Sugar Coated Murder

In this episode, Karen takes her turn behind the mixer and unleashes a batch of Brown Butter KillaVanilla Wafers—cookies so good they’ve risen to legendary status in our kitchen. They’re buttery, they’re bold, and they’re now officially our signature cookie! While Karen is elbow‑deep in vanilla‑scented bliss, Anne walks us through a devastating California true crime mystery involving the violent l...

In this deeply moving episode, Anne and Karen sit down with Amanda Seagal, the sister of Teresa Brantley, whose life was tragically taken in June of 1982. Teresa—portrayed as “Georgia” in  Deadly Route , part of the  Same My Name Series —was so much more than the violence that ended her story. With honesty and grace, Amanda shares who her sister truly was: her spirit, her memories, and the life sh...

Anne storms into the kitchen this week like a sugar‑dusted superhero, armed with strawberries and zero intention of behaving. She’s whipping up Strawberry Biscuits so fluffy, so radiant, so aggressively delicious they might actually file a restraining order against your self‑control. These little clouds of Spring sunshine don’t just melt in your mouth… they detonate with flavor. And because Anne r...

On April 26th 1996, in Washington State, a loving mother of 2 left her home to run errands in preparation for her son's 5th birthday. She never made it to her son's party.  She was never seen again.  In this episode, Anne gives us the victimology and case of Sandi Johson.  It's Karen's turn in the kitchen and she bakes up a yummy local favorite - Pawley's Island Pie.  It's like if a chocolate ches...

In this Anything But Murder Shorty episode, the sisters take a break from murder and baking.  Instead, they divulge their beauty secrets and kitchen gadgets. This episode is copyrighted. For links to any of these products, email us at: murder.sugarcoated@gmail.com Sugar Coated Murder is not affiliated with any of these products and receive no profit from discussing them. #beautysecrets #anythingbu...

In this long-awaited new episode, Anne takes her turn in the kitchen.  She whips up easy and delicious Peppermint Patties. Of course she breaks out the Killa Vanilla! Unfortunately, she forgot where she found the recipe so you will need to email us to request it for yourself. Karen unravels the tragic story of a family erased.  In October 2014, evil visited the Champion family in Cadiz, KY. It's a...

It's Karen's turn in the kitchen and she is on a mission to bake her son's birthday cake. As she constructs a gorgeous and delicious Blueberry Pound Cake with an Almond Glaze, Anne lends her perspective on the senseless murders of Emily Richitelli and Ashley Altman. The sisters provide updates on some court cases they have been following, and there are British Bloody Marys involved as well! Come f...

While Anne bakes up yummy Chocolate Sugar Cookies in the shapes of Buffalo and Cowboy Boots topped with vanilla icing, Karen unravels the mysterious disappearance of Crystal Rogers, mother of 5.  Bardstown, KY, has a handful of unsolved murders on the books, but in July of 2025, the case of Crystal Rogers was finally solved and justice served! Anne's recipe hails from our obsession - Sally. There...

In this episode, the kitchen is closed.  Anne and Karen detail their courthouse adventures during the Michael Colucci trial.  The bidding is opened on Karen's signed, original courtroom drawing.  You can email us at murder.sugarcoated@gmail.com to provide your bid.   #femalevoices #courtreport #murdertrial #colucci #truecrimepodcast #applepodcasts #spotify #goodpods #YouTube #courtroomartist #cour...

In this very special episode, the sisters welcome author and coach, Liz Bullard!  Liz has written many books, some mystery/thriller and some fantasy.  She has books for everyone! She currently has a Kickstarter Campaign and can use our support.   Liz and Karen bake up an exceptional recipe sent in by Luke of Howdy Beans podcast.  Check out Luke's podcast at  www.youtube.com/@TheHowdyBeansPodcast  ...

It's Anne's turn in the kitchen and she does not disappoint! She bakes us some delicious Cinnamon Roll Cruffins (https://iambaker.net/cinnamon-roll-cruffins/#wprm-recipe-container-177616). The sisters discuss their fossil hunting adventure with Capt. Ashby from Charleston Fossil Adventures. Follow him on Instagram or go to his website (chsfossiladventures.com) and book a trip today!! Karen takes u...

The sisters are finally successful at recording the episode with actual sound!  Karen tries out a recipe for Low Sugar Sweet Potato Bread and it turns out fluffy and nutty with warm spices.  It would make a delicious breakfast bread!  She found the recipe in a Better Homes and Garden magazine (Cut the Sugar issue) and then tweaked it to make it her own.  Of course she used Killa Vanilla! Anne unpa...

Karen performs for Anne. Anne pours strong drinks. Karen and Anne get tipsy. Anne bakes up delicious Chocolate Bourbon Mini Bundt Cakes. We got too tipsy and forgot to taste them during the episode. Karen tells the harrowing tale of a double homicide of two ladies who were living their lives and working their jobs. This story will make your blood boil! The ladies start the episode off with a Happy...

