Forever Dog

Scary Stories To Tell On The Pod

Comedy EN ↓ 300 episodes

Join SNL's Anna Drezen and comedian Andrew Farmer for an hilarious deep dive into the terrifying world of American folklore, ghost stories, hauntings, and urban legends, through the lens of the classic children's series Scary Stories To Tell In The Dark. Produced by the Forever Dog Podcast Network.

Author

Forever Dog

Episodes

The Ghosts of “A Christmas Carol” 21.12.2025 38:18

Anna and Andrew return for a ghostly Yuletide treat as they reflect on Dickens’ famed apparitions. - Credits & Links! Listener mail: scarystorypod@gmail.com Follow Andrew - @thatsajellyfish on Instagram & Twitter Follow Anna - @annadrezen on Instagram & Twitter Follow The Pod - @scarystory_pod on Instagram & Twitter MERCH - tee.pub/lic/bdCk0NATv7o Music - Chris Ryan Producing - Jas...

A Halloween Treat 31.10.2025 23:42

In honor of the spookiest day of all, Andrew reads the classic M.R. James ghost story "Lost Hearts." - Credits & Links! Listener mail: scarystorypod@gmail.com Follow Andrew - @thatsajellyfish on Instagram & Twitter Follow Anna - @annadrezen on Instagram & Twitter Follow The Pod - @scarystory_pod on Instagram & Twitter MERCH - tee.pub/lic/bdCk0NATv7o Music - Chris Ryan Producing - J...

St Elmo and Dirty Annie 23.10.2025 32:48

Anna and Andrew learn about an abandoned mining town and its legendary eccentric, then discuss hot people and the proper pronunciation of the word proboscis.  - Credits & Links! Listener mail: scarystorypod@gmail.com Follow Andrew - @thatsajellyfish on Instagram & Twitter Follow Anna - @annadrezen on Instagram & Twitter Follow The Pod - @scarystory_pod on Instagram & Twitter M...

We Gotta Talk About Harold Again 16.10.2025 29:38

Returning to their roots, Anna and Andrew once more crack open “Scary Stories to Tell in the Dark,” to revisit their favorite doll the size of a man, “Harold.” - Credits & Links! Listener mail: scarystorypod@gmail.com Follow Andrew - @thatsajellyfish on Instagram & Twitter Follow Anna - @annadrezen on Instagram & Twitter Follow The Pod - @scarystory_pod on Instagram & Twitter MERCH...

Orb in the Sears House (w/ Kelly Lyon) 12.10.2025 49:21

Anna and Jason(?!) are joined by Emmy Award-winning editor Kelly Lyon, who tells the tale of her haunted house. - Credits & Links! Listener mail: scarystorypod@gmail.com Follow Andrew - @thatsajellyfish on Instagram & Twitter Follow Anna - @annadrezen on Instagram & Twitter Follow The Pod - @scarystory_pod on Instagram & Twitter MERCH - tee.pub/lic/bdCk0NATv7o Music - Chris Ryan Pr...

Axe Murder House Reviews 02.10.2025 50:24

Anna and Andrew share the chilling tale of a house haunted by an axe murdering ghost, and the subsequent online reviews of the nightly rental it has become. - Credits & Links! Listener mail: scarystorypod@gmail.com Follow Andrew - @thatsajellyfish on Instagram & Twitter Follow Anna - @annadrezen on Instagram & Twitter Follow The Pod - @scarystory_pod on Instagram & Twitter MERCH -...

Phantom Island 25.09.2025 41:52

Anna and Andrew RETURN for High Spooky Season with a tale of haunting cartography and a tarot reading for our gentle listeners! - Credits & Links! Listener mail: scarystorypod@gmail.com Follow Andrew - @thatsajellyfish on Instagram & Twitter Follow Anna - @annadrezen on Instagram & Twitter Follow The Pod - @scarystory_pod on Instagram & Twitter MERCH - ⁠tee.pub/lic/bdCk0NATv7o⁠ Mus...

Industrial Ghosts and Hotel Hat Men 07.05.2025 52:18

Special guest Anna Thorup returns to weigh in on some reader submitted spooky tales! - Credits & Links! Listener mail: scarystorypod@gmail.com Follow Andrew - @thatsajellyfish on Instagram & Twitter Follow Anna - @annadrezen on Instagram & Twitter Follow The Pod - @scarystory_pod on Instagram & Twitter MERCH - tee.pub/lic/bdCk0NATv7o Music - Chris Ryan Producing - Jason Hammons Cov...

