Commander Cookout
Gemstone Mine cEDH Podcast
Hello and welcome to Gemstone Mine. If you've found us, you probably already know about the Magic: the Gathering format known as "Commander". This podcast will bring knowledge and insights to players who are looking to up their game, and maybe even learn a few things from the most powerful corner of the Commander format: the cEDH metagame. Even if cEDH really isn't your cup of tea, we think there are some useful lessons to be learned from what people are using the most powerful cards in the history of Magic for. From building and discussing the most powerful decks in the history of the format,...
Author
Commander Cookout
Category
Podcast website
Latest episode
Aug 30, 2025
Where to listen?
Podcasts in the app Replaio Radio Coming soonPodcasts are coming to the app soon. Install now and be the first to see a whole new take on podcasts
Episodes
Why Play CHEAP Commanders? - Lessons from cEDH 30.08.2025 17:17
Have you ever faced off a Commander deck where it just kind of felt like your opponent was two steps ahead of you? While you're still ramping and Getting Ready, they're establishing value engines and applying pressure? And no matter how many times you tried to stop them, they just kept bouncing back? If they were running a deck with a cheap commander, John may have some insight this week on how th...
The BEST Utility Lands in Commander!! - Lessons from cEDH 28.07.2025 14:07
John's back from hiatus and he's got the itch to start brewing again. While putting together some new low-color decks, he got to thinking about utility lands, how they can help decks eke out additional value and help them compete with higher-color shells common in cEDH. If you're still a Reliquary Tower believer or you've never heard of War Room, be sure to check this episode out! 00:00 Introducti...
The Most Powerful Unbanning in EDH History?! - Lessons from cEDH 25.04.2025 11:50
On April 22, 2025, FIVE cards came off of the Commander Banlist! How will these unbans impact your games? What are the implications from a competitive standpoint? Are any of these cards standouts? Chapters: 00:00 Introduction 01:45 Sway of the Stars 02:43 Coalition Victory 03:58 Panoptic Mirror 05:58 Braids, Cabal Minion 07:28 Gifts Ungiven 09:39 Closing Thoughts https://www. FusionGamingOnline.co...
How Brews FAIL in cEDH - Lessons from cEDH 11.04.2025 14:17
Not every brew comes together. When you brew as many decks as John does, a lot of them come up short, and the cutting room floor is littered with deck ideas which, for one reason or another, failed to come together. This week, John talks about many of the common deckbuilding mistakes you may make while coming up with your new decks, and he explains how the secret to building your next great comman...
What's the Deal with Thrasios in cEDH? - Lessons from cEDH 21.03.2025 17:17
"Few tutors" isn't in your #EDH deck ain't "no tutors". This week, John is looking at what more tutors means for #mtg deckbuilding in the lower brackets, and he has some tools for Moxfield users who may want a starting point for introducing tutors into their own decks for casual play. https://www. FusionGamingOnline.com Want a 5% discount off all of your MTG order? Head over to Fusion Gaming Onli...
Being Sneaky in EDH - How Can We Use Tutors in Brackets 1-3? 07.03.2025 16:58
"Few tutors" isn't "no tutors". This week, John is looking at what more tutors means for deckbuilding in the lower brackets, and he has some tools for Moxfield users who may want a starting point for introducing tutors into their own decks for casual play. Introducing Commander Brackets Beta: https://magic.wizards.com/en/news/announcements/introducing-commander-brackets-beta Tutors - Brackets 1-3:...
Reacting to Commander Brackets - Lessons from cEDH 14.02.2025 9:21
WotC has announced a new matchmaking system for Commander players and it's their Brackets system! John has some thoughts on the new proposed brackets and their list of GAME CHANGERS that he wanted to share this week. Introducing Commander Brackets Beta: https://magic.wizards.com/en/news/announcements/introducing-commander-brackets-beta https://www. FusionGamingOnline.com Want a 5% discount off all...
How Mana Sinks CHANGE THE GAME With Commander Deckbuilding! - Lessons from cEDH 31.01.2025 17:43
We've been exploring how many lands and how many mana sources to include over the past month, and today we're going to put that theory to practice as we focus on Reid Duke's article which argues that the simple answer is that adding more lands rarely hurts and will almost always help. John's got a casual brew this week that focuses on utilizing mana sinks to squeeze the most value out of every man...
