Let The Good Crimes Roll

Send us Fan Mail We are back from Covid! This week we start the documentary Meltdown: Three Mile Island. An accident at a Nuclear Power Plant on a small island called Three Mile Island creates havoc within the small town of Middletown, PA.  Workers and authorities involved with the accident are ready to tell their story after 40 years.  Reference: Meltdown: Three Mile Island Episode 1: The Acciden...

Send us Fan Mail Ya'll, Casey tested positive for the Covid again! As a precaution, we are taking this week off until she is over it. So, we've decided to re-release our favorite episodes so far: for Sarah, it's Oh, Canada! Relive when Dean-o joined the discussion and why have we not had him back? We will be back next week with a brand new, Covid-free episode Support the show

Send us Fan Mail Ya'll, I have the Covid (again, wtf?) Sarah and I are in quarantine as a precaution. Both of our families are fine, just want to give it some time to do it's thing then move on. For this week, we are picking out our favorite episodes so far. For me (Casey), it's the Scott Rogers one. We see you, listener from Bury St. Edmonds! Message us :) We will be back with a br...

Send us Fan Mail The conclusion is here and I am happy to report that Sasquatch gets vindicated. If he didn't murder 3 Mexican Men in the fall of 1993, who did? We follow David down some pretty interesting rabbit holes only to discover that those who frequently use Meth aren't super reliable sources. Check out the finale of Sasquatch: Episode 3: Monsters Among Us This is found on Hulu Su...

Send us Fan Mail In this continuation of Sasquatch,  we sadly lose sight of our beloved Squatchers and dive more into the violent history of Spy Rock Road. We learn how sweet land-loving hippies evolve into drug lords, seemingly both hiring  South and Central American Immigrants, while posing a small war against them at the same time.  Journalist David gets closer and closer to finding the answer...

Send us Fan Mail In the fall of 1993, 23-year-old David visited a friend working at a Cannabis Farm in Northern California. While helping his friend work, David hears rumors of the dangerous Sasquatch that plagued the area. In the middle of the night, David is surprised when two men tell his host that 3 men had been mangled by a Sasquatch.  David and his friend said nothing for 25 years!. David we...

Send us Fan Mail John List was a devout Lutheran living a seemingly picture-perfect life with his wife, Helen, and three children: Patty, John Jr, and Frederick.  When the family seems to disappear one day, concerned neighbors request a welfare check. What police find will shock the community to its core and create a mystery that takes 18 years to solve. Reference: Your Worst Nightmare Season 2, E...

Send us Fan Mail In the final episode of the Pharmacist: Dr Cleggett is dethroned, but only to be replaced by many, many more doctors willing to prescribe a highly addictive pill to get rich. What can Dan do to stop this? A lot, actually. Dan continues his mission despite a devastating Hurricane Katrina, feelings of hopelessness, and maybe a little encouragement from Danny, Jr.. This is truly a Da...

Send us Fan Mail Dan is on a mission, ya'll-shut down the pill mill that is destroying his hometown. The authorities have told him to stand down, his boss told him to stand down, his own family told him to stand down, but that's not what a hero does.  Dan suits up and he gets it done. After a wild ride, Dr. Cleggett finally gets held accountable for the pain she has caused and it's...

Send us Fan Mail Danny Jr's murder is solved, the killer is behind bars, now what? Dan and Annie try to return to normal life. As a Pharmacist, Dan starts to pay closer attention to this new drug that is being filled at an enormous rate. Being Dan, he starts asking questions and when he gets to the bottom of why so many young people in his community are dying, he can't sit still and let...

Send us Fan Mail In April, 1999, 22-year-old Danny Schneider was murdered in the Lower 9th Ward in New Orleans. Neither the 9th Ward nor the NOPD were ready for Danny's father, Pharmacist Dan Schneider. As Dan works to solve Danny's murder, he stumbles upon an issue that is even bigger than solving his son's murder. Reference: The Pharmacist Episode 1: Justice for Danny Netflix Supp...

Send us Fan Mail In 1988, Bert Montoya was taken into a boarding house run by what everyone thought was a sweet old lady named Dorothea Puente. When Bert went missing, the social worker who kept tabs on him, filed a missing persons report. When police respond, what they discover is something so shocking that they still speak about it today.  Reference: Worst Roommate Ever Season 1, Episode 1: Call...

