One night in Pinehurst

The NFL schedule is out and the boys are back. Matty P and Gibby break down the biggest takeaways from the 2026 NFL schedule release — from prime time overload and travel concerns to playoff sleepers, tanking candidates, and why the Jets might actually be… interesting? The guys dive into: Broncos and Patriots schedule reactions Why the Bengals and Cowboys could be dangerous The looming Arch Mannin...

We wrap up our 2026 NFL Draft Preview with the positions everyone wants to talk about — running backs and quarterbacks. Which backs can make an instant fantasy impact? Who are the safest QB prospects? And which team could change its future with one pick? Brandon, Matty P and Gibby close out the preview with bold predictions, draft night scenarios, and the names that could define the first round. T...

It’s Part 2 of our 2026 NFL Draft Preview and we shift to the flashy positions. The boys break down corners, wide receivers, and the playmakers who could hear their names called early. Who’s a future WR1? Which corner can lock down on Sundays right away? And who might become the steal of the draft? Casten, Matty P and Gibby bring the takes, sleepers, and a few disagreements along the way. Learn mo...

The boys are back with our 2026 NFL Draft Preview (Part 1) as we kick things off breaking down the defensive side of the ball. Which pass rushers can change a franchise immediately? Who are the safest bets in the secondary? And which prospects might be getting too much hype? Brandon, Matty P and Gibby talk impact defenders, draft fits, and the names you need to know before draft night. Defense win...

All things Masters—and it starts with one of the shots of the year. We break down Cameron Young’s absolute bomb on 18 at The Players and what it could mean for his breakout season, before diving headfirst into Augusta. In this episode: Who’s actually built to win at Augusta (and who might melt down) Why experience still trumps trends at the Masters Picks, long shots, and the guys flying under the...

The boys are BACK for one of our favorite episodes of the year — the annual March Madness deep dive with returning guest (and bracket savant) Mike Green. We’re breaking down everything you need to know heading into the tournament: Why this year’s top tier might be historically dominant The KenPom + efficiency data that could shape your bracket Where the real upset value lives (hint: power conferen...

Coach Hoy is back and we’re diving headfirst into the NBA stretch run. We break down the Celtics’ playoff ceiling, Tatum’s return timeline, whether OKC or San Antonio should be the real favorites, and which under-the-radar teams could make noise. Plus: Giannis rumors, Brad Stevens masterclass cap talk, and an early look at a loaded NBA Draft class. Spring hoops energy is officially here. Learn mor...

It’s Super Bowl week, and the noise is officially at full volume. We talk through what the week actually feels like — the overanalysis, the betting angles, Super Bowl squares, and that familiar stretch where optimism and skepticism live side by side. There’s some matchup talk, some fan therapy, and a lot of trying to figure out how we actually feel before kickoff. Nothing overproduced here. Just a...

Quinn Tuff of The Band Memo is back on the show, and it’s been a couple of years. We catch up on what he’s been up to with the band, talk music, life, and the weird experience of revisiting old recordings. There’s some reflection, some laughs, and the usual debate about whether Spotify is quietly hiding us from the world. We can't wait to see what is next for Quinn and The Band Memo Learn more abo...

Matt Captline from Low Stress Bets joins the show to talk discipline, playoff betting, and what it actually looks like to bet with a long-term mindset. The guys dig into what worked in 2025, where bettors tend to get themselves into trouble, and why alternate lines, weather, and knowing a division can matter more than chasing big payouts. There’s also a thoughtful conversation about treating betti...

Matty and Gibby are back after the break, diving straight into Championship Weekend and a big-picture quarterback conversation that’s been brewing all season. Who are you actually taking if you’re starting a franchise today? The guys build out a long-term QB ranking exercise — expansion draft style — breaking players into tiers, debating upside vs. availability, and separating narrative from reali...

Quick pit stop for the Milly Boys. We didn’t want to disappear on you this week, so we’re dropping a fast, no-nonsense DFS and Week outlook to keep the streak alive. Lineup thoughts, game environments we’re targeting, incentives, pace spots, and just enough chaos to get you set—then go lock in with our full episode featuring Pigtown Sports. We’ll be back at full strength soon. Learn more about you...

Episode 223 kicks off with a curveball as Gibby joins a little late—but the conversation is already humming when he arrives. The boys reunite with Alex and Zach for a wide-ranging, no-nonsense baseball discussion centered on one of the biggest questions of the offseason: who’s actually making the right moves—and who’s about to step on a landmine? The crew dives deep into the Orioles finally making...

