Pair O' Normal Dudes

Another Grab Bag… and this one’s… weird.

Every child fears what hides behind the door. In this episode of Pair O' Normal Dudes , hosts Mr. R and Mr. X open the door to the terrifying world of CLOSETS . We apply our signature comedic and skeptical analysis to the most chilling paranormal internet stories about entities that scratch from inside, eyes that glow through the slats, and things that step out when the lights go off, all sourced...

They move on all fours and they are not animals. In this episode of Pair O' Normal Dudes , hosts Mr. R and Mr. X investigate the unsettling phenomenon of CRAWLERS . We apply our signature comedic and skeptical analysis to the most terrifying paranormal internet stories about pale, humanoid creatures seen scuttling through forests, alleyways, and basements in the dead of night, all sourced from chi...

The bell rings, but not everyone leaves. In this episode of Pair O' Normal Dudes , hosts Mr. R and Mr. X return to class to investigate the creepiest paranormal internet stories set in schools . We apply our signature comedic and skeptical analysis to terrifying tales of haunted hallways, scholarly premonitions, and fluctuating uniforms sizes, all sourced from chilling Reddit stories and paranorma...

What stares back at you from the other side of the glass? In this episode of Pair O' Normal Dudes , hosts Mr. R and Mr. X take a long, uneasy look at Mirrors . We apply our signature comedic and skeptical analysis to the most unsettling paranormal internet stories about reflective surfaces that trap spirits, summon entities, or reveal something that shouldn't be there, all sourced from terrifying...

The Keystone State has a dark and mysterious side. In this episode of Pair O' Normal Dudes , hosts Mr. R and Mr. X explore the strangest paranormal internet stories to come out of Pennsylvania . We apply our signature comedic and skeptical analysis to chilling tales of cryptids, possible abductions, and the Amish? All sourced from eerie Reddit stories and local forums. This deep dive into regional...

Is anybody there? In this episode of Pair O' Normal Dudes , hosts Mr. R and Mr. X gather around the table to investigate Seances . We apply our signature comedic and skeptical analysis to the most haunting paranormal internet stories about attempted communication with the dead, from successful spirit contact to terrifying backfires and possessions, all sourced from chilling Reddit stories . Are th...

That vintage doll at the thrift store might come with more than dust. In this episode of Pair O' Normal Dudes , hosts Mr. R and Mr. X browse the eerie world of Thrifting Haunted Items . We apply our signature comedic and skeptical analysis to terrifying paranormal internet stories about cursed antiques, possessed jewelry, and haunted furniture purchased from secondhand shops, all sourced from spin...

They lurk in peripheral vision and vanish when you turn. In this episode of Pair O' Normal Dudes , hosts Mr. R and Mr. X confront the terrifying phenomenon of Shadow Men . We apply our signature comedic and skeptical analysis to the most chilling paranormal internet stories about these dark figures that stalk bedrooms and closets, influence dreams, and appear during sleep paralysis, all sourced fr...

Welcome to Cryptid Movie Club ! where three friends—Roger, Ethan, and the mysterious Mr. X—get together to roast the wildest cryptid movies ever made, with a heavy focus on Bigfoot. Part comedy, part bad cinema autopsy, this humor-based podcast tears into hairy messes like Harry and the Hendersons, Willow Creek, and straight-to-Tubi sasquatch disasters. Expect low-budget CGI, questionable fur suit...

In this episode of Pair O' Normal Dudes , hosts Mr. R and Mr. X dissect the semi-"viral" phenomenon of the so-called Time Traveler from 2264 . We apply our signature comedic and skeptical analysis to this bizarre paranormal internet story , examining the Reddit post, the cryptic predictions, and the countless Reddit comments that followed. Is this a genuine visitor from the 23rd century or an elab...

Does every child have an imaginary friend? What happens if that friend never leaves? In this episode of Pair O' Normal Dudes , hosts Mr. R and Mr. X investigate creepy-ish paranormal internet stories about imaginary friends . We apply our signature comedic and skeptical analysis to disturbing accounts of childhood companions who knew too much, mysterious figures only children could see, and entiti...

You don't know them, but they seem to know you. In this episode of Pair O' Normal Dudes , hosts Mr. R and Mr. X investigate the unsettling phenomenon of STRANGERS and the chilling paranormal internet stories that surround them. We apply our signature comedic and skeptical analysis to strange encounters with individuals who know too much, and eerie coincidences that feel anything but random, all so...