Welcome to our 150th episode!!! It's Karen's turn to bake this week and she doesn't disappoint. She shares the recipe for a festive green Pistachio Pound Cake with Cherry Glaze. First, Karen unpacks the details of the betrayal and murder of Brittney Gregory. Next, Anne presents the case of how the case of Heather Saul brings down a monster lurking in the shadows. For the full recipe, email us at m...

It's our first full video episode! Anne shares her recipe for freshly baked Brown Butter Sugar Cookies. They turned out so yummy! Karen narrates the story of how a psychic in Ohio solved a mystery unraveling in Arizona. This is the case of Stacy Hendrickson. Next, Anne covers the tragic case of Priscilla Gustafson. Please find our you tube channel - Sugar Coated in the House - and like, subscribe,...

In this episode, the ovens are off because it is way too hot to cook right now in the Lowcountry! First, Anne Varner unpacks the case of Gayle McCaffrey, who went missing under suspicious circumstances. Listen to see if Gayle ever got the justice she needs. Next, Karen discusses the tragic story of how Kendy Howard lost her life. Indie Pod promos: The Mystery Frequency https://linktr.ee/mysteryfre...

In this new episode, Anne conquers one of her bucket list recipe challenges - Baked Alaska. This one has a chocolatey brownie bottom, topped with creamy mint chip ice cream and sealed under a dome of Swiss Buttercream Meringue. So Delicious! Karen walks the listeners down a murderous path that ends up with a young man from a hit reality series shot dead on the steps of a complex in St. Louis, Miss...

Michael Colucci, a Summerville SC jeweler, stands accused of the 2015 murder of his wife, Sara Lynn Moore-Colucci. The original trial ended in a hung jury. Now, after over five years, Colucci is facing a retrial, scheduled to begin on May 13. In this episode, Anne reviews the mysterious death of Sara Lynn and the first murder trial. Karen bakes up some deliciously special Blondies. This recipe com...

Karen covers the case of the Disappearance and Murder of little Justin Lee Turner from Moncks Corner, SC. In celebration of Karen's birthday, Anne bakes scrumptious Meyer Lemon Cupcakes with Vanilla Rum Glaze.   #recipeswap #missingchild #justinleeturner #delayedjustice Hosted by Simplecast, an AdsWizz company. See pcm.adswizz.com for information about our collection and use of personal data for a...

Karen whips up a delicious, easy recipe for Tiramisu. This creamy, coffee-spiked dessert is simple and refreshing. Anne presents the darkest day for the family of Marilyn and Bobby Blewer who were food servers at the Iowa State Fair. Indie podcast spotlight: Casting Views The Movie Wire Show #coffeedessert #tiramisu #easyrecipe #IowaStateFair #FunnelCakes #murder Hosted by Simplecast, an AdsWizz c...

The Sugar Sisters are back with a new episode. Anne makes delicious Banana Cupcakes with scrumptious Cinnamon Cream Cheese Frosting. Karen recounts the story of who killed Rashawn Berry and what the motive was. Anne's recipe came from Sally's Baking Addiction, once again proving we are obsessed with Sally! Indie Pod Promos: Back to the Balcony (https://www.youtube.com/@back2thebalcony) F**ck My Wo...

Our interview with Dr. Kinsey continues in this episode. Did a ghost visit Dr. Kinsey? Was he intimidated by Alex Murdaugh at the trial? What did Dr. K think of the Strawberry Cake Roll we served him? These burning questions and more are covered in our talk with him. #specialguest #interview #kennethkinsey #jellyroll #killavanilla #karendevanie #annevarner Indie Pod promo: The Movie Wire Show - Th...

In this special episode, Karen and Anne welcome a crime scene expert, weapons expert, trial testified, an equalizer for the prosecution, and a co-star in the Alex Murdaugh murder trial - DR. KENNY KINSEY! In this part 1 of 2, we interview him and ask the pressing questions others won't ask like "have you ever had a paranormal experience at a crime scene" and many others. Of course, when...

Anne recaps the story of Gypsy Rose Blanchard who was convicted of 2nd degree murder of her mother, Dee Dee. Gypsy has just been granted parole after serving 8 years of her 10-year sentence. Gypsy Rose suffered unspeakable horrors at the hands of her mother who was thought to have had Munchausen By Proxy syndrome. Dee Dee had even lied to Gypsy about what age she actually was. Karen bakes up a del...

Anne bakes up memory-inducing Mini Powdered Donut Muffins that remind the sisters of their youth. These powdery pillows of softness are perfect for Christmas morning. Karen recounts the horrifying details of the kidnapping and torturous killing of Amy Robinson in Arlington, Texas. Amy was kind, dependable, and dedicated to her future; she was preyed upon by two heartless beasts. This case begs the...