Sinister Sisters Crime and Curiosity

Jennifer Schuett was only eight years old when she was abducted while riding her bike near her home in Texas in 1990. She was brutally attacked and left for dead in a field, but against all odds she survived and later became a powerful voice for victims of violent crime. Despite the trauma, she worked with investigators over the years to help identify her attacker, never giving up on the pursuit o...

In August 2013, 19-year-old college student Bryce Laspisa set out on what should have been a routine drive home to see his parents. But after days of strange behavior, hours spent sitting on the side of the road, and a series of unsettling phone calls, Bryce seemingly vanished without a trace. His SUV was later discovered overturned near Castaic Lake, with his personal belongings left behind—but B...

What began as a Labor Day weekend party ended in tragedy when 19-year-old Noah Presgrove was found dead along Highway 81 in rural Oklahoma. With conflicting accounts, unanswered questions, and lingering suspicions, Noah's death has left investigators, loved ones, and the public searching for the truth. Join us as we examine the timeline, evidence, theories, and mysteries surrounding a case tha...

On February 14, 2000, 9-year-old Asha Degree vanished from her home in the early morning hours in rural North Carolina. Witnesses reported seeing a young girl walking alone along a dark highway during a storm, but despite decades of investigations, searches, and countless theories, Asha has never been found. In this episode of Sinister Sisters Crime & Curiosity , we examine the timeline of her...

What began as a catastrophic crash soon exposed something far more unsettling. In this episode, we descend into the dark story behind Netflix's The Crash , where warning signs were overlooked, questions went unanswered, and tragedy seemed destined long before disaster struck. As the pieces are put back together, a chilling possibility emerges: this wasn't just a crash—it was a catastrophe...

In this chilling account, we uncover the unsettling disappearance of Relisha Rudd, a young girl who slipped into the shadows of Washington, D.C. We follow the eerie trail of unanswered questions, missed chances, and the haunting mystery that still remains.

In this episode, we delve into the unsettling mystery surrounding Rebecca Zahau’s death. Found under chilling circumstances at a mansion, questions linger—was it truly as it seemed? We examine the facts, theories, and lingering shadows behind “The Silence Behind the Mansion.”

We step into the eerie events of the day Kyron Horman vanished from his school, leaving behind only questions. This episode unravels the timelines, theories, and the haunting mystery that still surrounds his disappearance.

In this episode, we descend into the haunting enigma surrounding Elisa Lam. From the unsettling elevator footage to the chilling discovery atop the Cecil Hotel, we trace the unanswered questions that echo through the case. The mysterious death of Elisa Lam awaits.

On a dark spring night, Brandon Swanson vanished into the unknown after his car found a rural ditch. Despite phone calls, searches, and endless speculation, he was never seen again. In this episode, we unravel the strange timeline, chilling details, and the enduring mystery of Brandon Swanson’s disappearance.

This season, the shadows are darker, and the secrets are more curious than ever. Sinister Sisters: Crime & Curiosity—Season 2 is here, and the mysteries have only just begun.

Dive into the mysterious disappearance of Amy Lynn Bradley, a 23-year-old who vanished without a trace from the cruise ship Rhapsody of the Seas in 1998. In this episode, we explore the timeline of that eerie night, the unanswered questions, and the haunting theories that continue to surround her case. Did she fall overboard—or was something far more sinister at play?

Some people don’t just dream… they remember. This episode dives into the unsettling world of reincarnation—where the past refuses to stay buried.

Behind every story, there’s a storyteller. In this episode, Bree and Ash take a break from the cases to answer your questions and share more about themselves—their interests, experiences, and what brought them to Sinister Sisters Crime & Curiosity .

In the summer of 1972, sixteen-year-old Jeannette DePalma vanished without a trace from Springfield Township, New Jersey. Weeks later, a chilling discovery was made deep in the woods near Houdaille Quarry — her body lying in a remote clearing, surrounded by strange objects and whispers of occult activity. Rumors of ritual symbols, secret gatherings in the woods, and a town gripped by fear quickly...

On a snow-covered night in Philadelphia, Ellen Greenberg was found dead inside her locked apartment — stabbed again and again in what authorities ruled a suicide. But the scene felt wrong. The wounds, the timing, the unanswered calls… and a door no one could open. Was Ellen alone in that apartment, or did something far darker slip in before the lock sealed shut?

In this episode, we dive into the mysterious death of Kendrick Johnson, a Georgia teenager found inside a rolled-up gym mat in 2013. What was first ruled an accident quickly turned into a case filled with conflicting evidence, unanswered questions, and nationwide controversy. We explore the timeline, the investigations, and the theories that continue to surround Kendrick Johnson’s name.

A small-town disappearance. A brutal murder. A case that exposed jealousy, obsession, and betrayal. This episode dives into the tragic death of Darlene Kay VanderGiesen—an Iowa woman whose life was cut short in a shocking act of violence. What started as a missing person case quickly unraveled into something far more sinister.

In 1978, five men left a basketball game in Chico, California — and never made it home. Their car was later found abandoned high in the mountains. It wasn’t damaged. It wasn’t out of gas. Yet they walked away into freezing darkness with no clear reason why. Months later, disturbing discoveries revealed that one man survived for weeks, surrounded by food and shelter he barely used. Why did they lea...

When your body sleeps… your mind awakens. In this episode of Sinister Sisters , we step beyond reality and into the shadows of the subconscious. We break down different types of dreams — vivid dreams, nightmares, recurring dreams, prophetic-feeling dreams, and the ones that leave you waking up with your heart racing. Are dreams warnings? Memories? Messages from your subconscious — or something mor...

In this episode, we shine a light on two heartbreaking missing persons cases: Kevin Collins Jr. and William Ebeneezer Jones Jr. We discuss the known facts, timelines, and unanswered questions surrounding their disappearances, keeping their names and stories alive. Our goal is awareness, compassion, and the hope that sharing these cases may help bring answers and justice to the families who are sti...

Disclaimer We are not professionals just two friends who love true crime. This is raw audio and wasn't edited. Also this is our first episode. We hope you enjoy! In this episode, we discuss the Mysterious of Death of Tiffany Valiante , an 18 year old from Mays Landing, New Jersey, whose life was tragically cut far too short. Although her death was ruled a suicide, much of the surrounding evide...