Most Likely (Two) Podcast

Your favorite duo Paige and Dylan (Chillin’ with Dylan Podcast) break down the Challenge USA (on CBS) cast and make their season predictions. Between the cast of Big Brother, Love Island, Survivor, and Amazing Race, the Challenge franchise’s first spin off will be HUGE and it is so exciting to see the Challenge expand and include players from our favorite CBS shows. Spoiler free with the exception...

Perhaps the most notorious tea spiller in Challenge history, Jemmye Carroll joins Most Likely Two today to talk about her time on All Stars, who her rivals partners could be, who she was ALMOST paired with, where she stands with Zach, and if she is a shady, or just a smart player. Plus, learn why she keeps her personal life private now, what TikTok stars she’s obsessed with, and all about her new...

Join the recap for The Challenge All Stars 3, Episode 5: More Than Friends as host Paige and guest host Jennifer as they bring you through the shocking episode. Rivalries are running rampant throughout this season with Wes and Yes, Brad and MJ, and now Beth vs basically everyone. The Challenge is a game, but how far is too far? Special Pride spotlight on Real World alum Pedro Zamora at the end! SH...

Join Paige and Dylan (Chillin’ with Dylan Podcast) as they talk about the rumored cast for MTV’s The Challenge: Season 38. Pairs from all over the world have traveled to Argentina over the last few weeks to compete and it’s time to make predictions and get to know the cast. Although anything can change at any time (and it already has!), it is always fun to speculate and wonder about “what if”. As...

Melinda is part of one of the most remembered casts in Real World history and continues to make her mark on the Challenge: All Stars. Melinda talks about the hardships she’s gone through, how she’s different from Battle of the Seasons to now, and how her ankle is doing since she had to leave All Stars 3. Melinda is truly a STRONG MOTHER and she shows it. SHOP MERCH NOW. (25% of profits go to the A...

Join Paige and guest co-host Dylan Deckard as they recap All Stars Season 3, Episode 4, “She’s Back!” The hosts discuss anxieties the competitors faced on this episode, what Beth coming back means to the game, if the Authority made the right choice, and who has the best strategies. Find out who their MVP picks of the episodes are and who they think could have beat Beth and Jordan in eliminations....

Cynthia Roberts made her reality TV start in 1996 on the Real World Miami in one of the most memorable seasons in franchise history and then continued her legacy on the very first season of the Challenge. She came back from All Stars 3, so how have things changed? Join Cynthia as she humbly discusses her legacy, how she got cast, what she’s been up to since Battle of the Sexes and how she feels ab...

All Stars Season 3, Episode 3: Treehouse of Horror starts out with the Battle of Alliances and ends with two amazing women having to go home. How will this change the game? Join Paige and guest co-host Jennifer Nissim as they recap the episode, give their thoughts on alliances, the OG/New School battles, Wes v Yes and who is really running the house. Thanks for being patient for this episode, as P...

All Stars 1 champion Yes Duffy comes by the pod for his first interview of the new season. Yes is truly inspirational and talks about his return to TV, the women on the show he is ride or die for like Jemmye, what it was like to be reunited with his Semester at Sea sister, Veronica, and what advocacy means to him. All positive vibes from this walking stick wonder, but we had to discuss the "rivalr...

The Challenge All Stars 3 has FINALLY premiered and it started off with a bang with a double premiere. Join Paige and Dylan, from the Chillin' with Dylan podcast, as they recap both episodes. Hosts talk about their favorite moments, favorite players, moments that made them laugh (and cry) and give some predictions for the season. Thank you to everyone who contributed their feedback on Instagram! S...

We met Idris on War of the Worlds 2 and he joins Most Likely to talk about his experience on the Challenge, why he feels like he deserves a second shot, and what his strategy would be going forward. Plus, learn about his rigorous training schedule, who he think he could beat in a boxing match, and if he has found love. All Stars 3 premieres this week on Paramount Plus. Join Most Likely Two for rec...

Mike Lewis joins Most Likely Two and talks about his Challenge experience, his favorite interviews, and what he has coming next. Plus, Mike and Paige break down the iconic Cutthroat Season (20) of the Challenge and discuss the casting choices, format, what changes could have been made to flip the whole game around, and why Dunbar didn't get his prize money. Plus, Paige talks about Kam and Leroy's...

Episode 50 had to be epic, so Derrick Kosinski decided to come by and make that happen! Derrick and Paige talk about All Stars 1 & 2, his favorite seasons and moments, who his Vendettas partner would have been, and more. Derrick is a Challenge legend and a Chubbies icon and an All Star. Thank you to every single one of you for 50 episodes of support. I love you. I am grateful. I am nothing without...

