On Wednesdays We Watch...

Join Brody, Caitlin, and Jessi as they sing the very best shower song ever created.  Highlights include: strategic scene cuts, selling Brooke’s nasty used mattress, Caitlin’s sports knowledge, brother road trips, Keith you in danger!, lost and found thongs, technology peaked at cassette tape adapters, THE HOLIDAY SONG, isn’t Lucas grounded?, so many red flags from Jules, Anna gets the best line re...

Join Brody, Caitlin, and Jessi and they steal all the booze at Tric’s grand opening.  Highlights include: good for The Get Up Kids!, Grandma Pat doesn’t know what she watched…, he can’t help but say his full name, douchey rider requests, OTH character alignments, we know who the issue is in this conversation, hot girls get to be nerds now!, Dan Scott’s Grinch-like to do list, hey Menounos this isn...

Join Brody, Caitlin, and Jessi as they watch a meteor shower from a waterfront table on a private pond. Highlights include: wistfully looking at photos, stanning Keane, we know what the “F” stands for, it’s Tyler Hilton, guys!, opening other peoples’ mail is illegal, this isn’t Riverdale, single parent dating tropes, Brooke will not read your shitty books, Lucas is easy to stalk, smoke alarms are...

Join Brody, Caitlin, and Jessi as they fail to read all the instructions before starting a dare.  Highlights include: strong emotional reactions to Dare You To Move, our biggest fan is Hulu, enjoying Tim’s downfall, this is a Caitlin question, earning that explicit tag, high tech cell phones (for 2004…), throwing too many men at Jessi before a long break, losing fluids quickly, just another day in...

Join Brody, Caitlin, and Jessi as they make wild assumptions about the boy swimming in their pool.  Highlights include: starting the episode with some aggressive casual racism, HBO Max editing, songs about murdering your husband, connecting with Dan through garden gnomes, confronting the timeline question, google break theme song, Chad Michael Murray is almost 40 and now we feel old, hot young Aus...

Episode 3: Near Wild Heaven- Join Brody, Caitlin, and Jessi as they try their hardest to convince Tim not to hire a stripper.  Highlights include: effective bait and switches, the cat was concerned, mourning the loss of Keith’s bad facial hair, entering the timeline wormhole, Dan’s fake tan situation, punching Paul Johansson for the sins of Dan Scott, Chad Michael Murray’s glow up, 30 year olds do...

Join Brody, Caitlin, and Jessi as they speculate why on earth two teenagers would get married.  Highlights include: jamming to the theme song in our heads, throwing Steinbeck books into the ocean, can you expand her horizons without expanding her legs?, musical improv from Caitlin, 48 minutes of Brody’s favorite scenes, failing at acting sincere, she’s being a real Dan about the whole thing, cool...

Join Brody, Caitlin, and Jessi as they return to Tree Hill with new haircuts and new outlooks.  Highlights include:  FAKE FAN!, stricken blind by the death of his brother, nipple ring distraction, facial hair improvement, retiring the suck my ass moment (maybe), triggered by Luke’s fashion, all flashbacks all the time, your brains aren’t done cooking yet!, stop teasing us with Dan’s death, melting...

Join Brody, Caitlin, and Jessi as they try to recap the highs and lows of Season One, but just end up calling each other out for an hour.  Highlights include: just keeping it casual, Jessi is a filthy liar, long live Minus, Nathan Scott: from stealing buses to stealing hearts, rejoicing in the arrival of Deb Scott, rebounding with Shitty Tim, defending Jessi’s bad predictions, stanning Whitey and...

Join Brody, Caitlin, and Jessi as they realize there really is only ONE Tree Hill.  Highlights include: hashtag season one spoilers, regretting missing basketball, broody raven poetry, banned media is back!, this finale does not need punched up, sudden Dan Scott, nasty girls featuring Peyton Sawyer’s onlyfans, love confessions in the rain 5 feet from a covered porch, Caitlin wasn’t concerned becau...

Join Brody, Caitlin, and Jessi as they learn the dangers of clicking the saved links on a teenage boy’s computer.  Highlights include: dramatic recaps are dramatic, strong little brother energy, the return of Peyton’s OnlyFans, trying to win basketball games with the 6th grade bench warmers, sick Whitey burns *airhorn sounds*, did you know Jessi hates Dan Scott?, benching Tim’s friendship, it neve...

Join Brody, Caitlin, and Jessi as they feed the worst Dad in the world floor pretzels.  Highlights include:  the show’s music taking a hard turn for the better, shitty Tim ruins everything, planning a Bogey Lowenstein party, good brother moments, unnecessary flexing, not a good look for Brooke Davis, big “go home Roger” energy, rooting for a couple of teenagers to sex, King Midol of cool, leaving...

