Samantha Benigno

I Don’t Belong Here w/ Samantha Benigno

Welcome, Welcome, Welcome! This is The I Don't Belong Here audio channel, where the goal is to use psychology & behavioral analysis to delve deeply into popular true crime cases. Here we use the testimony of witnesses, interrogation videos, legal documents, etc., and all that we have access to, to get closer to the Truth. My name is Samantha Benigno, I am a behavioral scientist, a master’s level psychologist, a 6th year PhD candidate in Clinical Psychology, and a career psychotherapist with 25 years of clinical experience. Join me, as I dive deep into the evidence to develop a comprehensive un...

Author

Samantha Benigno

Category

True Crime

Latest episode

May 21, 2026

Where to listen?

Podcasts in the app Replaio Radio Coming soon

Podcasts are coming to the app soon. Install now and be the first to see a whole new take on podcasts

Get it on Google Play Install for free Android 5M+ downloads · 4.8 rating iOS soon

Episodes

The "Innocent" Final Episode. What Really Happened to John O'Keefe 21.05.2026

In this final episode you will hear my informed opinion of what happened to Boston Police Officer John O'Keefe and why I believe it. To see a video version of what I believe happened to John O'Keefe. To see a slightly different video version of the series you can check find it here .  If you are interested in this topic you will want to check out the prologue series called The End of Innocence whe...

"The Innocent" Finale Part 1 The Time of the Crime 30.04.2026

In this series finale Part 1 I review my current theory of the case, and will explain in great detail, exactly why and how I came to believe it. Fight Research Link https://youtu.be/YMgxjy5KvS0 Join me Samantha Benigno, MA, MS, CASAC, RYT, behavioral scientist and MA psychologist/counselor as I breakdown the fall out from the Karen Read murder case and continue to seek to find justice for Boston p...

"The Innocents". Part 4, Supporting Evidence For What I Believe Really Happened to John O'Keefe? 25.04.2026

While some of the McCAlbert's have elected to sue Karen Read and Aidan Kearney for conspiracy and defamation, for allegedly brainwashing all of us into believing that Karen Read is innocent and they are guilty of John O'Keefe's death. The real problem the McCalbert's have, however, those who allege to feel victimized by Karen & Aidan's mastermind, is that all of the folks who were in the house...

The Empire Strikes Back! Join Me, Loophole Lawyer & Special Guest Aidan "Turtle Boy" Kearney to Discuss the New Civil Suit Filed Against Him & Karen Read 23.04.2026

Join me, Samantha Benigno, MA, MS, CASAC, behavioral scientist, psychologist and psychotherapist, Attorney Loophole Lawyer, and our special guest Blogger, Aidan "Turtle Boy" Kearney to discuss the new lawsuit Jennifer McCabe, Brian Albert, Colin Albert, and Brian Higgins have brought against him and Karen Read. 

"The Innocents". Part 3 A New Theory. What Really Happened to John O'Keefe? 23.04.2026

As you know we have been closely examining the time just before John O'Keefe & Karen Read pull up in front of 34 Fairview Rd on that fateful night of 1/29/22. In this episode we explore a new and evolving theory, based on their own words and statements, of what could of happened. Please be advised, the opinions that you are about to hear, are just that, they are MY OPINIONS, and should not be...

"The Innocents" Part 2. The New Civil Suit Against Karen Read & Aidan Kearney, What Really Happened in the House ? 23.04.2026

As of this week some of the McCAlbert's have elected to sue Karen Read and Aidan Kearney for conspiracy and defamation, for brainwashing all of us into believing that Karen is innocent, and they are guilty of John O'Keefe's death. The real problem for the McCalbert's, however,  who allege to feel victimized by Karen & Aidan's mastermind, is no matter what they try to say, or do from now on,  t...

The New Civil Action V. Karen Read & Aidan Kearney A.K.A. Turtle Boy: My Authentic Reaction to The News 19.04.2026

A few days ago we learned that Jennifer McCabe, Colin Albert, Brian Albert, & Brian Higgins, "witnesses" who testified in the Karen Read criminal trials have elected to sue Karen Read & Aidan Kearney claiming they knowingly obfuscated justice by scheming a conspiracy to  brainwash all of us into believing John O'Keefe was killed by one of them, and not Karen Read. Listen to my first, off t...

The Innocent. How Their OWN WORDS Are Their Biggest Problem. What Happened to John O'Keefe? P1. 19.04.2026

As of this week some of the McCAlbert's have elected to sue Karen Read and Aidan Kearney for conspiracy and defamation, for brainwashing all of us into believing that Karen is innocent, and they (Higgins, Brian Albert, Colin Albert, and JEN McCabe??????) are guilty of John O'Keefe's death. While they may have duped some of their Canton pals (and a handful of half-wit's who believe science to be ov...

BUSTED! Caught In a Lie. What REALLY Happened to Lynette Hooker? Who Is Brian Hooker? 17.04.2026

Brian & Lynette Hooker are American sailors from Michigan, known for their "The Sailing Hookers" social media pages, where they had been documenting their sailing adventures. In 2020 the couple sold everything to live their dream of an "authentic" sailing life. Brian claims that on the night of April 4, while traveling from Hope Town to Elbow Cay in rough conditions, Lynette fell overboard wit...

"Best Life" Worst Nightmare. An Analysis of Brian Hooker's Story. DECEIT Part 2 15.04.2026

Brian & Lynette Hooker are American sailors from Michigan. Brian was arrested in the Bahamas after reporting his wife, Lynette, fell overboard from their 8-foot dinghy on April 4, 2026 in shallow waters. After days of detention and questioning, he was released without charges Monday night, April 13th. In the meantime, Bahamian police and the U.S. Coast Guard have shifted their search for Lynet...

