Kelsey Barberio and Olivia Lagaly
Normal Shit
Your weekly dose of late-night sleepover chit chat. From pop culture deep dives to unfiltered life talks, it’s the conversations you’d have at 1 a.m. with your best friends. By the girlies, for the girlies. ✨Hosted by Olivia Lagaly & Kelsey Barberio
Be sure to visit the podcast's website and support the creator: podcasters.spotify.com
Author
Kelsey Barberio and Olivia Lagaly
Category
Podcast website
Latest episode
Nov 19, 2026
Where to listen?
Podcasts in the app Replaio Radio Coming soonPodcasts are coming to the app soon. Install now and be the first to see a whole new take on podcasts
Episodes
The Secret Lives of Mormon Wives: OC Has Us OBSESSED (And We Have THOUGHTS) 19.11.2026 1:21:37
We found our new reality TV obsession! We're breaking down The Secret Lives of Mormon Wives: Orange County , from the cast members we're rooting for to the ones (*cough* Molly Mormons) we simply cannot get behind. We're talking Jen's divorce journey and the family pressure surrounding it, Madison and Kyler's relationship (ugh), McCall and Jordan's Mormon girl energy, and wh...
Love Is Blind Reunion DISASTER, DWTS Elimination Shocker & The Call Her Daddy Fallout Gets Juicier 12.11.2026 1:08:37
Reality TV is really feeding us this week! Love Is Blind: The reunion was a mess. We discuss John's cheating, the stripper texts, his dad's defense of him, the reunion's most ridiculous moments, and Michaella's unforgettable fall. Dancing with the Stars: We're shocked by Jenna Dewan's elimination, debate who deserves to win, and discuss the latest performances and ballroom...
Halloween Matchmaking, Love Is Blind Finale & DWTS 05.11.2026 1:13:25
We're recapping our Halloween night out as Mia Thermopolis and Princess Mia, attempting to play matchmaker with a 40-year-old finance guy dressed as Beetlejuice, and mourning the mysterious disappearance of Kelsey's beloved Celine sunglasses (St. Anthony, we're counting on you). We're also getting into all things pop culture: breaking down the Dancing with the Stars Disney Night pe...
You Can See Everything: What the hell was that?! 30.10.2026 43:04
What the actual hell did we just watch?! This week on Normal Shit , Kelsey and Olivia are breaking down Nathan Fielder’s You Can See Everything , the wild, three-hour Elizabeth Holmes documentary that left us with approximately one million questions and absolutely no consensus. Is Elizabeth Holmes a master manipulator, deeply misunderstood, or somehow both? Is Billy the most suspicious man alive?...
Savannah Chrisley’s Wild Engagement, DWTS & Love is Blind S11 Red Flags 29.10.2026 52:20
Dancing with the Stars Horror Night! We discuss Shirley Ballas’ brutal scores, Connor’s standout performance (proud of our king), the double elimination, and Val Chmerkovskiy’s return after the Carrie Ann Inaba Will Smithcontroversy. Then we chat Love Is Blind Rob and Michaella’s ever so concerning dynamic, the season’s lack of convincing couples, and why we’re not exactly betting on many (or any)...
Love is Blind Season 11: Connecticut "Rich" Boys, Ghosting & the Worst Season Yet? 23.10.2026 43:09
We’re breaking down Love Is Blind Season 11 through the second drop of episodes, and it's... something! From Connecticut’s self-proclaimed "rich" boy who is absolutely not giving JFK Jr., to the love triangles, general lack of love, and men who are pretty much the worst, we’re getting into all of it. Who’s actually here for love? Who’s going to make it for real? And, damn, is this re...
DWTS Dedication Night Recap: Val Chmerkovskiy Drama, Emotional Tributes & More 22.10.2026 38:36
It’s Dedication Night on Dancing With the Stars , and we have THOUGHTS. 💃 From the emotional performances and heartfelt tributes to the Val Chmerkovskiy drama that has everyone talking, we’re breaking down the biggest moments of the night, the dances that got us in our feelings, and everything happening on and off the ballroom floor. Who delivered the most memorable performance? Which moments had...
