Sugar Coated Murder

In the 2nd part of our episode with Jay & Kay from F**k My Work Life podcast, Karen describes what she attempted to bake and why the sisters considered it a failure. It was ooey and it was gooey, but not very magical. Kay finally gets her turn to disclose the murder case she brought. Using Wikipedia as her source, she recounts the story of the first female to be sentenced to death in the state...

In this episode, Anne and Karen welcome Jay and Kay from the F**k My Work Life podcast. Part 1 has Jay recounting the tragic loss of two special girls from Scotland at the hands of a monster. Jay's source came from Wikipedia - Ian Huntley. Enjoy the shenanigans. Indie Spotlights: Casting Views Voluntary Input #indiepodcast #womenpodcasters #womeninmedia #ianhuntley #murderinscotland #truecrime #ba...

In the 2nd part of the Casting Views episode, Karen unravels the horrific murder of Samantha Joshephson. Sami was a graduating Senior at the University of South Carolina in Columbia, SC. She had a bright future as she was planning to attend Drexel Law School after graduation. The night she and her friends went to celebrate her acceptance into Law School turned into a nightmare. Samantha got into w...

In this episode, the sisters welcome their British buddies, Dan and Lou from the Casting Views podcast. It's a dark thriller that they bring to us for a murder case as they unveil one of history's most depraved couples, Fred and Rose West. There is a trigger warning here because of the extreme violence and sexual situations. Buckle up and listen at your own risk and ENJOY this spicy murder case wi...

The sisters are back from their break and in this episode they chat about what they've been up to from traveling to NC to writing their book to what fun shows they've been watching. We've missed y'all and we hope you've missed us too! #couchchatting #newepisode #bookwriting #streamingtv #whattowatch Indie Podcast promo - The Movie Wire Show www.linktr.ee/Moviewireshow   Hosted by Simplecast, an Ad...

The sisters welcome Matt from the Decay' with the Boys Podcast for some hijinks and shenanigans. You can find Matt's (& Adam's) impressive podcast at https://www.podpage.com/decayin-with-the-boys Karen bakes up a healthy Blueberry Breakfast Bar. Meanwhile, Anne breaks down the murders of Sam Herr and Julie Kilushi in Costa Mesa, CA. Then, Matt plays "Karen" and steps in to present a...

In this episode, Anne bakes up delicious Strawberry Shortcake Cupcakes that are mind-blowingly tasty. Karen narrates the story of the Staudte murders, beginning with Mark, a married father of four and full-time local band member, and someone Anne really wants to call Mike. Next, Anne takes us on the journey of the Jennings murder out of Georgia. Indie podcast promotions: http://www.voluntaryinput....

This is a special episode of Slaying in the Kitchen! We welcome Leo Allen to bake with us. Leo is a fellow-podcaster who hosts Voluntary Input, which you can find at www.voluntaryinput.com. Anne leads Leo in a great recipe for Lemon Cooler Cookies from https://thecarefreekitchen.com/lemon-cooler-cookies/. Then, Karen and Leo unpack the crazy mystery of the Suitcase Murders from Wisconsin and Minne...

This episode brings us a skinny muffin recipe, more laughs, and a new word for the Sugar Coated Dictionary. Karen bakes up Skinny Strawberry Chocolate muffins from www.aprilflours.com. Anne unpacks the 1961 murder of Janet Staschak from Latrobe, PA. Next, Karen relays the 2017 murder of Lauren Hugelmaier from Raleigh, NC, also known as the "Cold Medicine Murder". There may or may not hav...

This week, because Karen is fighting the Carolina Crud, we have replaced our episode with our guest appearance on the Casting Views podcast.  Dan and Lou host a humorous show about everything.  No topics are off limits.  They hosted us as guests, and we had a jolly great time comparing British food to American food.  Please find them on all major podcasting listening platforms.  Tally Ho! #british...

Anne bakes up delicious Homemade Strawberry Pop Tarts that include homemade strawberry jam and buttery pastry. These are what childhood memories taste like! Karen unpacks the egregious acts of a murderous husband in the Lori Hacking case out of Salt Lake City, UT. Then, Anne brings us the Berfield murder from Medford, MA. There is much discussion about podcast friend, Antonio, from the Cultworthy...

In this episode, Karen bakes proper English biscuits from the show Ted Lasso. Anne gives an account of a harrowing murder between co-workers in Virginia Beach, VA. Afterwards, Karen unravels a 35-year cold case from Glasgow, Scottland. The giggles and laughter flow almost too freely and things get out of hand. The sisters are able to pull it together long enough to complete the episode. #livecomed...

In this episode, Anne bakes up a delicious Strawberry Swirl Pound Cake. The recipe calls for Almond Extract and Kill Vanilla. Anne deviates and uses yummy strawberry jam. Karen recounts a double murder in Bedford County, VA, which is near Lynchburg, VA. Then, Anne gives us the terrifying murders by the Dating Game Killer, Rodney Acala, whose victims are vast and there are still more out there unid...

