murder.ly

Hell and High Horror Podcast

Comedy EN ↓ 156 episodes

Hosts Austyn and Repy are two average young women who are casually obsessed with true crime and horror. Every week a topic is chosen and each host presents a story of murder, mystery, or the paranormal along with some comic relief and banter.

Author

murder.ly

Episodes

🚨 WE ARE NOW GHOULTALK - ANNOUNCEMENT 🚨 02.02.2025 0:59

Hell and High Horror is now GhoulTalk! We hope you'll join us on our new feed. Please use the following links to find us: LinkTree GhoulTalk on Spotify GhoulTalk on Apple Podcasts GhoulTalk on Instagram Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices

#141 - Halloween Hodgepodge (Talk About a BOOty Salon): The Napa Halloween Murders, The L.A. Trick-or-Treat Murder, The Murder of Yoshihiro Hattori, The Murder of Rebekah Gay, B.J., Liske, The Murder of Lisa Ann French, and The Murder of Shirley Ledford 31.10.2023 1:53:32

HAPPY HALLOWEEN! On this holiday episode, Repy and Austyn discuss seven Halloween murders; The Napa Valley Halloween Killings of Leslie Ann Mazzara and Adriane Insogna, The L.A. Trick-or-Treat Murder of Peter Fabiano, The tragic Murder of Yoshihiro Hattori, the Murder of Rebekah Gay, B.J. Liske's family annihilation, the Murder of Lisa Ann French, and the gruesome killing of Shirley Ledford. For d...

#140 - Kidnappings Part III (Fairytale Witch Behavior): Mary Agnes Moroney & Maria Ridulph 04.05.2023 1:26:48

In this episode, Austyn and Repy discuss two unimaginable cases of kidnapping. Austyn discusses the history and recent developments in the case of Mary Agnes Moroney who was taken from her Chicago home in 1930. Repy recounts the tragic kidnapping and murder of Maria Ridulph in 1957. 0:00 - 12:00: Banter 13:00 - 41:00: Mary Agnes Moroney 42:00 - 1:25:00: Maria Ridulph For donations please visit Pay...

#139 - Unsolved Disappearances Part II (The Pope’s Playhouse): Emanuela Orlandi & Anthonette Cayedito 09.03.2023 1:44:19

This week, Repy and Austyn discuss two unsolved disappearances. First, Repy takes us through the circumstances and theories surrounding the disappearance of teenager Emanuela Orlandi in Vatican City in 1983. Then, Austyn recounts the story of 9-year-old Anthonette Cayedito, who was abducted from her home in Gallup, New Mexico in 1986. For donations please visit Paypal.me/HellandHighHorror Our them...

#138 - Bank Robberies (Cocaine and Dick): John Wojtowicz & The Mendham Bank Robbery 02.02.2023 1:14:25

Austyn discusses the robbery of a Chase Manhattan Bank by John Wojtowicz, which was immortalized in the film Dog Day Afternoon. Repy uncovers the strange story of one of the most ridiculous robberies to ever shake the sleepy town of Mendham, NJ. ~ 0:00 - 14:00: Banter ~ 14:30 - 47:00: John Wojtowicz ~ 47:30 - 1:12:00: The Mendham Bank Robbery For donations please visit Paypal.me/HellandHighHorror...

#137 - Christmas Crimes (War Glow-Up): Tracey Mertens & The Ashland Tragedy 18.01.2023 1:09:37

On this belated Christmas episode (oops!), Repy and Austyn discuss two horrific Christmastime murders. First, Repy walks us through the brutal killing of Tracey Mertens. Then, Austyn recounts the details of the triple homicide that has come to be known as the Ashland Tragedy. 0:00 - 7:58: Banter 8:30 - 27:00: Tracey Mertens 28:00 - 1:06:00: The Ashland Tragedy For donations please visit Paypal.me/...

#136 - Cannibals (A Silly Mood): Omaima Nelson & Jamestown 08.12.2022 1:38:24

This week, Austyn and Repy bring you Thanksgiving goodness with tales of Cannibalism. Austyn discusses the murder of Bill Nelson by his wife, Omaima Nelson and Repy talks about Cannibalism at the Jamestown colony during the first Thanksgiving. 1:55 - 25:40: Idaho Student Murder 24:00 - 41:00: Shanquella Robinson 41:00 - 49:30: Debbie Collier 47:30 - 1:21:30: Omaima Nelson 1:21:30 - 1:38:15: Jamest...

#135 - Ghost Story Hodgepodge (When the Cock Rings): Doris Bither, The Ackley House, Beelitz Heilstätten Hospital, The Cock Lane Ghost, & The Los Feliz Murder House 31.10.2022 1:31:06

HAPPY HALLOWEEN! In this spooky episode, Austyn tells the tales of the haunted Ackley House in NY and the Cock Lane Ghost of London. Repy recounts the stories of the ghostly torment of Doris Bither, Germany's haunted Beelitz Heilstätten Hospital, and the Los Feliz Murder House in California. 0:00 - 5:00: Banter 5:00 - 15:00: Doris Bither 15:00 - 36:00: The Ackley House 38:00 - 48:00: Beelitz Heils...

