Murder, Murder on the Wall

Season 2, Episode 5: Cari Farver: The True Story of Stalking, Catfishing and Murder  In this episode of Murder Murder on the Wall, Stacey and Kelly dive into the shocking true crime case of Cari Farver, a Nebraska woman whose disappearance became one of the most disturbing stories of stalking, catfishing, obsession, identity theft, and murder in recent memory. What begins as a seemingly ordinary d...

Ugh, beauties—this is your warning: this episode is extremely dark. This week, we cover the case of Ian Watkins, former lead singer of Lostprophets, and the shocking crimes that went unchecked for far too long. It’s a devastating look at celebrity, power, and how systems can fail to act—even when warning signs are repeatedly reported. This is one of the most disturbing cases we’ve ever covered, in...

Netflix has a new documentary about pro-cyclist, Moriah Wilson. Her amazing life and tragic end. We recycyled (get it?) our episode detailing a beautiful life cut short.   It’s a winding (gravel) road that Kelly and Stacey are going down this week covering the heartbreaking murder of elite pro cyclist Anna Moriah “Mo” Wilson - and the unbelievable escape of yogi Kaitlin Armstrong. Yes, Stacey know...

Episode: The Pom Pom Mom – The Texas Cheerleader Murder Plot What happens when competitive cheerleading, small-town status, and obsessive parenting collide? In this episode of Murder Murder on the Wall, Stacey and Kelly dive into the infamous true-crime case of Wanda Holloway, the Texas mother who tried to hire a hitman to kill another mom — all to secure her daughter’s spot on the middle school c...

MMOTW Episode #21 Port Arthur Massacre We are re-releasing this episode in light of the horrific events at Bondi Beach in Australia and Brown University in Rhode Island.  We first released this episode in March of 2025. Since then, there have been approximately 330 mass shootings in the United States.    We are headed way down under to Australia today. Tasmania, to be exact. According to all my Go...

In this episode of Murder, Murder on the Wall, Stacey and Kelly dive deep into the true story of Meredith Kercher, the 21-year-old British exchange student murdered in Perugia, Italy in 2007. While most true-crime coverage focuses on Amanda Knox, this episode shifts the narrative back to Meredith—her life, her personality, and the details of her final days. We break down the real timeline, what ha...

It’s well into the school year but Stacey and Kelly are feeling very academic. New clothes, new pens. Sometimes green pens that get left behind at a crime scene. In this episode, we try to unpack how schools - specifically colleges and universities - have become fraught with tragedy. Like how none of us can unsee or unfeel the 2022 murders of four University of Idaho students who have heartbreakin...

MMOTW SEASON TWO! Episode 1 The Murder of Gail Katz HEY! We are back! We renewed ourselves for Season 2! Get ready, Beauties! This week we’re diving into the chilling case of Robert Bierenbaum, the handsome, charming New York plastic surgeon who seemed to have it all—a thriving career, a love of flying planes, and a picture-perfect marriage. But behind the polished surface was a dark and violent t...

Since Karen Read is repeating, we thought it would be a good time to repeat one of our first episodes. In episode 3, practically still in the womb, we dove right into one of the most polarizing and controversial cases in the history of ever. Or at least in the Northeast.

MMOTW Episode #21 Port Arthur Massacre   We are headed way down under to Australia today. Tasmania, to be exact. According to all my Google images, this island off the southern end of Australia is stunning, with beaches, bays, and quorkas. We are not a travel podcast, so we are not covering all of Tasmania’s tourist destinations, but we will talk about a horrific day at one of them. Port Arthur, w...

Welcome to our third trial-sized episode, which is not that much shorter than normal. Kelly and Stacey are back in the Hamptons for a shocking, gruesome murder that shook an ultra-elite resort and spa in the uber-wealthy community of Watermill this past fall. Sabina Rosas was an artist who championed women artists from Central Asia - and developed platforms to showcase their work (and hers). She a...

This week, we are sending out to you an encore performance of one of our fav episodes. The one where Kelly and Stacey head to Utah! Where we may have found one of the craziest “secret lives of Mormon wives” in all the land: Kouri Richins, who maybe killed her husband with a Fentanyl-filled Moscow Mule - and then wrote a book about grieving. We think Kouri may have killed her husband for the plot....

