Reasonably Afraid - A Horror Podcast

A while back we recorded Rey's birthday episode and never got a chance to put it out, but we finally got it ready for you! Rey's pick is the OG marvel movie, Blade. our buddy Andrew Fahey joins us so Enjoy the episode and join our Patreon for more exclusive content. Go support our sponsors! - Valley of Oh Lollipops https://www.instagram.com/valleyofoh https://valleyofoh.com - Maxwell Farms https:/...

This mother's day we are pulling out all the stops for the Mamiiiiiiiii's and the mommies. We are doing Dead Alive (aka Braindead) from 1992! Plus we got a special guest to join us, our buddy Danny Padilla! Enjoy the episode and join our Patreon for more exclusive content. Go support our sponsors! - Valley of Oh Lollipops https://www.instagram.com/valleyofoh https://valleyofoh.com - Maxwell Farms...

Another holiday episode! Happy 420 to all those who celebrate. Our buddy Cal Matthews joins us with our our buddy Max from Maxwell Pharms! We made sure to cover a fun stoner flick and we settled on Idle Hands from 1999. we had a lot of fun so get some munchies and enjoy! Also, go to the link below for some of Maxwell Pharm's incredible productions and order some fantastic sweets from Valley of Oh!...

It's our Easter celebration episode! There aren't a ton of Easter themed horror movies out there, so we decided to cover a really awful one for fun and to roast the crap out of it. So, enjoy us tearing apart Bunnyman: Grindhouse Edition! After the episode make sure to check out the links below if you want to help out bunny shelters, because every Easter hundreds of bunnies get purchased for childr...

We are back! Our buddy Cal Matthews joins us as we cover one of the few Saint Patrick's Day horror movies, Maniac Cop from 1988! We also have a drunk episode on our Patreon where we cover Leprechaun so check that out after this! Go support our sponsors! - Valley of Oh Lollipops https://www.instagram.com/valleyofoh https://valleyofoh.com - Maxwell Farms https://www.instagram.com/maxwellpharms See m...

It's a very special episode for a double dose of holiday horror, Friday the 13th & Valentine's Day! We are joined by our special guest, stand up comedian Katie Hettenbach from Katie Afraidy on the Fangoria Podcast Network. We delve into The 2025 horror comedy masterpiece that is Heart Eyes. There are some dumb dumbs out there who don't like this movie because they don't understand satire. But that...

It’s our birthdays so we want to give ourselves a special gift, Dead Snow from 2009. A Norwegian film about eradicating some SS cockroaches that surely has no relevance to our current situation in this country! Join us with our special guests Ben Brainard & Cal Matthews as we deep dive and remind you that history will not care about your justifications and only your actions. Party on! Go support o...

We have so many fun episodes coming this year but we had to kick it off with one of the best of the 90's, Tales From The Crypt: Demon Knight! We are joined by our buddy Cal Mathews to deep dive, laugh and talk horror! Go support our sponsors! - Valley of Oh Lollipops https://www.instagram.com/valleyofoh https://valleyofoh.com - Maxwell Farms https://www.instagram.com/maxwellpharms See more of our...

It's our Christmas Special, so of course we had to bring out the classic, Gremlins from 1984. Oddly one of the only films that Sean had actually seen prior to joining the podcast. And of course, our new holiday tradition of having our friend, Kara Lynn Dunton join us to give you all the fun facts and silly takes we can cram in an episode. Enjoy and we hope you have a happy horror days! Go support...

Three stand up comedians deep dive and lovingly roast the OG 1984 Silent Night Deadly Night with special guest, comedian, Tiffany Corrada! Make sure to follow for all the holiday horror we have coming this month with Terrifier 3 (2024) on Christmas Eve & Gremlins for Christmas Day! So Subscribe if you didn’t already ya dummy. Go support our sponsors! - Valley of Oh Lollipops https://www.instagram....

Three stand up comedians deep dive and lovingly roast the 1988 classic, Child’s Play as the kick off of our Holiday Season. Next week we are doing the original Silent Night Deadly Night (1984), Krampus (2015), then Terrifier 3 (2024) on Christmas Eve & Gremlins for Christmas Day! So Subscribe if you didn’t already ya dummy. Go support our sponsors! - Valley of Oh Lollipops https://www.instagram.co...

It's our Holiday Double Feature! This year, to celebrate Thanksgiving/Black Friday, we invited our friend and comedian Kara Dunton over to cover the OG home-made nonsense that is ThanksKilling (2008), about a demonic, murderous Turkey with Freddy vibes, followed by the super fun but little-seen movie, Black Friday (2021) starring Bruce Campbell, Michael Jai White, and Devon Sawa. You can also see...

