Sincerely Supernatural Podcast

Two fishermen. One river. Two terrifying encounters. In this episode of Sincerely Supernatural, we investigate two eyewitness reports from New Jersey's Musconetcong River involving a mysterious humanoid creature with the head of a praying mantis. Both witnesses describe an eerie atmosphere, intense eye contact, and something that shouldn't have been possible—including a creature that appea...

In 1955, two families in rural Kentucky claimed their farmhouse was surrounded by strange, glowing creatures unlike anything they had ever seen. What began as a reported UFO sighting quickly became one of the most famous—and bizarre—encounters in American paranormal history. In this episode of Sincerely Supernatural, we explore the Kelly-Hopkinsville Goblin encounter, the eyewitness testimony, the...

In 1961, Betty and Barney Hill reported what would become the most famous alien abduction case in history. Years later, under hypnosis, Barney recalled terrifying details of a UFO encounter that left him visibly shaken. In this episode of Sincerely Supernatural, we examine the Hill case, listen to the chilling hypnosis recordings, and discuss the evidence, theories, and lasting impact of a story t...

In this episode of Sincerely Supernatural, I interview my brother Richard about a series of strange experiences while hunting deep in Wyoming's remote Wind River Mountains. During one unforgettable night in elk camp, he and his son heard unexplained whistles and tree knocks outside their tent. As lifelong hunters familiar with wildlife behavior, they struggled to explain what they experienced....

In this episode of Sincerely Supernatural, my wife shares her firsthand encounter with a towering Sasquatch deep in the Montana wilderness. From strange noises in the forest to an unforgettable face-to-face sighting, we explore one of the most chilling Bigfoot stories we've ever discussed. Sincerely Supernatural delves into a myriad of subjects including ghosts, UFO's and aliens, demonic a...

In this episode of Sincerely Supernatural, Morgan shares multiple real-life paranormal experiences from her childhood, teenage years, and adulthood—including unexplained activity in family homes, disturbing nighttime encounters, and one of the most unsettling phone calls ever experienced. From objects moving on their own to footsteps, strange voices, and a phone call that seemed to come from insid...

Did the first real UFO footage come from Montana? In this episode of Sincerely Supernatural, we dive into the shocking Mariana UFO footage captured over Great Falls in 1950 — and the terrifying 1967 incident where glowing UFOs allegedly shut down nuclear missile silos at Malmstrom Air Force Base. Missing film frames. Military witnesses. Red glowing objects hovering over nuclear weapons sites. What...

The Black Eyed Kids are one of the internet’s most disturbing urban legends…but are they real? In this episode of Sincerely Supernatural, we dive into the original 1996 Black Eyed Kids encounter, creepy pastas, Slender Man, demonic deception, and whether fictional internet horror can become something much darker. Could modern paranormal legends be more than just stories? Links: Video of a rake cre...

In 1980, military personnel stationed near Rendlesham Forest encountered strange lights moving through the woods — and recorded the event on tape. In this episode of Sincerely Supernatural, we break down the Rendlesham Forest Incident, the real military audio recordings, witness testimony, UFO sightings, and the mystery surrounding Britain’s most famous UFO encounter. #RendleshamForest #UFO #UAP #...

Hunters deep in the Sierra Nevada Mountains recorded strange, unexplained sounds in the wilderness. What they captured has left many wondering… could this be Bigfoot? Listen closely and decide for yourself. Have you ever heard anything like this in the woods? Sincerely Supernatural delves into a myriad of subjects including ghosts, UFO's and aliens, demonic activity, cryptids, conspiracies and...

In 1974 Carl Higdon entered the Medicine Bow National Forest in search for Elk. This hunter had no idea that the he would become the hunted. Join Seth and Hudson as they recount Carl's incredible experience of UFO's, Aliens and interplanetary travel! Today's Links : A book about the encounter by Carl's Wife Sincerely Supernatural delves into a myriad of subjects including ghosts, U...

We're off to Flatwoods, West Virginia - As Hudson recounts a strange encounter from the 1950's. Did the inhabitants of a small farming community come face to face with an Alien, a Cryptid, or both!? Today's Links: Original newspaper article and artist rendition Flatwoods monster in the Zelda video game Flatwoods monster in Fallout video game Sincerely Supernatural delves into a myriad...

Travel back in time with us to Phoenix, Arizona - to one of the largest UFO mass sightings in History. Seth tells a story about a shapeshifting craft and Hudson recounts stories of ancient UFO's. Today's Links: Footage of the Phoenix Lights Arizona Governor Press Conference Arizona Governor Interview Kurt Russel Interview UFO's over Nuremberg Sincerely Supernatural delves into a myriad...

In this pilot episode, hosts Seth and Hudson recount the strange experiences from the their pasts that propelled them into their interest in the paranormal and the supernatural. Sincerely Supernatural delves into a myriad of subjects including ghosts, UFO's and aliens, demonic activity, cryptids, conspiracies and more! Have you had an encounter with the paranormal? Send your stories to sincere...