#134 - Hometown Murders Part II (Not Enough Lakes): The Denville 13 & Paula Oberbroeckling 11.10.2022 2:13:26

Austyn and Repy discuss true crimes from their hometowns, starting with the murder of Ross Midgette and the trial of the Denville 13 in Denville, NJ in 1953. Then, Repy tells us about the 1970 unsolved murder of Paula Oberbroeckling in Cedar Rapids, Iowa. For donations please visit Paypal.me/HellandHighHorror Our theme music is a derivative work featuring samples from Top Pop by Jumbo Seller Music...

#133 - Unexplained Events Part III (Tag, Bitch): The Green Children & Colonel Philip Shue 08.09.2022 1:29:24

Austyn and Repy discuss the unexplained (and possible fictional?) appearance of the Green Children in Woolpit England as well as the mysterious and strange death of Colonel Philip Shue. For donations please visit Paypal.me/HellandHighHorror Our theme music is a derivative work featuring samples from Top Pop by Jumbo Seller Music and clips of dialog from Peeping Tom (1960), The Shining (1980), and...

#132 - Unidentified Murder Victims Part III (It’s Always a Mannequin): Louisiana Jane Doe & “Bobby Copeland” 13.08.2022 2:16:04

Repy and Austyn discuss the possible circumstances surrounding the murder of The St. Louis Jane Doe as well as the mysteries surrounding the boy known as "Bobby Copeland" and the missing boys and men that he may be. 0:00 - 21:30: Banter 22:00 - 1:12:00: The St. Louis Jane Doe 1:12:00 - 2:13:00: Bobby Copeland For donations please visit Paypal.me/HellandHighHorror Our theme music is a derivative wo...

#131 - Survivor Stories Part V (Oopsie Doopsie Treason): Ada Blackjack & The Big Thompson Canyon Flood of 1976 08.07.2022 1:39:51

Austyn and Repy recount the extreme survival situation endured by reluctant Inupiat explorer Ada Blackjack on Alaska's Wrangell Island as well as the harrowing stories of survival during Colorado's Big Thompson Canyon Flood of 1976. 0:00 - 25:30: Banter 26:00 - 1:19:30: Ada Blackjack 1:20:00 - 1:38:00: The Big Thompson Canyon Flood of 1976 For donations please visit Paypal.me/HellandHighHorror Our...

#130 - Mass Murders (All The Parrots): The Port Arthur Massacre & Éric Borel 10.06.2022 1:55:14

Repy and Austyn discuss two major mass murders outside of the United States; The 1996 Port Arthur Massacre perpetrated by Martin Bryant in Australia and the 1995 rampage killing perpetrated by 16-year-old Éric Borel in Cuers, France. 0:00 - 40:00: Banter (Cooking Companions update, the loss of another Austyn, Pride and sex, our biggest fight, one of the hosts talks about starting another podcast a...

#129: Horror Origins of Pop Culture (Belly Sleepers): The DeFeo Family Amityville Murders & Cooking Companions 25.05.2022 1:58:59

This week, Austyn and Repy dig into the dark inspiration behind the Amityville Horror franchise and the new dating simulator game, Cooking Companions. 0:00 - 4:30: Banter 4:35 - 1:20:00: The DeFeo Family Murders 1:20:30 - 1:55:00: Cooking Companions For donations please visit Paypal.me/HellandHighHorror Our theme music is a derivative work featuring samples from Top Pop by Jumbo Seller Music and c...

#128 - Unsolved Murders Part III (It Could Always Be Aliens): Caylee Anthony & Graziella “Lolita” Franchini 20.04.2022 2:11:24

This week, Repy takes us through the infamous 2008 murder of Caylee Anthony and the trial of her mother, Casey Anthony. Then, Austyn recounts the story of Italian pop star Graziella "Lolita" Franchini, who was brutally murdered in her home in 1986. 0:00 - 20:30: Banter (Mental health updates, Repy's Twitter, Austyn's fear of death, and E-girls) 29:30 - 36:00: Soft Start (Ciudad Juárez Murders) 36:...

#127 - Poisoners (The Mischief Was the Problem): Graham Young & Genene Jones 07.04.2022 2:41:43

Austyn and Repy discuss the cases of "Teacup Poisoner" Graham Young and pediatric angel of death Genene Jones. For donations please visit Paypal.me/HellandHighHorror Our theme music is a derivative work featuring samples from Top Pop by Jumbo Seller Music and clips of dialog from Peeping Tom (1960), The Shining (1980), and Psycho (1960). Our cover artwork was created by Pineberrry. The hosts of He...