How to Fix your Mana like the PROS! - Lessons from cEDH 17.01.2025 23:41
John has always hated building manabases for his #mtg and #edh decks. So, he went on a mission to learn from the pros and turn a weakness into a strength. After a deep dive on counting how many lands a deck needs, he decided to go even deeper and learn how pros like Frank Karsten balance all of the colors of mana that a deck needs to cast its spells reliably! If you can't stand building manabases...
Are You Playing Enough Lands? - Lessons from cEDH 03.01.2025 21:47
Lands are an intrinsic part of how the resource system of Magic works, and there are some very bright people who have poured thousands of hours into trying to solve for the optimal land base. This week, John reviews the work of pro players like Reid Duke and mathematicians like Frank Karsten to understand how players are optimizing for 60-and-4 Magic and what we can learn as Commander players. 00:...
Interrogating SOUL SISTERS! Upgrading Your Favorite MTG Decks 13.12.2024 19:48
New decks are always coming with the never-ending tidal wave of new releases, but sometimes the most satisfying thing for a brewer like John is to take a long, hard look at an old deck: Trelasarra's Sweet Soul Sisters. It's been a favorite of his ever since the commander came out, and a staple of all of his MagicCon and CommandFest decks! If you want to see how to tune up one of your old favorite...
Foundations for Nutty NEW cEDH Combos - Lessons from cEDH 22.11.2024 24:23
There are a *lot* of combos that Commander players can take advantage of, and with the flood of new sets coming down the pipeline, there are new ones being discovered every day! Which ones are right for your cEDH deck? How do brewers in cEDH integrate the new tech into their decks? This week, John tackles the oft-requested topic of how combos are built for cEDH! 00:00 Introduction 02:26 Combos in...
Analyzing NEW MARVEL Commanders for cEDH! - Lessons from cEDH 01.11.2024 19:26
John got a little excited when he heard about the new Marvel Secret Lair Superdrop, and not just because two out of the five new cards are members of the X-Men: there's also some really interesting options for cEDH builds here! This week, we take a look at how to analyze a potential commander from a cEDH perspective, then apply that to the five Marvel legends coming out this year! 00:00 Introducti...
Blue Moon's Back in cEDH! | Lessons from cEDH 18.10.2024 15:13
Stax is back in cEDH, #mtg Commander's most competitive format! - Malcolm/Kediss Decklist: https://www.moxfield.com/decks/CNk1WWgAIEyKEsNJhn6Wgw - Izzet Vhal Decklist: https://www.moxfield.com/decks/BeSZq1KvzE-rWlh9grRXZw https://www. FusionGamingOnline.com Want a 5% discount off all of your MTG order? Head over to Fusion Gaming Online and use exclusive promo code: CCOSUMMER at checkout. For a l...
The NEW cEDH Metagame! 04.10.2024 21:00
09/23/2024 brought four new bans to the Commander format, and if you're going to be playing Commander competitively, you need to know how the bans are set to shake things up! This week, John shares his thoughts on how cEDH is set to change after the bannings! 00:00 For the Academy's Consideration... 01:00 Introduction 02:20 A Word from Future John 03:19 The Bans 06:15 Mana Crypt's Influence 08:57...
Storming Off Like a Pro in Commander 20.09.2024 16:36
It's called "the Storm Scale" because Storm is a fundamentally powerful mechanic, so dangerous that designers are Wizards of the Coast are loathe to revisit it for fear that a format becomes dominated by spellslinging decks. This week, takes a look at how to play Storm in commander (and keep track of all of those triggers)! 00:00 Introduction 02:22 What is Storm? 03:55 Storm Finishers 05:21 Storm...
