One night in Pinehurst

The Milly Boys are back for Week 4 — with AB’s long-awaited return to the lineup and plenty of sins to wash away from the rough first three weeks. Gibby, Matty P, and AB dive into the DFS slate, debating TreVeyon Henderson’s fumbling-free upside, James Cook’s hip fluidity, and why Roma Dunze might just be the most consistent receiver you’re not playing enough. Along the way, the guys tackle Caleb’...

Matty P and Gibby are back with one of their sharpest FanDuel builds yet — and this one feels like it’s got true Milly Maker upside. The guys open with a heartfelt nod to the upcoming Tee Off for 2E charity event, celebrating 14 years of supporting Camp Sunshine and passing the $100K milestone. From there, it’s all about Week 3. They break down why Caleb Williams and Rome Odunze are a sneaky stack...

Gibby and MP are back to break down a wild Week Two in the NFL — from quarterbacks surprising (and disappointing) to teams already showing their true colors. The guys hit on everything from Dak Prescott to Christian McCaffrey, vent a little about some head-scratching plays (and even more questionable fan behavior), and, of course, build out their fantasy lineup for the week ahead. Plenty of laughs...

Football is back, and so are the Milly Boys! Gibby and Matty P welcome AB back to the show as the crew builds their Week 1 FanDuel Millionaire Maker lineup. From AB’s ride-or-die loyalty to Christian McCaffrey, to Gibby’s gut calls, to Matty’s data-driven breakdowns, the guys lock in their picks and debate the best value plays on the slate. This week’s lineup features a mix of proven stars and und...

Continuing the conversation, Matty P, Gibby, and Eric Pocock offer a deep dive into NFL over/under win totals, providing predictions and expert analysis. This episode covers a range of teams and scenarios, offering listeners engaging and informative content that will keep you on the edge of your seat. Don't miss out on this comprehensive look at the upcoming NFL season. Learn more about your ad ch...

In this episode, hosts Matty P and Gibby, joined by West Coast correspondent Eric Pocock, dive into the NFL over/under win totals, focusing on the Broncos and the competitive AFC West. They explore key factors, potential surprises, and offer insights into which teams might exceed expectations. Whether you're a seasoned fan or new to the game, this episode is packed with valuable insights to enhanc...

Matty P and Gibby, joined live in studio by Brandon Casten put a twist on the NFL postseason by taking each playoff team and swapping playoff teams from 2024 with who will rise to the top in 2025. We talk vibes, injuries, schedules and are prepared to look like idiots in 4 months. Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices

This week, we’re joined by longtime friend and wrestling aficionado Pat Casten to reflect on the complex legacy of the recently passed icon, Hulk Hogan. We dive deep into what made Hogan larger than life, where he fits in wrestling history, and how nostalgia and controversy collide when icons fall. Then it’s time for our Mount Rushmore of WWE superstars — expect bold picks, fierce debate, and a li...

Former big leaguer Zach Moore of Pigtown Sports joins the show as Matty and Gibby attempt to talk Orioles fans off the ledge after a rough stretch in Birdland. We cover what’s real, what’s fixable, and why this team still has the tools to contend. Zach also takes us inside one of baseball’s most surreal moments: the MLB Draft phone call — and what it felt like to go from a kid with a dream to a Ma...

On this episode of One Night in Pinehurst, we’re joined by the genre-bending, soul-stirring Taylor Rae — fresh off the release of her latest album The Void. Calling in from Austin ahead of her show in Cambridge, Taylor talks with us about life on the road, the evolution of her sound, and what went into making her second record. We dive into songwriting, staying grounded in a fast-moving industry,...

The boys are back, and it feels real good. After a brief hiatus, Matty and Gibby return to the mic to celebrate 200 episodes of One Night in Pinehurst. It’s part self-congratulations, part therapy, part reunion — and fully ONIP. They reflect on what kept them away, why this podcast still gallops like a thoroughbred, and why Shohei Ohtani’s return mirrors their own. Cheers to 200 and the ride ahead...

The mock drafts are in the trash — it’s time for the real thing. On this episode of One Night in Pinehurst, Matty P and Gibby welcome back recurring guest and college football insider KJ Hancock, who gives us a front-row seat to draft day emotions as his brother, Jordan Hancock, gets selected by the Buffalo Bills. We talk Patriots optimism, front office chaos, new grading systems, and what it real...

