan,” and a history lesson with a supernatural twist. Gray is the new black : Dean’s black-and-white worldview...

Listen in for Supernatural Season 2, Episode 8 "Crossroad Blues." Join your host Kimberly as she covers: What making a "deal with the devil" really means why Dean’s got extra attitude (and baggage) when the subject of fatherly sacrifice comes up what it means now that Dean’s officially wanted... by more than just monsters ...and whole lot more! Share your thoughts, insights and predictions at spnf...

Join your host Kimberly as she breaks down Supernatural Season 2 Episode 7 "The Usual Suspects." She covers the Winchester brothers' run-in with the law and supernatural consequences what happens when Supernatural flips the script and goes full police procedural a ghost story with more warnings than revenge a sly guest star nod to the horror classic The Exorcist why being an insurance agent (or pr...

In this episode of Supernatural, Season 2 Episode 6 No Exit, Kimberly explores a chilling episode. She covers the real-life monster behind this week's ghostly antagonist (hint: murder castle, anyone?) Jo’s drive to hunt—and testy clashes with protective mother Ellen how a salt circle and a cement truck become the hunter's latest ghostbusting combo messy Winchester family secrets that shake up ever...

Listen in to Season 2 Episode 5, "Simon Said." as Kimberly explores why Sam’s psychic visions are getting more unpredictable—and way more deadly the ethics of mind control, and what happens when two people have the same creepy power the ultimate “evil twin” showdown, complete with disco vans and questionable fashion choices what Ellen thinks it’ll take to survive the coming supernatural war whethe...

Welcome back to the Supernatural First Watch Podcast ! In this episode, Kimberly guides us through the creeptastic "Children Shouldn't Play with Dead Things," where the Winchester brothers find themselves dealing with more than just graveyard dirt and sibling bickering. Dean’s guilt and grief are bubbling over, threatening to explode in more ways than one (watch out, Sam's jaw). Sam tries to force...

Join your host Kimberly as she breaks down Supernatural Season 2 Episode 3, Bloodlust. She covers what happens when not all vampires fit the evil mold Dean’s new BFF Gordon and the questionable hunter bonding that follows a showdown over whether a hunter’s job is really all black and white why keeping secrets might be the Winchester family’s true pastime This episode doesn’t just give us scares —...

In the second episode of the season 2, Kimberly explores "Everybody Loves a Clown," where the Winchester brothers juggle grief, new allies, and a carnival filled with supernatural shenanigans. She covers why Sam would rather face demons than clowns—seriously, Ronald McDonald tears were involved introductions to a merry band of hunters and the oddball genius Ash (spoiler: mullets are back) how the...

Season 2 Begins! Listen in as Kimberly explores "In My Time of Dying," where the Winchester family's aftermath of a demon-driven car crash leads everyone straight into the hospital—and the veil between life and death gets alarmingly thin. She covers What really happens when Dean wakes up in a hospital bed, and why nobody seems to notice him Sam channeling his inner slumber party host for a uniquel...

Listen in on Supernatural Season 1 Episode 22, Devil's Trap as Kimberly explores the nail-biting finale of Supernatural’s first season. She covers Just how well the Winchester family handles demons—and whether anyone’s actually prepared for all-out war The debut of Bobby, mysterious hunter extraordinaire, and why his expert demon advice seems oddly overdue Dean’s gut-wrenching moral crisis after a...

Join your host Kimberly as she dives into Supernatural Season 1 Episode 21, Salvation. We follow the Winchester family and tune in for: The big reveal of Meg’s true nature Sam’s haunting visions and what they mean for the family High-stakes impersonations and tense break-ins John’s risky plan (what a shock....not) Emotional Winchester family moments and biting questions for next episode Ready for...

Join Kimberly as she dives into Supernatural season 1 epsiode 20, "Dead Man's Blood," Everyone's favorite creature from horro joins the the Supernatural world and family tensions reach new heights. Vampire Lore Gets a Makeover: Supernatural turns traditional myths on their head—Don’t trust everything you’ve read! Legendary Objects and Future Stakes: pretty doesn't mean it can't be deadly! A fancy...

Join your host Kimberly as she explores Supernatural Season 1 Episode 19, "Provenance." The episode where ugly family portrait wreak more havoc than a simple crime against the art world. She covers How a haunted painting becomes the center of a chilling investigation The brothers’ questionable art dealer disguises and why wearing a suit might actually matter Super awkward first date to rule them a...

Join your host Kimberly as she explores Season 1 Episode 18, "Something Wicked," the Supernatural episode where childhood scars, creepy folklore, and family legacies collide. Pop culture Easter eggs! Thundercats on the TV, a nod to “The Shining,” and a Macbeth-inspired title. The many uses of a souvenir shop “Bikini Inspector” badge Are you really a hunter if you haven’t donned a white lab coat at...

Join the host Kimberly as she explores Supernatural Season 1 Episode 17 “Hell House.” She talks about.... how Sam and Dean’s latest hunt gets derailed by prank wars, internet legends, and amateur ghost hunters why the haunting in Richardson, Texas, might be less supernatural and more “crowdsourced terror” what happens when urban legends and internet forums combine to bring monsters to life a philo...

Listen in as Kimberly explores Season 1 Episode 16, Shadows of Supernatural. In this episode be aware of what lurks in the shadows. We cover Someone's mysterious return and how much they're hiding behind a smile A goth girl, a demonic shadow, and an iPod: the episode’s classic horror movie flair Bright lights and rickety elevator shafts for the win Zoroastrian demons, blood rituals, and the family...

Join Kimberly on the Road So Far in Season 1 Episode 15, The Benders. How this flips the script on monsters Dean's best puppy dog impression and the unlikely buddy-cop dynamic with Deputy Kathleen Why some episodes just feel a little too creepy—and might be worth a skip even for seasoned fans Get ready to hit the road for “Shadow” next as we leave the Bender family far behind. Don’t forget to subs...

In Supernatural Season 1 Episode 14, Nightmare, listen in as Kimberly explores -Sam's psychic headaches are BACK (did they ever leave?) -Undercover as priests (yes, they're THAT prepared), Sam & Dean infiltrate a wake and sniff out more family skeletons than a Halloween pop-up store. -This isn’t your usual salt-and-burn; it’s an ethical deer-in-headlights moment. Absolute must-listen if you lo...

In Supernatural Season 1, Episode 13, Kimberly explores "Route 666," the Supernatural episode where a killer ghost truck takes center stage and Dean reunites with his old flame, Cassie. She covers A haunting mystery tied to a vanishing monster truck and eerie legends from the 1960s How Dean's relationship with Cassie shakes up long-standing Winchester family rules A spirited debate about salt, bur...

Join your host Kimberly as she dives into Supernatural, Season 1, Episode 12, “Faith.” Things take a sharp turn from the usual monster chase when Dean winds up in the hospital with only months to live after a hunt gone sideways. Here’s what you can look forward to in this deep-dive: Dean’s brush with death (and his stubborn resignation to it) Faith healing, morality, and the fine print in making d...