Rare Breeds

Karsyn’s dating life has been awfully quiet… until now. On this episode of Rare Breeds, Karsyn and Caitlin open an Emotional Purse with plenty of highs and lows. Karsyn details an out-of-nowhere breakup that she never saw coming, while Caitlin describes her son’s adventure to create a gift basket for his crush.  A new segment, Rarely Reality, debuts this week, and the girls are all in on Love Isla...

We’re back, better than ever, and just in time for Love Island USA… Karsyn Elledge and Caitlin Waltrip return after a summer break just as the hit reality show is getting good. The girls kick things off by emptying their surprisingly joyful Emotional Purse. Karsyn is an auntie now (sort of) and can’t believe a man would willingly wear flip flops to his child’s birth. Meanwhile, Caitlin spent most...

After a week off, we’re back for another episode of Rare Breeds. Karsyn and Caitlin jump right into a chaotic Emotional Purse where Karsyn accidentally buys an undersized lawn chair and immediately regrets it. Caitlin looks ahead to baseball season with her kids as Karsyn recaps an underwhelming experience at a Titanic Museum. Messy Draft’s topic this week is “Unmatched Feelings,” and it has us fe...

We went to a Magic Mike show at a bar that took raunchy to a whole new level. Let’s recap it! On this episode of Rare Breeds, Karsyn and Caitlin reminisce on a girl’s trip to a local bar that they never could’ve imagined. Caitlin’s Emotional Purse gets real when she details an embarrassing moment at a gas station. Messy Draft follows as we detail things that aren’t illegal, but we think they shoul...

Karsyn lost her debit card, Caitlin finally watched the Kentucky Derby, and someone got chlamydia... If you're looking for variety, this episode of Rare Breeds has it. Karsyn literally empties her Emotional Purse, admitting she lost her debit card. Caitlin gets complimented at the liquor store before admitting she's never watched the Kentucky Derby — until now. Karsyn recalls her own trip to the K...

Some hills are worth dying on. In our case, they're expected. On this episode of Rare Breeds, Karsyn Elledge and Caitlin Waltrip dig deep in their Emotional Purse as Karsyn prepares for a ground shaking (literally) Bruno Mars concert. This week's Messy Draft has the girls debating the hills they'll forever die on — including ranch dressing at every restaurant and double texting (it's a standard, y...

Is Dakota Mortensen really stepping out of the spotlight, or is this just the beginning? On this episode of Rare Breeds, Karsyn Elledge and Caitlin Waltrip dive into Mortensen’s public statement amid his return to social media. The girls recap an uncharacteristically tame weekend trip to a cabin where moving a mattress became a back breaking affair. In Messy Draft, Karsyn and Caitlin display just...

We’re sick with Bieber Fever… so naturally, it’s time to talk about Coachella. Karsyn Elledge and Caitlin Waltrip return on this episode of Rare Breeds and talk Justin Bieber’s Coachella performance that healed a generation. Alix Earle is back in the spotlight, and her drama with Alex Cooper sparks an age-old question: Is the drama just a PR stunt? Karsyn then recounts a life-changing dating story...

Would you rip off your own shirt sleeves to have toilet paper in the woods? For Karsyn, when you gotta go, you gotta go. You'll need your wine glasses (or plastic cups) for this episode of Rare Breeds. Karsyn and Caitlin kick things off discussing Dakota Mortensen's removal from other reality TV shows. Caitlin recalls her first soda bar experience and, needless to say, she wasn't impressed. The gi...

Did Karsyn really drink $1,000 wine for free? We'll let you be the judge. Grab your wine glasses, because this episode of Rare Breeds sees Karsyn and Caitlin regroup to talk even more Bachelorette drama and whether or not we'll ever see this season of the beloved sitcom. Karsyn thinks this could be the real end of MomTok. Caitlin reminds us why you should never judge a girl by her broken nail in a...

Bachelorette drama, celebrity ex-husbands, and skid marks. If you’re looking for range, this episode of Rare Breeds has it all. Karsyn and Caitlin break down the upcoming Bachelorette season being cancelled and what that might mean for the Secret Lives of Mormon Wives future. Plus, Miley Cyrus called Alex Cooper “creepy” at the Hannah Montana 20-year reunion, and Karsyn has all the tea. In Text Hi...

On today’s episode of  Rare Breeds , Karsyn and Caitlin dive into the big life questions—like where all the cover bands disappeared to, and the unspoken rules of splitting bills on a bachelorette trip. Caitlin somehow made it back from spring break in one piece… despite losing her car keys on day one. Karsyn, on the other hand, may have cracked the code on her future retirement plan—and, funny eno...