Kelly Clarkson’s Bird Drama, Gosselin Family Secrets & MORE | Pop Culture Roundup 15.10.2026 58:50
Is Harry Styles actually dating Zoë Kravitz?! We’re unpacking the blind items, recapping his concert at Madison Square Garden, and getting into this week’s biggest pop culture headlines. From Kelly Clarkson’s bird-buying Pretty Woman fiasco and Selma Blair’s plane incident to Ciara Miller's elimination on Dancing with the Stars, Collin Gosselin family drama, and Lindsay Hubbard and Carl Radke...
The Swan Documentary Was INSANE, Kim K's Squad of Nannies & Other Things We Can’t Stop Talking About 08.10.2026 1:12:59
From The Swan documentary and its absolutely wild behind-the-scenes details to Kim Kardashian’s aggressive multi-nanny system, Khloé Kardashian’s double-king bed, the Pillowfight Championship, the death of Gypsy-Rose Blanchard's boyfriend, and Breaking Bad being named the #1 show of the 21st century, we’re unpacking the pop culture stories that we can't stop talking about. Plus, our though...
We’re Too Old for This Sh*t 01.10.2026 49:37
We’re officially at the age where we’re supposed to have our shit together… so naturally, we went way too hard at our friend Tori’s wedding welcome party in Atlanta and ended up at the Claremont Lounge watching a Dolly Parton “9 to 5” performance, women catching dollar bills in a thong, and a rather strategically placed Solo cup, all while embracing some truly inspiring body positivity. Then we ge...
Olivia Is Engaged! The Full Storytime 24.09.2026 1:04:08
Olivia is engaged! After all this time! (9 years) In this episode of Normal Shit , we’re getting into the engagement, how it all went down, the surprises that absolutely did not go according to plan, and some of the funniest stories from along the way. A very special episode about love, friendship, overthinking, anxiety, and the fact that nothing ever goes exactly as planned. Normal Shit | A podca...
Getting Laid Off, Starting Over & Our August Favorites 03.09.2026 1:07:58
This week on Normal Shit , Kelsey is officially one week into being laid off, and we're talking about the weird emotional roller coaster of losing a job, figuring out who you are outside of work, and what might come next. From freelancing and the future of traditional media to whether everyone on TikTok is now a journalist, we get into what it means to build a career in an industry that's...
Married at First Sight Season 20 Finale + Reunion: We Have THOUGHTS 28.08.2026 58:20
**SPOILERS for the entire Married at First Sight Season 20 season, finale, and reunion, obviously!** We made it to Decision Day… and the drama really lived up to our expectations. On this episode of Normal Shit, we’re breaking down the Season 20 finale, Decision Day decisions, and the reunion, including who stayed together, who absolutely should not have, the most shocking revelations, and all the...
Is a Wedding Actually Worth the Money? 20.08.2026 1:11:45
How much should you actually spend on a wedding? We’re talking wedding regrets, what couples wish they spent more (and less) on, the rising popularity of elopements and smaller weddings, and whether spending tens of thousands of dollars on one day is really worth it. Plus, Olivia is potentially getting engaged soon, so we’re using real wedding experiences (including listener stories!) and some sur...
Hilary Duff Gave Us Our Girlhood Back + Botox, Beauty & Reality TV 13.08.2026 1:13:39
In this episode of Normal Shit, we're very much still recovering from the Hilary Duff concert (including the possibility that we caught the plague there). We recap the concert, the last-minute tickets, and why the whole experience felt like getting a little piece of our girlhood back. We also discuss why we desperately need more experiences that make us feel that kind of pure, nostalgic joy. T...
Cruises, Conspiracies & Bubble Necklaces 06.08.2026 1:01:44
This week, we’re taking a trip down memory lane. From crying at the Hilary Duff concert and reliving our Lizzie McGuire childhoods to uncovering old journals that absolutely needed to be burned. We’re revisiting the fashion choices that defined our college years (bubble necklaces, Chacos, giant sorority T-shirts and peak Tory Burch fashion), debating which brands deserve a comeback and sharing our...
