Sports Cards Live

The conversation doesn't end when the auction begins. Jeremy Lee, David Chase, Joe Poirot, Josh Adams, and Robert Rothenberg wrap up this episode with a discussion about one of the hobby's most talked-about developing stories: the controversy surrounding assets formerly held by Collectible and their appearance in an upcoming Heritage Auctions sale. The panel explores the responsibilities of auctio...

Every collector's journey eventually changes. Jeremy Lee, Joe Poirot, Josh Adams, and Robert Rothenberg discuss what it's like to experience an entire hobby market cycle, from the explosive boom of 2020 through the correction that followed and into today's evolving market. Robert shares how he re-entered the hobby chasing the next superstar before eventually finding his passion in T206 cards, rare...

What actually makes a sports card beautiful? Jeremy Lee is joined by Robert Rothenberg, Josh Adams, and Joe Poirot for a fascinating conversation that challenges one of the hobby's most accepted beliefs: is centering really the most important part of eye appeal? The panel debates whether sharp corners, registration, color, focus, or centering should carry the most weight when evaluating vintage ca...

What is a sports card really worth? Jeremy Lee is joined by David Chase, Robert Rothenberg, Joe Poirot, and Leighton Sheldon for a wide-ranging discussion that begins with PSA's grading guarantee and quickly expands into some of the hobby's biggest unanswered questions. How should collectors interpret comparable sales when buyers and sellers often pay vastly different amounts after premiums, taxes...

Is the hobby quietly changing its mind about card restoration? Jeremy Lee, David Chase, and special guest Robert Rothenberg continue one of the most important conversations in today's hobby by examining real-world examples of restored vintage cards, including dramatic before-and-after transformations that have collectors questioning where conservation ends and alteration begins. The discussion exp...

The hobby's biggest ethical debate may just be getting started. Jeremy Lee and David Chase dive into one of the most polarizing topics in sports cards today: restoration, conservation, cleaning, and where the line should actually be drawn. Is removing scrapbook residue acceptable? Does soaking a card fundamentally alter it? Is restoration becoming normalized, and if so, what does that mean for gra...

As the world becomes increasingly digital, what happens to physical collectibles? Jeremy Lee and Chris Hoge close out the show with a wide-ranging discussion about the future of sports cards, exploring why tangible collectibles may become even more meaningful in an increasingly virtual world. The conversation examines everything from digital collectibles and NFTs to the psychology of collecting, t...

Has PSA's submission pause unintentionally created an entirely new market? Jeremy Lee, Chris HOJ, and Chad Hawk explore one of the most thought-provoking ideas to emerge from the grading discussion: could the hobby be witnessing the rise of the "soft slab"? With grading companies facing unprecedented demand, the panel discusses whether intermediate services like GCC, Beckett's former Raw Card Revi...

Where is the line between preserving a card and altering it? Jeremy Lee, Chris Hoge, and Chad Hawk tackle one of the hobby's most controversial topics after watching a video that demonstrates the restoration of a valuable LeBron James rookie card. Is restoration simply conservation, or does it fundamentally change what collectors are buying? The conversation expands into the growing challenge of d...

Can sports card grading evolve without completely reinventing the hobby? Jeremy Lee and David Chase continue their conversation with Chad Hawk, founder of GCC and former executive at Certified Collectibles Group, exploring whether the industry needs an entirely new approach to condition assessment. The discussion dives into the limits of traditional grading, the promise and challenges of AI, why T...

PSA has paused several of its most popular submission tiers, and the ripple effects are being felt across the hobby. Jeremy Lee and David Chase welcome Chad Hawk, founder of GCC and former executive with over two decades of experience at Certified Collectibles Group (CCG), to discuss what this moment means for collectors, dealers, grading companies, and the future of authentication. The conversati...

Can you really tell someone else how they should enjoy the hobby? This episode begins with a conversation that goes far beyond sports cards. Jeremy Lee and David Chase react to viewer feedback from last week's show and explore one of collecting's biggest philosophical questions: should collectors be concerned with how other people spend their money? The discussion covers funding purchases by selli...

