Let The Good Crimes Roll

Send us Fan Mail Join Casey and Sarah as they discuss the case of Tara Baker. Years after a law student is murdered, renewed attention leads to an arrest and a courtroom twist. Source: Dateline Support the show

Send us Fan Mail We kid, we kid. On this week's episode we finally finish the covering the case from the documentary,  Trust Me: The False Prophet. Support the show

Send us Fan Mail In this episode, One Bowling Ball of a Man , we dive into the first two episodes of Trust Me: A False Prophet and unpack the unsettling story at the center of it all.  Join us as we react to the shocking details introduced in episodes one and two. This is just the beginning, and already, there’s a lot to unravel. Support the show

Send us Fan Mail In this episode, we dive into the haunting and complex case of Jenny Pandos, as explored in the HBO documentary Burden of Proof . When Jenny disappeared without a trace, the story left behind raised more questions than answers—and decades later, those questions still linger. Using Burden of Proof as our guide, we unpack the timeline of Jenny’s disappearance, examine the evidence,...

Send us Fan Mail  In this episode, Casey and Husband Derek dive into the chilling true story behind the documentary The Scream Murder: A True Teen Horror Story . We discuss the shocking crime that rocked a small community, the influence of horror culture on the case, and the disturbing line between fiction and reality. Join us as we unpack the details of the investigation, the psychology behind th...

Send us Fan Mail Sarah and Casey discuss the case of Aileen Wuornos, using the Netflix documentary, Aileen, Queen of the Serial Killers, as a source. Support the show

Send us Fan Mail Join Sarah and Casey as they interview Stephanie and her best friend, Elizabeth, discuss the conclusion of Season 1 of the Podcast, "Everything They Missed." https://podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/everything-they-missed/id1834984809 Support the show

Send us Fan Mail Do you like true-crime stories? Do you like thrillers? Well, I like them both, but I also love to write. In the weeks ahead, join me, Casey Forbes, as I venture into a new project, where I’m I nspired By a True Crime. Support the show

Send us Fan Mail We're going international, ya'll. Join Sarah, Casey, and Husband Derek as they discuss Netflix's documentary, Murder in Monaco. When billionaire Banker Edmond Safra dies in a safe room, the question isn't who started the fire that took his life, it's why. Just when you think you've figured it out, there's another crazy turn of events. Support the...

Send us Fan Mail We didn't want to, but we have to...talk about Casey Anthony's three-part documentary. It's bananas.  Support the show

Send us Fan Mail Join Casey with Cousin Amber and Husband Derek as they discuss the case of Nada Altantawi, Casey Anthony's documentary, and how to pronounce basic words. Support the show

Send us Fan Mail Natalie Wood's death remains a mystery to this day. Sarah and Casey discuss the mysterious circumstances surrounding the day she died. Support the show

Send us Fan Mail In December, 2000, a young father and husband went hunting one morning in Florida and never returned. It took 18 years, but when it was discovered what truly happened to him, it was a tough pill to swallow. Source: Mr. & Mrs. Murder on Hulu Support the show

Send us Fan Mail Join Casey & Sarah as they discuss the case of Lynn Stomps. When Jerry Stomps goes missing and his wife is found by a bridge, police fear the worse, But, is the culprit inside the Stomps home? Killer Grannies Season 1, Episode 4 Streamed on Hulu Support the show

Send us Fan Mail Join Casey and Sarah as they discuss the case of Brandon Johnson, who's controlling behavior was brought to light thanks to his two ex wives and their podcast. Source: Don't Date Brandon on Paramount Plus Support the show

Send us Fan Mail We had to re-record (thanks Riverside), Join Casey, Sarah, Husband Derek, and Cousin Celeste as they discuss the case of Kelly-Anne Bates. The Case of Kelly Ann Bates Source: Prime Britain’s Darkest Taboos Season 4 Episodes 12 Can be Streamed on: Prime Support the show

Send us Fan Mail We have questions for Derek! Tune in for another unhinged episode. Support the show

Send us Fan Mail Today's originally scheduled episode was supposed to be about Kelly-Anne Bates, but due to technical difficulties, we will have to re-record it. In the meantime, enjoy this replay of "Wait, He's From England?" Happy Monday, ya'll! Support the show

Send us Fan Mail Join Casey, Sarah, Husband Derek, and Friend Celeste as we discuss everything that happened this week. I apologize about the sound! There was a button I didn't press and did my best to fix it, if it sounds like I'm (Casey) is yelling. Support the show

Send us Fan Mail Join Casey and Sarah as they discuss the death of Ellen Greenburg in Hulu's documentary, "Death in Apartment 603." Support the show

Send us Fan Mail Happy Halloween! Enjoy this out-of-control Friday Follies. Support the show

Send us Fan Mail Everyone's talking about it, so we decided to give it a go! That's right, Netflix's "The Perfect Neighbor."  A seemingly idyllic neighborhood becomes the scene of a horrific crime. Was it self-defense? We will discuss! We get a little unhinged in this one with Husband Derek, too. Support the show

Send us Fan Mail Enjoy part 1 of 2 Friday Follies as we discuss our unhinged lives!  Support the show

Send us Fan Mail Tune in as Cousin Dawn, Husband Derek, and Casey listen to Cousin Amber catches us up on her love life. Support the show

Send us Fan Mail We have three special co-hosts today! Join Cousin Amber, Cousin Dawn, and Husband Derek as they discuss the case of Cliff Lambert. Cliff was a retired art dealer who went missing. It takes over a decade to discover what happened to him. Source: Dateline, Season 34, Episode 3 Support the show