Strange and Undecided

Episode 47 - On the night of March 17, 1995, something strange happened in the quiet lakeside city of Pickering, Ontario. Six teenage boys vanished mysteriously due to unknown circumstances that continue to haunt families, investigators, and true crime buffs. Despite extensive searches, multiple leads, and decades of speculation, no definitive evidence has ever explained where these teens went or...

Episode 46 - In the early morning hours of September 4, 1972, three masked men entered the Montreal Museum of Fine Arts through the roof via a skylight and successfully stole valuable paintings, figurines and jewelry and escaped into the night. Despite another heist occurring in Montreal already that weekend, this heist’s bold execution and mysterious aftermath captured global attention and imagin...

Episode 45 - This story is about an indigenous settlement near Angikuni Lake in Nunavut, Canada that was reported to have vanished entirely without a trace. This report comes from a fur trapper who visited the village only to find no one was there. Huts, personal items of value, and food was left behind. Even a fire was still smoldering in front of a hut. It was as if they simply vanished into thi...

Episode 44 - On the morning of May 3rd, 1975, a farmer stumbled across something that they would never forget. A body was floating face-down in a river. Authorities came to the scene and recovered the body only to find that it belonged to a woman who was bound and wrapped in cloth and towels. For nearly five decades, the identity of this woman and the circumstances of her death remained unknown. S...

Episode 43 - On November 10th 1975, the largest ship on the Great Lakes sailed into one of the worst storms Lake Superior had ever seen. The ship attempted to make it to shore in Whitefish Bay but ended up vanishing without a trace, never reaching its destination. The SS Edmund Fitzgerald, considered the pride of American inland shipping, was lost along with twenty-nine crew members. At the time n...

For our Halloween Special we decided to investigate alleged haunted locations! Be sure to tune in on YouTube (see link below) October 17th, October 24th, and October 31st for 3 locations we visited. You're not going to want to miss this!   YouTube: http://www.youtube.com/@StrangeandUndecided  

Episode 42 - On May 10th, 1973, in the sleepy town of Kenora, Ontario. A man entered the Canadian Imperial Bank of Commerce (CIBC) on Main Street. He was armed with a rifle, a handgun, and a bomb. He demanded money from the bank and wouldn’t leave until he got what he wanted. Police officers arrived at the scene as well as a thousand civilians. But what happened next, became forever imprinted in t...

Episode 41 - Toronto, Ontario, a city known for its multiculturalism, gastronomy, the CN Tower, the Toronto Blue Jays, the Toronto Maple Leafs and much more. But what many people don’t realize is that Toronto has a much more mysterious and hidden side to it. One that lies underground. Beneath the bustling streets of Toronto's Cabbagetown neighborhood lies a legend that has been a mystery for over...

Episode 40 - On November 11th, 1975, a Canadian air force base in Falconbridge, Ontario picked up an unidentified object on their radar. Not only was this object detected by radar, but people could see it from the ground as well. Two fighter jets were scrambled to intercept the object but couldn't find it. This case is important as the witnesses involved here were highly credible military personne...

Episode 39 - The city of Abbotsford, British Columbia was calm on October 13th, 1995. Two teenagers were coming back from a party and decided to go to their friend’s house as they weren’t ready to call it a night. When they were walking, the teenagers were suddenly attacked by someone who jumped out of the bushes with a baseball bat. One of the girls managed to make it on foot to a nearby hospital...

Episode 38 - On May 16th, 2022, the partial remains of a woman were discovered in a garbage bin behind an apartment building in Winnipeg. The resulting investigation pointed towards the work of a serial killer and as time went on more people would be linked to this case. As of now in 2025, 4 indigenous women have been officially identified as victims however, finding these women’s bodies was a dif...

Episode 37 - On the afternoon of July 31, 1987, the city of Edmonton, Alberta, was struck by a sudden natural disaster. An exceptionally powerful tornado tore through the eastern edge of the city leaving behind a path of destruction. This was one of the deadliest tornadoes in Canadian history injuring many and leaving 27 people dead in its wake. The event came to be known to the citizens of Edmont...

Episode 36 - On December 15th, 2017, the bodies of 75-year-old Barry Sherman and his 70-year-old wife Honey Sherman were discovered in a room that contained their swimming pool. After an initial investigation, the police implied that this might be a case of murder-suicide but did not state it directly. It would prove to be a grave mistake. A separate private investigation conducted their own inves...