Happy 100th Episode! The sisters get out of the kitchen, pour some bourbon, and give updates on some of the episodes they have covered over the years. Sit back, relax, and reminisce. #bourbon #casereview #100episodes #truecrimepodcast #darkhumor indie podcast spotlights: F**CK My Work Life  https://podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/f-k-my-work-life/id1555824690 Voluntary Input  https://podcasts.apple....

In this episode, the sisters have gotten into the bourbon again. Karen misses the mark on this recipe for Double Layer Chocolate Chip cake that turns out more like a double cookie, but actually tastes good. Anne takes us on a wild ride with the Fuss Family out of Stone Mountain, Georgia. Karen tells the story of Brad Perry's senseless death and how his mother embraced the mother of his killer. #ch...

In this episode, Anne Varner bakes up a festive and delicious Mardi Gras King Cake in celebration of Fat Tuesday. Karen covers a senseless triple murder out of Amity, Maine. Anne discusses the case of a Brother in Blue taken out in the line of duty by 3 idiots. #fattuesday #kingcake #killavanilla #triplemurder #lineofduty #mardigras #celebrationcake #darkhumor #truecrimepodcast #murdervicitims Kar...

This episode finds Karen in the kitchen, baking up delicate Lemon Lavendar Sable Cookies from http://www.casualfoodlist.com. Both cases this week come out of the state of Ohio. Anne describes the story of sweet, retiree Barbara Howe, in Hamilton, OH. Karen unpacks the harrowing tale of survivor Sarah Maynard and what happened to her family in Mt. Vernon, OH. #cookingwithlavendar #lemoncookies #isa...

In this episode, there is great debate on the term "blouse". Anne thinks it is out-dated and old fashioned, while Karen feels that it is a current term used frequently by everyone except Anne. Anne takes us through a delicious recipe for Brandied Apple Cake. Karen unpacks the disturbing case of Jennifer Harris out of Fannin, TX. Then, Anne describes the McCoy case from Chesapeake City, M...

In this episode, Karen bakes a recipe for Red Velvet Cupcakes using beets instead of food coloring.  Then, the sisters discuss the victimology of murder victims Ross, Critchley, and Pangburn.   #redvelvetcupcakes #cookingwithbeets #victimology #murdervictims #murderinvestigation #darkhumor #truecrimepodcast #murdermystery Hosted by Simplecast, an AdsWizz company. See pcm.adswizz.com for informatio...

The sisters are excited to finally be back in 2022. Anne bakes up easy, delicious Oatmeal Cream Pies that put Little Debbie's to shame. Karen recounts the harrowing case of Ginger Hayes and her son, Nicholas. Then, Anne reveals the appalling story of Catherine Beard from Ord, Nebraska. Promo: Super Familiar with the Wilsons Podcast #murderpodcast #oatmealcreampie #kidnapping #victimology #lifesent...

There is a mental health trigger warning for this story as well as a trigger for the gruesomeness of the crime. #mentalhealth #cannibalfratboy #jupiterfl #christmasrecipe #gingerbreadcheesecake Sources: https://heavy.com/news/2016/08/michelle-mishcon-stevens-john-stevens-iii-austin-harrouff-victims-state-university-face-biting-married-couple-murder-jupiter-florida-fraternity-photos-bath-salts-flak...

Happy Holidays to the Sugar Squad from Karen & Anne!  As a bonus episode, the sisters allow the Murder Incorporated Podcast to take over an episode! Two best friends, Harley and Buddy, bring you the case or Paul Bernardo.  They bring you into the muck of a twisted killer with a little humor to lighten the mood.   You can find Murder Incorporated on all your favorite listening apps. Hosted by Simpl...

Anne & Karen welcome true crime author, Joni West, to the show.  Joni has written a thrilling book called Full Frontal Murder Memoir.  She talks about what is what like having a dad that committed murder and how his medical affliction played a role in his court case and made history.  While Joni and the sisters discuss astonishing relationship with her family, Karen rolls up some delectable bourbo...

In this week's episode, the Sugar Sisters are talking about Ladies Gone Bad!  While Anne makes Almond Crescent Cookies for Momma's goodie box (these are Momma's favorite Christmas cookies), Karen starts off by unraveling the horrific mystery of Christian Rojas's brutal slaying.  Then, Anne describes the life and death of sweet Abraham Shakespeare who hit it big in the lottery which started nefario...

In this Slaying in the Kitchen episode, we welcome Liz from Coffee Convos with Liz Podcast.  We discuss the unsolved mystery of the disappearance of Jennifer Dulos in CT while creating yummy Apple Pie Tacos with homemade mason jar whipped cream. Use Liz's linktree below to find all the ways to listen and contact her: https://linktr.ee/CoffeeConvosLiz   #killavanilla #applepierecipes #desserttacos...