Rated P For Paranormal

Home Is Where The Pod Is 30.05.2026 12:26 ↓

In celebration of Matty's return the boys share their TOP 3 Coming Home Moments in film history, and not knowing each other's picks, they actually both had one film in common. But what movie?? Tony & Matty also share a personal coming home moment.

Matty’s Got Seoul 21.05.2026 8:38 ↓

A micro episode w/ Matty recording from South Korea. The boys give their T3 Forest Scenes in film history.

THE TRAIL with Jake Robards 13.05.2026 53:34 ↓

In this very special episode, Jake Robards shares about his father Jason, his incredible career and drops great stories about A Boy and His Dog. Tony joins in with thoughts about his famous father as well. Just an incredible episode!

SPECIAL REPORT: The Missing Scientists 07.05.2026 9:37 ↓

Tony & Matty address the potentially disturbing phenomena of the growing number of missing scientists. Matty sets the stage for Tony, who makes intriguing connections to film and beyond…

A BOY AND HIS DAWG 28.04.2026 1:03:47 ↓

Miami Vice K-9 Unit. Or something. With special guest The Puppy Bowl Ref DAN SCHACHNER!

THE BEST THING WE SAW THIS WINTER 23.04.2026 8:05 ↓

In this special episode, Tony and Matty each reveal the best thing they watched during this long, cold, brutal winter of 2026!

KPOP DEMON HUNTERS 17.04.2026 55:26 ↓

Two olds enter the world of K-pop. This should go well.

This Island Earth 26.03.2026 1:12:21 ↓

We only want to help you humans! Stop punching us.

THEM! 17.01.2026 1:11:18 ↓

Did a giant ant eat little Matty’s giant street pretzel? Or was that Elliot Gould? All will be revealed in this episode! It’s 1954’s THEM!

Amelia Campbell from The Chair Company 18.12.2025 58:01 ↓

A very special episode! We sit down once again with Amelia Campbell, from the new hit show: The Chair Company (& she’s Tony’s wife!) Merry Christmas and see you in 2026!

TOGETHER 15.12.2025 1:15:56 ↓

Did this one stick with us? Let’s find out, all together now. Plus T3 bathroom stalls. Nice barnduminium, babe.

Deadly Friend 27.11.2025 1:32:55 ↓

Owen doesn’t have any friends, but you sure do: Tony & Matty! And they’re gonna guide you through this 80’s lost gem. Plus top three balls in film history.

Mausoleum 14.11.2025 1:29:13 ↓

Wanna dance?

2025 HALLOWEEN SPECIAL w/ PuppyBowl Ref Dan Schachner 30.10.2025 1:07:22 ↓

Hold on to your pumpkins

REC 22.10.2025 1:15:40 ↓

REC means record. NO MATTER WHAT !! Plus T3 Shoe Shots in film history.

Things Herd & Scene 13.10.2025 1:12:19 ↓

For the first time, in P4P history, the boys were issued a challenge: could they sit through & then discuss the 2021 film Things Heard & Seen. Challenge accepted.

Phantasm 01.10.2025 1:22:37 ↓

Check out our phantastic new ep Phantasm ! Plus: Top 3 ManTails in philm history!

The Arrival 23.09.2025 1:09:30 ↓

We have discovered a truly hidden 90’s gem for all time.

Apollo 18 08.09.2025 54:06 ↓

Did you know there was a secret mission to the moon? Neither did we. It didn’t turn out too well. But did the found footage style film about it turn out ok? We’re no rocket scientists’ …but we’ll try to explain.

THE MONKEY 08.09.2025 54:49 ↓

The boys argue over Osgood Perkins film THE MONKEY

Revelations 29.05.2025 58:14 ↓

The boys receive a Revelation from S Korea. Or DO they…? And Tony has UAP footage! Plus: Top 3 Body Dumps in film history,

Presence 16.04.2025 1:00:32 ↓

Great Led Zeppelin record. But how’s the movie? Plus Top Three O.J. moments in film history. The drink not the killer guy.

HOT FROSTY w/ the Puppy Bowl Ref 19.12.2024 1:32:00 ↓

The boys review HOT FROSTY w/ Puppy Bowl Ref Dan Schachner. Plus Top 3 Scarves in film history. AND the first ever P4P Quiz!

Poltergeist 2 & Top 3 Station Wagons 10.12.2024 1:26:59 ↓

Poltergeist 2 the RePolterying

The Sentinel & Top 3 Contact Lensed Eyes 27.11.2024 1:22:28 ↓

What is exactly is the Sentinel..? That is not rhetorical, we were actually hoping you could help us out with that one. PLUS! Tony's hat causes problems. AND the Top 3 Contact Lensed Eyes in Film history. HAPPY THANKSGIVING!