Second Rounds On Us

Welcome back to I Killed My Tamagotchi! The tape starts rolling and Tommy James confesses that every Sunday night before school, he'd watch Wayne's World... followed by Spice World. That confession launches the first You Only Get 10: Guilty Pleasure Movies, as Tommy and Matt each bring ten movies they're almost embarrassed to admit they love and fight to build the ultimate guilty pleasure box set....

Welcome back to I Killed My Tamagotchi! The tape starts rolling and Mista Malave finally makes his long-awaited debut with a confession that proves his childhood obsession with Britney Spears may have gone just a little too far. With A-Town away, Tommy James and Mista Malave aka. The Music Man expand Secret Mixtape Vol. 1 with five more guilty pleasure songs, defending forgotten favorites, revisit...

Welcome back to I Killed My Tamagotchi! Tommy James and Alex "A-Town" Ryan kick off the first-ever Secret Mixtape, each bringing ten guilty pleasure songs to the table but with only ten spots available, every pick has to earn its place. Along the way, they debate what truly qualifies as a guilty pleasure, defend some questionable favorites, and try to build the ultimate nostalgic playlist. Plus, "...

Welcome back to I Killed My Tamagotchi! Tommy James and Alex "A-Town" Ryan morph into the world of Mighty Morphin Power Rangers to revisit the franchise that helped define a generation. From unforgettable Rangers and iconic villains to the episodes that still hold up today, the guys debate what made the original series so special—and why some of its biggest creative decisions still spark arguments...

Welcome back to I Killed My Tamagotchi! Tommy James and Alex "A-Town" Ryan dive headfirst into the golden age of Nickelodeon game shows, revisiting the slime, the legends, and the unforgettable challenges that made kids dream of getting picked from the audience. From favorite hosts and iconic sets to the games they'd love to play today, the guys relive one of television's most chaotic eras. Plus,...

Welcome to the very first episode of I Killed My Tamagotchi! Tommy James and Alex "A-Town" Ryan take on one of the toughest nostalgic debates imaginable: ranking the greatest songs from the Disney Renaissance. From unforgettable ballads to show-stopping anthems, every pick is up for debate as they try to decide which classics truly deserve a place at the top. Plus, "Where Were We When?" heads back...

Mista Malave steps in as host and throws A-Town Ryan and reigning Second Rounds On Us Champion Tommy James into the deep end of Absurd Logic, where the rules are simple: take two completely unrelated TV shows and somehow make it make sense. We’re talking chaotic crossover pitches featuring worlds that were never meant to collide—like Always Sunny In Philadelphia, Westworld, Scrubs, and Breaking Ba...

Fresh off his totally deserved (he’ll tell you himself) championship win, Tommy James takes the host chair to run everyone’s favorite beautifully unhinged game: Absurd Logic. This round, Florida’s Favorite Creep Sabrina Ace squares up against Mista Malave in a battle of creativity, chaos, and questionable decision-making. The challenge? Take a completed sitcom, keep only two human characters, and...

In this episode of the 2026 Who You Got Challenge, the crew takes on The Smooth Bracket — a tournament packed with characters that range from unstoppable icons to picks that make you immediately question someone’s judgment. Joining Tommy James, Florida’s Favorite Creep Sabrina, and defending chaos enthusiast Mista Malave is special guest Bobby from The GNP Project, while Challenge Administrator A-...

The 2026 Who You Got Challenge for MegaCon Orlando continues on with The Creep Bracket—a lineup so chaotic it probably violates several laws of physics, logic, and basic common sense. Joining the madness are Florida’s Favorite Creep Sabrina, Mista Malave, Tommy James, Mike “Schmidthauser”, and our suffering Challenge Administrator Mr. A-Town Ryan, whose job is basically to keep this circus from co...

The 2026 Who You Got Challenge truly begins with Malave’s side of the MegaCon bracket, and things get messy fast. Mista Malave, Florida’s Favorite Creep Sabrina, Tommy James, and Mr. A-Town Ryan step into the arena to break down a lineup of fictional fights that absolutely no one on the internet agrees about. Under the Fair Grounds rules, characters are capped, prep time exists, and “because they’...

The Who You Got Challenge is officially out of retirement — rebuilt from the ground up for 2026. Old brackets? Gone. Previous records? Cleared. Excuses? Deleted. This year starts with the MegaCon Draft. Reigning champion Mista Malave returns to defend his reputation. Tommy James is here to cause problems. And making her official challenge debut, Sabrina Ace steps into the game. Four categories:Mov...

We're back from Spring Break as we inch ever close to finishing the second semester, the class gets together to discuss VAMPIRES! We really wish Salma Hayek was here with us as we sink our teeth into the Vamp lore, the good and the bad of Vamp powers.  The movies that had just wanting to be one and movies that made us question why Vampires exist!  Join us as we say hello to the night while as...