Episode 35 - On December 15th, 2017, the bodies of 75-year-old Barry Sherman and his 70-year-old wife Honey Sherman were discovered in a room that contained their swimming pool. After an initial investigation, the police implied that this might be a case of murder-suicide but did not state it directly. It would prove to be a grave mistake. A separate private investigation conducted their own inves...

Episode 34 - This week Jarret, Pat, and Brando narrate some scary stories from reddit. Make sure you’re cozy and somewhere safe. Check under your bed and your closet as well. Now that you’re ready, try not to get too scared. STORIES [True] The woman in the white dress : r/freehorrorstories I was stalked while on a hockey trip : r/freehorrorstories [True] Terrifying Childhood Dreams : r/freehorrors...

Episode 33 - On the night of February 3rd, 1880, a mob formed a plan to rid their town of a problem. This problem was the Donnelly family. They had been a problem for too long and made the community’s lives a living hell, it was time to deal with them once and for all. The mob attacked the Donnelly’s in their home and by the end of the night killed 5 of them. The main question is why? Why was the...

Episode 32 - On a cold night along the Klondike Highway in the Yukon Territory of Canada, something strange was spotted hovering in the sky. What people witnessed that night puzzles them to this day, but many are certain it was a UFO. To researchers, this case remains one of the most significant and mysterious UFO sightings in Canada history. The reason for its significance was that it involved a...

Episode 31 - On Labor Day Weekend in 1990, the Sousa family returned home from vacation. That night, someone broke into their house and attacked them. Lora Sousa, the mother, survived the attack however, her daughter Leah Sousa was not so fortunate. Her body was found the next day amidst a brutal crime scene. How was someone able to get away with such a heinous crime without being seen or heard? W...

Episode 30 - Canada’s nickname has been the great white north for as long as I can remember. The country is no stranger to snowstorms or ice. Some of these storms can cause schools and workplaces to shut down or even vehicles to slip off roads and highways. But some storms are worse than others. Much worse. Heading back in time to January of 1977, there was one such storm that hit Southern Ontario...

Episode 29 - When it comes to Halloween, what is the first thing that comes to mind? Carving pumpkins, trick or treating, or maybe dressing up. Dressing up as a terrifying monster perhaps? Some usual creatures that pop up this time of year might include vampires, werewolves, and even ghosts. Monsters that are simply make-believe and purely fun for the season, right? Well, what if I told you that t...

Episode 28 - During the late 1960's into the 1970's, farmers in Canada began noticing strange rings and circles showing up in their fields overnight. Nobody was quite sure what they were and with the UFO surge in the late 1970’s, the idea arose that they were made by aliens. People would travel from all corners of the world just to catch a glimpse of these "alien made" crop circles. Not everybody...

Episode 26 - Beginning in 2007, an individual was breaking into people's homes in the area of Tweed and Belleville in Ontario, Canada. They would pose in women’s and girl’s undergarments and steal them. The same thing began happening in the Ottawa suburb of Orleans, but these crimes started to escalate. Police believed that as this person kept evading authorities, they would become more emboldened...

Episode 25 - We have all heard about or have seen Canada’s breathtaking wilderness. Thickly packed forests, towering mountain ranges, and beautiful turquoise rivers. This week's story takes us to the Nahanni Valley, a place that many of you have never heard of before but it is no exception to the beauty of Canadian wilderness. Situated in the Northwest Territories, this national park consists of f...

Episode 24 - This week Jarret and Pat read you some more horror stories. Now sit back, get cozy, and try not to get too scared!   STORIES A disturbing chase. (TRUE) : r/freehorrorstories (reddit.com) [TRUE] Paranormal: My grandmothers haunted house : r/freehorrorstories (reddit.com) [FICTION] Do Not Enter : r/freehorrorstories (reddit.com) [TRUE] Was he holding a knife..? : r/freehorrorstories (re...

July 8th, 1965. Air Traffic Control in Vancouver was relatively quiet, and everything appeared normal. All of a sudden, they received a transmission “Mayday, mayday, mayday” but from who? Little did they know, one of their passenger planes carrying 52 people on board had crashed in a forest near 100 Mile House in the Cariboo Regional District of British Columbia. An explosion inside the plane caus...