"Best Life" Worst Nightmare. An Analysis of Brian Hooker's Story. DECEIT Part 1 14.04.2026

Brian & Lynette Hooker are American sailors from Michigan. Brian was arrested in the Bahamas after reporting his wife, Lynette, fell overboard from their 8-foot dinghy on April 4, 2026 in shallow waters. After days of detention and questioning, he was released without charges Monday night, April 13th. In the meantime, Bahamian police and the U.S. Coast Guard have shifted their search for Lynet...

The Gerhardt Konig Verdict. The Jury's View of the Case, How I Came to My Conclusions & What's Next 10.04.2026

Well we have a verdict in the Gerhardt Konig case, and was a bizarre way to end this unusual case. Dr. Gerhardt Konig, an anesthesiologist living in Maui, is accused of attempting to kill his wife while the two were on a hike in Honolulu. According to investigators, Dr. Konig allegedly pushed his wife toward a cliff, tried to inject her with a syringe, and struck her repeatedly with a lava rock. W...

What About Emile? How Do We Make Sense of His Testimony? An Alternative View. 07.04.2026

Dr. Gerhardt Konig, an anesthesiologist living in Maui, is accused of attempting to kill his wife while the two were on a hike in Honolulu. According to investigators, Dr. Konig allegedly pushed his wife toward a cliff, tried to inject her with a syringe, and struck her repeatedly with a lava rock. His son Emile supports Arielle's testimony, at least as far as anyone can tell. Is there anything in...

Who is Telling The Truth? He Said Vs. She Said. A Head to Head Analysis Part 4 07.04.2026

What really happened on that mountain? The only way to get at the truth is dissect their words, actions, and statements AND that is exactly what we are doing here, in this 4 part series! Here in part 4 we will begin our head to head analysis of Gerhardt vs. Arielle's testimonies. Dr. Gerhardt Konig, an anesthesiologist living in Maui, is accused of attempting to kill his wife while the two were on...

Who is Telling The Truth? He Said Vs. She Said. A Head to Head Analysis Part 3 06.04.2026

What really happened on that mountain? The only way to get at the truth is dissect their words, actions, and statements AND that is exactly what we are doing here, in this 4 part series! Here in part 3 we will begin our head to head analysis of Gerhardt vs. Arielle's testimonies. Dr. Gerhardt Konig, an anesthesiologist living in Maui, is accused of attempting to kill his wife while the two were on...

Who is Telling The Truth? He Said Vs. She Said. A Head to Head Analysis 06.04.2026

What really happened on that mountain? The only way to get at the truth is dissect their words, actions, and statements AND that is exactly what we are doing here, in this 4 part series! Here in part 2 we will begin our head to head analysis of Gerhardt vs. Arielle's testimonies.   Dr. Gerhardt Konig, an anesthesiologist living in Maui, is accused of attempting to kill his wife while the two were...

Who Is Telling the Truth? The Gerhardt Konig Case. Gerhardt's Testimony 06.04.2026

Who Is Telling Us The Truth? What really happened on that mountain? The only way to get at the truth is dissect their words, actions, and statements AND that is exactly what we are doing here, in this 4 part series focusing on the testimony of Gerhardt Konig himself. Dr. Gerhardt Konig, an anesthesiologist living in Maui, is accused of attempting to kill his wife while the two were on a hike in Ho...

The Gerhart Konig Case: An Analysis of Arielle Konig's Shocking Testimony 05.04.2026

Dr. Gerhardt Konig, an anesthesiologist living in Maui, is accused of attempting to kill his wife while the two were on a hike in Honolulu. According to investigators, Dr. Konig allegedly pushed his wife toward a cliff, tried to inject her with a syringe, and struck her repeatedly with a lava rock. While it may be my instinct to of course believe a woman in such a predicament, I tried to approach...

The Gerhart Konig Case: An Analysis of Arielle Konig's Testimony That Might Surprise You 05.04.2026

Dr. Gerhardt Konig, an anesthesiologist living in Maui, is accused of attempting to kill his wife while the two were on a hike in Honolulu. According to investigators, Dr. Konig allegedly pushed his wife toward a cliff, tried to inject her with a syringe, and struck her repeatedly with a lava rock. While it may be my instinct to of course believe a woman in such a predicament, I tried to approach...

The Gerhardt Konig Case. Who Do We Believe? 01.04.2026

Dr. Gerhardt Konig, an anesthesiologist living in Maui, is accused of attempting to kill his wife while the two were on a hike in Honolulu. According to investigators, Dr. Konig allegedly pushed his wife toward a cliff, tried to inject her with a syringe, and struck her repeatedly with a lava rock. While it may be my instinct to of course believe a woman in such a predicament, I tried to approach...

The Gerhardt Konig Case. An Important Warning About This Case! Episode One "The Foot Chase" 31.03.2026

Dr. Gerhardt Konig, an anesthesiologist living in Maui, is accused of attempting to kill his wife while the two were on a hike in Honolulu. According to investigators, Dr. Konig allegedly pushed his wife toward a cliff, tried to inject her with a syringe, and struck her repeatedly with a lava rock. While it may be my instinct to of course believe a woman in such a predicament, I tried to approach...

Listen to the I Don’t Belong Here w/ Samantha Benigno podcast in Replaio

Radio and podcasts in one app - free, with no sign-up. Install today and do not miss the launch

Get it on Google Play

Replaio is not a podcast publisher; show names, artwork and audio belong to their authors and are distributed through public RSS feeds.