Welcome to a special bonus segments from Night School Horror, entitled "The Study Hall".  The Study Hall will be a short separate piece of NSH where a single host comes on to talk about Trends in Horror or maybe a specific movie they've seen that doesn't require a full class episode.  On this The Study Hall, Florida's Favorite Creep heads into the booth to discuss the colorfu...

Tonight we show our appreciation and disapproval for Blumhouse Productions.  Join our class as The Movie Guy Bay Bay Tommy James and Florida's Favorite Creep Sabrina Ace pull up the Blumhouse timeline and see where they started to where they are now, while Mista Malave stands outside to stare at the eclipse!  The films that make us happy, cry, scared and mostly....MAD. Jason Blum as given us m...

Join the class today as we play "Choose Your Own Adventure" with our guest student Mr. A-Town Ryan!  Today Florida's Favorite Creep guides The Movie Guy Bay Bay, Mista Malave and Mr. A-Town Ryan through a world of decisions, mystery and fear!  Together as a team they decide whether to go left, right, up, down....live or die? Piano rift or not to Piano rift????? Tune in to find out mo...

Welcome to a new special bonus segments from Night School Horror, entitled "The Study Hall".  The Study Hall will be a short separate piece of NSH where a single host comes on to talk about Trends in Horror or maybe a specific movie they've seen that doesn't require a full class episode.  On the first edition of The Study Hall, our register Movie Guy Bay Bay is here to discuss Bl...

Join us in the classroom as "Florida's Favorite Creep" Sabrina Ace takes the lead alongside, "The Movie Guy Bay Bay" Tommy James, and a cast of demonic entities lurking in the shadows. With Mista Malave on a quest for sage to exorcise the looming spirits, the stage is set for an electrifying discussion. Listen as they rank between 8 possession movies from best to worst base...

Mr. A-Town calls for the greatest team to assemble to defeat the greatest evil of them all as Florida's Favorite Creep Sabrina Ace, Mista Malave and The Movie Guy Bay Bay Tommy James try to come up with their perfect Power Rangers team to defeat the threat that Mr. A-Town has brought forth to us! Listen as we create our own stories, team, powers and twist as Absurd Logic returns with a topic b...

Our friends at Strike Media Ltd have hooked us up with a doozy! In todays class we discuss the film being brought to you by Shudder and Vertigo Releasing called, Late Night With The Devil . In 1977 a live television broadcast goes horribly wrong, unleashing evil into living rooms across the United States. The film stars David Dastmalchian (Dune, The Dark Knight) as Jack Delroy, host of a late-nigh...

Welcome back to another surprise POP QUIZ!  Join Florida's favorite creep for three rounds of bone-chilling questions and unexpected twists. Watch as Mista Malave faces off against "The Movie Guy Bay Bay" Tommy James in a battle for academic supremacy where victory may not matter, but the adrenaline rush surely does! Think you can pass our pop quiz? Let us know how you did and enroll...

After a little hiatus from our classroom, the crew has returned with a special project brought to us by Strike-Media and Hammer Films! A modern re-imagining of the infamous Dr. Jekyll from Robert Louis Stevenson's 1886 novella The Strange Case of Dr Jekyll and Mr. Hyde, Doctor Jekyll starring Eddie Izzard and Scott Chambers. Listen as we breakdown the acting and aura of Eddie Izzard, the funny...

Get ready for a post-MegaCon whirlwind as our dynamic trio, The Who You Got Champion Mista Malave, Florida's Favorite Creep Sabina Ace, and The Movie Guy Bay Bay Tommy James, return to the podcasting classroom! This week, they're taking on the challenge of reimagining three iconic movies for the better. Join us as we embark on a cinematic journey where the rules are rewritten, the cast is...

We're swapping textbooks for floaties as Night School Horror meets Night Swim Horror. Join the splashy chaos as we dissect this years January's haunted pool flick—where Marco Polo turns sinister, and Rose Byrne is conspicuously absent. Get ready for a wet and wild ride as we unravel the mystery, questioning why no one saw it coming. Will this aquatic nightmare sink or swim into a sequel?

Join our charismatic hosts as they assemble dream teams from Scrubs, Brooklyn Nine-Nine, New Girl, and How I Met Your Mother. Get ready for the laughs and chaos as Dr. Turk, Jake Peralta, Jessica Day, and Marshall Eriksen face off in the gymnasium! Will the Scrubs squad outwit the Nine-Nine crew? Can New Girl's quirkiness triumph over HIMYM's legendary playbook? It's a battle of sitcom...