Only Show Fans

The girls are more than halfway thru season 1 and Maggie is still all in on the best political procedural that ever was. They talk about Maggie's love for teeth, songs you can and can't sing anymore, and what new body part of Amanda has been diagnosed as double-jointed. They're creeping up on the end of Season 1 (IYKYK) so it's not too late to rewatch with them and join in on the fun.  And if you'...

Four more episodes! Or four more years? Episodes 9-12 really packed a punch (and almost got Josh Lyman punching people) in the first season of The West Wing. Amanda and Maggie talk about how they'd decorate The White House if they were in charge, whether or not they'd follow their boss's orders, and the difference between a real easter egg and a hypothetical easter egg. And Amanda's temporary fost...

Laced up and stompin' in their Air Force Ones, Amanda and Maggie are cruisin' at an altitude where they can take in the sights and sounds of the Bartlett Administration. They discuss problematic characters and problematic actors, who they would leave behind when given a nuclear "get out of jail free" card, and the best places for people to visit when it's their first time coming to America. And wh...

As the girls jump back into a deep dive of one of the best tv shows ever made, they're hardly winging it. They've got hot thoughts! They've got depos! They've got quizzes! And a new, fancier way to get to prediction town. They talk about the ideal job for a president JUST before they become president, they talk about kids trolling parents on social media, and how they would spind a presidential bi...

That's right. Or left, should we say. We're going back to our roots to deep dive on another show that has long since left the air but will never leave our hearts. The West Wing. The most beloved political procedural of all times. Hop back in and watch it again or relish in your memories of the show and just soak it in. It's a show so nice Amanda has watched it twice and a show so great that Maggie...

Court is in session for this next round of TV pranks when the girls review the newest Jury Duty: Company Retreat. It's so wild, it's so well done, and it's such a great watch/binge. They talk about when they would have discoverd it was a prank, when (or if) they'll ever cast a woman as the hero to be pranked, and what cast could they be thrown into and have zero idea who any of the key players are...

Young Sherlock wasn't what either of the girls thought it would be, but they're on the case to get to the bottom of Season 1 and what might be in store for Season 2. They talk extensively about accents and also talk extensively in accents. They discuss what the other would do if one was left injured while on the job. Amanda finds the Travis Tanner of the series, a special gift she's developed just...

The Pitt is a lot of things, and an ABSOLUTE HIT is one of them. Maggie and Amand are more obsessed after Season 2 than they were with season one. And thinking ahead to Season 3? Well that's hardly a tough pill to swallow because they are hydrated, mediacated, and ready for more Pitt action. They talk about their favorite doctors and who they would want to treat them in real life, how well the Pit...

If there was ever a limited series to fall in love with, it's Love Story. In this episode, the girls recap the limited series about America's sweethearts, JFK Jr. and Carolyn Besset. The talk about the nostalgia of it all, how Amanda will exclusively be dressing like Carolyn, and how this beloved couple was taken from us too soon. They talk about who the modern day "most eligible bachelor" is and...

Reviewing the Pilots for Rooster and Imperfect Women  Well cockadoodledo...these perfect women took a binging break this week and watched two pilots to preview so much good tv headed your way this spring. The gave their hot thoughts on the pilots for Rooster and Imperfect Women. More importantly, they talked at length about creatine, Amanda's new efforts to enter a muscle competition, and they det...

This episode is dedicated to sweet Whisky, the Producer Dog. He was the goodest of boys and the absolute best producer dog in the biz. No one could lap up water for minutes at a time or bark when it was lease expected like Whisky could. He will be missed and the podcast won't be the same without him. Because Whisky would want the show to go on, the girls talked about Runaway, the limited series dr...

A six-episode show to cleasne the bing-watching pallet? Why yes, the girls did love it. So much you could say it did steal their hearts. In this episode, Amanda and Maggie talk about Judy Blume, McDonalds nuggets vs Jack in the Box tacos as a currency comparision, and whether or not they could actually pull off a heist like this. They discuss the logistics of hiding the digital money card, whether...

Reviewing Season of The Burbs Since Maggie recently made a big move to The Burbs, it was only fitting the girls recap this new spooky comedy to prepare her for her life as a Suburbanite. they discuss how similar her life is to The Burbs, including nice walks through the HOAs and bodies in the basement. They also discuss what's the appropriate amount of time to leave a dead body in the house before...

