Knife in the Dark

💀 Some people just can’t escape the dead—and Jay might be one of them. In this bone-chilling episode, Jay sits down with Joey to unravel a lifetime of paranormal chaos: ❌ A fridge that toppled over on its own 👻 Stalked by the ghost of a railroad worker 🕯️ Run-ins with a spirit that might be his own father This isn’t just another ghost story—it’s a relentless hunt for the truth behind the haunti...

👻 Sick of the same tired ghost stories from a hundred years ago? So are we. That’s why Knife in the Dark is all about real, raw encounters with the things that go bump in the night—and the evil that’s still out there, lurking just beyond the light. 🔥 This Episode: Joey throws himself straight into the fire, spending a night in a hotel room with a reputation for ruining sleep—and sanity. First, h...

🎧 Knife in the Dark | DEMON DOLL NIGHTMARE: Justin & Joey Investigate Peggy – The Truly Haunted Doll from Baggins Museum 👁️🪓 SHE’S MORE THAN JUST A DOLL… SHE’S A PREDATOR.This episode isn’t for the faint of heart. Justin and Joey go full paranormal detective mode as they expose the terrifying truth behind Peggy, the infamous haunted doll from the Baggins Haunted Museum—where visitors have fa...

🚨 FINAL DESTINATION: BLOODLINES | Death’s Design Just Got Deadlier 🩸⚰️ This week, Justin and Joey step into the kill zone with Final Destination: Bloodlines—the franchise’s gnarliest chapter yet, where Death’s Rube Goldberg machinations hit overdrive. Does this legacy sequel honor the series’ iconic creative carnage, or does it flatline under the weight of its own gory ambition? We dissect: ✔️ T...

🔪 Knife in the Dark | 🐒 Regrettably Watch The Monkey – Leaving us to wonder why the hell people are still making Stephen King-inspired movies. 😩 In this episode, Joey, Murph, and guest Aaron attempt to sift through the monkey shit 💩 and struggle to figure out the plot of this film—is it a story about family 👨👩👧👦, revenge 🔥, a slapstick comedy 🤡, or did director Osgood Perkins make anothe...

🎬 Knife in the Dark | FNAF Movie Roast: Joey, Bobby & Horror Geek Dungeon Rip Apart Five Nights at Freddy’s 🔪🤖 THEY WENT IN EXPECTING HORROR… THEY LEFT WITH RAGE. This week, Joey and Bobby team up with special guest Horror Geek Dungeon to eviscerate the Five Nights at Freddy’s movie—a film so bafflingly bad, it made them question if the animatronics were the only soulless things on screen....

🔥 Knife in the Dark | SPECIAL EPISODE: Justin Interviews Sammy (of Knife in the Dark) – Descending into the Sonic Abyss 🖤 This isn’t just an interview—it’s a ritual. In this very special episode of Knife in the Dark, host Justin sits down with Sammy, the enigmatic force behind the band Knife in the Dark, whose music is as haunting as the podcast’s namesake. Together, they carve open the raw, emo...

🔪 Knife in the Dark | The Substance: Body Horror, Beauty, & the Monstrous Feminine 🩸 This week, we dissect The Substance—Coralie Fargeat’s vicious new body horror masterpiece starring Demi Moore and Margaret Qualley. Equal parts grotesque, satirical, and deeply unsettling, the film claws at Hollywood’s obsession with youth, the cost of "perfection," and the terrifying lengths one woman goes...

Host Justin and co-host Joey sink their blades into Longlegs, the 2024 horror gem where the devil pulls strings and birthdays bleed red. Joined by horror maestros Murphy Lawless and Nightmare Nerd, they dissect Dale Cobble’s descent—from a glam-rock ghost with fuzzy amps and feather boas to a Satanic puppet smashing his skull in front of Agent Lee Harker. Ninth birthdays turn to slaughter, dolls r...

Get ready to dig up a cult classic! We're exhuming another cinematic oddity: the 1990 sexploitation sensation, Frankenhooker. Join Joey and Murph as they dissect the film's outrageously sexy plot and the surprisingly dark motivations of its protagonist. Just how far will he go for love? We also dive into a truly bizarre theory: did director Frank Henenlotter predict the future? We explore the eeri...

Does "Heart Eyes" deliver a fresh and terrifying take on the Valentine's Day slasher, or does it fall flat, leaving us with a bloody mess? Justin, Joey, Astrid, and Bobby explore the film's attempt to blend romantic tropes with brutal kills, analyzing its plot, characters, and mind-blowing twists. Was the "Heart Eyes" killer a memorable villain, or just another masked menace? We unpack the themes...

Join us on Knife in the Dark for what was supposed to be a deep dive into the original Scream 1996 movie, but turns out to be something unexpectedly twisted. With hosts Justin and Joey, horror expert Bobby, and guest Alvin, we embark on a journey into the Scream franchise that's full of laughs, scares, and meta-commentary. Alvin brings a fresh perspective, but it's not quite what you'd expect from...

Join Justin and Joey as they lock down with the 2022 slasher 'Sick,' where quarantine becomes the ultimate horror setting. In this episode, we dive deep into the movie's twists, turns, and how it turns the concept of safety at home into a nightmare. We're dissecting the kills, the chills, and everything we missed the first time around. Like, subscribe, and visit horrorfacts.com and knifeinthedark....

Join us as we talk about the new Street Trash 2024 remake!

Episode 01.

The DeFeo Family murders remain one of the most infamous crimes in American history—not just for their brutality, but for what followed. This episode unpacks the chilling events that took place on that November night in 1974, when Ronald “Butch” DeFeo Jr. took the lives of his entire family as they slept. These murders would later become the dark foundation of the Amityville haunting legend, but w...