Send us Fan Mail This week, Casey and Sarah cover the latest episode of Dateline! Our favs! 911 gets a frantic call from the wife of an owner of a snake farm. As police high-tail it to the Florence, MO, farm to investigate, they discover it is not death by Monty the Python, but murder! Was it the brother? The wife? A disgruntled snake customer? This case of who did it has many twists and turns, bu...

Send us Fan Mail Join Sarah and Casey as they discuss the case of Jeffery Lee Guillory, the third Baton Rouge serial killer who took the lives of three women between 2000-2003. When an attack failed 60 miles away from Baton Rouge, it was the combination of two police forces that finally got this killer off the streets. Reference: Murder By Numbers Season 2, Episode 1 ID/Discovery Plus Support the...

Send us Fan Mail Join Casey, Sarah, and their Dad's as they cover the case of the Baton Rouge Serial Killer, Derrick Todd Lee. Between 2002 and 2003, Baton Rouge was plagued by murder after murder. A tip leads investigators in the wrong direction and it was a small police department outside of Baton Rouge that helped capture the capital city's most notorious serial killer. Support the sh...

Send us Fan Mail In this mini episode, we discuss the conclusion to the local murder of the Duplantier's, how kids make you crazy, the Krewe of Mutts, and the Asher House. References: The Advocate: Baton Rouge Community “shocked,” “heartbroken” after Denis, Suzanne Duplantier found dead at Hammond truck stop     The Advocate: Landscaper found guilty of murder in Highland Road couple’s zip tie...

Send us Fan Mail Casey and Sarah discuss the case of Genore Guillory. Genore was found murdered in her home after her coworkers notified police in the small town of Clinton, LA. The beloved woman's murder is a complete mystery until one night when another Parish contacts the Clinton Police about a domestic violence dispute. This one is a heartbreaker, ya'll!! References: Southern Fried H...

Send us Fan Mail Join Casey and Sarah as they discuss the case of Chiquita Tate, a Baton Rouge Criminal Defense Attorney who was making a name for herself. When she was murdered in her own law office, police are baffled by strands of hair left in her hand. It's the discovery of a Gucci wallet that seals the fate of the killer. Support the show

Send us Fan Mail In this Mini Episode, we talk about our headline of the week, and, that time Sarah was a very pregnant Juror in a Federal Case (huh!?!) Take a quick moment to decompress with this pre-episode before we take a deep dive into our Crime this week! Support the show

Send us Fan Mail Casey, Sarah, and Cousin Amber dive into the murder of Addie Hall. Hurricane Katrina was a nightmare for most, but for some who stayed in the French Quarter, New Orleans Post Katrina became an oasis of sorts. Zack and Addie fell deep in love between the catastrophe and the reemergence of life in New Orleans. Once the lights came back on, the romance turned toxic, leaving one dead...

Send us Fan Mail Ronald Dominique was 1 of 3 serial killer between 1997-2006 that terrorized the southern part of Louisiana. He confessed to murdering 23 young men across multiple parishes. Join us as we dive into the Bayou Strangler. References: Bayou Blue (Amazon Video) Killer Profile (A & E Crime Central): Season 1, Episode 5 Support the show

Send us Fan Mail A woman found in a plastic container? Also, a great cause! Catch up with Casey and Sarah on this mini episode with local headlines before they dive in to the case of the week. Support the show

Send us Fan Mail A lady by the name of Delphine LaLaurie seemed to have it all in the 1800's: beauty, money, children, success. She lived in the up-and-coming city of New Orleans. A fire in her mansion one night would reveal a dark secret and send the LaLauries fleeing for their lives. Support the show

Send us Fan Mail Darn it, Lin-Manuel, you got us again! Check out this episode as we totally talk about Bruno, along with a dismembered girlfriend in New Orleans, an update on the case of the 87-year-old man beaten outside his home,  and, Henry Cavill (swoon). Support the show

Send us Fan Mail In this episode, Sarah discusses a local case and asks for the public's help tracking down an assailant who attacked an 87-year-old man collecting firewood. In our main story, Casey and Sarah explore the case of Elizabeth Holmes and her company Theranos: where it started, where it went wrong, and the latest from Elizabeth's Holmes recent conviction. References: ABC'...