On this week’s episode of Rare Breeds, Karsyn and Caitlin are celebrating their 15-year friend anniversary…on Facebook. Caitlin releases some childhood trauma from being told she “takes up too much space spiritually,” and Karsyn details her chaotic start to record day. In our pop culture update, Karsyn reveals she went to Zendaya’s Sweet 16, what guys the new bachelorette, Taylor Frankie Paul, wil...

On today’s episode of Rare Breeds, Karsyn and Caitlin debut their new studio, and the tea is as hot as ever. Karsyn recaps her weekend, which started with unplugging a restaurant’s lights and ended up at Charlotte’s most well-known dive bar. Caitlin previews her upcoming chaperone duties for her son’s school field trip, and the two list out everything they hate in this week’s Messy Draft. Plus, tw...

After a week off, Karsyn and Caitlin are back for another episode of Rare Breeds, and they have a lot to talk about. Karsyn & Caitlin recap their eventful week in Daytona, which included meeting some celebrities on the grid. We introduce a new segment, which means absolute chaos, as the girls play Hear Me Out, a segment dedicated to their weirdest and most unhinged romantic crushes. Plus, they giv...

Karsyn returns from her ski trip, which was almost over before it started, and Caitlin has to deal with a snowstorm of her own in NC. The girls get into the best & worst fits from the GRAMMYs, especially Chappell Roan's dress that had two points we wanted to cover... Next up, things get heated in a Text Him or Wreck Him when video games & Valentine's Day are brought to the table. In Ask Rare Breed...

Kissing John Cena, caviar taste test, and Margot Robbie co-dependency, this episode of Rare Breeds has serious range. Karsyn updates us on Chicago Man, and if there’s a future reunion brewing, Alix Earle has a new reality TV show that we’re all excited for, and what’s up with Margot Robbie and Jacob Elordi? In Text Him or Wreck Him, Caitlin might have got AI Catfished, a bride-to-be hates her enga...

This week on  Rare Breeds , chaos is fully activated. Karsyn gives us an update on Chicago Man, and Caitlin is handing out unhinged but somehow solid relationship advice. We debate whether  Pitbull is actually a lifestyle , why  couples who cook together are cringey , and how to spot the  psycho friend who’s low-key trying to steal your man . There’s a deep dive into the ever-confusing  Brooklyn B...

On today’s episode of Rare Breeds , it’s Caitlin’s birthday, and the confetti is flying. Karsyn and Caitlin dig into what’s really in their emotional purses this week, before Caitlin flips the script and puts Karsyn in the hot seat to prove she’s truly her best friend. In Text Him or Wreck Him, listeners write in for advice on handling the “pick me girl” in the friend group—and how to stop being t...

Karsyn and Caitlin are back for another episode of Rare Breeds. It’s 2026, and Caitlin is participating in Dry January…for the first 20 minutes of today’s show. Karsyn is bringing back having an arch-nemesis, and we’re listing what’s in and what’s out for us in 2026, including posting daily updates on Instagram, celebrity couples, and more! In Text Him Or Wreck Him, one listener needs advice on wh...

On today’s episode of Rare Breeds, our luck is starting to change! Karsyn is now the proud owner of a slushie machine, and Caitlin won a porch swing at the holiday Christmas party. We have Caitlin try the “say the word on beat challenge”, a listener got the ick from her situationship getting roasted by 10-year-olds dressed as Santa, and Karsyn is looking for love on New Year’s…under a table with s...

On today’s episode of Rare Breeds, Karsyn and Caitlin are basically FBI investigators, as they try to find out if the Alix Earle breakup is real or fake. Karsyn reveals she’s big into Legos, as every hot girl is, and Caitlin recalls one Christmas where the family hired a real-life Bad Santa, father and son edition. In Text Him or Wreck Him, Caitlin gives one listener advice on how to deal with a M...

Rare Breeds is back after Thanksgiving break, and things picked up right where they left off. Karsyn does a deep dive into her Spotify Wrapped recap, which may have revealed why she feels older than she is. Then Karsyn and Caitlin learn a new term used to call someone who uses Snapchat, and they're NOT thrilled about it. Ask Rare Breeds is back, where Caitlin helps all our male listeners with Chri...

Rare Breeds is back, and Karsyn has breaking news to share involving an old situationship and a Hinge profile. Caitlin debates why there's no need to wash your feet in the shower, and are joint bachelor and bachelorette parties the move? In Text Him or Wreck Him, we help a listener get over being "the other girl" in an engagement love triangle, and why liking other girls' bikini pictures is the wr...

Rare Breeds is back, and things go off the rails fast. Caitlin reveals the shocking picture somebody sent in her family group chat, Karsyn pulls a prank on Caitlin in public that may lead to an all-out prank war, and Karsyn and Caitlin recap their day at the Renaissance festival. We talk about why the wife making more money than the husband is iconic, a person’s hobbies can tell a lot about them,...