Broken Mirrors and Elevator Accidents 01.05.2025 29:50

Special guest Anna Thorup (Monster High) regales the pod with tales of her childhood ghost-hunting service and home haunting. - Credits & Links! Listener mail: scarystorypod@gmail.com Follow Andrew - @thatsajellyfish on Instagram & Twitter Follow Anna - @annadrezen on Instagram & Twitter Follow The Pod - @scarystory_pod on Instagram & Twitter MERCH - tee.pub/lic/bdCk0NATv7o Music -...

Yoko, Faulkner & Sloppy Joe 22.04.2025 33:24

Anna and Andrew weigh in one Yoko Ono, “The Crucible” and “As I Lay Dying” in this eclectic episode. - Credits & Links! Listener mail: scarystorypod@gmail.com Follow Andrew - @thatsajellyfish on Instagram & Twitter Follow Anna - @annadrezen on Instagram & Twitter Follow The Pod - @scarystory_pod on Instagram & Twitter MERCH - tee.pub/lic/bdCk0NATv7o Music - Chris Ryan Producing - J...

Ghouls and Moral Conundrums 15.04.2025 23:59

Anna and Andrew crack open an account of a supposed "Pishach" encounter in an Indian graveyard and discuss savior complexes and what form a ghoul would have to take in order to fall for their scheme. - Credits & Links! Listener mail: scarystorypod@gmail.com Follow Andrew - @thatsajellyfish on Instagram & Twitter Follow Anna - @annadrezen on Instagram & Twitter Follow The Pod - @scaryst...

Big Bird. No Not That One. 09.04.2025 27:17

Anna and Andrew soar into the world of Avian Cryptids, both the frightful and the majestic. - Credits & Links! Listener mail: scarystorypod@gmail.com Follow Andrew - @thatsajellyfish on Instagram & Twitter Follow Anna - @annadrezen on Instagram & Twitter Follow The Pod - @scarystory_pod on Instagram & Twitter MERCH - tee.pub/lic/bdCk0NATv7o Music - Chris Ryan Producing - Jason Hamm...

Frankenstein Reflections 26.03.2025 36:55

Anna and Andrew unearth an excerpt from Mary Shelley’s classic “Frankenstein” and discuss various abominations they’ve been responsible for. - Credits & Links! Listener mail: scarystorypod@gmail.com Follow Andrew - @thatsajellyfish on Instagram & Twitter Follow Anna - @annadrezen on Instagram & Twitter Follow The Pod - @scarystory_pod on Instagram & Twitter MERCH - tee.pub/lic/bdCk...

Bats, Olive & The Faces on The Ceiling 19.03.2025 21:27

In this special edition li'l minisode, Andrew shares some true stories about attic bats, harbinger doppelgangers and a haunted hospital from his new solo show "I Don't Wanna Scare You." Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices See Privacy Policy at https://art19.com/privacy and California Privacy Notice at https://art19.com/privacy#do-not-sell-my-info .

Talking to Ghosts and Producers 11.03.2025 31:46

Anna and Andrew crack into the worlds of paranormal investigation and movie producing only to stumble upon the surprising qualities that link them. Other topics discussed: confusing 90's toys, dubiously heroic dogs and pond ghosts. - Credits & Links! Listener mail: scarystorypod@gmail.com Follow Andrew - @thatsajellyfish on Instagram & Twitter Follow Anna - @annadrezen on Instagram & T...

Grim Reaper SIghtings 04.03.2025 35:51

Inspired by a gentle listener’s drive-thru encounter with the Grim Reaper, Anna and Andrew unearth other such encounters in hospitals, cemeteries, Pizza Hut ads and the coronation of King Charles. - Credits & Links! Listener mail: scarystorypod@gmail.com Follow Andrew - @thatsajellyfish on Instagram & Twitter Follow Anna - @annadrezen on Instagram & Twitter Follow The Pod - @scarystory...