Who were you before you were you? In this episode of Pair O' Normal Dudes , hosts Mr. R and Mr. X explore the haunting concept of past lives . We apply our signature comedic and skeptical analysis to the most compelling paranormal internet stories about reincarnation, from being "normal" guys to inexplicable phobias and past life regression experiences, all sourced from fascinating Reddit stories...

We are not alone, and apparently, they're taking passengers. In this episode of Pair O' Normal Dudes , hosts Mr. R and Mr. X dive deep into the unsettling world of r/AlienAbductions with special guest Mr. E ! We apply our signature comedic and skeptical analysis to the most terrifying paranormal internet stories from this infamous subreddit, examining chilling accounts of missing time, strange exa...

Dust off the microfilm machine. In this episode of Pair O' Normal Dudes , hosts Mr. R and Mr. X need to pivot, so they dig through digital archives to uncover bizarre Historical Accounts from News Clippings . We apply our signature comedic and skeptical analysis to vintage newspaper reports of unexplained phenomena, from strange intruders to unexplained apartment poltergeist, all sourced from forg...

He's been spotted everywhere from forests to TikTok. In this episode of Pair O' Normal Dudes , hosts Mr. R and Mr. X venture into the woods to investigate the legendary Bigfoot . We apply our signature comedic and skeptical analysis to the most compelling paranormal internet stories about Sasquatch encounters, from blurry footage to terrifying close encounters, all sourced from gripping Reddit sto...

Strap in for a wild ride through the internet's weirdest corners! Another Grab Bag Episode of Pair O' Normal Dudes sees hosts Mr. R and Mr. X serving up a fresh batch of bizarre paranormal internet stories . We're applying our signature comedic and skeptical analysis to a rapid-fire mix of chilling Reddit stories , unsolved internet mysteries , and head-scratching encounters, all pulled from the d...

That feeling you're not alone is more than just paranoia. In this episode of Pair O' Normal Dudes , hosts Mr. R and Mr. X investigate the chilling phenomenon of being followed . We apply our signature comedic and skeptical analysis to terrifying paranormal internet stories about shadowy stalkers, IDs in the bushes, and entities that hitch a ride home, all sourced from the most unsettling Reddit st...

Hold on to your reality and your sanity. In this episode of Pair O' Normal Dudes , hosts Mr. R and Mr. X dive headfirst into the bizarre digital rabbit hole of r/retconned . We apply our signature comedic and skeptical analysis to the most mind-bending paranormal internet stories from this controversial community. We're dissecting accounts of the Mandela Effect, glitches in reality, and personal o...

Grab your flashlight and gather ‘round the fire. In this episode of Pair O' Normal Dudes , hosts Mr. R and Mr. X are trading s'mores for scares as they investigate terrifying paranormal internet stories set at summer camps . We apply our signature comedic and skeptical lens to chilling tales of cursed cabins, alien abductions, and woodland creatures that are more than they seem, all sourced from c...

Portal? What Portal? In this episode of Pair O' Normal Dudes , hosts Mr. R and Mr. X investigate the ultimate internet mystery : real-world portals . We apply our signature comedic and skeptical analysis to terrifying paranormal internet stories about glowing doorways, staircases in the woods, and mysterious vortices that swallow people whole... or just vague understandings of what a "portal" is.....

Ever had your keys vanish only to reappear in plain sight? In this episode of Pair O' Normal Dudes , hosts Mr. R and Mr. X investigate the eerie phenomenon of things that disappear . We apply our signature comedic and skeptical lens to baffling paranormal internet stories about object glitches, spontaneous teleportation, and items lost to thin air, all sourced from perplexing Reddit stories and fo...

Why is 3am the witching hour? Join Mr. R and Mr. X on the Pair O' Normal Dudes podcast as we dissect the viral phenomenon of 3am happenings . We apply our signature comedic and skeptical analysis to the most chilling paranormal internet stories about waking at this cursed time—tales of shadow figures, unexplained sounds, and overwhelming dread sourced directly from terrifying Reddit stories and on...

This episode isn't about the mall Santa... At least we hope not! Join Mr. R and Mr. X on Pair O' Normal Dudes as they investigate bizarre and creepy Santa Claus sightings that belong in a horror movie. We're applying our signature comedic and skeptical analysis to strange paranormal internet stories about a crimson-suited stalker, Krampus-like encounters, and unsettling home intrusions, all source...