Hughie comes back on the pod to talk about the Traveller Community and educate listeners about the prejudice the community faces and what exactly it means to be an Irish Traveller. Plus, we talk about UK reality shows, if he would return to the Challenge and play an amazing game. Follow us on IG @mostlikelytwopod https://www.instagram.com/mostlikelytwopod SHOP MERCH NOW. https://mostlikelytwopod.m...

Jam packed bonus episode that starts with follower-favorite guest host, Jennifer Nissum, as she and Paige bring listeners through their trip to NOLA and the All Stars 3 cast. Then, Ben from the Off the Hook Podcast breaks down his top 3 eliminations in Challenge History and some matchups that need to happen. Last but certainly not least, super-fan Jonni joins the pod to talk about how Mania is fro...

Sam is a Challenge Champion from one of the most memorable finals in Challenge history, Battle of the Seasons. Join Sam as she sits down with Paige and discuseses her season of the Real World San Diego, where she stands with Frank and Zach, who was almost her Rivals II partner, if she would come back for All Stars, and so much more. Sam is truly a positive person and this interview was highly requ...

Emanuel was one of the last rookies standing on Season 37 of the Challenge and stood out for his style, game play, and of course his showmances. He comes by the pod and talks about all three, plus his dance career, time on Survivor, and exactly what the cast did after the reunion in Amsterdam. Emanuel is truly one of a kind and it was a blast to talk to him. NOLA recap is postponed due to evil all...

Katie Cooley is a Challenge LEGEND. 9 regular seasons, 2 All Stars seasons, multiple black eyes, and a treadmill elimination that lives rent-free in our mind, Katie is an icon. She stops by the pod today to talk about how much she's changed and how much the show has changed, how All Stars 1 and 2 were different, her feelings on TJ, and her main problem with the Challenge house. (It's not what you...

Did we just become best friends? Hell yes! Tyler joins the pod for a candid, and incredibly fun interview to talk about Bananas Backpack, All Stars 2, LGBTQ+ representation on reality TV, and Wes. Tyler is truly an ALL STAR and proves why. Plus, Paige updates listeners on the crazy ex-boyfriend story from Friday's bonus episode and gives some Challenge news updates. Follow us on IG @mostlikelytwop...

Special Bonus episode with the lovely ladies of the Unbothered Podcast join Paige as they talk about females of the Challenge: who they love, who they could do without, and why they think production doesn't respect winners. Plus some fun relationship drama and opinions. Can't miss this one! Follow us on IG @mostlikelytwopod https://www.instagram.com/mostlikelytwopod SHOP MERCH NOW. Use code JANELL...

Jasmine sits down for an *exclusive* interview where she talks about her new single mom life, what All Stars 2 was like, how she has changed since her flagship days, and where her and Jonna stand. She also gets real about what heartbreak has been like, how she got her groove back, and what racism on the Challenge has been like. Plus, Paige has some Challenge updates. Don't forget to tune in Friday...

Derek Chavez comes back to the pod to talk about his All Stars return, what it was like reconnecting with his Cancun sisters, and the tragedy he experienced right before filming. Derek also talks about what's next in his life and if he threw his elimination against Nehemiah. Plus, the Challenge Fandom podcast joins Paige for an awesome roundtable where Corrina, Tony, Josh, and Rick talk about who...

TJ Lavin. That's right...TJ LAVIN joins the pod today to talk about how the show has changed over time, why he doesn't like quitters, an his running habits. He also talks about what he does when he isn't filming and how the locals in filming locations are the best part of his job. Also, street dog sleepovers. Then, MTV Malik joins Paige for a fun discussion about the Challenge community, favorite...

Hannah Chaddha is part of one of the most iconic alliances in Big Brother, if not reality tv, history and she sits down with Paige to talk about what it meant to her and what she hoped it meant for viewers. Chaddha also talks about her education and what she hopes to do in the future, her Starbucks order, and what Real Housewives she loves the most. Hannah is truly inspiring! Plus, Paige talks abo...

LT is the King of Pole Wrestle on the All Stars franchise, but what is his life like outside the show? LT is a Southern gentleman, who isn't afraid of competition. Find out what he has to say about getting fired up before eliminations, who he spent the Superbowl with, and if he would return to the flagship show. Paige also gets real about her mental health and shares some Challenge news. Follow us...