Gev, Scaled Scorch - cEDH Goblins?! -- HOT BREWS with Fenix from the Mindsculptors! 06.09.2024 24:37
Goblins. The bane of many tables with commanders like Muxus and Krenko striking fear into the hearts of players everywhere have yet to crack into the cEDH metagame, at least until FENIX of THE MINDSCULPTORS got his hands on a brand new commander from Bloomburrow! This week, we have a brand new HOT BREW featuring Gev, Scaled Scorch with a layered combo deck which pivots seamlessly from one win cond...
Rakdos in cEDH - cEDH Decktech | Lessons from cEDH 23.08.2024 19:01
cEDH is a metagame where breakneck speed is almost taken for granted. Rakdos is a color combination that gets all the 0-mana artifact-based ramp in addition to the best rituals in the format and the added consistency of unconditional tutors, making it a powerful shell to build turbo decks in. This week, John breaks down the core strengths of Rakdos in cEDH, how to use the tools this color gives yo...
Nyssa of Traken - cEDH Decktech/Tune-up 09.08.2024 18:29
You've taken your new deck out on its maiden voyage, played a few games with your group or at the LGS, or maybe you got to premier it at a convention. Now that you *know* that it's a keeper, how do you tune it so it plays *just right*? This week, John is sitting down with his deck from CURBSIDE PICKUPS to analyze potential additions to make the deck more flexible while also taking on that most pai...
Imskir Iron-Eater - cEDH Decktech/Primer 29.07.2024 15:11
This week, we're taking a look at Imskir Iron-Eater through the lens of cEDH! It's time to draw a bucketful of cards, cast our Dockside Extortionists and combo down the table. Plus, everything you ever wanted to know about how Affinity works with Treasures (but were too afraid to ask). 00:00 Introduction 00:59 Fusion Ad 01:38 The Commander 02:40 Affinity and "Locking In" Costs 03:57 More Imskir! 0...
3 Steps to WIN More Games of Commander! - Lessons from cEDH 12.07.2024 17:57
Games of Commander can get incredibly complex, and decision making can be incredibly difficult. What's the optimal line? What should you tutor for? What cards even make the cut in your deck in the first place? This week, John breaks down 3 steps to winning more games of Commander! 00:00 Introduction 01:25 Fusion Ad 02:31 Play to Your Deck's Strengths 07:42 Play to Your Seat's Strengths 11:15 Play...
Exploring Landfall | Competitive and Casual Commander Analysis 05.07.2024 16:19
There are a number of popular strategies in Commander, and one of the most popular is Landfall! Lands decks in Commander can sport some very powerful value engines. This week, we Explore the strategy of Landfall, delving into what Enablers they tend to favor, what their Payoffs are... and of course, how to tackle an opponent's Landfall deck! https://www. FusionGamingOnline.com Want a 5% discount o...
Casual Decks from cEDH Decks | Competitive Commander Analysis 28.06.2024 14:23
John's been covering LESSONS FROM cEDH for a minute now, but he still enjoys a game of casual Commander. In fact, some of his favorite casual decks have come about specifically because of innovations made by brewers in the cEDH metagame who have found new tech and blazed new trails to make the decks in this video possible! 00:00 Introduction 01:30 Fusion Ad 02:11 Why Play cEDH? 03:07 Temur Nyssa T...
No Tymna?! Four-Color cEDH Midrange | Competitive Commander Analysis 07.06.2024 26:05
For years, high-color cEDH decks have had a go-to partner in the form of Tymna, the Weaver. It's easy to see why: she's cheap and she helps you draw more cards while giving you access to black and white. This week, John brings together our Lessons from cEDH for this the Arc of Sans-Red with the radical suggestion that not every Sans-Red deck needs Tymna at the helm, and maybe dorks *can* find a pl...
How Partners DEFINE cEDH | Competitive Commander Analysis 24.05.2024 13:09
Commander was once defined by 2- and 3-color decks, but the printing of Commander 2016, enabled by the raw power of a manabase built on Fetchlands plus typed-dual lands created the conditions for one of the earliest cEDH metagames to take shape. Want to know how we arrived at a world dominated by Blue Farms and Sisays and Najeelas? Tune in to this week's episode as John dissects the design choices...
Similar podcasts
Replaio is not a podcast publisher; show names, artwork and audio belong to their authors and are distributed through public RSS feeds.