#126 - True Origins of Horror Movies Part IV (Free the Shrooms): Ruthie Mae McCoy/Candyman & National Parks Disappearances/Missing 411 09.03.2022 2:45:00

In this episode, Repy and Austyn recount the true disappearances featured in the documentary "Missing 411" and the story of Ruthie Mae McCoy, whose tragic murder influenced the 1992 horror classic "Candyman". For donations please visit Paypal.me/HellandHighHorror Our theme music is a derivative work featuring samples from Top Pop by Jumbo Seller Music and clips of dialog from Peeping Tom (1960), T...

#125 - Serial Killers Part IV (A Snail Makes a Web): Alexander Pichushkin & Ernesto Picchioni 02.02.2022 2:04:27

This week, Austyn and Repy cover two foreign serial killers; Alexander Pichushkin (aka The Chessboard Killer) of Moscow, Russia, and little-known Italian killer Ernesto Picchioni (aka The Monster of Nerola). Stories Start at ~20:00 For donations please visit Paypal.me/HellandHighHorror Our theme music is a derivative work featuring samples from Top Pop by Jumbo Seller Music and clips of dialog fro...

#124 - Winter Disasters (A Tinge of Garbage): The Children’s Blizzard & Nicholas Williams 05.01.2022 1:40:03

Trigger Warning for content discussing suicide from 15:14 to 20:00 Stories Start at 22:25 This week, Austyn and Repy discuss two Blizzard-related winter disasters. Austyn tells tales from the Children's Blizzard of 1888 and Repy recounts the harrowing story of Skiier Nicholas Williams. For donations please visit Paypal.me/HellandHighHorror Our theme music is a derivative work featuring samples fro...

#123 - Holiday Crimes (Kwanzannukmas): The Wholaver Murders & The Carnation Murders 24.12.2021 1:59:22

Happy Holiday Hauntings! This week it's all about Christmas family annihilations. Repy discusses the Wholaver murders from Pennsylvania and Austyn covers the Carnations Murders out of Washington state. For donations please visit Paypal.me/HellandHighHorror Our theme music is a derivative work featuring samples from Top Pop by Jumbo Seller Music and clips of dialog from Peeping Tom (1960), The Shin...

#122 - Stories that Make Our Skin Crawl (The Worst Cryptid) The Tuskegee Syphilis Study & Mermaids 09.12.2021 1:31:54

This week, Austyn and Repy discuss things that just really creep them out. Austyn talks about the horrifying history of and experiments involving Syphilis and Repy discusses theories and legends of Mermaids. For donations please visit Paypal.me/HellandHighHorror Our theme music is a derivative work featuring samples from Top Pop by Jumbo Seller Music and clips of dialog from Peeping Tom (1960), Th...

#121 - Home State Legends Part II (Flamenco Sheep): The Mount Holly Witch Trials, The Tallahassee Witch Grave, & Sybil’s Cave 28.10.2021 2:33:35

In this largely unedited episode, Austyn and Repy revisit their home states' legends just in time for Halloween. Austyn discusses the Mount Holly, New Jersey Witch Trials, and the link between Sybil's Cave in Hoboken, New Jersey and one of the most infamous unsolved murders of the 19th century, the killing of Mary Cecilia Rogers. Repy tells the story of the Tallahasse Witch's Grave and Elizabeth "...

#120 - Survivor Stories Part IV (Cheese and Murder): Teri Jendusa Nicolai & Tanya Rider 25.08.2021 1:58:42

Repy and Austyn recount the harrowing experiences of two badass survivors. First, Repy describes the attempted murder and abduction of Teri Nicolai. Then, Austyn details the miraculous survival of Tanya Rider. For donations please visit Paypal.me/HellandHighHorror Our theme music is a derivative work featuring samples from Top Pop by Jumbo Seller Music and clips of dialog from Peeping Tom (1960),...

#119 - Unsolved Mysteries Cases (Where There’s a Cracker Barrel, There’s a Waffle House): Blair Adams & The Freemans 04.08.2021 1:36:43

This week we're covering two of our favorite Unsolved Mysteries cases; the unsolved death of Blair Adams and the murder of The Freeman family and Lauria Bible. Stories start at For donations please visit Paypal.me/HellandHighHorror Our theme music is a derivative work featuring samples from Top Pop by Jumbo Seller Music and clips of dialog from Peeping Tom (1960), The Shining (1980), and Psycho (...

#118 - Fatal Disasters Part II (Planein’ It Up): The Tenerife Airport Disaster & The Batavia 14.07.2021 1:52:49

This week, Repy details the strange twists of fate the led to the 1977 Tenerife Airport Disaster which claimed 583 lives. Austyn recounts the horrors that followed the shipwreck of the Batavia in 1629. For donations please visit Paypal.me/HellandHighHorror Our theme music is a derivative work featuring samples from Top Pop by Jumbo Seller Music and clips of dialog from Peeping Tom (1960), The Shin...