AB is back, the lineup is locked, and the boys are officially due. Gibby and Matty break down this week’s DFS slate with a simple goal: stop overthinking it and start cashing again. From paying up for Christian McCaffrey to trusting Puka, Jacoby Myers, and a few value plays that won’t send AB into a spiral, the crew walks through a lineup built for sanity and upside. They also hit Patriots–Bills p...

It’s Week 13 on One Night in Pinehurst, and the boys are back for a slate so bad it should come with a warning label. Gibby and Matty break down a weekend of leftovers — the “cut down the tree” Sunday — where the only people watching all day are degenerates chasing parlays and FanDuel points. Between Gibby guiding his son away from Patriots fandom (into the warm wings of Eagles nation), a full-blo...

The boys are back and firing up Week 12 with a full ONIP lineup build — starting with a Detroit Lions explosion spot. Gibbs, the Cousin, and Jameson Williams headline a week where Matty and Gibby are all in on the Lions getting right in the dome. From there, it’s a tour around the league: • Jacoby Brissette’s record-setting pace • Why this Arizona/Jacksonville matchup might quietly shoot out • The...

AB is back in the chair for Week 11, and the Milly Boys are feeling dangerous. Gibby, Matty P, and America’s Best Friend build out their FanDuel lineup, debate whether Lamar’s hamstring is worth worrying about, make the case for RJ Harvey as a volume play, and land on a cheap Atlanta defense ready to torment Bryce Young. There’s plenty of Broncos therapy, early-morning trolling, and a “team full o...

Part I kicks off with a full-on college football deep dive as former Kennesaw State Owl KJ joins Matty P and Gibby to break down the rise of the Owls, the chaos in Conference USA, and why Ohio State looks untouchable this year. From NIL money and coaching carousels to sleeper bowl projections and next-gen quarterback prospects, the boys cover everything from the field to the film room—with plenty...

Part I kicks off with a full-on college football deep dive as former Kennesaw State Owl KJ joins Matty P and Gibby to break down the rise of the Owls, the chaos in Conference USA, and why Ohio State looks untouchable this year. From NIL money and coaching carousels to sleeper bowl projections and next-gen quarterback prospects, the boys cover everything from the field to the film room—with plenty...

We’ve officially hit the halfway point of the NFL season — and Matty P and Gibby are in midseason form. This week, the boys break down a packed slate featuring Bills-Chiefs at 4:25, Denver’s sneaky playoff chances, and whether the Patriots are on a collision course with destiny (or disaster). They dig into lineup strategy with a few familiar names and some new faces: 🏈 Rashee Rice as the new Kels...

The boys are back — winners of four of their last seven FanDuel contests — and feeling (just barely) in the black for the season. In classic One Night in Pinehurst fashion, Gibby, Matty P, and America’s Best Friend (AB) dive into a mix of lineup logic, football therapy, and completely off-the-rails tangents that somehow circle back to fantasy value. They kick things off with “Love on Time” by Quin...

Matty P and Gibby are back, breaking down Week 8 of the NFL season with the signature ONIP blend of humor, strategy, and mild disbelief at how bad the international games are. From Canada-based FanDuel bets to fantasy lineup pivots, the boys hit it all — dissecting why Mahomes remains a top fantasy play, why Judkins could feast against Miami, and how Lad McConkey might finally reward AB’s trust is...

Matty P and Gibby welcome Matt Captline, founder of Low Stress Bets, to talk about how his disciplined, data-driven approach to sports betting has outperformed the S&P 500 in seven of the last twelve months. They dive into the art of “low stress” betting — avoiding parlays, stacking small wins, and applying investment logic to sports wagers. From Steelers futures to live PGA picks, Matt explains h...

The Milly Boys are back and searching for that elusive big cash. Gibby, Matty P, and AB break down a fresh FanDuel lineup after last week’s near miss — including a “get-right” pick from AB that’s got the crew all-in on Josh Jacobs. They debate whether to trust Rhamondre Stevenson, laugh through Brock Purdy family tree conspiracies (yes, Chuba Purdy is real), and drop a few gems on which defenses a...

Gibby, Matty P, and AB put together their Week 5 FanDuel Milly lineup, debating risky plays, chalk locks, and sneaky stacks that could win big. Along the way, they roast Boomer’s bad nicknames, sneak in a Broncos reference, and celebrate the 14th annual Tee Off for 2E — on track to raise $100K for Camp Sunshine. Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices