Highly Unlikely with Josh & Jenaye

What if the path to stronger relationships, steadier parenting, and a deeper walk with God is already within your reach? Pastors Josh and Jenaye are joined by mental health counselor Peter Pinon to unpack the “hand model” of the brain, understand why we “flip our lid,” and learn practical ways to regulate emotions and build healthier connections. Explore how emotional awareness, simple relational...

What if you're not waiting on God but waiting to feel ready? Donna Pisani joins Pastors Josh and Jenaye to unpack the profound difference between entitlement and entrustment. Discover how life's hardest seasons can become the foundation for your greatest purpose, and why your gifts may be more ready than you think.

Christianity and Mormonism often share similar language, but do they teach the same message? Pastor Kyle and Pastor Sam join Pastor Jenaye to discuss the foundational beliefs that separate these two faith traditions, offering biblical insight and practical wisdom for understanding and navigating these important conversations with grace and truth. Books to read Unveiling Grace by Lynn Wilder Podcas...

Step beyond the game and into a powerful conversation about identity, faith, and purpose. Carson and C.J. share raw and honest testimonies about the struggles men face; balancing self-reliance, pressure, and the deeper call to surrender. Through authentic vulnerability, they reveal how true strength comes from surrendering to God’s guidance instead of trying to carry every burden alone.

What does it really mean to belong in a church family? In this episode of Highly Unlikely, several couples share how moving from simply attending church to actively investing in community transformed their faith, relationships, and sense of purpose. Their stories reveal that genuine spiritual growth happens when people step beyond the sidelines—serving, connecting, and contributing instead of rema...

Pastors Josh and Jenaye share practical tools that help them stay aligned as a team in marriage and parenting. They highlight the importance of focusing on the “big rocks”—the key things that need to be clearly communicated to your spouse and kids. Especially in busy seasons, this rhythm helps families look ahead together, anticipate what’s coming, and stay connected while navigating full schedule...

In a culture chasing independence and instant gratification, Pastors Josh and Jenaye point families back to God’s design—intentional connection and lasting influence. Through “common sense parenting,” rooted in Proverbs 2:7, they challenge parents to move away from both extremes of over-control and disengagement, offering the wisdom needed to raise kids who know God’s voice over simply achieving s...

What if the key to effective parenting isn’t in the latest hack, but in living out your faith? Pastors Doug and Vicki Graham join Pastors Josh and Jenaye to share how "Vertical Parenting" transformed their family. Drawing from their experience raising four thriving adult children, they emphasize that effective parenting starts with parents living out an authentic faith. They remind us th...

What if the key to effective parenting isn’t in the latest hack, but in living out your faith? Pastors Doug and Vicki Graham join Pastors Josh and Jenaye to share how "Vertical Parenting" transformed their family. Drawing from their experience raising four thriving adult children, they emphasize that effective parenting starts with parents living out an authentic faith. They remind us th...

Join Pastors Josh and Jenaye, along with Pastor Kyle and Hailey, for an honest and hope-filled conversation about building affair-proof marriages. Through personal stories and practical wisdom, they unpack how intentional boundaries, open communication, and shame-free dialogue create safety and trust. By proactively protecting against both emotional and physical affairs, this episode offers a clea...

Pastor Josh and Jenaye explore four key dynamics that either help or hurt our relationships, grounding their insights in both biblical wisdom and real-world experience. From the power of humility over pride to the irreplaceable value of in-person community over digital connections, they unpack how authentic relationships require intentional choices and sometimes uncomfortable vulnerability.

What turns church attendance into a life-changing experience? In this episode, leaders share how stepping into biblical community transformed their faith through authentic, Christ-centered relationships. From men’s groups to investing in the next generation, discover why real community isn’t about having all the answers—it’s about pointing each other to Jesus. If you’re seeking connection or feeli...

What does it truly mean to understand Scripture in its original context? In this compelling conversation, Pastor Josh talks with biblical scholar and Center for Holy Lands Studies director Jeremy Stein about how encountering the physical locations of biblical events brings God’s Word to life. As our church prepares to launch Life on Purpose groups centered on the book of Colossians, the conversati...

Feeling caught between different faith backgrounds? Pastor Josh, with Pastors Dylan and Sam, offers guidance for those in our church community navigating questions particularly after transitioning from a Catholic context. Hear personal stories, biblical insight, and encouragement to follow Jesus with clarity, confidence, and freedom.

As we approach 2026, Pastors Josh and Jenaye sit down for a candid conversation about fresh starts and living with purpose. From reflecting on the past year to shaping healthy family rhythms, they share practical insight for marriage, parenting, and growing in your walk with God. If life feels busy or overwhelming, this episode will help you refocus on what matters most.

Pastors Josh and Jenaye are joined by Lisa Harper, Susie Larson, Donna Pisani and Madison Gross. Lean in for a powerful session at Unique Conference 2.

Feeling overwhelmed by the holiday frenzy and wondering if there’s a better way to celebrate? Pastors Josh and Jenaye share how their family shifted Christmas from a hectic, consumer-driven season to a meaningful, Christ-centered celebration. Drawing from trial and error, they offer practical wisdom on planning finances, managing time with intention, and embracing generosity. Their approach helps...

Pastors Josh and Jenaye sit down with Pastor Sam to discuss generosity and what it means to leave a lasting legacy. Legacy Makers goes beyond giving — it’s about joining God’s mission to reach the unreached through five ministry lanes: Vulnerable Kids, Local and Global Missions, Future Leaders, and Future Projects. Whether you give, go, or pray, your participation fuels God’s global work.

Pastors Josh and Jenaye are joined by Alex Seeley, Lisa Harper, Susie Larson and Donna Pisani. Lean in for a powerful session at Unique Conference 1.

Have you ever wondered what it looks like when strength meets humility in leadership? In this episode, Kevin Larson shares with Pastor Josh how his personal health battles and professional challenges taught him that true power comes from depending on God—not self-reliance. Kevin’s transformative insight—that letting go of control actually increases capacity—shapes how he leads both on construction...

What if following God’s call meant an unexpected detour? Pastors Josh and Jenaye are joined by Kayla, who shares how God redirected her lifelong dream of overseas missions back to ministry in Bismarck. Her story reveals how surrendering control opened unexpected doors of ministry and offers encouragement and hope for anyone navigating a divine detour.

How do we help the next generation build lasting faith in a world that keeps changing? Pastors Josh and Jenaye are joined by Pastor Kyle, who shares insights from years of NextGen ministry—shaped by his parents’ influence and a life soaked in Scripture. He talks about helping kids discover their identity in Christ and writing music with his friend QB that the whole family can enjoy (without the cr...

What if your calling isn’t just about what you do on Sundays, but also how you live and serve every day of the week? Pastors Josh and Jenaye are joined by Pastor Raymond who shares about his journey from military service to vocational children’s ministry. His experience highlights the importance of patience and trusting God's timing. We are reminded how God uses both our careers and our willi...

Pastors Josh and Jenaye sit down with longtime staff member Jen to talk about keeping our hearts healthy in the midst of change. Having spent over a decade navigating the evolving landscape of a growing church, Jen shares her journey of embracing change and growth, reminding us that longevity in any community requires trust and humility. Together, they encourage us to remain open-handed with our c...

In this special milestone episode of Highly Unlikely, Pastors Josh and Jenaye reflect on how the podcast has become a way to connect with the church body. Like conversations over coffee, it’s become a space to share stories, better understand others (and themselves), and introduce listeners to the voices that have shaped them and the church—friends, mentors, church members, and staff alike. They s...