Pretty Guilty

This week on Pretty Guilty, we’re diving into one of the most disturbing criminal cases in American history: Gary M. Heidnik. Behind the facade of an ordinary life lurked a nightmare that would shock the nation. We explore the horrifying crimes, the victims who endured unimaginable abuse, and the investigation that ultimately exposed the truth.

This week, I sat down with Brady and Caroline for one of our longest episodes yet — and somehow we still barely scratched the surface of all the paranormal things these two do! From unhinged stories and random tangents to deeper conversations we probably overshared in, this episode feels like sitting in on a late-night conversation with friends when nobody wants to go to bed. Expect chaos, laughs,...

In this episode, we dive into the chilling mystery of the “13 Minutes” case — a story filled with unanswered questions, suspicious timelines, and details that continue to haunt investigators and true crime followers alike. What really happened during those missing 13 minutes, and why do they matter so much? We break down the evidence, explore the theories, and discuss the twists that make this cas...

A chilling deep dive into one of New Hampshire’s most haunting unsolved cases, the Bear Brook murders. In this episode, we unravel the discovery of multiple unidentified victims in the woods, the decades-long mystery surrounding their identities, and the groundbreaking forensic techniques that finally brought answers. It’s a story of loss, persistence, and the relentless pursuit of truth.

In November of 1966, something was seen in Point Pleasant, West Virginia—and it wasn’t human. Witnesses described glowing red eyes, massive wings, and a creature that could keep up with cars in the dead of night. What started as a few sightings quickly turned into something much bigger… something no one could explain. In this episode of Pretty Guilty, we dive into the legend of the Mothman, the ey...

Welcome to Pretty Guilty — the podcast where true crime meets the unexplained. Each episode, we dive into chilling cases, eerie mysteries, and the stories that keep you up at night. From shocking crimes to spine-tingling paranormal encounters, we’re here to explore the darker side of reality… and everything that lurks just beyond it. Stay curious—and maybe keep the lights on. Instagram-@prettyguil...