Replay Reviews

We're closing the season out by looking back at all the games we've played and handing out awards to our favorite moments and characters. We'll see you next season! Don't forget to watch or play along - gameplay is posted weekly on our YouTube channel! You can also find us on our website, Instagram, Reddit, and Twitter. Please consider supporting Eggy Toast if you enjoyed the music in this episode...

Scerry Christmas! This year, we are discussing the legendary Red Dead Redemption DLC, Undead Nightmare. In part two, with help from West Dickens, John find his way to Mexico where he allies with Mother Superior Calderon, helping her perform tests on the undead. In this episode, we dig into Mother Superior's insightful quote and are not surprised to hear "National Gigolo" Abraham Reyes is involved...

Scerry Christmas! This year, we will be discussing the legendary Red Dead Redemption DLC, Undead Nightmare. In part one, we pick up after John returns to his farm, but before the Pinkertons come knocking. Uncle is mysteriously missing until he arrives in an even more mysterious state. In this episode, we discuss how John's demeanor has changed from the main game, as well as Seth's NUMEROUS issues,...

Welcome back to Uncharted 1! In the summary episode, we investigate our burning questions, reveal the stats we tracked, and hand out KFC (Kathy's Favorite Character) Awards. We'll also give our final thoughts on the ending and speculate about the rest of the franchise. Don't forget to watch or play along - gameplay is posted weekly on our YouTube channel! Join us next week as we start a new game...

Welcome back to Uncharted 1! In part five, we analyze our final gameplay video where competition for the lost treasure heats up as the trail nears its end and loyalties are tested. When an unexpected discovery is made, some questions are answered and a new threat presents itself. In this episode, we talk about Nathan's probable regret after discovering Sir Francis Drake's true demise, and his rela...

Welcome back to Uncharted 1! In part four, we analyze our fourth gameplay video where Francis Drake's diary leads Nathan underground as he continues to search for the treasure... and a way out. However, as Nathan closes in, so do Roman and Navarro. In this episode, we talk about Roman's accent (did he always sound like that?), Nathan's dramatics, and WHAT was that noise? Also discussed, is the rel...

Welcome to our 100th episode! In this special episode, we discuss our favorite moments, out-of-context clips, and decide on an ultimate character. Thank you to all who listen to RRPod and share in our memories of two friends replaying, reviewing, and analyzing your favorite video games. We'll see you next week as we continue Uncharted! Please consider supporting Eggy Toast if you enjoyed the music...

Welcome back to Uncharted 1! In part three, we analyze our third gameplay video: when new clues and questions of loyalty come into play, Nathan questions the safety of continuing in the hunt for the El Dorado treasure - especially when he and Elena run into a chilling discovery. In this episode, we talk about the satisfying and realistic character development, as well as Elena's invincible camera...

Welcome back to Uncharted 1! In part two, we analyze our second gameplay video where Nathan traverses unfamiliar ruins looking for Elena and clues to El Dorado. Notably, we talk about the miracle map (no way it's still in the plane), Nathan and Eddy Raja's background, and who else may be involved in all of this. Also discussed, is the imbalanced gameplay and enemies' sudden switch to English. Don'...

Welcome to Uncharted 1! In part one, we analyze our first gameplay video where we we join Nathan Drake in his search for Sir Francis Drake's treasure. Notably, we talk about Nathan's lack of survival instincts (maybe don't run in FRONT of the torpedo?), the irresistibility of a shoulder holster, and is that Neal McDonough? Also, is Sully a slut... 🤔 Don't forget to watch or play along - gameplay...

Welcome back to The Forest! In the summary episode, we investigate our burning questions, such as, what's with the red paint, and how can Sahara keep knocking planes out of the sky? We'll also discuss game theories, hand out KFC (Kathy's Favorite Character) Awards, and give our final thoughts on the two endings. Don't forget to watch or play along - gameplay is posted weekly on our YouTube channel...

Happy Horror Month and welcome back to The Forest! In part four, we analyze our fourth gameplay video where some mysteries are solved but others still remain as the story comes to an end. Though Eric makes his escape from the island, the aftermath of Sahara Therapeutics' testing appears to be far from over. In this episode, we talk about the downfall of Dr. Cross, learn of his "Jarius Project," an...

Happy Horror Month and welcome back to The Forest! In part three, we analyze our third gameplay video where we inch ever so closer to finding Timmy while additional discoveries lead us to question the identities of the other plane passengers, as well as the backstory of our protagonist, Eric LeBlanc. In this episode, we talk about the prevalence of red paint and what makes Eric instantly know to p...

Happy Horror Month and welcome back to The Forest! In part two, we analyze our second gameplay video where we continue the search for Timmy and find signs of him in the cave systems. In this episode, we talk about that creepy humming, how Timmy is managing to draw in the dark, and try to decipher a poorly translated clue. Also discussed, is the deepening of the missing children plotline, as well a...

Happy Horror Month and welcome to The Forest! In part one, we analyze our first gameplay video where we crash-land in a mysterious forest and start exploring our surroundings while searching for our missing son. As we uncover more clues, it becomes clear that something unusual is taking place. In this episode, we talk about the creepy octaperson and flesh pile that chase us, as well as the humans(...

Welcome back to MAFIA II! In the summary episode, we investigate our burning questions, reveal the stats we tracked, and hand out KFC (Kathy's Favorite Character) Awards. We'll also give our final thoughts on the ending, character, and the Tommy connection. Don't forget to watch or play along - gameplay is posted weekly on our YouTube channel! Join us next week as we start a new game 🎮 Please con...

Welcome back to MAFIA II! In part five, when an ally is attacked, Vito acts without thinking of the fallout he may be causing. Later, he gets one last chance to make things right, but is fully aware of the cost? In this episode, we judge Vito's floppy running and laugh at him for being out of bath time. More seriously, we talk about Joe making things worse again (surprise, surprise), Vito burning...

Welcome back to MAFIA II! In part four, mixed loyalties come into play again as old friends get caught in the crossfire, and Vito's past catches up to him. In this episode, somehow the fake mustaches are not the worst part of Joe's plan, and could there be a worse song on the radio at a time like this? More seriously, we talk about why Joe is so effected but a certain death, whether or not he's be...

Welcome back to MAFIA II! In part three, we analyze our third gameplay video where Vito is released from prison, Joe and Vito join up with Falcone, and a rescue mission brings an underground war between Falcone and Clemente into the light. In this episode, we wonder WHAT is wrong with that lady, we rejoice when Vito finally gets irritated at Joe, and we pound the Advil after listening to Marty tal...

Welcome back to MAFIA II! In part two, we analyze our second gameplay video where Vito and Joe's success on odd-jobs for the Mafia put them on the shortlist to be accepted into the family, but when Vito's riskiness catches up to him, he finds himself being held accountable. In this episode, we react to Vito's morning beer, the incredibly obvious stake-out, and that taunt about "shoving a potato up...

Welcome to MAFIA II! In part one, we analyze our first gameplay video where we meet Vito Scaletta, whose difficult childhood pushes him to make some questionable choices with his Mafia-connected friend, Joe. Notably, we talk about Vito's lack of guilt, his irritating choices and the impact the "twooo thouuusand dollas" worth of family debt has on him. Also discussed are the terrible audio issues,...

Welcome back to Red Dead Redemption! In the summary episode, we investigate our burning questions, reveal the stats we tracked, and hand out KFC (Kathy's Favorite Character) Awards. We'll also give our final theories on the Strange Man, discuss our afterthoughts on the ending, and talk about Jack - why does he look at the gun like that? Don't forget to watch or play along - gameplay is posted week...

Welcome back to Red Dead Redemption! In part five, we analyze our fifth gameplay video where Ross and Fordham continue to threaten a frustrated John into tracking down Dutch. With his mission now complete, John is released and is reunited with his family - but is his redemption complete? In this episode, we laugh at John's toying with MacDougal and Uncle's words of encouragement . More seriously,...

Welcome back to Red Dead Redemption! In part four, we analyze our fourth gameplay video where John retaliates against de Santa and later finds Javier, another member of the old gang. In this episode, we react to "national gigolo" Reye's insanity, Javier's acrobatics, and MacDougal's fear of trees. More seriously, we react to John providing more details about his past in the gang. We also continue...

Welcome back to Red Dead Redemption! In part three, we analyze our third gameplay video where John makes connections in Mexico while on Bill's trail, inserting himself in the middle of a revolution. In this episode, we question Rickett's lock-breaking strategy, Luisa's dramatics and Abraham's... memory issues. More seriously, we debate whether John is desperate or dumb, and why he didn't cut ties...