Reviewing Season 1 of Heated Rivalry Maggie and Amanda finally watched and reviewed Heated Rivalry and they're still unsure how all that heat didn't melt the ice! It's hardly a spoiler alert to say they both loved this show and they are making it their goal to make sure everyone watches it (and listens accordingly to OSF). I mean, if you watched Heated Rivalry and didn't fall in love with it, then...

Reviewing Season 1 of The Studio. Isn't it great when two Sisters-in-law both absolutely love a show they are reviewing that is a tv show about peope who make moview who think they are really good about movies and it's reviewed on a podcast about tv shows (and sometimes movies?) Yeah, we think so, too. Two thumbs up for the cast, the writing, the art direction, and of course Brian Cranston in seas...

Recapping Season 1 of Plurabis Amanda and Maggie were so excited to watch this show because apparenty everyone "couldn't stop thinking about it." The girls? Well, they had a hard time thinking about how they could make it all the way through, until they did. And one of them even ended up really liking the show. The girls talk about what they would do if they were in this situation, are they team C...

Recapping Season of The Pitt! Amanda and Maggie are together again! Maggie makes a guest apperance in the Dallas studio and they have the most fun talking about the best show, The Pitt. They loved this "ER meets 24" medical drama. Very real. Very intense. Very exicted for Season 2. They talk about their favorite doctors and who they would and would NOT want to treat them from the cast of The Pitt....

Reapping Season 1, Part 2 of All's Fair There's nothing fair about the fact this show is actually on TV but it's 2026 and here we are. Amanda and Maggie discuss this show in detail, much to Amanda's dismay. Maggie tries to convince her of all the redeemding qualities of this show while the only thing Amanda can get on board with is a nice, monochromatic dress code that really pulls an outfit toget...

Recapping Season 1 of The Chair Company-Part 2. Back on their same bullshit for 2026 and here to recap the last half of this Tim Robinson tv treat. They talk about both the predictability and unpredictabilty of Season 1. They discuss who would be "banter" and who would be "bits" if they changed their name to "Banter and Bits." Amanda finally tells the story of the time she was wrongfully arrested....

Recapping the 83rd annual Golden Globes While Amanda and Maggie must have both missed their invites in the mail, they were still delighted to recap some of their favorite moments from this year's ceremony. They talk about Nikki Glaser and what a rock star she is, their favorite Globes looks, the shows that won, and all the new TV they have to add to their list. It's fair to say they're going to be...

Reviewing When Harry Met Sally  They may not remember where they where the first time they met this movie, but the girls do know they haven't met another film quite like it. One of the best films of our generation that culminates on New Years Eve, Nora Ephron's writing and Rob Reiner's directing couldn't be a better match. Amanda and Maggie talk about all the wonderful quotes and moments that come...

Reviewing My Secret Santa. It's no secret that the girls kinda liked this holiday film. Was it giving Mrs. Doubtfire meets problematic HR issues? Yes. Was it somewhat unbelievalbe and still charming? Yes. Does Amanda think the male lead is the Travis Tanner of Hallmark films? Obviously, yes. Amanda ad Maggie dish about their favorite moments from this holiday film that was ranked #1 on Netflix (on...

Reviewing Holiday Touchdown: A Bills Love Story Amanda and Maggie really nose their stuff in this epsiode. They talk about what it's like to get "work done", what it's like to be a Bills and/or a Cowboys fan. They also talk about what it's like to live in a helluva lot of snow and how not-so-acurate the clothing for negative wind chill temps. They even discuss where they'd set the scene for next y...

Reviewing The Beast In Me.  Well if it isn't another psychological thriller that requires at least one hand basket, if not two, for viewing! Maggie and Amanda give their hot takes on this show with a star-studded cast. They discuss when it is and is not appropraite to go to the bathroom while on the phone, how to properly pronounce the name Lauren, and why everyone needs a show psychologist. They...

Reviewing the epsiodes 1-4 of All's Fair... Amanda gave in to Maggie's request to watch this "law procedural" starring none other than Kim Kardashian. As someone who barely keeps up with any of the Kardashians, this one was a stretch for Amanda. Maggie talks about all the redeemding qualities of this show while Amanda sides with most critics who genuinely can't stand it. It's truly a show unlike a...