Happy Lunar New Year, Valentines! Today, Stacey and Kelly are doing a deep dive on the undoing of a picture-perfect marriage. There’s no such thing you say? Well we couldn’t believe it either but as it turns out, Suzanne and Barry Morphew’s marriage was anything but perfect. On Mothers Day 2020, Suzane went out for a bike ride and never came home. That is until 2023 when her remains were found in...

Hey Beauties! We hope this podcast finds you well. This week, Kelly and Stacey bring you a cautionary tale about seeking enlightenment. Turns out not all self-help helpers are the same. James Arthur Ray was a self-help guru who thought very highly of his abilities to ‘help’ people. But in October of 2009, a Spiritual Warrior retreat went way off the hot rails - and three people lost their lives. S...

Trigger Warning: *This episode covers sexual assault* Welcome to MMOTW 2025! It’s a new year, but it’s a tale as old as time of horrible people doing horrible things. Stacey and Kelly are kicking off the year covering an unimaginable crime from the South of France - one that has been reported on far and wide. Picture-perfect Provence is home to boulangeries, boutiques, cheese, lavender and more ch...

Happy holidays, beauties. Hopefully Santa has come and gone wherever you are, and that he brought you everything you dreamed of - because Kelly and Stacey have decided to close out the year with an absolute nightmare. Meet Bruce McArthur: Santa for hire, landscaper - and serial killer who terrorized the gay community in Toronto, Canada for at least a decade, probably more. Why don’t we know for su...

Well we’re back, beauties, and boy do we have an episode for you. First, Kelly and Stacey head home (well to Stacey’s home) for the holidays to cover Rochester, New York’s infamous, horrible serial killer, Arthur Shawcross. Two fun facts! First, this was supposed to be our very first episode, but we put it on ice - and made some much-needed edits - and voila. It’s a holiday miracle. Fun fact two:...

Hi, Beauties!! A quick message for you!

It’s Self-Care Week at MMOTW, and Kelly and Stacey are here to help you self-care your way through whatever it is you need to work out. But first, we deliver your weekly dose of True Crime - and the very sad, very true story of Helen Mintiks - a talented, young violinist who was murdered at the Metropolitan Opera House. If you’ve never heard of this case, well, you’ve unfortunately heard many just...

Just as we promised, Beauties!! A brand new episode for you. Yes, a little bit behind. However, this week was all about politics and some sort of election, so Kelly and Stacey are nothing if not on theme, so we are keeping things politics-adjacent with this case. We are going back in time again to 1975 and the (unsolved) murder of 15-year-old Martha Moxley. This murder involves some Kennedy cousin...

We're busy electioning today and we bet you are too. But. We will be back on Friday with our regularly scheduled murder and beauty. Take care, beauties! 

It’s Halloween Week here at MMOTW, and that means it’s time to dress up.  Kelly and Stacey travel back to 1990s NYC for some inspiration: the infamous Club Kids. From the Tunnel to the Palladium to the Limelight, we cover all of the velvet-roped venues owned by Peter Gatien  - and the very tragic murder of Andre “Angel” Melendez at the hands of the top Club Kid, Michael Alig. PLUS. We don’t go clu...

It’s a very special trial-sized episode this week for Kelly and Stacey because we have Next Level Lexus…aka the heroine of last fall’s Tabi Thief drama…and her fashion picks for fall and beyond. But first, we take you through some of the worst dates in history - followed by our retelling of the infamous Tabi Thief. It was supposed to be a shorter episode than it is…but there’s a lot of ground to c...

If you are a doctor, or even if you are not a doctor, you probably know that the Hippocratic Oath is the official doctor promise. Part of that promise is “Do No Harm” - and we’re not sure Dr. Scott Sills understood the assignment. Maybe he missed doctor class that day. This week, Kelly and Stacey have found another staircase with another dead wife at the bottom - and we’re not happy about it, eith...

Ezra McCandless is a free spirit…well maybe not anymore. But she was at one point. A deep, complicated thinker and tortured artist, pondering all of life’s questions. Is my art speaking to people? Is my nose ring infected? Who is going to pay for my oat milk latte today? Kelly and Stacey are examining all of these questions and more on this episode of MMOTW. Ezra crossed paths with more than a few...