Not Your Sunday School

Eight episodes in, Erin and Kaitlyn pause to look back on how much life and faith have shifted since they first launched the podcast. From church communities to personal callings, seminary studies to Sunday school, grief to grace, they share the real changes that have deepened their Christian walk over the past six months. ✨ Not Your Sunday School Moments: [00:15] From idea to milestone Erin and...

What does it really mean to be a “lukewarm Christian”? And how do we know if we’ve slipped into going through the motions instead of living on fire for Christ? In this episode, Erin and Kaitlyn wrestle with a challenging passage from Revelation and explore how it plays out in their own lives, from drifting faith and half-hearted habits to bold moments of conviction. Through honest stories, family...

Rituals don’t have to be rigid. They can be deeply personal, grounding, and even surprising ways we connect with God. In this episode, Erin and Kaitlyn open up about the practices that keep them steady: from praying the Rosary in community, to walking labyrinths, to the simple but powerful act of saying grace at mealtimes. Along the way, they share how yoga, journaling, and Scripture study have sh...

This week’s conversation comes from a listener request. Shoutout to Sydney in Vestavia Hills, Alabama! She asked how social media is shaping Christianity, and Erin and Kaitlyn dive right in. Social media connects us, inspires us, and spreads the gospel in ways our grandparents never imagined. But it also fuels comparison, performative Christianity, and digital footprints that never fade. From AOL...

We hear it all the time: “Just pray about it.” But what does that really mean, especially when you're new to faith, coming back, or still unsure what you believe? This episode dives into the practice of prayer, not as a performance or obligation, but as something real, honest, and grounding. Erin and Kaitlyn share how prayer has reshaped their spiritual lives, from grief and guilt to trust and...

In this episode, Erin confesses something that’s felt taboo in church circles: she really doesn’t like worship music. From the loudness and theatrics to the pressure to “feel something,” it’s never felt like her way in. Kaitlyn brings her own perspective from ancient Latin hymns to the chants of her yoga practice, and together they unpack how sacred sound can connect us… or completely shut us down...

In this episode, Erin takes us through her unconventional path from a science-only worldview to embracing Christianity at age 30. She opens up about years of staunch atheism and how unexpected encounters became the gentle catalysts for her spiritual awakening. This is a story of mid-life reinvention, community found in strange places, and the surprising ways longing can turn into lasting faith. ✨...

We’re kicking off the podcast with Kaitlyn’s story — a vulnerable return to Catholicism that had nothing to do with rules and everything to do with grace. In this episode, she shares her messy, meaningful journey back after years away, and the powerful moment that reshaped everything. Faith and family. Guilt and healing. This is where we begin. ✨ Not Your Sunday School Moments: [00:37] The unlike...