🚨 NFL Draft Season is Here 🚨 The One Night in Pinehurst war room is live and fully loaded for a complete 2025 NFL Draft Preview. Matty P and Gibby are joined by the always insightful Brandon Casten to talk fits, surprises, sleepers, and what your team should do (but probably won’t). From top-10 trades to late-round gems, the crew dives deep into every angle of the draft board. No gimmicks. Just...

The playoffs snuck up on Matty P, but that won’t stop the ONIP crew from diving deep into the NBA postseason. Gibby and Matty P are joined by the one and only Coach Hoy to preview every angle of the 2025 NBA Playoffs — from whether the Celtics should be feared to the most chaotic matchups out West. They talk first-round fears, surprise x-factors, pressure-packed coaching situations, and who’s got...

It’s the best week of the year—Masters Week—and One Night in Pinehurst is going full azalea mode. Matty P and Gibby are joined by our favorite golf expert and cohost of Fairways & Dreams, Bud Copeland, for a deep dive into everything Augusta. We’re talking course changes, favorite traditions, the players to watch (and fade), and why this year’s tournament could be one for the books. Bud brings the...

Matty P and Gibby are joined by college basketball expert Mike Green for a definitive 2-part March Madness preview! We’re diving deep into Vegas lines, uncovering upset specials, and breaking down key storylines to follow. Plus, we tackle the KEMPOM method to identify teams primed for a deep run and discuss the wild rumor of Belichick recruiting at halftime of the UNC game. Whether you’re filling...

Matty P and Gibby are joined by college basketball expert Mike Green for a definitive 2-part March Madness preview! We’re diving deep into Vegas lines, uncovering upset specials, and breaking down key storylines to follow. Plus, we tackle the KEMPOM method to identify teams primed for a deep run and discuss the wild rumor of Belichick recruiting at halftime of the UNC game. Whether you’re filling...

The first wave of NFL free agency is in the books, and we’re breaking it all down! Who were the biggest losers of the offseason? Can Denver hang another banner, or are they just hanging on? And did the Patriots actually get value out of their moves, or are they just treading water? Matty P and Gibby tackle all the big questions, plus some underrated signings and the most head-scratching deals. Tun...

The conversation continues as One Night in Pinehurst welcomes back Ryan Ripken for Part 2 of our MLB Spring Training Preview. Ryan dives deeper into his baseball experiences, reflecting on the legendary players he’s crossed paths with and the lasting impact of the game beyond the stat sheet. Matty P and Gibby get into the latest storylines, including key player developments, Baltimore’s pitching o...

Spring is in the air, and that means baseball is back! Matty P and Gibby are joined by two special guests—Ryan Ripken, host of The Ryan Ripken Show, and Alex Bastow, our resident Baltimore Orioles superfan. The crew dives into all things MLB, from early season storylines to what’s brewing in Baltimore. Ryan shares insights from his time with Bills Mafia and reflects on his whirlwind travels, while...

Set sail for smooth tunes and good vibes on this special episode of One Night in Pinehurst! Matty P and Gibby are joined by recurring guest AB and Eric from the band Discourage for the ultimate Yacht Rock Fantasy Draft. From Hall & Oates to Michael McDonald, the guys assemble their dream teams of soft rock legends, debating what truly makes a song worthy of the high seas. Expect heated debates, de...

Matty P and Gibby are joined by two special guests—renowned musician Sarab Singh and Gibby's friend from elementary school, Eagles superfan John Breunig—for a Super Bowl preview that isn’t entirely about the Super Bowl. Expect a mix of football, Grammy talk, and insights into the LA music scene as the crew navigates one of the biggest weekends in sports and entertainment. Tune in for an episode wh...

In this episode of One Night in Pinehurst, Matty P and Gibby are joined by special guests Bud Copeland (#ThisBudsForYou) and Nate Hryn, founder of Acorn Hills. Nate shares exciting updates about the future of Acorn Hills, while Bud dives into the brand-new TGL and breaks down !the storylines to watch in the 2025 PGA Tour season. Don’t miss this deep dive into the world of golf and beyond! Learn mo...

In this episode of One Night in Pinehurst, Matty P and Gibby gear up for an action-packed weekend of football. We break down our fantasy lineup picks for the NFL Divisional Round, spotlighting the players who could make the difference in your contest. Matty also previews the highly anticipated college football championship, sharing insights on key matchups and players to watch. Plus, we predict th...

Matty P and Gibby wrap up the regular season by exploring players chasing those all-important incentives 💰, diving into a critical matchup up north ❄️, and giving AB a well-deserved week to rest. Don’t miss the final fantasy tips of the season! Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices