Most Likely (Two) Podcast

Double or nothing with Brandon Nelson, one of the most underestimated competitors in Challenge History and Talik Monroe, mental health advocate and motivational speaker as they join Paige for a candid discussion about not being ok, racism, and how MTV has, or hasn't, changed over the years. Follow us on IG @mostlikelytwopod https://www.instagram.com/mostlikelytwopod SHOP MERCH NOW. Use code JANELL...

Wes Bergmann...enough said. Wes and the Challenge go hand in hand but we know he is also a serial entrepreneur so what's next? The Blox is a new series, available on an app that is easily downloaded, where you can stream 17 episodes of Season 1 NOW. Join Wes on this new and exciting journey and get the best of both worlds: reality tv and business education. Plus, Paige talks War of the Worlds, Pen...

Teck Holmes is back and better than ever. Fresh off the All Stars 2 finale, Teck talks about how this season was different than the last, how he feels about not finishing the final, and The King's Palace. Teck is one of the shining personalities of the Challenge and brings a new energy to fans of the show. So blessed to have him back and of course you know we talked about the possibility of him co...

Marlon is an iconic "one hit wonder" on the Challenge, making his mark on Rivals II. Before that he was a cast member on the Real World Portland, one of the franchises' most controversial seasons ever. Since taking a step back from reality TV, Marlon has stepped into the world of music, fitness, podcasting, clothing, and micro-influencing...but would he come back? Join Paige as she sits down with...

Jodi has a long resume in Challenge world...and she just keeps adding to it! As the first female individual champ, Jodi had a lot to bring to All Stars over 15 years later. Join Jodi as she talks about her experience back in the Challenge house, the infamous knot blunder, who she wishes would have come to All Stars, and what it was like seeing Brad and TJ after all these years. Jodi does "knot" ma...

Co-host of Rotten Bananas podcast, Ali Evans, joins Paige as they talk about how they got into the Challenge world, how the show has changed over time, who their "most watchable" Mt. Rushmore consists of, and what it's like to be a female in the world of media. Ali also discusses her incredible jewelry line and her true thoughts about Lucas Scott from One Tree Hill. Paige also has a great giveaway...

The All Stars 2 final left a lot of questions in the minds of viewers, and Janelle is here to share her experience and clear some things up. Janelle's performance was exceptional this season and she stops by to talk about what went wrong, and why she left Cancun without $250,000. Janelle has two beautiful kids, a wonderful husband, and a successful career, and now she's an All Star. Little self ca...

Natalie Negrotti is a BOSS, but is she fake? Ms. Negrotti stops by the pod to talk about her many career paths, why she took a break from competition reality TV, what it was like to be outed, and if she really is "fake" like some of her former castmates like to claim. She also gets REAL about her Venezuelan roots and what is next in her career. This meeting was a long time coming and Natalie is a...

Nehemiah stops in to talk about his experience on both seasons of All Stars, the fate of the Real World Homecoming Austin and if he really is psychic. He also shares the surprising origin of the King's Palace and dishes on his friendship with Brad and where it stands. Paige is also joined by follower favorite Rachel as they discuss All Stars Episode 8 and Season 37 Best and Worst Dressed. Rachel a...

Love her or not, she is the female face of The Challenge for reason. Join Paige and Cara as they eat chicken tenders in a random restaurant in New Hampshire as they talk fitness, animals, skincare, and of course The Challenge. Cara gets real about her relationship with Paulie, if she would return to the show, and some of her favorite, and least favorite, memories from her 14 seasons. Paige also ge...

Roxanne Lavin comes by and talks about being TJ's better half and what he's really like. We also talk about travel, mountain climbing, and of course a healthy lifestyle. Roxanne is an incredible advocate for vegan and plant based living because it's informational-NOT judgemental. Join us on this last episode of 2022 and learn about simple changes that might make you feel good and don't miss the fu...

She's baaaack! Casey Cooper has had the craziest 2021 of all: All Stars 1 alternate, All Stars 2 rockstar, unexpectedly expecting, and a wedding! Casey joins Paige and talks about her power moves on AS2, her and Cohutta getting DQ'd, how NO ONE knew she was pregnant, and if she would ever return. Paige gives very short into because there is a BONUS episode this week with Roxanne Lavin on 12/31 so...

Devin, fresh off his Season 37 performance, stops in and talks to Paige about CT's beatability, whether or not he owes Tori an apology, and how he feels about all the DQ's this season. He also talks about his alleged Bananas apology video and how he would feel about an Exes season. Devin truly holds nothing back and this episode is not short on laughter. Plus Paige talks about Challenge Mania Live...

MJ joins Paige to talk about the Real World Philadelphia, All Stars 2 and what returning to the limelight is like. He talks about the importance of where your room is in the Challenge house, what he thinks about the using of life shields, and who he was close with in the house. MJ also gets real about mental health and gives us an update on his beautiful daughters. Paige also breaks down All Stars...

Leah Gillingwater of the Real World Paris and All Stars 2 literally sits down (in person) with Paige and discusses life in Paris, TV after 18 years away, and the Real Housewives. Leah gets very candid about where her relationship with CT stands today and if she would do All Stars again. Plus, the Darrell tea you've all been waiting for. Short intro today because Friday (12/17) there will be a bonu...

Brittany Baldassari sits down with Paige and discusses what it was like to be on the blueprint of Are You The One?, talks about her season on Battle of The Exes II with Adam, and what she's been up to since. Brittany has a successful sports podcast and uses her platform to educate young women on toxic relationships and being comfortable in your own skin. She also shares a heartwarming story about...

Michaela stops in to talk about her two seasons on Survivor, the infamous "list" on the Challenge Season 37 and if she would do it all again. Paige and Michaela talk about the physical demands of Survivor, what your body goes through after the show, and the differences between the two fandoms. Michaela is truly a light and shows another side to her in this fun interview. Paige also breaks down The...

Fresh off her epic elimination win, Ayanna sits down with Paige and discusses where she got the strength to pull off the win, how it feels to be back in the public eye, and what we can expect on this season of All Stars 2. Was it really her paper? Find out during this incredible interview. Plus, Paige goes solo and discusses All Stars 2, Episode 2, Season 37, Episode 15, whether she's Team Tori or...

Episode 20 is jam-packed with all things Challenge. Jessica McCain is the guest star this week and she keeps it real as she talks about her tumultuous season on the Real World Portland, her true thoughts on her cast members, how her Challenge seasons went, and opens up about her journey to motherhood. Guest host Rachel comes back and joins Paige as they talk about All Stars, Season 2, Episode 1 an...

Trishelle and reality TV go hand in hand and she proves that by talking to Paige about Big Brother, Love Island, and all things from Bravo. She also discusses her famous Real World reason, her time on All Stars, who she thinks is the GOAT of the Challenge, and Leonardo DiCaprio. She also talks about perception vs. reality and what fans think about her may not be true! Paige goes solo today and tal...

Dan Walsh stops by to talk about his time on the Island, and how he turned it all around by the time Cutthroat happened. Dan also talks about his friendship with Abram, his comedy career, what it's like to be a "man", his thoughts on Bananas, and if he would come back for All Stars. This two and a half hour interview was cut down but there is still A LOT there to digest. Dan is candid about his me...

Fresh Meat II champ Carley stops by to talk about her impressive win, what those exiles were really like, and whether of not she had a crush on Landon while they were partners. She also talks about life after reality TV and what she did with her winnings. Paige is also joined by co-host Rachel as they talk about Episode 11 of Spies, Lies, and Allies, if MTV truly has diverse castings, and upcoming...

We know you missed Noor so he sat down with us to hypothesize why he hasn't been asked back, his thoughts on All Stars and what he is up to now. Paige also has a special co-host with a wicked awesome Boston accent to talk about All Stars 2 & 3 and the latest episodes of the Challenge 37. "Follow us on IG @mostlikelytwopod https://www.instagram.com/mostlikelytwopod Follow Noor on IG https://www.ins...

Sarah Rice is a gem! Tune in and hear her talk about Rivals 3 experience, why she hasn't come back, mental health, and Halloween. Paige and Sarah just talk about anything and everything but also get very real about the truth about reality tv and remember Ryan Knight. Very short intro but Paige gives some Challenge Mania insight and gives an update on Shaun! Follow us on IG @mostlikelytwopod https:...

Emy doesn't shy away from being exactly who she is as she talks about Uncle CT, her blooming music career, and how the Challenge saved her life. She also gives listeners some cool information about Romania and unsurprisingly knows a lot about astrology. Shaun is taking a small break so Paige is joined by guest co-host Domonique and the pair talk about The Challenge 37, Episode 8, BB23, true crime,...