Going Viral, Hate Comments & How to Become a UGC Creator 23.07.2026 50:26
Olivia shares what happened after her very first viral TikTok approached one million views, and why the experience wasn't nearly as glamorous as it looked. We discuss the emotional side of going viral, dealing with hate comments, body shaming, and whether chasing viral moments is actually worth it. We also break down the difference between influencers and UGC creators, how brands hire creators...
The Unhinged Reality of Moving to NYC (Flex Walls, Roaches & Subway Mistakes) 16.07.2026 44:52
This week, we're taking a trip down memory lane to our very first years in New York City (and wow, were we thriving... or were we?) 😂 From living in flex-wall "bedrooms" and battling roaches to falling asleep on the subway, sneaking into clubs with random guys, and spending way too much money on broker fees, we're sharing the once-stressful stories that somehow turned into our f...
Why We'd Get Kicked Off Love Island, June Favorites & Birthday Chaos 02.07.2026 1:00:51
Olivia is officially 31! 🎉 We recap her birthday weekend in NYC (including giant margaritas, jungle bars, comedy shows... and one unfortunate puke), then share all of our June favorites - from home decor, beauty products and workout finds to swimsuits we're loving this summer. Then we spend way too long discussing Love Island USA because we have THOUGHTS. Casa Amor fallout, our favorite Islan...
We Need to Talk About DCC: Reece, Kelly Finglass & Impossible Expectations 25.06.2026 57:19
We accidentally turned this week's episode into a full-blown Dallas Cowboys Cheerleaders dissertation. From Kelly Finglass & Judy Trammell's terrifying feedback sessions to Reese's surprising exit, we're unpacking everything that had us screaming at our TVs. Along the way, we discuss reality TV fame, social media money, perfectionism, people-pleasing, and why we'd both last approximately 30 se...
Spray Tan Disasters, RHORI Obsessions & Birthday Blues 18.06.2026 1:04:49
We're talking spray tan fails, birthday feelings, beauty routines, the horrors of the Aritzia dressing room, and reality TV chaos. This week, Olivia recounts a self-tanner disaster that had her showering into infinity, while Kelsey shares her current tanning routine and summer beauty favorites. We also get real about getting older, birthday expectations, Botox, and what celebrating yourself lo...
Honeymoons, Hot Takes & Hot Islanders 11.06.2026 1:06:02
On today's episode of Normal Shit , the girls are going international. They're recapping Kelsey's dreamy honeymoon in Greece, Olivia's adventures through England and Norway, and sharing all their latest Love Island hot takes. Olivia's Matchbox Link: https://us.mgco.com/collections/matchbox-sleeves
AITA w/ Brett: Public Toilets, Dog Phobias & Wedding Drama 04.06.2026 20:42
This week Brett returns to the podcast for a Reddit “Am I the Asshole?” episode that includes: a heated discussion about sitting on public toilet seats whether dog owners owe tourists a bench sibling wedding jealousy porta potty survival tactics and whether Beyonce secretly travels with custom toilet seats Normal stuff, honestly. Normal Shit | A Podcast by Kelsey Barberio and Olivia Lagaly
Brett Joins the Podcast: Summer House Drama, Child-Free Conversations & Girl Mathing a Chanel Bag 28.05.2026 53:08
Brett officially joins the pod this week while Olivia is away! We miss her dearly and thank Brett for his service to the pod. We break down the latest Summer House chaos, our thoughts on Amanda and West, the wild Netflix documentary The Crash , and the show that completely consumed our Memorial Day weekend. We also get into: our honest thoughts on having kids relationship pet peeves anxiety and pa...
Chicken Breast Nails, Color Analysis Crises & Trad Wives 14.05.2026 1:13:21
This week on Normal Shit , we spiral over “chicken breast nails,” debate whether color analysis is a scam or life-changing diagnosis, and unpack the emotional ~tRaUmA~ of being told certain colors “don’t work” on us. We also get into shopping addictions, spring cleaning our apartments (and our lives), dog training updates with Fig, love languages, Kindle obsessions, trad-wife thrillers, Housewives...
Similar podcasts
Replaio is not a podcast publisher; show names, artwork and audio belong to their authors and are distributed through public RSS feeds.