Join Brody, Caitlin, and Jessi as they unironically play Everybody Hurts during an end of episode montage.  Highlights include: Caitlin’s feeling British, resolving all the cliff hangers, never forget carousel girl, Lucas handling a situation well (until he really doesn’t), the tragedy of rejecting Daddy Uncle Keith, nipple rings glowing in the sun, faulty tattoo sharpies, Dan’s new best friend Je...

Join Brody, Caitlin, and Jessi as they try to bid on all the boys in the Boy Toy auction!  Highlights include: Jessi is very uncomfortable, Speedo Tim (but just for this episode), Whitey is here for a mascot strip tease, there is no way to tell how old any one is, we forgot about the nipple rings, thirsty girl in the corner can’t catch a break, the focus groups need more Mouth, bad language choice...

Join Brody, Caitlin, and Jessi as they stop by the Peppermint Zebra for ladies night!  Highlights include: podcasting through a garbage disposal, what is the timeline of this show?, OTH names Jessi hates, Mouth living his best life, expecting more out of the press, website time travel, pause for giggles, we are not mature enough for this TV show, alphabetical order bitches!, replacing real Dan wit...

Join Brody, Caitlin, and Jessi as they overcharge Sheryl Crow for a cup of coffee. Talking points include: an amouse bouche of plot reveals, American Idol and aggressive David Cook love, don’t buy 3rd party concert tickets kids!, the origins of JakeJake, Mustang bribes (the car not the horse), setting people on fire with a look, the return of the bucket bar, rebounding with a crazy brunette is the...

Join Brody, Caitlin, and Jessi as they learn the downside of having a webcam on in their bedroom 24/7.  Talking points include: cakey makeup, double dream sequences, crochet updates, secret actor babies,  Don’t forget to subscribe and rate the podcast on itunes or any of your favorite podcatchers!  Follow us on Instagram, Facebook, Twitter, and TikTok at @onwednesdayspod, follow us on Spotify at N...

Join Brody, Caitlin, and Jessi as they chalk up the river court in honor of Lucas’s missing spleen. Talking points include: Shonda Rhymes’s OTH inspiration, On Thursdays We Watch Bridgerton, get a clue Brooke!, the Italian boyfriend scenario, Italian Boyfriend=more basketball, Jessi’s butterfly effect, apologizing for the suck my ass moment, Lucas deserves Medicare for all, WDDD?, HIPAA compliant...

**Caitlin would like to take a brief moment to apologize for the quality of her audio in this episode. She's not sure what happened!** Join Brody, Caitlin, and Jessi as their excitement for Karen’s return comes crashing into us!  Talking points include: the plot of 127 Hours, Brooke Davis would NEVER, poncho shade, beach whore Carrie, helping Hayley with her freeshots, gym class talk, strong...

Join Brody, Caitlin, and Jessi as they attend the most uncomfortable birthday dinner imaginable for the very worst dad on the planet.  Talking points include:  too many daddies, passing on stupid names to future generations, dabbling in amphetamines, mature decisions from Brooke Davis, Jessi’s horny romance books, one singular bean unspilled, curly hair envy, Dan Scott married his mom, Caitlin’s c...

Join Brody, Caitlin, and Jessi as they bond with Papa Sawyer before he leaves for New Zealand!  Talking points include: family therapy nightmares, revisiting Lucas’s taste in books, no tits are worth jail time, emergency man-stealing CDs, dredging boat googles, Larry Sawyer: Sand Collector, Dan Scott keeps hitting on children, the many bad hats of Hayley James, Poncho talk, giving the gift of puki...

Join Brody, Caitlin, and Jessi as they stumble onto Gavin DeGraw at a record store and convince him to perform at an open mic for free!  Talking points include:  avoiding 17 year old spoilers, shitty apologies, a blessed lack of Steinbeck, baggage shaming, Petyon’s beautiful car, Hos before Bros, the high cost of polaroid film, the cons of whipped cream, parenting by locking Lucas in the cellar, f...

Join Brody, Caitlin, and Jessi as they try to get better at basketball by taking whatever drugs Tim’s brother has to offer.  Talking points include: songs that are definitely not Creed songs, very special episodes, trying to make Steinbeck sexy, coffee is hard, juicy tracksuits, evil family meetings, poor Tim (but not for long), fractions are hard, sudden Brooke Davis, Jessie Spano is Brody’s only...

Trigger Warning- This episode deals with sexual assault, attempted rape, and the date rape drug.  If you’re easily upset by those topics, maybe sit this one out and join us next time! Join Brody, Caitlin, and Jessi as they spend their day trying to rebuild their karma while wearing sensible blazers.  Talking points include: North Carolina geography with Caitlin, low rise jeans, eskimo brother equi...

Caw! Join Brody, Caitlin, and Jessi as they save the fancy fundraising party with Karen’s baked goods!  Talking points include: debunking Jessi’s theories, T9-ing history answers, character development, this could be on the test, the return of JakeJake, Minnesota interesting, poncho watch 2020, Caw!, sick burns from Deb Scott, screaming orgasm recipes, mandatory romance swings, Dan Scott’s worst n...