It's our first ever live episode from Zach's home town of Daytona Beach, FL during our lead up to Spooky Empire in Orlando! This week's episode we are joined by are friend and fellow comedian Andrew Ramos from Random Acts of Insanity Improv Troupe as we deep dive the 1968 George A Romero classic that started it all, Night of the Living Dead. Go support our sponsors! - Valley of Oh Lollipops https:...

Three stand up comedians deep dive and lovingly roast the 80's cult classic, Night of the Demons! As usual when it comes to the 80's Sean is a problem, Rey enables him and Zach tries to keep the train moving with the fun facts and history of the film and it's lore. Seriously, if you love this movie... Sorry about Sean. He lacks vision! Come see us for our upcoming live shows in Florida before we g...

Friday the 13th from 1980 (OG's may recognize from Episode 11) is a throw back episode from when we first started and tried to squeeze in 2 movies and went too long haha. We have taken the liberty of splitting some of early episodes into 2 separate shorter ones for the new listeners. Still the same silly nonsense and fun facts as always but quicker. This film was the 80s first wave og rip off slas...

In honor of Spooky Season we are doing ANOTHER redacted bonus episode from our Patreon vault for you guys to enjoy! Today's episode is a modern classic and has redefined new horror, Terrifier (2016). Full uncut version can be found at our Patreon linked below. Make sure to subscribe and join stand-up comedians Rey Reyes, and Zach Bennett (also sometimes Sean Dolan and Amanda Fritz) as they deep di...

WE MADE IT TO EPISODE 50! How bout that? We were able to lure Sean out to show him one of our favorite films, the 1990 classic onslaught of insanity and humor that is Frankenhooker! Producer Turner even makes a brief appearance. Hope you guys enjoy! If you havent seen the film yet DEFINITELY go watch it right now! This film has a watch along on Patreon as well if you want to hear us reacting to an...

To kick off Spooky Season and to honor of the new Strangers movie coming out we wanted to give you a Christmas in October Halloween present, an exclusive Patreon episode in full and completely uncensored! Let's be real, we probably wont stay monetized for long if we ever do haha so why not. for you guys to enjoy! See more like this at our Patreon linked below as well as behind the scenes content,...

I Know What You Did Last Summer (OG's may recognize from Episode 11) is a throw back episode from when we first started and tried to squeeze in 2 movies and went too long haha. We have taken the liberty of splitting some of early episodes into 2 separate shorter ones for the new listeners. Still the same silly nonsense and fun facts as always but quicker. This film was the 90s first wave ride afte...

In honor of the new Conjuring movie coming out we felt like you all deserved a treat so we are releasing an exclusive Patreon episode | redacted | for you guys to enjoy! The Conjuring (2013) full uncut version can be found at our Patreon linked below. Make sure to subscribe and join stand-up comedians Amanda Fritz, Rey Reyes, and Zach Bennett (also sometimes Sean Dolan) as they deep dive into the...

We are back with our buddy Cal Mathews again but we let him pick the movie this time. Rob Zombie's 2003 breakout film, House of 1000 Corpses. It's a beautiful mess and we were excited to give you fun facts and laughs. Enjoy! Go support our sponsors! - Valley of Oh Lollipops https://www.instagram.com/valleyofoh https://valleyofoh.com - Maxwell Farms https://www.instagram.com/maxwellpharms See more...

Our Summer Series comes to an end with part 3 of horror movies shot on the Santa Cruz Boardwalk, finishing strong with Jordan Peele's Masterpiece, Us (2019)! If you haven't seen Part 1 - The Lost Boys (1987) or Part 2 - Killer Klowns From Outer Space (1988), go check them out! Make sure to subscribe and join stand-up comedians Amanda Fritz, Rey Reyes, and Zach Bennett (also sometimes Sean Dolan) a...

We continue our summer series honoring the Santa Cruz Boardwalk filming location with our second installment, Killer Klowns From Outer Space (1988)! Next week we will have Jordan Peele’s classic, Us (2019) and a special guest! If you have seen the first episode in this series it came out last week where we covered The Lost Boys (1987). Join stand up comedians Amanda Fritz, Rey Reyes and Zach Benne...

Our Summer Series Returns! This year we are doing the Santa Cruz Boardwalk Trifecta and kicking it off with The Lost Boys from 1987! Next week will be Killer Klowns From Outerspace (1988) followed by Jordan Peele's Masterpiece, Us (2019). Join stand up comedians Amanda Fritz, Rey Reyes and Zach Bennett (also sometimes Sean Dolan) as they deep dive into the iconic films we all love for different re...

It's finally here! The Rocky Horror Picture Show with our special guest, stand up comedian, Effie Meadows! This one was so much fun and we hope you enjoy! Be sure to check us out at Spooky Empire this year in Orlando, October 31st - November 2nd. Live shows will be announced soon! Go support our sponsors! - Valley of Oh Lollipops https://www.instagram.com/valleyofoh https://valleyofoh.com - Maxwel...