Let Us Judge You

HAPPY HALLOWEEN!! Join us as we review three podcasts that have covered the The Stanley Hotel! This is our last spooky episode (in lieu of true crime) for the season. Podcasts and their episode(s) reviewed during this episode: Haunted American History - "Colorado - The Stanley Hotel, Central City Cemetery, and Riverdale Road" (2/12/23) Insidious Inspirations - "The Shining - Stanley Hotel" (5/30/2...

It is STILL SPOOKY season!! This is our third week having a paranormal story in lieu of true crime. Join us as we review three podcasts that have covered the Winchester Mystery House! Podcasts and their episode(s) reviewed during this episode: Strange Occurrences The Podcast - "Winchester Mystery House" (6/18/23) Killers, Cults and Queens - "The Freaky Secrets of The Winchester Mystery House" (12/...

It is SPOOKY season!! This is our second week having a paranormal story in lieu of true crime. Join us as we review three podcasts that have covered this paranormal story! Podcasts and their episode(s) reviewed during this episode: Horrifying History - "The White Witch of Rose Hall" (1/11/2020) True Hauntings - "Case 46: the White Witch of Rose Hal" (11/4/2021) Unexplained Inc. - "The White W...

It is SPOOKY season!! This week's episode covers a paranormal story in lieu of true crime. Bobby Mackey's Music World sounds like an amusement park... but it is actually a nightclub and honky tonk bar in Wilder, Kentucky. This previous home of a slaughter house is said to be a place of hauntings, murder and suicide. Join us as we review three podcasts that have covered this paranormal story! Podca...

From October 1977 to February 1978, the Hillside Stranglers terrorized the streets of Los Angeles. Cousins Kenneth Bianchi and Angelo Buono Jr. murdered 10 girls and women, mostly of which were done by strangulation. Join us as we review three podcasts that have covered this true crime story! Podcasts and their episode(s) reviewed during this episode: The Hard Luck Show - "HLS Ep. 078: The Hillsid...

Dorothea Puente, who ran a boarding house in Sacramento, California in the 1980s was a compulsive liar, and convicted murderer. She preyed on elderly, mentally disabled and drug-addicted men and women. Join us as we review three podcasts that have covered this true crime story! Podcasts and their episode(s) reviewed during this episode: Evil Pudding (2 episodes) - "Episode 5 (Part 1 of 2) - Doroth...

When two young teenagers go missing on February 13, 2017, the small community of Delphi, Indiana quickly come together to search the trails where they were last seen. The next day, February 14, 2017, the bodies of Abigail "Abby" Williams and Liberty "Libby" German were discovered near the Monon High Bridge (part of the Delphi Historic Trails in Delphi, Indiana). Video footage from Libby's phone wa...

Also known as the Visalia Ransacker, the East Area Rapist, and the Original Night Stalker, the Golden State Killer (Joseph James DeAngelo) was active for over a decade starting in 1976. From Sacramento to Santa Barbara County, he committed at least 13 murders, 50+ rapes, and more than 100 burglaries. Join us as we review three podcasts that have covered this true crime story! Podcasts and their ep...

One of the most heinous crimes in the the state of Iowa's history, the Villisca Ax Murders, took place overnight on June 9, 1912. The bodies of Josiah and Sarah Moore, their four children and two visiting girls were found in the Moore home. These murders are still unsolved over 110 years later. Join us as we review three podcasts that have covered this true crime story! Podcasts and...

Robert "Willy" Pickton is Canadian serial killer and former pig farmer. He murdered many women, dismembered them and fed them to his pigs. Although he was found guilty by a jury on six counts of second-degree murder, Pickton claimed to have killed 49 women. Join us we review three podcasts that have covered this true crime story. Podcasts and their episode(s) reviewed during this episode: True Cri...

**OFF-CYCLE / EXTRA EPISODE!** Herb Baumeister was a suspected American serial killer from Westfield, Indiana, a suburb outside of Indianapolis. He was a businessman who was under investigation for murdering over a dozen men in the early 1990s, most of whom were last seen at gay bars. Join us as we review three podcasts that have covered this true crime story! Podcasts and their episode(s) re...

Jeffrey Dahmer was an American serial killer who murdered and dismembered 17 men and boys between the years of 1978 and 1991. Dahmer’s crimes were quite gruesome, involving cannibalism and necrophilia. He sought out his victims at gay bars, malls, and bus stops, lured them home with promises of money or sex, and gave them alcohol laced with drugs before strangling them to death. Join us as we revi...

Mary Bell is a British woman who was convicted in December 1968 of the manslaughter of two boys: Martin Brown (4-yr-old) and Brian Howe (3-yr-old). Bell was 10 years old when she killed Brown and 11 when she killed Howe, making her one of Britain's most notorious child killers. Join us as we review three podcasts that have covered this true crime story! Podcasts and their episode(s) reviewed...

**OFF CYCLE/EXTRA EPISODE!** David Parker Ray, also known as the ‘Toy-Box Killer,’ was a serial rapist, torturer of women, and a suspected serial killer. Based on accusations by his accomplices, he is believed to have killed at least 60 people, though no bodies could ever be found. Join us as we review three podcasts that have covered this true crime story. Podcasts and their episode(s) reviewed d...

Karla Homolka and Paul Bernardo, also know as the Ken and Barbie Killers, were a previously married Canadian couple. Karla acted as an accomplice to Paul, committing multiple rapes and murders of teen girls, including one of Karla's sisters. Join us as we review three podcasts that have covered this true crime story. Podcasts and their episode(s) reviewed during this episode: Canadian True Crime -...

Israel Keyes was an American who murdered at least three victims and committed dozens of other felonies including armed robbery, arson, rape and burglary across the United States from July 2001 to February 2012. Podcasts reviewed this episode: 48 Hours - Tracking the Murders of Israel Keyes It Happens Here, Too - Episode 1: Israel Keyes True Crime in the 50 - Alaska Serial Killer: Israel Keye...

Matthew Hoffman is a convicted murderer from Ohio known for the triple murder of Tina Hermann, Cody Maynard and Stephanie Sprang. He is also known for the kidnapping and rape of a teenage girl, which happened over the course of four days. Podcasts reviewed this episode: Egg Talk - The Leaf Killer Murders and Martinis - Ep. 16 “The Leaf Killer Murders” Uneasy The Podcast - The Leaf Killer - Matthew...

Tara Calico is an American woman who disappeared near her home in Belen, New Mexico on September 20, 1988. She is widely believed to have been kidnapped. Podcasts reviewed this episode: A Nefarious Nightmare - s2e6 - Tire marks and striped fabric - Where is Tara Calico? Feat. JT - Brew Crime Crime Junkie - MISSING: Tara Calico Small Town Missing - Missing in New Mexico: Tara Calico Sources: https:...

Jack the Ripper was a serial killer between August and November of 1888. He murdered at least five women near the Whitechapel District of London's East End. He was never identified or arrested. Podcasts reviewed this episode: Killer Psyche - Jack the Ripper The Casual Criminalist - Jack the Ripper: Monster, Mystery, Legend History Unplugged - The Escape of Jack the Ripper: History's Most Infamous...

Let Us Judge You is sort of a true crime podcast hosted by Paula, Ashley and Megan. For each episode, we choose one true crime case and three podcasts; each of the podcasts are reviewed and rated by us. We discuss what we like and do not like about each of the podcast episodes reviewed. The cases are discussed in general during our episodes as well. We hope to lead you to the best podcast you can...