The final segment of this special Sports Cards Live discussion brings the art collector versus investor debate to its conclusion as the panel explores what gives cards meaning beyond their price tags. Chris McGill, Joe Poirot, David Novak, Joshua Adams, and Jeremy Lee dive into the emotional, historical, and personal factors that shape collecting decisions and why some cards become far more signif...

The discussion takes a philosophical turn as Chris McGill introduces a framework comparing sports card collectors to both stock market investors and art collectors. Inspired by visits to the Chicago Art Institute and the Milwaukee Art Museum, Chris explores how collectors assign meaning, value, and significance to the items they pursue. The result is one of the most thought-provoking conversations...

The panel expands as Chris McGill and Joshua Adams join the conversation, leading to a fascinating discussion about late-90s football cards, hobby growth, collecting philosophy, and what truly makes a card significant. David Novak explains why he believes 1997 and 1998 football represent some of the most overlooked collecting opportunities in the hobby, while Chris McGill dives deep into the rarit...

The conversation gets deeper as David Novak joins Jeremy Lee and David Chase for a spirited discussion about sports cards as investments, generational attitudes toward risk, and whether collectors should view cardboard as part of a broader financial strategy. David shares his perspective on why some millennials are more willing to take calculated risks with their investment portfolios, sparking an...

Jeremy Lee and Joe Poirot welcome David Novak of Upstate Sports Cards to Sports Cards Live for a deep discussion on collecting philosophy, consolidation, and the mindset of today's hobbyist. David shares his journey from collecting everything from ultra-modern stars to vintage icons before ultimately narrowing his collection down to just a handful of cornerstone cards. The conversation explores wh...

Jeremy Lee and Joe Poirot kick off Episode 317 of Sports Cards Live with a look at several major developments happening across the hobby. Jeremy shares details on his new exclusive Fanatics Collect Originals series, The Hunt, including what viewers can expect from the live interactive format and why this next chapter is such an exciting opportunity. The conversation then shifts to Enter the Infern...

Following Bruce's appearance, the panel reflects on what they heard, what remains unanswered, and where the situation may go from here. The conversation explores credibility, responsibility, law enforcement, missing information, and the challenges of forming conclusions when key pieces of the story remain unknown. The panel also discusses the role of the mysterious third party at the center of the...

After unexpectedly joining the show, Bruce is given the opportunity to respond directly to the allegations surrounding the missing Tom Brady card and the funds at the center of the dispute. Bruce shares his version of events, explains his role in the transaction, addresses questions from Steve and the panel, and responds to accusations that have followed him throughout the hobby. As the discussion...

The panel continues its discussion on GOATs, Mount Rushmores, hobby significance, brand equity, aesthetics, and the forces that drive collector demand. Along the way, the conversation explores why some cards become hobby icons, whether brand recognition outweighs design, and how collectors develop their own personal rules and preferences. Then, something completely unexpected happens. A familiar n...

The conversation shifts from hobby scams to hobby opinions as the panel explores social media criticism, collecting philosophies, and the people who always seem to have the "right" way to collect. How much attention should collectors pay to critics, hobby gurus, and self-appointed experts? Is there really a correct way to collect, or is the hobby at its best when everyone follows their own path? T...

As the conversation continues, Diamond Card Collector opens up about life after the loss, why he refuses to walk away from the hobby, and the steps collectors can take to protect themselves when pursuing high-end cards. The discussion turns to accountability, trust, and the real-world impact these situations can have on collectors and their families. Steve also addresses the person he believes is...

Jeremy Lee and David Chase discuss a record-setting Wayne Gretzky and Gordie Howe card sale, the psychology of collecting grail cards, and the prices collectors would demand for pieces they never intended to sell. The conversation then shifts as Diamond Card Collector joins the show to revisit the Tom Brady card deal that stunned the hobby. Steve shares how the opportunity first came together, the...

The conversation moves beyond cards and into something deeper: how collectors with completely different motivations can still share the same hobby. As the debate over collecting versus investing continues, the panel explores the role of perspective, bias, identity, and why so many hobby disagreements stem from people approaching sports cards in fundamentally different ways. The discussion touches...