Murder, Mayhem, & Merlot

On May28th, 1980, Dorothy Scott offered to give one of her co-workers a ride to the E.R. after a work meeting. Another co-worker tagged along with the two and made their way there. After the group was set to leave the hospital, Dorothy went outside alone to retrieve her car and pull it up to the door, but she never made it. The two co-workers watched as Dorothy's car sped towards them and then lef...

In June of 1969, what was suppose to be a fun camping trip to The Great Smoky Mountains for young Dennis Martin and his family, turns into largest national park search and rescue operation in history. What happened to young Dennis? Did he wander off? Fall and hit his head? Did an actual animal get a hold of him? Did a sinister stranger abduct him? Was it more supernatural? If only the mountains co...

While waiting in her garage on her husband John Stevens to return from walking their dog, Michelle Mishcon is brutally attacked by a young stranger. Their neighbor, Jeff Fisher, hears the screams and goes to help only to be attacked himself. Jeff makes it back to his home where he calls 911. From this point, things go in a direction no one could have imagined. 19 year old Austin Harrouff is arrest...

It was a rainy morning in Midlothian, Texas on April 18th, 2016. That didn't stop Fitness Instructor Missy Bevers from hosting her workout class at Creekside Church of Christ. Instead of having the class outside, they would just have it inside. Little did she know when she made her way into the church to set up, her killer, decked out head to toe in SWAT gear, was patiently waiting for her arrival...

In late 2012, Dave Kroupa thought he would try his hand at online dating. He meets a woman named Liz Golyar and things go well, but 6 months later meets a woman named Cari Farver at his work and sparks fly for 2 weeks. Suddenly, Cari has disappeared from sight after sending Dave a weird message. Though no one has seen her, she is still sending harassing messages to Dave and Liz and vandalizing the...

What does a preteen girl, a 300-year-old Werewolf, and the 1994 film Natural Born Killers have to do with one another? Well, murder, that's what. When three members of The Richardson Family were found murdered in their home, the police had two big questions: Who did it and where was the Richardson's 12-year-old daughter? As police start to investigate, they realize that the two may be one and the...

***This is a special bonus episode for our listeners this week. Carlie is Cayla's niece and also one of Kaitie and Cayla's best friends. She was gracious enough to sit in for Cayla while Cayla and her family were on a trip this past December. Enjoy!*** On July 20th 2020, Grant Solomon headed to Gallatin TN, to meet his dad at a baseball training club. Shortly after arriving. Grant’s father called...

After having financial difficulties and marriage issues, most couples would just opt for divorce as their last resort, but Christian Longo had another idea: cold blooded murder. The Longo family was made up of five members: Mary, Christian, and three small children. After Christian gets caught in lie after lie by his wife Mary and his money issues are revealed, Christian chooses to annihilate his...

Once upon a time, there lived a little old lady in Sacramento, CA in the 1980s. Dorothea Puente ran a boarding house for the sick and elderly. She provided a room to stay and food to eat, but no one could have imagined what she was really doing. Dorothea spent her time as a landlady poisoning those that lived under her care, stealing their Social Security checks, and burying their dead bodies in h...

In October of 2023, Sean Williams escaped police custody while on transport in Greene Co, Tn. We did a deep dive into all of Sean's alleged crimes that span years and states. Also, we had a special interview with Mikayla Evans, who mysteriously fell out of Sean's fifth floor apartment in 2020. Buckle up. Grab your wine. This one is a doozy, guys. Sources: https://www.fbi.gov/wanted/additional/sean...

On December 2nd, 2010 a strange and horrific discovery was made inside a trash compactor room in the basement of an apartment complex. Phoebe Handsjuk, just 24, lay on the concrete floor dead. A death investigation is started and the conclusion is suicide. Phoebe’s family takes it upon themselves to try to get to the bottom of Phoebe’s mysterious and sad death. Sources: https://medium.com/@Lillyin...

Today we thought it would be fun to share our own scary stories with each other and you guys! If you have any scary stories you would like to share please feel free to send them our way, we would love to read them!

In 1817, the Bell’s were a prominent farming family in Red River, Tennessee (which would later be named Adams, TN). They lived seemingly normal lives until strange occurrences started happening at the family home. From seeing strange looking animals, to hearing voices, and even enduring physical attacks, the Bell family had no explanation for what was happening to them. All they knew was that an i...

Rotherwood Mansion has lived as a local haunted legend since its first brick was laid. The mansion holds years of sadness and cruelty, with walls full of stories. These stories still live on today in the form of hellhounds and women in white gowns. Sources: https://hauntedspotslibrary.wordpress.com/2016/03/02/rotherwood-house-of-hell/ https://www.wjhl.com/haunted-tri-cities/haunted-tri-cities-tale...

In 2001, Los Angeles fashion student Ashley Ellerin was found murdered inside of her home. As police are interviewing friends, family, and neighbors, they're given one name that sticks out the most: Mike, The Furnace Man. As police are looking into this name and trying locate him, they get an interesting phone call from a police department in Illinois. They soon realize that the man they are all l...

Aaron Hedges and two friends had decided to go on a routine hunting trip in The Crazies. After Aaron loses most of his supplies in a horse accident, he decides to hike to his hunting cache a few miles north of their campsite. When Aaron's location is revealed on GPS, he is miles east of where he should be. This spirals into a series of extremely strange discoveries over the following two years. Aa...

Mary Jones was just 16 and Mitzi Holt Sizemore just 15 in the summer of 1980 when a man pretending to be a police officer lured them into a trap. Mitzi survived the vicious attack but tragically, Mary did not. Police did not have much to go on at first but they did have Mitzi, who was ready to talk and tell them everything. The puzzle pieces start falling into place and it doesn't take long for po...

Bryce Laspisa had a successful first year in college, but when he returns for a second year something happens that sends Bryce into a spiral of strange behavior. His parents find out about his alcohol and drug use and ask that Bryce come home. Bryce's odd behavior continues on his drive home until his car is found at the bottom of an embankment, but Bryce is missing. If you have any information ab...

In March of 1998, The Bradley's went on what they thought was going to be a relaxing yet fun vacation on a cruise ship to the Caribbean. However, it soon turned into their worst nightmare. Amy Lynn Bradley, just 23 years old at the time, went missing one early morning after a night of dancing on the ship. After years of speculation, conspiracy, leads, and even possible sightings.....we're still as...

Betty Sue Short was 65 years old at the time of her murder. The twisted and curious pieces to her puzzle fall together and land the police on one man, Jonathan Slemp. It is claimed that Betty Sue Short was entangled in drug exchanges with Slemp, but is that really why he killed her? Or...are we missing a piece to this story? Resources: https://thecinemaholic.com/betty-sue-short-murder-is-jonathan-...

On New Years Eve 1980, Karen Potack was attacked by a man who came out from the shadows. Miraculously, she survived, but it would be the beginning of a series of attacks against women in the Minneapolis area. What was strange, was that the killer would call police after these attacks and weep...hysterically. Sources: https://victimsofhomicide.fandom.com/wiki/Kimberly_Compton https://www.oxygen.com...

We have all known a pair of sisters that are attached at the hip, but Christine and Lea Papin take this to a new level. After a traumatic childhood, the two form a special and incestuous bond. The Papin sisters felt like it was the two of them against the world. One evening the two snap and mercilessly murder two of the family members they were employed by. Sources: https://allthatsinteresting.com...

Lizzie Borden took an axe…and used it to commit a gruesome crime. Or did she? With no physical evidence found at the crime scene, lack of blood throughout the house, and Lizzie Borden being a woman of her time, she was found not guilty. But, with the motive and time, she is the likely perpetrator. Sources: https://my.clevelandclinic.org/health/diseases/24213-pelvic-congestion-syndrome https://stan...

TW: Suicide/Self Harm January 26th, 2011 was just another winter’s day in Pennsylvania. That is, until Sam Goldberg tried to re-enter his apartment that he shared with his fiancé, Ellen Greenberg. After having to break into his own apartment, Ellen is discovered lying on her back in the kitchen floor with a knife sticking out of her heart. After more investigation, twenty stab wounds were found al...

Scotty Trexler was a 21-month old that was living in East Tennessee in 1987. After enduring abuse his entire life at the hands of his mother, Tammy Trexler, and her live-in boyfriend, Kerry Bowers, he eventually succumbed to his injuries and died on May 29th, 1987. Scotty had to live through sadistic abuse from Kerry Bowers while people continuously failed him by knowing of the abuse, yet they nev...