Fan Death and Devil Questions 19.02.2025 31:14

Anna and Andrew unpack the urban legend of “Fan Death” then peruse the internet for their low-stake questions about Lucifer. - Credits & Links! Listener mail: scarystorypod@gmail.com Follow Andrew - @thatsajellyfish on Instagram & Twitter Follow Anna - @annadrezen on Instagram & Twitter Follow The Pod - @scarystory_pod on Instagram & Twitter MERCH - tee.pub/lic/bdCk0NATv7o Music -...

A Sleepy Triptych 13.02.2025 46:04

Anna and Andrew doze off into three different sleep related tales, concerning a haunted headrest, a prophetic dream and a longwinded lecturer. - Credits & Links! Listener mail: scarystorypod@gmail.com Follow Andrew - @thatsajellyfish on Instagram & Twitter Follow Anna - @annadrezen on Instagram & Twitter Follow The Pod - @scarystory_pod on Instagram & Twitter MERCH - tee.pub/lic/bd...

The Horrors of ChatGPT 04.02.2025 44:39

Anna and Andrew delve into the deeply basic horror of AI text generators and discuss inventive nightmares and throat bumps. - Credits & Links! Listener mail: scarystorypod@gmail.com Follow Andrew - @thatsajellyfish on Instagram & Twitter Follow Anna - @annadrezen on Instagram & Twitter Follow The Pod - @scarystory_pod on Instagram & Twitter MERCH - tee.pub/lic/bdCk0NATv7o Music - C...

Dracula's Guest 28.01.2025 34:59

Anna and Andrew return with the classic Bram Stoker short story "Dracula's Guest" and discuss natural disasters, non-Dracula vampires and panic responses. - Credits & Links! Listener mail: scarystorypod@gmail.com Follow Andrew - @thatsajellyfish on Instagram & Twitter Follow Anna - @annadrezen on Instagram & Twitter Follow The Pod - @scarystory_pod on Instagram & Twitter MERCH - te...

Sit-Up Pillow People 24.12.2024 33:44

In this cozy Yuletide ep, Anna and Andrew share some stories of Appalachian phantom knocks, seasonal home invasions and a couple truly jolly listener emails. - Credits & Links! Listener mail: scarystorypod@gmail.com Follow Andrew - @thatsajellyfish on Instagram & Twitter Follow Anna - @annadrezen on Instagram & Twitter Follow The Pod - @scarystory_pod on Instagram & Twitter MERCH -...

“The Dead Girl” or “A Bimbo For Snow” 19.12.2024 38:21

Anna and Andrew read Guy de Maupassant’s terrifying romantic tragedy “The Dead Girl” and discuss French horror, media literacy and embarrassing tombstone confessions. - Credits & Links! Listener mail: scarystorypod@gmail.com Follow Andrew - @thatsajellyfish on Instagram & Twitter Follow Anna - @annadrezen on Instagram & Twitter Follow The Pod - @scarystory_pod on Instagram & Twitte...

Coffin Naps and Severed Heads 11.12.2024 35:19

In this grab bag ep, Anna and Andrew discuss spooky “it girls” like Sarah Bernhardt, Medusa and Herman Melville. - Credits & Links! Listener mail: scarystorypod@gmail.com Follow Andrew - @thatsajellyfish on Instagram & Twitter Follow Anna - @annadrezen on Instagram & Twitter Follow The Pod - @scarystory_pod on Instagram & Twitter MERCH - tee.pub/lic/bdCk0NATv7o Music - Chris Ryan P...

The Wicked Witch of the West 04.12.2024 46:14

In honor of a certain recent blockbuster film, Anna and Andrew go back to the literary origins of the Wicked Witch of the West. - Credits & Links! Listener mail: scarystorypod@gmail.com Follow Andrew - @thatsajellyfish on Instagram & Twitter Follow Anna - @annadrezen on Instagram & Twitter Follow The Pod - @scarystory_pod on Instagram & Twitter MERCH - tee.pub/lic/bdCk0NATv7o Music...

Good for Gay! 26.11.2024 23:59

In this Thanksgiving-adjacent ep, Anna and Andrew mine for ghoulish gold in the collection of West Virginian ghost stories, “The Telltale Lilac Bush” but find things a lot gayer than they expected. - Credits & Links! Listener mail: scarystorypod@gmail.com Follow Andrew - @thatsajellyfish on Instagram & Twitter Follow Anna - @annadrezen on Instagram & Twitter Follow The Pod - @scarystor...